The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post descriptions of your brilliant successes and unfortunate demises.

Moderators: wdolson, Don Bowen, mogami

Cathartes
Posts: 1585
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2001 10:00 am

The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by Cathartes »

I stand behind all that is Good, Just, and Righteous. (Allies)
My opponent Chimaera represents all that is Dark, Nefarious, and Imperialist. (Japanese)

Chimaera, currently holds title to the “Plunder” part, while I currently reside under the words of “the Blunder and the Agony.” I'm hoping to share my titles.

This is an OPEN AAR, and both Chimaera and I will post and read here at our pleasure.

Be forewarned all ye seekers of truth! Chimaera may attempt to spread all sorts of propaganda and to spin events from his perspective. Don’t be fooled!


THE SKINNY
This is a CHS 155 game with PDUs on.
This AAR begins mid-June, 1942, after 6 months of slugging it out (game time).


House Rules

Allied damage control: ON
Weather: ON
PDU: ON

-No 4E bombing below 10K feet/ only operate from base size 4+ (B29s at 6+)
-2E Allied bomber can’t upgrade to 4E
-Japanese dive bombers can’t upgrade to Sallys or Helens (light 2E bombers only)
-50x stacking limit (+15%) per airbase level
-ASW TF max 6 ships
-No Allied air units (except AVG) can operate from China
-No Japanese strategic bombing of China
-6PT boats per TF max, 2 PT TFs per hex max
-Only base hex invasions allowed
-No sneaky sub invasions.
-No execution of prisoners
-No shooting dolphins (no exceptions!)


AAR Rules (more guidelines than strict rules)

-No subterfuge or propaganda
-No combat.txt (unless it really, really, really matters)
-No whining, hissing, or spitting
-No loitering
-No panicking
-Taunting and ribbing is allowed


Image
Attachments
drink.jpg
drink.jpg (38.5 KiB) Viewed 428 times
Cathartes
Posts: 1585
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2001 10:00 am

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by Cathartes »

Breezing over the last 6 months:

Pearl Harbor strike: The classic opening fails to sink any allied BBs. Major destruction of airfields and aircraft, but no fish dropped. The US Navy gets beat up badly but lives to fight another day!

Central Pacific: There are a few notable events: (1) Tarawa and Saipan have been taken by the Japanese, all other major CenPac islands remain untouched through June ‘42. (2) A clandestine US carrier raid west-northwest of Marcus Island caught a Japanese transport convoy by surprise back in early Feb ‘42. (3) Several forays by KB have thus far caught a few US destroyers and AKs. The USS Mississippi narrowly escapes being sunk by KB (Chimaera didn’t know how close he came!) after She took two fish and then KB darted into the vicinity. The sharks would remain hungry.

Papau New Guinea and SW Pac: Rabaul and Port Moresby are quickly taken early in the war. There was no chance to defend Port Moresby, and KB escorted an invasion force inside the Louisiade archipelago, and up toward Moresby. Rabaul is already an 8/8 base, and Moresby is a level 5 AF. Australian troops in New Guinea were successfully evacuated by sub transport. Having captured the key strategic bases in PNG, my opponent is now mopping up allied bases at his leisure. To the south, Koumac and Noumea have just fallen, giving the Japanese free reign over New Caledonia and surrounding water. Nonetheless it took the effort of the entire KB, dozens of IJA bombers, the 52nd Div, and three IJN LCUs over a 10-day siege to secure Noumea.

Australia: Wallabies wander hither and yon. One notable event was KB sweeping by to the north of Darwin early in the war, assisting with the landings in Timor. As KB skirted by, a mass of my Hudson bombers, which I had forgotten were on naval attack, sortied out and were met by 130 Zeros. Not one Hudson made it through, and all their crews (those that survived to bail out) became bait for wandering Leopard Sharks. We hate leopard sharks, they are the most feared sharks across the warm-water Pacific. While we will not shoot dolphins (unlike the evil Japanese Empire) we will happily strafe leopard sharks.

