Iron Storm (Scenario 50): Playtest

Post descriptions of your brilliant successes and unfortunate demises.

Moderators: wdolson, Don Bowen, mogami

Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

2/12/42

Post by Alikchi2 »

Coming back to this game after a short break and looking at it from a fresh perspective makes me realize what a huge, ungodly mess it is. Little convoys floating all over on their way to god-knows-where..

Well that's the Japanese for you. Anyways!

2/12/42

Today was something of a disappointment.

Once again the Burma air war did not go out way. The AVG and their little Hurricane friends are absolutely tearing our Oscars to pieces.

[center]Image
Ki-43 Oscars over Moulmein, about to get bounced by American Tomahawks. These fighters have the strength and durability of paper mache.[/center]

The battle in Malaya continues to grind away, with lots of air support bestowed upon the units assaulting Taiping. Kuantan and Georgetown are slightly quieter.

Another 10 Spitfires showed up on CAP over Johore Bahru today. Hmmm..

Also in the news was a successful bombardment of Balikpapan (it at least shut the Dutch up for today) and an unsuccessful air attack on Soerabaja harbor by Nells and Zeroes from Kuching. The defending Brewsters did not even engage the Nells as they arrived over the harbour unmolested, but heavy flak disrupted the formation. No bomb or torpedo hit.

In the Philippines Clark Field is fully operational under new ownership! The IJNAF launched heavy raids on Manila today, destroying much of the port structures. An IJA Sonia dive-bomber sunk another PT boat as well. IGHQ wants this theatre finished up quick so we can free up units for Java and.. other ventures!

[center]Image
A Liz bomber under repair at Clark after today's sortie.[/center]

--
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

Random bits

Post by Alikchi2 »

Here's an interesting little battle I cooked up while testing IS 2.0. Note that this has nothing to do with the current game!

VADM Phillips (Eastern Fleet RN) versus VADM Kondo (2nd Fleet IJN), 200 miles north of Kuching, December 30th, 1941.

Code: Select all

 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Night Time Surface Combat
  
 Japanese Ships
 BB Ise, Shell hits 19,  on fire,  heavy damage
 BB Hyuga, Shell hits 6, Torpedo hits 1,  on fire
 BB Fuso, Shell hits 2
 BB Yamashiro, Shell hits 1
 CA Takao, Shell hits 13
 CA Suzuya, Shell hits 4
 CL Suzuka, Shell hits 1
 CL Yodo, Shell hits 5
 DD Uranami, Shell hits 12,  on fire,  heavy damage
 DD Shikinami, Shell hits 3,  on fire
 DD Ayanami, Shell hits 49, and is sunk
 DD Asagiri, Shell hits 5,  on fire
 DD Sagiri
 DD Yugiri
  
 Allied Ships
 BB Prince of Wales, Shell hits 17,  on fire
 CA Dorsetshire, Shell hits 1
 CA Devonshire, Shell hits 5,  on fire
 CL Perth, Shell hits 4,  on fire
 CL Hobart, Shell hits 1
 DD Electra, Shell hits 11, Torpedo hits 1,  on fire,  heavy damage
 DD Express, Shell hits 11, Torpedo hits 2, and is sunk
 DD Fortune, Shell hits 3, Torpedo hits 1,  on fire,  heavy damage
 DD Eskimo
 DD Nubian, Shell hits 6,  on fire,  heavy damage
 BB Rodney
 DD Ashanti, Shell hits 3,  on fire,  heavy damage
  
 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Night Time Surface Combat
  
 Japanese Ships
 BB Nagato, Shell hits 2,  on fire
 BB Mutsu, Shell hits 5
 CA Ibuki
 CA Aso, Shell hits 2
 CL Otawa, Shell hits 5, Torpedo hits 1,  on fire,  heavy damage
 DD Shirakumo, Shell hits 2,  on fire
 DD Isonami, Shell hits 1
 DD Shirayuki
 DD Hatsuyuki, Shell hits 1, Torpedo hits 1,  on fire,  heavy damage
 DD Murakumo, Shell hits 5,  on fire
 DD Sazanami
  
 Allied Ships
 BB Warspite, Shell hits 2,  on fire
 CA Hawkins, Shell hits 2
 CA Frobisher, Shell hits 5, Torpedo hits 1,  on fire,  heavy damage
 CL Danae, Shell hits 3,  on fire
 CL Dragon, Shell hits 1
 DD Active
 DD Anthony, Shell hits 1
 DD Jupiter, Shell hits 1
 DD Janus, Shell hits 2, Torpedo hits 1,  on fire
 DD Javelin, Shell hits 1
 DD Jervis, Shell hits 1
 BB Malaya, Shell hits 1
  
