Page 1 of 2
Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2004 7:36 pm
by Brady
Below is a passage from The Japanese Merchant Marine in WW2, in the Chapter "Rumbling Down the Way's" I don not regreatable have a compleat listing of all the ships built withen the following classes, though I hope to aquire a source with more specific data withen the month...
p.164:
"In late 1942, therefore , the Navy General Staff ordered a magor reorganization of the industry. The Authorities first implemented an upgrading of the shipbuilding facilities inspection system. Coal steal and other related industries also received more carefull quality controle and study. The formost change howeaver was the navys assumption of Jurisdiction over all shipbuilding plans and scheduals (except for woden hull construction) from the ministery of communications. This authority passed to the technical buero of the Navy Ministery, which accordingly opened a special section for merchant ship management and expanding its powers to include materials allocations among shipyards. As in the past , the goverement held the real authority and left execution to a private agency, the industrial equipment corporation. But with the Navy directly involved, the harried communications ministrys administration of the shipbuilding program gave way to direction that was more streamlined, organised, and forcefull.
The impact was immediate and dratmatic. Most private idustries began to experance decreased allocations as the navy funneled more resources into merchant shipbuilding. At a glance the monthly yen input figures will readly confirm this. In the fifteen months up to and including October 1942, the average monthly input to shipbuilding was just under 25 Million yen. But for the Next 15 months the average was 82,385,000 yen, including the wartime pinicle of 162,278,000 yen reached in January 1944. Monthly input did not drop bellow the 150 million yen mark untill very late in the year."
Thier is an acomping chart and it indacates that not till November/Dec is thier an apricable drop.
"The navy used some of this mony and material to expand facilities in old yards and to build several new and efficient specilised shipyars, but the majority of resources went into merchant ship construction. This accounts in large meashure for the fine preformance of the shipbuilding industry in 1943 and 1944, when it grew from the 10th to third largest employer among all manufacturing types, behind only Aircraft and Ordance production. Power consumption withen the industry had nearly doubled by then too.
Their were howeaver some other factors worthy of of partial credit for the unexpectedly high wartime productivity of Japans shipyards. Heading the list was the standization of various merchant ship designs. With an eye toward the obvious advantages of componet interchangeability, simpler construction, and incerased efficiency through repetition, several yards had already developed their own standard specifications for various hip types before the war. Early in 1942 the ministry of Communications studied some of these designes and made minior modifactions, and accepted a dozen of them as national standards. When the Navy ministrys technical beauro assumed authority for the industry soon after, it eliminated five of the standard types, added two otehrs, and substantialy reworked the remaining designs to simplify construction.
The standard designs included five freighter types (A,B,C,D, and E) ranging from 530 to 6,400 tons, three tankers (TS,TM and TL) of from 1,000 to 10,000 tons, and a 5,400-ton ore carrier (Type K). All nine varities crused at 10 Knots or more (the TL could steam efficiently at over 16 Knots0 and had maximum speads of about 3 knots higher. A transport (Type M) and a railroad car fery (W), and another freighter (F) were among the original standard types but the Ministry of comunications never awarded any contracts for them.
"Their can be no question that standarization stimulated tonnage production beyond what would have otherwise been achieved. The standard 6,600 ton cargo vessel, for example , averaged ninety days from keel laying to outfitting in 1942. But during the course of the war, the Japanese yards turned out 121 of these vessels, and so the delevery times droped impresively, one yard even managed to finish one in 36 days. It is imposable to calculate how many extra merchant men that the standardization allowed the Japanese to turn out, but since standard ship types acoounted for three out of ever four wartime tons launched and all new tonnage after 1943, undoubtedly the gain was substantial."
For example the book quotes that nearly 400 Type E tankers were built during this time frame(aprox 870 tons, they could be sunk with one torpedo).
It should be noted that many of the above types were not built with double bottoms and transverse bulkheads, and some had engine relability issues, Typicaly the Private sector made use of the standard types, and the Military almost always used the prewar types.
So If WiTP is leaving out these ship types, were looking at a HUGE hole in the OOB.
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2004 8:08 pm
by pasternakski
If I remember correctly, one of the test team addressed this a long time ago by saying that a significant amount of minor merchant shipping is already factored into the game, because major elements of the Japanese economy are just simply not modeled, but absorbed shipping to be supported.