DEI: One word describes it: Firestorm. Only minor base remains in NW Borneo along with Bali and Manado (as of mid-June ’42). Everything else has fallen. Palembang was captured with all its resources intact—so much for moving extra engineer units into it ($#%$&!). Japanese losses were light overall. IJA divisions did all the gruntwork in the DEI. They were supported by powerful surface TFs and elements of KB. A huge force of CAs and BBs with their collection of naval search aircraft covered all the major invasions. They were impenetrable by air and by sea. Allied subs were spotted instantly and everywhere when in range of large numbers of Japanese patrol planes. KB’s massive, impenetrable CAP moved where the invasion forces moved. Only after they passed could I hope to achieve a few hits with the Dutch AF—a few AKs and APs succumbed to hit and run tactics. Java was entirely over by early March, easily overrun by many IJA divisions and supporting elements.

Malaysia: Also easily swept up (with one of the wide, thick-bristled industrial brooms, like you use on driveways), though Singapore held out through the 3rd week of February. Sumatra waits for its mopping.

Phillipines: This was the neglected child at the expense of the DEI. Chimaera completely ignored Luzon unit the beginning of April. Early on he took a base or two in the southern PI and used it as a covering air base to catch fleeing allied ships and his ventures toward Borneo and beyond. A lot of my transports managed to escape by mid-December ’41—due east across the Central Pacific to the US west coast. Several DDs and the USS Houston and USS Langley were sunk by light Japanese carriers. Joining baby KB was at least one large Japanese carrier (think it was Akagi) that did not join the others in the Pearl Harbor strike. Chimaera has only now moved into Luzon in May/June. Previously PTs have been playing a cat and mouse game all over Luzon and Mindinao. They managed to make a few surprise attacks on transport convoys sending a few escorting MSWs, PCs and a APDs to the bottom. My PTs were a small thorn in the side of my opponent, but he pursued them to death with surface TFs and by air. Up until now, my troops have been lazy in Luzon, drinking heavily, sleeping in every morning, and doing a lot of nothing. Even McArthur has been seen boozing it up at the local Manilla watering holes. Once in a while the AVG paid a visit to our local airfield and surprised a few IJA bombers over the neighborhood. We used to wander Luzon at leisure, hunting, visiting old friends, and soaking up the Malaria-infested air. But now… we are getting regularly bombarded by over 5,000 AV worth of IJN troops, with more coming from Naga. The first deliberate attack just took place on June 17, 1942.

South Pacific: Crickets are chirping from palm frond rafts afloat the moonlit ocean. KB wanders.

New Zealand: Sheep grazing on steep hillsides.

Alaska/Aleutians: An Orca pod is sighted off Kodiak and my Bolo pilots gain one experience point.

China: Overall quiet until April ’42 when Chinese elements sneak up on Swatow (just east of Canton) and take it from the Japanese. Only a base unit was defending it. Also, an IJA division was moved out of Canton for the war abroad, and smelling opportunity, a mass of Chinese units descended on the city and are now lodged within (about 3000 AV worth). The Chnese attacked once and bled horribly. Blunder. Currently they are target practice for Japanese LBA. The Japanese have since retaken Swatow after I abandoned it and sent the troops to Canton. Otherwise China remains a relative backwater to the war where my opponent transfers more and more troops from.

Burma: All hell breaks loose in March. Chimaera finished wiping up in Singapore and DEI and then sailed his troops up to invade Moulmein via the Makassar straights. I could see his little plan coming a long ways off and I tried to maneuver most of the British Navy into striking position. I couldn’t believe my opponent was going for this with only one airbase —Bangkok— providing search and cover. He had Tavoy, but no one was home in the runway. Making a long story short, I lunged too quickly and gave away my little plan. Tavoy quickly filled with Bettys and Nells, and I managed to lose a lot of CLs and a couple DDs. If I had only waited a little longer, until he committed to the invasion, I may have done better. I bungled an epic opportunity that may have stemmed the tide in Burma for months to come. Instead, Chimaera’s seemingly poor risk turned into a golden capitalization, and he is now knocking on the gates of Mandalay Palace, although the knocking has been going on for almost 6 weeks now. Mandaly has become a fetid cesspool of sinking morale, disease, death, and disintegration (5 points for alliteration here).