 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Night Time Surface Combat
  
 Japanese Ships
 BB Nagato, Shell hits 3,  on fire
 BB Mutsu, Shell hits 5
 CA Ibuki
 CA Aso
 CL Otawa, Shell hits 16,  on fire,  heavy damage
 DD Shirakumo,  on fire
 DD Isonami, Shell hits 4,  on fire
 DD Shirayuki, Shell hits 4,  on fire
 DD Hatsuyuki, Shell hits 4,  on fire,  heavy damage
 DD Murakumo,  on fire
 DD Sazanami
  
 Allied Ships
 BB Warspite, Shell hits 1,  on fire
 CA Hawkins, Shell hits 4,  on fire
 CA Frobisher,  on fire,  heavy damage
 CL Danae, Shell hits 1,  on fire
 CL Dragon
 DD Active
 DD Anthony, Shell hits 1
 DD Jupiter
 DD Janus,  on fire
 DD Javelin
 DD Jervis
 BB Malaya
  
 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Night Time Surface Combat
  
 Japanese Ships
 BB Nagato, Shell hits 7,  on fire
 BB Mutsu, Shell hits 4
 CA Ibuki, Shell hits 3
 CA Aso
 CL Otawa, and is sunk
 DD Shirakumo, Shell hits 1,  on fire
 DD Isonami,  on fire
 DD Shirayuki,  on fire
 DD Hatsuyuki, Shell hits 6, Torpedo hits 1, and is sunk
 DD Murakumo, Shell hits 1,  on fire
 DD Sazanami, Shell hits 1
  
 Allied Ships
 BC Repulse, Shell hits 2
 CA Melbourne
 CL Sydney, Shell hits 2,  on fire
 DD Vampire, Shell hits 3,  on fire,  heavy damage
 DD Vendetta
 DD Voyager
 DD Stuart, Shell hits 1
 DD Jaguar
 DD Jackal
 BC Australia, Shell hits 1
  
 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Night Time Surface Combat
  
 Japanese Ships
 BB Hiei, Shell hits 8,  on fire,  heavy damage
 BB Kirishima, Shell hits 6
 CL Hirado, Shell hits 10,  on fire,  heavy damage
 DD Makigumo
 DD Kawagiri
 DD Yamagiri
 DD Umigiri, Shell hits 2
 DD Tanigiri, Shell hits 1
  
 Allied Ships
 BC Repulse, Shell hits 1
 CA Melbourne, Shell hits 4,  on fire,  heavy damage
 CL Sydney, Shell hits 10, Torpedo hits 1,  on fire
 DD Vampire, Shell hits 6, Torpedo hits 2, and is sunk
 DD Vendetta, Shell hits 8, Torpedo hits 3, and is sunk
 DD Voyager, Shell hits 2,  on fire
 DD Stuart, Shell hits 3,  on fire
 DD Jaguar, Shell hits 2, Torpedo hits 2, and is sunk
 DD Jackal
 BC Australia, Shell hits 4,  on fire
  
 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Night Time Surface Combat
  
 Japanese Ships
 BB Hiei, Shell hits 14,  on fire,  heavy damage
 BB Kirishima, Shell hits 6,  on fire
 CL Hirado, Shell hits 8,  on fire,  heavy damage
 DD Makigumo
 DD Kawagiri
 DD Yamagiri
 DD Umigiri, Shell hits 3
 DD Tanigiri, Shell hits 1,  on fire
  
 Allied Ships
 BB Warspite,  on fire
 CA Hawkins, Shell hits 8,  on fire,  heavy damage
 CA Frobisher,  on fire,  heavy damage
 CL Danae, Shell hits 5,  on fire
 CL Dragon
 DD Active
 DD Anthony, Shell hits 3,  on fire
 DD Jupiter, Shell hits 1
 DD Janus, Shell hits 6, and is sunk
 DD Javelin, Shell hits 4, Torpedo hits 1,  on fire,  heavy damage
 DD Jervis
 BB Malaya, Shell hits 2
  
 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 

Prince of Wales tore into Ise, pounding her with 14" shells and forcing the ship away through sheer weight of metal. Ise has 76 system damage and 74 float damage and it doesn't look like she'll make it back to Saigon or Cam Ranh. PoW took a pretty rough pounding from Ise and Hyuga but her protection stood up to them well and the ship is still fully operation with only ~10 system damage. Hyuga took an 18" torpedo from charging RN destroyers (all sunk) and is at roughly ~20 system damage. Fuso, Yamashiro and Rodney did not engage.

