Page 1 of 1
BOA benchmark
Posted: Tue Sep 02, 2025 4:05 pm
by boldairade
How do you know how you are doing as the axis in the BOA?
For instance: how many MM would you need to sink by 1/1/41 in order to be pressuring the UK?
Re: BOA benchmark
Posted: Wed Sep 03, 2025 2:19 am
by Nirosi
It is very tough to say as it depends on how many MMs UK has build in the previous year.
For the same amount of damage you could put the UK in big trouble (most beginner UK player build too few MMs even tough it should the main a priority of its build) or not that much.
But the UK can also "hurt" by buying too many. If the UK is serious and buys MMs every second turn in 1940, it should be "ok" (hopefully) in 1941 even if the Germans are serious and reach 9-12 active U-boats. But if the Germans do no invest much in u-boats, then the UK has probably build too many MMs and that will still "hurt" them even if it will never miss MMs, just because of the opportunity cost.
Re: BOA benchmark
Posted: Wed Sep 03, 2025 1:28 pm
by boldairade
Nirosi wrote: Wed Sep 03, 2025 2:19 am
It is very tough to say as it depends on how many MMs UK has build in the previous year.
For the same amount of damage you could put the UK in big trouble (most beginner UK player build too few MMs even tough it should the main a priority of its build) or not that much.
But the UK can also "hurt" by buying too many. If the UK is serious and buys MMs every second turn in 1940, it should be "ok" (hopefully) in 1941 even if the Germans are serious and reach 9-12 active U-boats. But if the Germans do no invest much in u-boats, then the UK has probably build too many MMs and that will still "hurt" them even if it will never miss MMs, just because of the opportunity cost.
this is a good answer.
It's also a good illustration of WP's ability to mirror real world choices.
many nations invested hugely in the 'wrong' resources, often for what seemed the right reasons.
also, good to hear from you old friend/sparring partner
Re: BOA benchmark
Posted: Wed Sep 03, 2025 2:06 pm
by Nirosi
I still remember our game fondly. It was epic!
