To Wild Bill and the MC:WT team
Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2003 11:56 pm
I purchased all of the MC's one day last year and I will admit I never gave WT its proper amount of playing thing
But I am trying to remedy that now
And I must say...WT is now my favorite MC
I started out by selecing the Tulagi-Gavutu option
I couldnt of asked for a better intro to the MC
I stormed onto Tulagi in the face of bitter mortar and machine gun fired and managed to sweep the area clear (those USMC paratroopers are a group of badass's) and won a DV (those naval guns really help)
The next battle I crossed the causeway onto Gavutu and ran into a bit more trouble their
I only scored a Draw because I landed the troops on the northern shore way too late into the battle...I also didnt take full advantage of those 75's even thought they had near endless ammo thanks to the ammo dumps
To tell you how intense that fight was....I used ALL the ammo from 4 outa 6 of my M3 tanks Mg's and the other 2 had ammo left under 5
The next battle they finally put me on the big island where I had to clear the flanks of the division to the edge of Henderson field
Fighting up that trail next to the mixed brush and the fighting in the cocunut field (vision was limited to one in the cocunut farm
) was very heavy
I destroyed every unit on the map but took such heavy losses I got a MV
Through stupidity and a lucky AT rifle shot I lost both my M3's and both tanks so that hurt me alot
Again I used every mortar shell I had (arty is a godsend in this MC)
Next I decided to play the part that Intel Lt. and Lead the prisoner to negotiate a surrender at the mouth of the Mantanikau river
This was a good map and a well thougt out battle...but I felt you could (or whoever the designer was) could of done a little better job in explaing how to use those transports
I didnt know that those Higgins boats could only hold one unit...so I wasted an entire turn figuring that out
As such I only got about 25% of my units off the map (I did get the HQ off which was 1500 points)
I did however only take 11 casulties and dished out over 70 on the Japanese so I did get a MV
But due to my lack of understanding of the tranports I lost a chance at a DV
I think whenever you make a special scenario such as this you need to explain how to use the speical units in the scenario
The battle im currently on is the USMC raider scenario in the solemons (although I wish I could of played all the options...they all look fun)
My units are still in the assault boats and I cant wait to put them ashore
Mogami made a nice looking map for this scenario
In case you havnt noticed im having a very fun time playing this MC
You made me feel actual empathy for those Marines on the island...I think if you can make the player feel as if they are a part of the battle then you have achieved the pinnacle of scenario design
The pictures and documentation are all excellent and I have greatly enjoyed all of the reading you and the team have provided for us
I didnt know much about the battle before hand but you have made me put several books on Guadalcanal on my Christmas list
I also apprechiate the small things now
Like M3 tanks...60mm mortars and .30 cal machine guns
I actually feel joy now when I see things like 75mm howitzers are going to be given to me, I would pay their weight in gold however if I could get a battery of 105's
What is all comes down to is, is that im greatly enjoying the MC so much I wanted to write and tell you and the rest of the board how amazing of an experience it is
Now if you will all excuse me Cap. Dobbs and his company have an island to take over
P.S.
I renamed one of the platoon leaders after myself and its great fun pretending like im their
I cant wait for CL to come out and you to make a MC for it as well
Thanks for taking the time to make this and show the sacrifices the USMC made on that island
But I am trying to remedy that now
And I must say...WT is now my favorite MC
I started out by selecing the Tulagi-Gavutu option
I couldnt of asked for a better intro to the MC
I stormed onto Tulagi in the face of bitter mortar and machine gun fired and managed to sweep the area clear (those USMC paratroopers are a group of badass's) and won a DV (those naval guns really help)
The next battle I crossed the causeway onto Gavutu and ran into a bit more trouble their
I only scored a Draw because I landed the troops on the northern shore way too late into the battle...I also didnt take full advantage of those 75's even thought they had near endless ammo thanks to the ammo dumps
To tell you how intense that fight was....I used ALL the ammo from 4 outa 6 of my M3 tanks Mg's and the other 2 had ammo left under 5
The next battle they finally put me on the big island where I had to clear the flanks of the division to the edge of Henderson field
Fighting up that trail next to the mixed brush and the fighting in the cocunut field (vision was limited to one in the cocunut farm
I destroyed every unit on the map but took such heavy losses I got a MV
Through stupidity and a lucky AT rifle shot I lost both my M3's and both tanks so that hurt me alot
Again I used every mortar shell I had (arty is a godsend in this MC)
Next I decided to play the part that Intel Lt. and Lead the prisoner to negotiate a surrender at the mouth of the Mantanikau river
This was a good map and a well thougt out battle...but I felt you could (or whoever the designer was) could of done a little better job in explaing how to use those transports
I didnt know that those Higgins boats could only hold one unit...so I wasted an entire turn figuring that out
As such I only got about 25% of my units off the map (I did get the HQ off which was 1500 points)
I did however only take 11 casulties and dished out over 70 on the Japanese so I did get a MV
But due to my lack of understanding of the tranports I lost a chance at a DV
I think whenever you make a special scenario such as this you need to explain how to use the speical units in the scenario
The battle im currently on is the USMC raider scenario in the solemons (although I wish I could of played all the options...they all look fun)
My units are still in the assault boats and I cant wait to put them ashore
Mogami made a nice looking map for this scenario
In case you havnt noticed im having a very fun time playing this MC
You made me feel actual empathy for those Marines on the island...I think if you can make the player feel as if they are a part of the battle then you have achieved the pinnacle of scenario design
The pictures and documentation are all excellent and I have greatly enjoyed all of the reading you and the team have provided for us
I didnt know much about the battle before hand but you have made me put several books on Guadalcanal on my Christmas list
I also apprechiate the small things now
Like M3 tanks...60mm mortars and .30 cal machine guns
I actually feel joy now when I see things like 75mm howitzers are going to be given to me, I would pay their weight in gold however if I could get a battery of 105's
What is all comes down to is, is that im greatly enjoying the MC so much I wanted to write and tell you and the rest of the board how amazing of an experience it is
Now if you will all excuse me Cap. Dobbs and his company have an island to take over
P.S.
I renamed one of the platoon leaders after myself and its great fun pretending like im their
I cant wait for CL to come out and you to make a MC for it as well
Thanks for taking the time to make this and show the sacrifices the USMC made on that island