Nagato and Mutsu (Kondo's flagship) fended off multiple attacks from RN units throughout the night. Mutsu came out relatively okay (17 system damage due to 15" hits from Malaya), while Nagato suffered a bit more - 40/40 system/float. It looks like she'll make it back to Cam Ranh but she'll be out of the war for a while. In retaliation, she knocked out both of Warspite's rear turrets and send several other 16.1" shells through that ship, reducing the speed to 19 knots. The old heavy cruisers Frobisher and Hawkins suffered heavily at the hands of Aso and Ibuki in this engagement but not before sinking CL Otawa and helping the RN destroyers get the better of the Japanese Fubukis.

At this point Repulse, Australia and their supporting cruisers and destroyers showed up from the south, catching Kondo off guard and opening fire on Nagato and Mutsu from extremely close range. Multiple 15" shells from Renown smashed into Nagato and forced this enemy group away. The RN ships launched torpedoes as they sped north, sinking Hatsuyuki.

Finally they blundered across Hiei and Kirishima which were certainly not expecting an attack. Hiei was raked from stem to stern with 13.5" and 15" shells from Australia and Repulse and was left listing, but the Japanese admiral reacted quickly and launched a Long Lance attack. Three destroyers were struck and sunk by Lances almost immediately with CL Sydney also heavily damaged. Kirishima reared to life at about this time too and began playing her 14" guns against Australia and 4000 yards. Australia could not take this pounding for long (final damage level: 20 sys) and the remainder of the RN/RAN group turned towards Singapore.

However the battle had not ended! Warspite and Malaya had circled around to the northeast (a ludicrous idea at the time, seeing as Warspite had lost half her firepower) and moved towards the sound of the guns. Hiei and Kirishima were once again caught and this time Hiei went down for good. Pounded by 15" shells from all angles she slipped beneath the waves. Kirishima was given a few salvoes for good measure before Warspite and Malaya headed for home, minus several destroyers.

--

Final tally of losses -

IJN:
1x BB sunk (Hiei)
2x BB heavily damaged (Ise, Hyuga)
3x BB moderately damaged (Kirishima, Nagato, Mutsu)
Multiple cruisers and destoyers sunk or damaged to varying degrees

RN:
2x BB moderately damaged (Prince of Wales, Warspite)
1x BC moderately damaged (Australia)
Again, lots of cruisers and destroyers damaged/sunk - more than the IJN

--

Fun to watch? I think so. [:)]
User avatar
viberpol
Posts: 854
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2005 3:16 pm
Location: Global village, Poland, EU

Ironstorm major must-have changes?RE: Ironmod version?

Post by viberpol »

Once you suggest to wait till Christmas for the v.2.0, I have just one short question:

What are the bugs/errors you discovered in v1.01 during the playtesting?

I'm keen on starting this mod. I even have my opponent waiting.
But I cannot think of it like starting the game, and then starting once again because of new version... It's like marriage -- I take this mod for some (?) time home [;)]

However, I'd like to know whether there are some small errors (if any) I can fix by myself.
Do you suggest any changes to be introduced -- a must-have changes?

Przy lackim orle, przy koniu Kiejstuta Archanioł Rusi na proporcach błysł
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

RE: Ironstorm major must-have changes?RE: Ironmod version?

Post by Alikchi2 »

sure! Although I would still suggest waiting for version 2.0 :)

There are a few minor bugs. The Yoshino class cruisers have their torpedoes all mounted on the left side (should be 1 mount on the left, one mount on the right). The Hood class has some problems with its armaments (Terminus posted this earlier in this thread).

The North Carolina uses the Hood's shipside (whoops. I must have been sleepy when I added the Hood).

Japanese cruiser Kasuga has no floatplanes.

Other than this the scenario should be bug-free. :)
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

End of the road

Post by Alikchi2 »

An announcement!

This game, and as a consequence this AAR, ends here. With Iron Storm v2's release coming up relatively soon, and the playtest's slow pace, I've lost interest - and I just don't have enough time to give the game or the AAR the treatment they deserve. :/

However!

When IS v2.0 is released, Cruft and I will be starting yet another game. Not a playtest, a full game, with myself as the Allies (thank God [:D]) and probably separate AARs. You should see us before Christmas, as I said earlier.

And also - I am not going to leave this AAR hanging. Instead I will continue with the AAR, but the content will be completely fictional. I will be writing yearly summaries for the rest of the war, starting with 1942 below, and more later. Again, this is all entirely fictional, but I hope you enjoy it..