Below is a broad look at the extent of Japanese expansion and plunder. Key bases are shown in ownership at the margins, red for Japanese and white for Allies. JUNE 1942:


Image
Attachments
mapJune42.jpg
mapJune42.jpg (70.62 KiB) Viewed 428 times
Chimaera
Posts: 48
Joined: Wed Dec 05, 2007 5:54 pm

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by Chimaera »

My respected opponent has done a great job outlining the opening phases of the war, except where the blatant Allied propaganda machine is at work. For example, it is the evil Western powers who are the imperialists. Japan is merely liberating her oppressed Asian brothers from their yoke. The discerning reader is encouraged to completely disregard those erroneous portions. [:)]
 
I include some statistics as of June 18th, 1942.
 
Total aircraft lost 1272 Allied to 1020 Japanese.
Air-to-air kills are 633 Allied to 299 Japanese. Relatively few large scale air battles so far. The Allies have been so overawed by the performance of the A6M2 that they generally refuse to engage our air on even terms [;)]
 
Ship losses stand at 153 Allied to 58 for the Kaigun. The Allied figure includes 1 heavy cruiser, 8 light cruisers and 14 destroyers. We are pleased to note that Japan has not lost even a single destroyer at this point. Banzai!
 
Troop losses are 6406 Allied to 345 Japanese. Three very significant hauls of Allied prisoners were taken at Singapore (about 105,000), Soerabaja (29,640) and Merak (41,557).
 
Land campaigns

Very significant forces are currently committed in Burma (mostly at Mandalay) and at Manila in the Philippines. Despite heroic efforts, progress at Mandalay has been slow. The Allies enjoy considerable advantages there, including the terrain and proximity to a major Allied colony/supply base (India). At Manila, the enemy – over 100,000 troops - is well dug-in and is making excellent use of the heavily fortified city. It will require major efforts to eradicate this large army.
 
Major enemy units are also investing Canton, but General Shunroku Hata (commanding the China Expeditionary Army) has assured me that the defenses there are impregnable.
 
Naval war

The Kaigun rules the waves. The enemy has not dared to make significant sorties for some months now. Admiral Yamamoto is surprised. He had not reckoned on such a quick collapse in Allied (naval) morale.
User avatar
Jim D Burns
Posts: 3989
Joined: Mon Feb 25, 2002 6:00 pm
Location: Salida, CA.

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by Jim D Burns »

ORIGINAL: Cathartes
Nonetheless it took the effort of the entire KB, dozens of IJA bombers, the 52nd Div, and three IJN LCUs over a 10-day siege to secure Noumea.


What was the island defended with, my game is just getting to the Noumea part of the campaign.

Jim
Cathartes
Posts: 1585
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2001 10:00 am

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by Cathartes »

What was the island defended with, my game is just getting to the Noumea part of the campaign.

Jim

Dilemma of an open AAR: do I remind my opponent of exactly what I was defending with in Noumea? He may tell you if he knows. If he forgot it may be slightly helpful to me. I will say my AV was about 145. I had a base force, one small infantry unit, and one medium-sized unit. I will divulge for the entertainment of my lucky opponent that I was just about to unload a certain large infantry unit onto Noumea when KB was spotted nearby. I nearly pulled off what you are doing now, however, my supply situation may have been in doubt if I managed to land the extra troops.

