Planet Generation: Geology Report

Moderator: Vic

Post Reply
zgrssd
Posts: 5101
Joined: Tue Jun 09, 2020 1:02 pm

Planet Generation: Geology Report

Post by zgrssd »

The Geology report is not giving nearly enough/the right information. Here is what I think it needs:

Mountains:
Should be split into high and low mountain.
Some other hard terrain like sand dunes should also be counted - if that is possible. Of course, forrests are a problem.

Water:

Problem 1: You only tell us how much Ocean Water there is. Lakes can just as well provide rain. Plus providing fresh water and being just about as hindering as the oceans. "Surface Water" could be a better term, that can include lakes and oceans equally.

Problem 2: The water can be very heavily localized. It could be that all the water is basically on 1/4 of the planet. Meaning that roughly only 1/2 of the planet has actually farmable land. The rest can be a giant desert.
It is not so much about how much rain there is, but how well it is distributed.
A "Arid" Hex count for everything to dry for hosting grass would be helpfull.

Temperature:
Water can be in regions so cold, it is all frozen over. Wich prohibits producing rain.
You already know the temperatures and wich body of water is salty. So it should be relatively easy to figure out.
Ideally this would also be substracted from "Surface Water".

If you can not actually do it preciesly before Biology, at least give us a estimate.
User avatar
GodwinW
Posts: 511
Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2020 9:05 pm

RE: Planet Generation: Geology Report

Post by GodwinW »

This is why I toggle the option to 'complete FoW after terrain generation', so that I can check the map itself and see if it looks cool/fun to me.

Try it out :)
zgrssd
Posts: 5101
Joined: Tue Jun 09, 2020 1:02 pm

RE: Planet Generation: Geology Report

Post by zgrssd »

ORIGINAL: GodwinW

This is why I toggle the option to 'complete FoW after terrain generation', so that I can check the map itself and see if it looks cool/fun to me.

Try it out :)
I run only with partial fog of war.
User avatar
Malevolence
Posts: 1798
Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2010 11:12 am

RE: Planet Generation: Geology Report

Post by Malevolence »

It doesn't show you the map during planet creation?
Nicht kleckern, sondern klotzen!

*Please remember all posts are made by a malevolent, autocratic despot whose rule is marked by unjust severity and arbitrary behavior. Your experiences may vary.
User avatar
GodwinW
Posts: 511
Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2020 9:05 pm

RE: Planet Generation: Geology Report

Post by GodwinW »

ORIGINAL: zgrssd

ORIGINAL: GodwinW

This is why I toggle the option to 'complete FoW after terrain generation', so that I can check the map itself and see if it looks cool/fun to me.

Try it out :)
I run only with partial fog of war.

Well then, maybe you didn't know you can move the map during the generation phase? Click to close the planet generation tab and you can inspect the map in detail.
Atros
Posts: 48
Joined: Thu Jun 25, 2020 9:09 pm

RE: Planet Generation: Geology Report

Post by Atros »

ORIGINAL: zgrssd

The Geology report is not giving nearly enough/the right information. Here is what I think it needs:

Mountains:
Should be split into high and low mountain.
Some other hard terrain like sand dunes should also be counted - if that is possible. Of course, forrests are a problem.

Water:

Problem 1: You only tell us how much Ocean Water there is. Lakes can just as well provide rain. Plus providing fresh water and being just about as hindering as the oceans. "Surface Water" could be a better term, that can include lakes and oceans equally.

Problem 2: The water can be very heavily localized. It could be that all the water is basically on 1/4 of the planet. Meaning that roughly only 1/2 of the planet has actually farmable land. The rest can be a giant desert.
It is not so much about how much rain there is, but how well it is distributed.
A "Arid" Hex count for everything to dry for hosting grass would be helpfull.

Temperature:
Water can be in regions so cold, it is all frozen over. Wich prohibits producing rain.
You already know the temperatures and wich body of water is salty. So it should be relatively easy to figure out.
Ideally this would also be substracted from "Surface Water".

If you can not actually do it preciesly before Biology, at least give us a estimate.

I agree on the water part that there should be more options to affect the water distribution.

On the physical side, generally other water bodies than oceans have minimal effect on rains, as the vaporization rate is usually much smaller on anything else than oceans and seas for lower overall volume of water and the vaporization surface area. Also the sweet water deposits tend to mainly form where it rains most, which is downwind from the oceans (winds tend to most commonly blow planetary rotation direction near equator and opposite direction everywhere else, same as water currents. See Coriolis effect). Naturally there can be planetary traits like mountains and "pressure magnets" like large seas that affect the wind directions locally, but Coriolis tends to be the main deciding factor in large scale air movement.

Also there is physical effect known as sublimation, which causes water on solid form (ice/snow) to instantly turn into gaseous form, which does contribute to rain. This is the basic reason why there can be blizzards and snow-rain on planets that are covered with ice. Because the sublimation takes more energy than vaporization, it generally takes more time for rain clouds to form in icy settings than around open water seas.

Anyways, personally my favorite settings are planets where are great deserts with some farming oasis' around the main water bodies that everybody is fighting over.
Post Reply

Return to “Suggestions and Feedback”