February 13th, 1942 - December 31st, 1942

The Japanese war machine continued to grind through Southeast Asia through the rest of February. On the 16th, Taiping fell, cutting off tens of thousands of Commonwealth troops in the "Georgetown pocket". After 9 days of sustained and heavy fighting, the city fell, and all 7 divisions of Yamashita's army streamed south through Malaya towards Singapore.

Until they hit a roadblock: Johore Bahru, the best-prepared and defended of all of General Slim's defensive positions, save Singapore itself. For nearly two weeks Yamashita's divisions hammered at the British, Indians, Australians and New Zealanders with no effect. Flanking was impossible, with every stretch of jungle covered by scores of weapons, forcing the Japanese into fruitless banzai charges - with disastrous effects. The 56th and Imperial Guards Divisions were actually taken out of the theatre to be rebuilt in early March, but not just for combat-related reasons. For Yamashita was no fool. His supply system had been run on a shoestring from the very beginning, his China veterans were suffering from climate shift, and his entire army, including himself, was feeling the effects (directly or indirectly) of malaria. An uneasy stalemate prevailed as both sides caught their breath.

The British were even worse off. Although ammunition was plentiful, food was not. Japanese air superiority had cut Singapore off from the rice of Burma and many of the new troops (18th Division being a prime example) were relatively green. Their air force was gone, and their navy had fled, and Singapore laid bare to Japanese bombers. Much of the city centre was gutted by night attacks from Liz heavy bombers.

On March 21st, Yamashita felt prepared enough to again launch the attack, and was shocked when the Commonwealth forces before him seemed to melt. They were nearly starving men with far too little fresh water and even less sleep. Johore Bahru fell quickly and, not pausing, Yamashita moved to bludgeon his way across to Singapore. Casualties were even worse than the Johore battle - his army was shedding blood with every advance at this point - but under massive aerial bombardment and outnumbered four to one, the British reluctantly gave ground. There was no formal surrender, on Churchill's orders - the 50,000 Commonwealth troops remaining on the island eventually gave themselves up in small packets. Under the noses of the Japanese, tens of thousands of soldiers and civilians had been evacuated via the Sunda Strait. Slim and Wingate flew to India to reunite with former AOC Malaya Park.

Singapore itself was a shattered husk, the door-to-door fighting and constant bombing having almost entirely destroyed the once-proud city. The battle became representative of Commonwealth stubbornness and bravery - a sort of Empire Alamo. Yamashita had lost nearly 60,000 men to disease and the fighting by the formal end of the campaign on April 6th.

In the Philippines, the collapse was already imminent by late February. 100,000 Japanese troops faced a quarter of that number of Filipino and American forces in Manila. Although stubborn, they were starving from the beginning (unlike the British) and under a man whose leadership was questionable at best. Douglas MacArthur was killed during a visit to the front lines by Japanese machine-gun fire. Some say he intentionally placed himself in the line of fire, but the true story behind his death will remain a mystery. Richard Sutherland, his Chief of Staff, never divulged exactly what the General had said to him beforehand.

On February 28th, the Japanese entered Intramuros, fighting rag-tag Filipino units for control of the old Spanish portion of the city. General Wainwright surrendered the remaining Allied troops in the Philippines (including the stubborn troops still holding at Cagayan) on the 29th. 5 new Japanese divisions were free for use elsewhere.

And they were needed, badly. The Allies had been using the time bought by stubborn resistance to reinforce their holdings. American and British aircraft were appearing over the skies of Java in greater and greater numbers. The Japanese struck with a vengeance and for a while it seemed like December again. Balikpapan, Amboina, Kendari and Palembang fell in quick succession, but Java's flying defenders still refused to stay down, putting any invasion at risk.

Until the Kido Butai showed up. In conjunction with Japanese land-based air nearly all the airfields on Java were struck with overwhelming force within a two-day period. Losses on both sides were heavy, but the Allied air forces were demolished. A small carrier engagement also occurred when CarDiv 1 (Akagi and Kaga) encountered the British light carrier Eagle, apparently ferrying aircraft to Tjilitjap, and sunk it. The Royal Netherlands Navy was nowhere to be seen. Kido Butai sailed back to Kendari victoriously (to lay anchor next to the shattered hulk of the battleship Valiant) while Admiral Kondo led the convoy carrying 2nd, 48th and 6th Divisions towards Kragen, covered by battlecruisers Kongo and Haruna.