My 140 odd AV put up a good fight, and the first adjusted defensive AV was over 400--initially against two naval units. The division joined the fight several turns later. He needed to mass a LOT of bombers and use over 180 dive bombers to pummel my position over the course of 10-12 turns. I was surprised I had done so well, but I think his units were fatigued from the trip down from Koumac.
Cathartes
Posts: 1585
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2001 10:00 am

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by Cathartes »

Harken back to 1975 (for those of you that had graced the world by then--like me). Were you a boxing fan? If not you might have at least been a Muhammad Ali fan. September 1975 had the original "Thrilla in Manilla".

Well unbeknownst to all of you, the first "Thrilla in Manilla" was June 17, 1942. This was the date that the Imperial Japanese forces suffered their worst single-day ground loss of the war. Over 22,000 casualties and 363 guns were destroyed while our brave-hearted American and Phillipine forces, with their backs to the wall in this well-healed, care-free, sophisticated Pacific city, suffered a mere 3000 odd casualties with 89 guns destroyed.

Now let's not talk about the fact that Ali dodged the draft, so as not to taint the comparison here, but let's see if we can go 15 rounds against these chumps. With level 9 forts and an urban hex, we might be able to go the distance!

The Japanese are in fact well prepared and can take the punishment. The have amassed nearly 300,000 men, 2,000 guns with a total of appr. 7,000 AV!




Image
Attachments
tim.jpg
tim.jpg (32.21 KiB) Viewed 428 times
Chimaera
Posts: 48
Joined: Wed Dec 05, 2007 5:54 pm

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by Chimaera »

Noumea was secured by a combined-arms effort on May 18th. Almost 6,500 Allied soldiers were captured there. The 14th New Zealand Brigade put up a spirited fight but was essentially destroyed at Noumea. The evil Yankees obviously have few qualms letting their lesser allies take the body blows …
 
The Allied correspondent erred about the Japanese losses in Manila. Both sides took heavy losses, but never doubt that it is the Allies (who have nowhere to run and finite supplies) who will concede first.
 
In other news, Thursday Island was taken by a daring use of our parachute forces. Almost 1,000 prisoners were captured there.
User avatar
BigBadWolf
Posts: 584
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2007 7:01 am
Location: Serbia

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by BigBadWolf »

Ah, yes, the evil American propaganda... After all, what is few thousands lives compared to the glory of the Empire? [:)]
Image
Chimaera
Posts: 48
Joined: Wed Dec 05, 2007 5:54 pm

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by Chimaera »

ORIGINAL: BigBadWolf
Ah, yes, the evil American propaganda... After all, what is few thousands lives compared to the glory of the Empire? [:)]

Hear hear! [:D]

And welcome to the thread.
Cathartes
Posts: 1585
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2001 10:00 am

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by Cathartes »

No propoganda here. We've got Boy Scouts running the press and they tell it like it is.

Bulletin Chittagong, June 19, 1942: Japanese Bettys and Zeros make two strikes against transport shipping over the port. The strikes are sharply rebuffed resulting in over 35 Japanese Zeros shot down along with several Betty bombers. The Allies suffer only a few airframes lost. Unfortunately one transport is sunk, but it managed to unload a very large supply of Bombay Sapphire gin before going under.




Image
Attachments
airbattle1.jpg
airbattle1.jpg (28.87 KiB) Viewed 428 times
User avatar
cantona2
Posts: 3749
Joined: Mon May 21, 2007 2:45 pm
Location: Gibraltar

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by cantona2 »

Are those stock plane tops?
1966 was a great year for English Football...Eric was born

Cathartes
Posts: 1585
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2001 10:00 am

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by Cathartes »

Cantona2: made them myself--have my own custom set. Many are in the latest BigB mod.
User avatar
cantona2
Posts: 3749
Joined: Mon May 21, 2007 2:45 pm
Location: Gibraltar

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by cantona2 »

Cathartes
 
Take my hat off to you, they look brilliant[&o]
1966 was a great year for English Football...Eric was born

User avatar
HMS Resolution
Posts: 350
Joined: Wed Jan 10, 2007 3:31 pm

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by HMS Resolution »

Cleverly written AAR so far, gentlemen. I'm enjoying reading it. Keep us posted on the wallabies.
Image
Chimaera
Posts: 48
Joined: Wed Dec 05, 2007 5:54 pm

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by Chimaera »

June 23rd

Two small but noteworthy successes were scored today.

