That's a bit harsh, but then again everyone is entitled to their own opinion.
The reason for a closed BETA has been explained in another thread.
I just hope that in the next week they start to let more info out, I sure don't want to wait for the beta to get completed before any info from testers is out. Normally when you give someone a month with something their perception changes as they get used to the way things work. So their initial problems with the game may not be in their heads in a month's time.
Matrix and David, you should try and find a happy medium because the pure strictness surrounding this game and what is and is not allowed to be told is getting a little on the rediculous side. No disrespect, just an opinion and one that I hope is taken into consideration the next time the 2 parties talk about the game.
I understand David is on holiday until early October, well deserved I'm sure. I just don't think I can wait that long to hear anything about the game.
And lets not forget about MaxFB's main site
www.maximum-football.com
This site needs an update badly, even one to indicate game is currently in closed beta at the moment and to check the forums for further updates. I know it is pretty obvious for people to check forums for udpates, but how about those who look at the site, see the last update was January then think "oh, I guess it may not be coming out"....just take a look at
www.divisionrivals.com it's hard to figure out if the game is still in developement or not.