The Dutch fleet (and as many soldiers and civilians who could make it) had left for Ceylon, the defence of Java abandoned by their Allies. Embittered, they would still play a crucial role later in the war. Java fell quickly and almost bloodlessly (relative to the other campaigns for the Southern Resource Area, at least). Dutch General Hein ter Pooten surrendered all Allied forces on Java on April 1st. Timor and the rest of Sumatra followed quickly.

By May 1st, the Japanese empire extended from Rangoon to Timor, to Rabaul, to Wake Island. Japan had won great victories, but not easy ones. The price in time, energy and blood had been heavy. The monsoon season of Burma prevented any further advance in this theatre beyond Rangoon, which was already being bombed by Wellingtons. Timor and Rabaul were malarial hellpits and Wake Island was just another strategically useless island to supply. The Imperial Japanese Navy and Army had shot their bolts. It was time to consolidate.

For the next few months no territory was taken on either side (other than Port Moresby in New Guinea, by the rebuilt 56th Division). While the Japanese government moved to exploit its new holdings, the Navy proceeded with its pre-war raiding plan. Multiple sweeps of the eastern Pacific by CarDivs 4 and 5 put a temporary end to American contact with Australia and New Zealand. Japanese battlehips ranged as far as French Polynesia. With 3 American carriers sunk or (presumably) still damaged, there was essentially no need to leash them. The rest of the Kido Butai, with battlecruisers Hiei and Kirishima, raided the Indian Ocean and Ceylon, forcing the Royal Navy to move to Madagascar. The Kido Butai turned for home in late July, while the battlecruisers stayed behind to raid for a few more weeks. They dallied too long, and met the 15" guns of battlecruisers Hood and Repulse. Hiei and Kirishima were pounded under the waves by accurate long-range gunnery, the first Japanese loss of major fleet units since Ise and Hyuga.

After this disaster, the IJN once again withdrew into its shell. The Allied offensives would surely come soon, but not this year. The British were massing in Burma, but that was the Army's problem. The Navy was focused on the Americans, and the Americans simply did not have the carriers to attack in any strategically meaningful way at this time. Throughout the Pacific, the Japanese fortified themselves and waited. August, September, and October passed with intense fighting over the skies of Darwin and Timor, but no moves by the Americans. What, exactly, were they doing? Unbeknownst to the Japanese, their early successes against the US Navy had simply lent more weight to the "Germany Firsters". Admiral King did not get his massive reinforcements for the Pacific. Instead, Nimitz sat in Pearl, read SIGINT, and twiddled his thumbs for 6 months, having neither the strength to attack nor any attack to defend against. It couldn't last.

--

1943 to follow soon.

User avatar
Terminus
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: End of the road

Post by Terminus »

Good idea, Alikchi-san! Keep 'em coming!
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
User avatar
Capt. Harlock
Posts: 5379
Joined: Sat Sep 15, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Los Angeles
Contact:

RE: End of the road

Post by Capt. Harlock »

August, September, and October passed with intense fighting over the skies of Darwin and Timor, but no moves by the Americans. What, exactly, were they doing? Unbeknownst to the Japanese, their early successes against the US Navy had simply lent more weight to the "Germany Firsters". Admiral King did not get his massive reinforcements for the Pacific. Instead, Nimitz sat in Pearl, read SIGINT, and twiddled his thumbs for 6 months, having neither the strength to attack nor any attack to defend against.

Your alternate history means that the Allies kept two major areas: the Solomons chain and the Burma road. It seems likely there would be considerably more activity by Chines units, accompanied by Western troops and air squadrons. Likewise, there should be major airfield construction on the southern Solomons islands.
Civil war? What does that mean? Is there any foreign war? Isn't every war fought between men, between brothers?

--Victor Hugo
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

RE: End of the road

Post by Alikchi2 »

I will preface what I say by noting that I wrote this at four in the morning [;)]

You are quite correct about the Burma road - it had not even crossed my mind. The Chinese would probably play a much more active role. Well spotted.

I do not think that the Solomons will play as important of a role here. Tulagi and Guadalcanal remain in Australian hands, with US support - but not much of it. MacArthur is dead and SWPAC does not, technically, exist. American Army and Air Force units of course play a major role but not the overwhelming one they assumed after April 42 in our timeline. Instead, the Australians are essentially running their own on-off war against the Japanese with Allied support. The US (led by the USN) is saving its resources for a Central Pacific drive in 43.

Still, of course, there would be fighting - but nothing on the scale that we saw. The Solomons are not strategically important in the minds of anyone except the Australians.

Thanks for your comment! I will probably edit the above post to incorporate China and a few other things (the Coral Sea battle, for example - how did I forget to mention that? Argh). Anything else you spot would be appreciated. [:)]
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”