I don't see you clamoring for inclusion of the literally thousands of coasters and other small transport vessels operated by all of the Allied countries, both along their seaboards and throughout their colonies (the Dutch, in particular, had large numbers of these in their Dutch East Indies possessions).
The only "dratmatic" effect of inclusion of all this flotsam and jetsam would be to render the game, playing of which already appears to be a gigantic undertaking, unplayable due to the sheer numbers of ships and craft included - hulls that I believe are already taken into account by the game design.
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2004 8:27 pm
by mogami
Hi How much fuel/oil can 1 870 ton tanker carry? My understanding is that weights given for a ship equal it's loaded weight so 1 870 ton tanker would be 870 tons of fuel minus the weight of the ship and fuel required to run it. (seems to be about half the total deadweight value) so we are talking about 400 ships that could carry 435 tons of fuel each. I wonder if 1 point of fuel/oil or supply/resource equals 1 ton. I think in UV for air transport it did work out that way. So Palembang would fill up 2 of these ships per day. and all 400 together could move Palembangs output for 248 days before each ship needed to make a second trip.
Sounds impressive unitl you realize it takes 19 of the regular Tankers (9k) or 11 of the larger ones (16k) to do the same thing. There are over 300 AK in Japanese production schedule. And at least 60 Tankers.
28 tankers (9k) can carry a full year of Palambang production before they need to make 2 trips. (Palembang at 100 percent production is the single largest oil producing base)
Japanese fuel/oil/resource/supply moves over water in home Islands to where required without any shipping. If this was calculated it would require significant tonnage. Also barges exist in large numbers for coastal traffic.
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2004 8:46 pm
by Brady
The merchant shiping that was referend to before that was absent and was aparently compensated for was the Wooden hulled fleat, though nothing could realy compensate for it adaquately other than it realy being their.*
The encnomy of the Allies is prety much aotomated and the smaller vessels that played their waters are not realy as much a factor because of this, also many of the smaller vesseles in the SRA were comandeared and the yards that constructed them were used by the Japanese to build their vast wodden hulled fleat.
The main topic of this thread has nothing to do with the wooden hulled fleat, it is intended to adress only the Standard Steal hulled merchants produced during the war.
This "flotsam and jetsam" as you refer to it is hardly that they are fullfledged merchants ranging in size from 530 ton to over 6,000 ton ships over 120 of the later alone were built.
The reasion I posted this is of course to adress the isue of their absence from the game, I have been lead to beleave they are indead absent from the OOB, if they are not then thats just great.
* The Big problem with this reduction of Hull's, other than the obvious reduction in tonage available to move suplys and resources, is the substantial reduction in Targets for the Allied subs, if you replace six 1,000 tin ships with a generic 6,000 ton ship than you have given the Allies a bit of edge in the way of killing 6 birds with one torpdo. I doubt the Allied sub force has been reduced in number to compensate for any reduction in Japanese merchant ship hulls.
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Mon Mar 29, 2004 4:38 pm
by Damien Thorn
ORIGINAL: Mogami
There are over 300 AK in Japanese production schedule. And at least 60 Tankers.
60 tankers for the whole war doesn't seem like a lot. Can Aks and Aps still carry oil at 1/2 the rate they carry resources? Will the automated computer-controlled convoy system use them in this way if a tanker is not available to pick up oil?
I thought I read in one of the threads here where someone posted that Japan greatly increased tanker production later in the war.
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Mon Mar 29, 2004 4:57 pm
by Mr.Frag
I thought I read in one of the threads here where someone posted that Japan greatly increased tanker production later in the war.
94 exist at game start to which 67 are built. Thats a huge rate!
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Mon Mar 29, 2004 6:01 pm
by denisonh
I don't see you clamoring for inclusion of the literally thousands of coasters and other small transport vessels operated by all of the Allied countries,
Depending how fast you lose them.........
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Mon Mar 29, 2004 7:01 pm
by Damien Thorn
ORIGINAL: Mr.Frag
94 exist at game start to which 67 are built. Thats a huge rate!
OK, my mistake. I thought that 60 some was all that Japan got for the whole year.
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Mon Mar 29, 2004 7:57 pm
by Mr.Frag
ORIGINAL: Damien Thorn
ORIGINAL: Mr.Frag
94 exist at game start to which 67 are built. Thats a huge rate!
OK, my mistake. I thought that 60 some was all that Japan got for the whole year.
Hmm, I think we are still not eye to eye.
When you start the scenario, there are 94 TK/AO already in your hands.
