I mean common, it's been 5 years since WitP was released, how many fence sitters can there be?
It strange that people see reality as something freezed in time and not as dynamic. There are no people that get kids and wifes and now after been established get some time to return to teenage hobby, inverse people that go out, got other projects and drops gaming, new kids that arrive to spaceship Earth. People from all over the world that got internet in meantime, people that didn't discovered this hobby. People that got an interest in Japanese History in meantime, people that for some reason visited Pacific Islands and got curious?