Page 1 of 1

Innefficient Loading

Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 2:42 pm
by Fafner
I realize this has probably been asked before but here we go again.

I sent 3 APs (each with capacity of 8000) to transport an an airborne regiment.

The loading cost was something like 5000 for AP. Technically, that transport TF has 4X the capacity.

Low and behold, after loading, 1/2 the unit is still on the island, and my transports are only 12% full.


Am I missing something?

RE: Innefficient Loading

Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 2:50 pm
by Feinder
No, you're not missing anything. The AI is unionized; its load-masters do whatever they want.

At least your tranports got loaded (lop-sided as they are). Just wait until you get a convoy that only loaded the first fragment of a unit onto one transport, and the other 12 ships are empty. 3 turns later, you check on your convoy which is now half-way Anchorage. You notice that other ships are empty, and 90% of the original unit is still enjoying the beach at Pearl.

-F-

RE: Innefficient Loading

Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 3:08 pm
by Twotribes
Depending on the ops points available when loading started, it may take 2 days. I nwould think with 24000 capacity and only needing 5000 it would load in a day. Sounds like your Transports probably fueled before loading using up ops points , dont let it sail it should finish loading the next day.

RE: Innefficient Loading

Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 3:25 pm
by Sardaukar
Large AP/AKs are very slow in loading. They run out of ops point before they can fill up, so they need 2 days to get loaded. I never issue destination to Transport TF before checking if it has loaded fully. If it says "Loading troops" you need to leave it where it is and put it to "Do not unload". If it says "Idle" (or in case of using Load Only Troops "Loading supplies") it means it is fully loaded and ready to go. Of course it's still easy to try it with too small capacity TF..[:)]...and end up leaving some troops behind again..[:D]

Cheers,

M.S.

RE: Innefficient Loading

Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 3:28 pm
by Dereck
I usually play things safe and load my transport without setting a destination and set "Do Not Unload" on so I can make sure the whole unit gets loaded before I ship the transports off.

RE: Innefficient Loading

Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 3:40 pm
by DuckofTindalos
A good idea is to make sure your ships have 0 ops points when you start loading.

RE: Innefficient Loading

Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 3:44 pm
by Sardaukar
ORIGINAL: Terminus

A good idea is to make sure your ships have 0 ops points when you start loading.

Definitely !! I've have had some bad experiences when finding that some of the ships didn't load at all because of that...[8D]. Sometimes it can cause large delays to get things going.

RE: Innefficient Loading

Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 3:54 pm
by Dereck
I usually combine several ships together to form one large convoy. Since I do that I just set "Do Not Unload" and load them on any ship I can regardless of fuel level and then after the ships are loaded and combined into one large convoy I will refuel from port and then set it's destination and set "Unload" to on.

RE: Innefficient Loading

Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 6:18 pm
by Feinder
What I normally do is
Create a mini-TF for each LCU to load. Set it's home base to it's final destination. Set it's destination to it's current port. Patrol, and NoUnload. Then load the LCU. When all the mini-TFs are done loading, they're still parked. Then I combine all the mini-TFs into whatever I'm sending.

But the instance I was talking about (them not loading the unit), was very odd. It was the beginnning of turn. None of the ships had expended any ops points on loading or refueling. I thought there might be an issue when I tried forming the TF, when it initially only loaded the fragment onto one ship. So I separated, and dispanded the other ships, formed them into another TF, and tried loading again. Still no joy. So formed a new TF, and moved all the ships (the empties, plus the one with the already loaded fragment), into one new TF, and selected load. It -did- say "loading", but the next turn, the convoy was away with 7 empty transports, and 1 with the fragment. Very annoying. I'm sending the 7 back at this point, and even sending 7 more from different port, to see if that helps. I'm thinking something is screwed up somewhere tho. I expect I'll have to unload that fragment, before anything loads at this point.

Just annoying.

-F-

RE: Innefficient Loading

Posted: Tue Aug 16, 2005 12:28 pm
by Sardaukar
ORIGINAL: Feinder

What I normally do is
Create a mini-TF for each LCU to load. Set it's home base to it's final destination. Set it's destination to it's current port. Patrol, and NoUnload. Then load the LCU. When all the mini-TFs are done loading, they're still parked. Then I combine all the mini-TFs into whatever I'm sending.

Hmm...never thought of that !! It's quite neat..unless you want to move units from US to Australia. Then it can cost you !! [8D]

RE: Innefficient Loading

Posted: Tue Aug 16, 2005 3:23 pm
by Lord_Calidor
Size of the ship has nothing to do with loading speed. Size of the port and any port damage has everything.
When loading, ship spends op points, so if you see 1000 ops, that means ship has done something this turn and can't do anything else for that turn. With transports, it usually means loading is still incomplete and will continue in following turns.
If you load only troops, you can set your destination in advance, ship will not depart untill whole unit is loaded or it has run out of cargo space. This ensures that ship will depart as soon as it's loaded and has op points left from previous turn, even in the night phase, and not sitting in port doing nothing until the next turn.