15 September 1918
After the evacuation of Baku, a disgusted Lieutenant-Colonel John Warden, highly critical of his commander, recorded in his diary:
[font="Times New Roman"]
Baku could have been held by good sound management & organization but Gen. Dunsterville was not capable of doing either & his staff was far worse … Mjr. Gen. Dunsterville should be made a full Gen. & knighted & kicked out as they do everyone who makes a mess of his job.
[/font]
This appears to be highly unfair to Dunsterville. The task of defending Baku was actually nearly impossible: the attackers were superior in equipment, supplies, training, and above all they enjoyed unity of command. It is well worth noting that Dunsterville controlled less than a tenth of the anti-Ottoman coalition soldiers. The Russians were essentially mercenaries receiving very little support from either the Red or the White armies, and the Armenians were not fighting for their own soil.
Whether Dunsterville did a good job or not, he was blamed for the fall of Baku, and actually treated somewhat worse than Colonel Warden’s suggestion. He would receive neither knighthood nor promotion, and appears to have languished in obscurity for the rest of his life. His Dunsterforce, however, had achieved one major strategic objective. In the limited time they had left until the end of the war. the Ottomans and their German advisers were unable to deliver any of the precious oil to the Central Powers; the first shipment appears to have gone only as far as Georgia. And meanwhile, the fuel-starved German air force was losing control of the skies to the Allies.
Although the city of Baku was now essentially defenseless, the Ottoman commanders decided not to send in their regular troops just yet. Instead, the less disciplined irregular forces, and in particular the soldiers known as Bashi-Bazouks, entered first. Everyone knew what that meant: for decades the Bashi-Bazouks had been a watchword for atrocity.

And the Muslims had a massacre of their own to avenge: with the weakening of law that followed the collapse of the Russian Empire, there had been a terrible pogrom known as the “March Days" in Baku. Roughly 10,000 people had been killed, the great majority of those being Muslims killed by ethnic Armenians.
Many of the Armenians in Baku crowded to the harbor in a desperate effort to escape, but virtually all of the ships had sailed with the evacuation of the Dunsterforce the evening before. And because Baku is located on a peninsula into the Caspian Sea, there was no other route open. Wholesale killing began, the last major massacre of WWI. The Bashi-Bazouks did not spare women or children, and it appears that a number of the regular troops of the Islamic Army of the Caucasus joined in, against the orders to stay out of the city for two days. The German advisers in the area protested the slaughter, and asked the Ottoman commanders to stop it. They were ignored.
At St Mihiel in France, the Americans completed their mopping-up operations. They had captured 15,000 Central Powers soldiers, and had killed 2,000 and wounded 5,500 more. The cost had been relatively low, but oddly, the Allies had lost 4,500 men killed and only 2,500 wounded. But it appears that the Americans became overconfident, and their next action would be against troops determined to hold rather than withdraw.
The Central Powers began definite moves towards peace. The German government, hoping to divide the Allies, made a formal peace offer to Belgium. The Austro-hungarian government sent a diplomatic note to President Wilson, proposing a peace conference.
In northern Greece, General Franchet d’Esperey had managed to bring his Allied Army of the Orient up to 31 divisions: 8 French, 6 Greek, 7 British, 6 Serbian, and 4 Italian. They were under-strength from sickness and thin in artillery, but d’Esperey had finally received permission for an offensive. There were 19 divisions opposing him: 17 Bulgarian and 2 Ottoman. This might have been enough for defense in the mountainous terrain, but the Bulgarians were tired of war by this time.
The Allies launched the attack in two places. The British were assigned the toughest task; an assault against a well-defended range of hills. They made very little progress on this date. Happily for the Allies, it was primarily a holding attack, meant to stop the Bulgarians from reinforcing the Dobro Pole Ridge, where the main thrust was made. Here the French and Serbians inched forward, gaining some key high ground. Far more important was the effect on the Bulgarian troops, many of whom broke and ran from the artillery barrages, infantry fire, and airplane attacks. When sundown brought a temporary lull in the fighting, almost half of the 12,000 Bulgarian troops opposing the French and Serbian attack were out of the fight. This included 3,000 captured and 2,689 killed. In addition, about a third of the Bulgarian artillery had been seized. In turn, the Allies had lost 1,700 French and 200 Serbian casualties, serious enough, but still leaving the units ready and willing to fight.

Civil war? What does that mean? Is there any foreign war? Isn't every war fought between men, between brothers?
--Victor Hugo