To this total, 67 are built during the course of the WAR, not the YEAR. [X(]
Now, that may not seem like much, but that means Japan produced over 2/3rds of their pre-war fleet while getting the crap kicked out of them. Pretty impressive when you think about it.
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Tue Mar 30, 2004 4:25 am
by Brady
JFC..."To this total, 67 are built during the course of the WAR, not the YEAR"
Anyone besides me want to now see the 400 , 870 ton tankers added to the game pluss all the other types not included???
Or how about reducing the US subs included in the game to compensate for the HUGE NUmber of Missing Japanese Merchants. From What I gather all the Wartime built Standardised types are Not Included.
"The standard designs included five freighter types (A,B,C,D, and E) ranging from 530 to 6,400 tons, three tankers (TS,TM and TL) of from 1,000 to 10,000 tons, and a 5,400-ton ore carrier (Type K). All nine varities crused at 10 Knots or more (the TL could steam efficiently at over 16 Knots0 and had maximum speads of about 3 knots higher"
What my source indicates is that 400 of the smaller tankers(870 tons) were built and 121 of the 6,000 ton Merchants...the other typeswere built as well, but no numbers are given in my book, it should be noted again that 3/4 of all merchant tonage built from 42 to the end of the war were standaradised types.
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Tue Mar 30, 2004 9:19 am
by mogami
Hi there are 300 Ak and 60 TK in the production system. (300 is larger then 121) 400x870=348,000 60x9000=540,000 (some of the 60 are 16,000)
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Tue Mar 30, 2004 5:26 pm
by Damien Thorn
Mogami, if you feel there are enough Tankers for the Japanese to bring the available oil home then I will believe you. I do, however, share Brady's concerns that having fewer, if larger, tankers will make it easier for allied subs.
Since tankers are as critical to the Japanese as minesweepers are to both sides, perhaps tankers should be added to the Japanese "respawn" list. After all, if tanker losses were higher than historical then the Japanese would surely have built more (assuming they still controlled the oil fields to make the tankers useful). This is the same logic that is being used to give the US 4 free ESSEX CVs so I don't see how someone could oppose this suggestion while supporting the free CVs.
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Tue Mar 30, 2004 5:30 pm
by Rendova
I don't know if I agree with respawning tankers, seems Japan didn't have any extra capacity to built these things, but I am all for inculding any tankers that Japan actually had, they are going to need them
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Tue Mar 30, 2004 6:04 pm
by Brady
Mogami, I see what you mean, but as mentioned above, if those ships you are refering to are being built instead of the standardised types than that is not realy a good thing as fewer larger ships would make things easer for the allies. If Non of the standarised types are being built (of which I have shown figuers for only two of the types, several others types were built as well), then were looking at a huge gap in Japanese merchant tonnage. Normal types were still being built during the whole course of the war (Non Standarised types), though from 42 on they represented only 1/4 of the tonage being built, what apears to be the case hear is that non of the Standarised types are being constructed, so we should realy see :
"(300 is larger then 121)"
300 is but that 121 refers ONLY to that one ship class not all the clases built or the number of ships in any of the other clases. so it should since that class is NOT represent be 300 Pluss that 121 Plus those as yet unlisted withen the standarised types.
"400x870=348,000" 60x9000=540,000 (some of the 60 are 16,000)" ....
Again this is some what misleading and not all inclusive, does this include all the Merchant Ships converted to tankers during the war? it clearly does not include the 400 Smaller tankers built, not the other standarised types of tankes, it apears to only include Non Standard types built during the war, I say that because:
"three tankers (TS,TM and TL) of from 1,000 to 10,000 tons"
The Standarised types Came in three Sizes of Tankers, the TS-870 Tons (1,000) TM-I asume in the 4-5K ton range and the TL-10,000 ton range, the ships you list dont realy match these figures, so I asume they are Non Standarsied types, futher indicated a huge gap in what the Japnese realy had.
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Tue Mar 30, 2004 10:50 pm
by Brady
If 540,000 tons is all that is produced in the game for the whole war time perioud then were looking at a considerable problem hear, take a look at the following charts, From Parillos book,540k tons is about what they built in Just 44 alone for tankers:

RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Tue Mar 30, 2004 11:05 pm
by pry
Brady let me clarify something here for you and maybe then you will finally understand...Once and for all…
There is absolutely no need to account for each and every ship in Japans or any other countries merchant fleet, simply because not all the mundane uses for those vessels are accounted for in the game.