SS KVII was hit twice by aerial AP bombs off Luzon and sank quickly.

In a sharp air battle over Amboina, 5 B-17Es were brought down for the loss of 1 A6M2. Raiding at 15,000 feet, damage to the airbase was very slight and several other planes on the ground suffered minor shrapnel damage.





Image
Attachments
AirJun231942.jpg
AirJun231942.jpg (12.4 KiB) Viewed 428 times
Cathartes
Posts: 1585
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2001 10:00 am

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by Cathartes »

The Japanese propaganda factory is at it again! In fact only one B-17 was shot down, 4 others were lost to ops. You can ask the experienced pilots that made it home alive! Also, some 7 Japanese Zeros were destroyed, mostly on the ground AND two turns later, Chimaera-san is STILL repairing the damage at Amboina. This is all minor stuff, but it's a classic example of the ongoing Japanese Propaganda Machine!


It's June 23, 1942 and two days ago the Japanese began moving troops out of Mandalay. Chimaera-san has been trying to take Mandalay since mid-April. It has been a bloody quagmire. The forts have dropped to as low as level 6, but are now back up to level 9. The hapless Japanese troops are bombarded constantly from the air. They are languishing and growing weak from malaria and poor morale.

Is Chimaera-san now withdrawing? Rotating troops? Time will tell, but so far, our stalwart, multi-national troops have held fast for two months in Mandalay!


Image
Attachments
mandalayconf.jpg
mandalayconf.jpg (58.34 KiB) Viewed 428 times
User avatar
BigBadWolf
Posts: 584
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2007 7:01 am
Location: Serbia

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by BigBadWolf »

Bah, no one is believing your lies. Imperial Army does not suffer from bad morale, for they fight for their Emperor, and what can one ask more in life? Soon, Burma and India shall be liberated from your oppresive yoke!

[:)]
Image
Cathartes
Posts: 1585
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2001 10:00 am

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by Cathartes »

June 25, 1942
The Japanese Imperial Army has withdrawn from Mandalay! Recon has shown enemy troops, guns, and vehicles streaming south towards Rangoon. Mandalay has held! While it's not quite time to break out the champagne, it is time to breathe a little easier, and take some much needed R&R.

Is this a tactical victory, the end of Imperial Japan's efforts against Mandalay? We will not rush to any conclusions just yet. But this is certain: the Allies positively ruled the skies over Mandalay. It was the air war that carried the defense of Mandalay. Aerial re-supply, heavy CAP, and continuous bombardment turned the tide.

The Third AVG in a victory flight over the Irrawaddy:

Image
Attachments
3rdAVG.jpg
3rdAVG.jpg (56.63 KiB) Viewed 428 times
Chimaera
Posts: 48
Joined: Wed Dec 05, 2007 5:54 pm

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by Chimaera »

June 25th

Japan's withdrawal from Mandalay is merely tactical. To paraphrase a famous commander, who happens to share names with one of the Kaigun's heavy cruisers - we are not retreating, merely attacking in a different direction! Our forces are intact and moving in a disciplined manner (no routs, shoving, jeering, panicking).

Imperial forces also secured an important piece of Australian territory at Portland Roads. There was no opposition.

We also received confirmation that the Dutch submarine KX sank off Luzon, almost certainly as a result of aerial AP bomb hits suffered earlier.




Image
SS KX circa 1940
Attachments
SSKX.jpg
SSKX.jpg (11.88 KiB) Viewed 428 times
User avatar
NormS3
Posts: 526
Joined: Mon Dec 10, 2007 9:31 pm
Location: Wild and Wonderful WV, just don't drink the water
Contact:

RE: The Plunder, the Blunder, and the Agony

Post by NormS3 »

Good AAR.  Really like the tops Cathartes.
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”