The thing you need to understand is that the game only models half of the Japanese economy. The only part that comes into play is the Military portion, the civilian portion does not exist so you as the Japanese player do not have to face the burden of feeding the population nor do you need to import resources and materials to maintain the population. All you have to do is provide 2 basic resources to feed military industrial production, The net effect of this is the number of ships in Japan's merchant marine that went solely to support the civilian economy are not accounted for or included because the civilian economy is not accounted for or included either. This is what's known as a trade off.
The game has a routine (as Mogami mentioned before) that allows transfers of supply and fuel between 2 bases separated by 1 hex of ocean. This is both an abstraction and a trade off, that result in even fewer ships being needed for the Japanese player and it is a safe automatic efficient source of supply not subject to being sunk by US subs.
The Japanese side has been provided a very generous number of cargo ships and tankers to haul the resources and oil and a generous number of transports to keep the military aspect of the game going for Japan. The Japanese player also has the benefit of hindsight and common sense and will not use his ships in a wasteful manner, that aspect alone makes each ship MORE productive and more effective than its historical counterpart.
Is each and every merchant vessel Japan produced down to sampans hauling rice going to be included the short answer is NO, the reason is as stated only half of the economy is modeled and there is no need for every ship.
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Tue Mar 30, 2004 11:51 pm
by tsimmonds
The game has a routine (as Mogami mentioned before) that allows transfers of supply and fuel between 2 bases separated by 1 hex of ocean. This is both an abstraction and a trade off, that result in even fewer ships being needed for the Japanese player and it is a safe automatic efficient source of supply not subject to being sunk by US subs.
Coastal Shipping! Hooray, SPIs WitP lives on!!
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Tue Mar 30, 2004 11:55 pm
by Brady
Pry, That half you refer to is not realy Half, while it is true that for prety much all the war, that Half the Shiping was under Civilain controel, and Half was under Military controle, the Civilian half looked somthing like this:
" Coal transportation would occupy 1.8 million tons, while the movement of Aragrcutural products and suplies (450,000)and steal making materials(300,000) would absord the rest."
So as you can see the Civialan controeld shiping acounted for the movement of the suplys that fueled the empires war machine, the Military ships were largerly and soly ocupied with the movement and sustaining of troops in the field.
Tankers almost soly suplied the Militarys neads, and thusly should be almost interly considered as Military:
"Every year of the war the nation would use from 4 to 4.5 million tons and the Military would account for the bulk of this total"
But as you say the Ecenomy of Japan in WiTP and the Neads of the Empire have been artificaly created based losely on Historical fact, to better facilitate good game play. So much of this is then mute. Howeaver this still playes directly into the Allied sides hands, in that WiTP has Cut the Empires playable felat by 50% (the Steal Hulled fleat), while the Number of Allied Subs Is I belave still at 100%, and still at 100% or near to it I suspect are all those things that would also hunt them like Planes, Mines ect. Further compounding this problem is the larger than average number of Big ships present to acheave the ttoal tonage figures, which is also aidding the Allied cause. If you want to creat Historical proportions then you nead to adjust the number of predators, and better represent their prey.
On a side note, I do understand that the Wodden Hulled fleat, is not represented in the game because it is simply to vast to model, these ships also were the targets of the attentions of Allied subs and aircraft throught the war.
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Wed Mar 31, 2004 1:44 am
by pasternakski
ORIGINAL: Brady
... the Neads of the Empire have been artificaly created based losely on Historical fact .... So much of this is then mute .... WiTP has Cut the Empires playable felat by 50% (the Steal Hulled fleat), ... I suspect are all those things that would also hunt them like ... Mines ....
My god, I've been wrong all this time. This man is the second coming of James Joyce (whom I figure came more than twice in his own lifetime, but you never know ...)
RE: Standardised Japanese Merchants...
Posted: Wed Mar 31, 2004 2:30 am
by Rendova
ORIGINAL: pasternakski
ORIGINAL: Brady
... the Neads of the Empire have been artificaly created based losely on Historical fact .... So much of this is then mute .... WiTP has Cut the Empires playable felat by 50% (the Steal Hulled fleat), ... I suspect are all those things that would also hunt them like ... Mines ....
My god, I've been wrong all this time. This man is the second coming of James Joyce (whom I figure came more than twice in his own lifetime, but you never know ...)
ROFLMAO [:D][:D][:D]