Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
- EarlyDoors
- Posts: 758
- Joined: Sun Dec 16, 2018 10:28 am
- Location: uk
- Contact:
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
April 1942 - Battle for the Atlantic
The MTB HMS Cheetah is lost in skirmish with the German Battle Cruiser Guiseneau in the North Sea.
Observers at Gibraltar spot the Italian Battleship Giulio Cesare heading for the open Atlantic
At the moment the UK-USSR Arctic Convoy is providing a vital lifeline. There is more loss around the Commonwealth Convoys from Canada and Sudan.
The MTB HMS Cheetah is lost in skirmish with the German Battle Cruiser Guiseneau in the North Sea.
Observers at Gibraltar spot the Italian Battleship Giulio Cesare heading for the open Atlantic
At the moment the UK-USSR Arctic Convoy is providing a vital lifeline. There is more loss around the Commonwealth Convoys from Canada and Sudan.
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
Thanks, Brave, for helping solve the riddle. I never notice that hex 129,46 was a marsh hex.
May 10th 1942
The Allies lost a good number of ships since the war started: the Royal Navy deployed 32 naval units and the US Navy 21 for a total of 53. The Axis had a total of 51 naval units with Germany 18, Italy 9 and Japan 24. Almost Naval parity in the Oceans. Axis naval strategy from the beginning of the war have been to sink as many Allied ships as possible. No big naval battles had taken place yet, but in continuous small naval actions the Allies kept losing ships every turn.
German U-Boote have not attacked seriously the Allied convoy lanes so far, the UK and the USSR losing few MPPs. But from April 1942, with new German type III U-Boote available, the incoming UK convoys in the Atlantic were furiously attacked (140 MPPs lost).
With no investment at all in new technologies since 1940, the UK economy was not growing and their troops and ships were lagging behind in all kind of new weapons. The Fuhrer’s idea was to strangle
the UK economy, centered in supplying Stalin with as many MPPs as possible. With a collected income of about 270 MPPs, if we could sink 200 MPPs each month not much would be left to organize any kind of offensive actions against the Reich.
The USA started a new round of intensive research while their diplomats bullied the Turkish government…
May 10th 1942
The Allies lost a good number of ships since the war started: the Royal Navy deployed 32 naval units and the US Navy 21 for a total of 53. The Axis had a total of 51 naval units with Germany 18, Italy 9 and Japan 24. Almost Naval parity in the Oceans. Axis naval strategy from the beginning of the war have been to sink as many Allied ships as possible. No big naval battles had taken place yet, but in continuous small naval actions the Allies kept losing ships every turn.
German U-Boote have not attacked seriously the Allied convoy lanes so far, the UK and the USSR losing few MPPs. But from April 1942, with new German type III U-Boote available, the incoming UK convoys in the Atlantic were furiously attacked (140 MPPs lost).
With no investment at all in new technologies since 1940, the UK economy was not growing and their troops and ships were lagging behind in all kind of new weapons. The Fuhrer’s idea was to strangle
the UK economy, centered in supplying Stalin with as many MPPs as possible. With a collected income of about 270 MPPs, if we could sink 200 MPPs each month not much would be left to organize any kind of offensive actions against the Reich.
The USA started a new round of intensive research while their diplomats bullied the Turkish government…
La clé est l'état d'esprit
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
Stalin’s economy was strong (800 MPPs per turn) and the Red Army was able to replace all lost troops but depended on the continuous supply of the incoming MPPs form the Western Democracies. Soviet Morale was at 81%, UK 75%, India 72% and China 71%.
Things were heating in the South Pacific. Our Intelligence Office in Tokyo reported the presence of a US CV near Samoa. That meant that the US Navy was surely planning an invasion of the island (and the “activation of the auto-spanning US marine tanks”). After the capture of the Marshalls and the Gilberts the US Navy had sailed south…
With as many as possibly 3 US CVs in the South Pacific Admiral Yamamoto dispatched Admiral Nagumo with 3 CVs and 3 BBs to the Palau Islands. Nagumo was told to be ready to engage the enemy US Task Force at short notice. Additionally, 2 subs and a CVL were sent to Carolinas Islands to protect Truk Atoll.
Things were also heating in the North Sea. The Royal Navy have been involved for months in a series of low intensity naval attrition battles in the area. During April 1942 the Kriegsmarine ventured out in force looking for a fight. A series of naval engagements would take place during the following turns, the Royal Navy taking heavy losses. Our 2 naval bombers were operating from Norway’s south coast covered by Luftwaffe fighters.
Things were heating in the South Pacific. Our Intelligence Office in Tokyo reported the presence of a US CV near Samoa. That meant that the US Navy was surely planning an invasion of the island (and the “activation of the auto-spanning US marine tanks”). After the capture of the Marshalls and the Gilberts the US Navy had sailed south…
With as many as possibly 3 US CVs in the South Pacific Admiral Yamamoto dispatched Admiral Nagumo with 3 CVs and 3 BBs to the Palau Islands. Nagumo was told to be ready to engage the enemy US Task Force at short notice. Additionally, 2 subs and a CVL were sent to Carolinas Islands to protect Truk Atoll.
Things were also heating in the North Sea. The Royal Navy have been involved for months in a series of low intensity naval attrition battles in the area. During April 1942 the Kriegsmarine ventured out in force looking for a fight. A series of naval engagements would take place during the following turns, the Royal Navy taking heavy losses. Our 2 naval bombers were operating from Norway’s south coast covered by Luftwaffe fighters.
La clé est l'état d'esprit
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
In the AGC area of operations, General von Leeb, was at last ready to start his offensive after refitting his forces. For unknow reasons the Soviets were fortifying the heavily forested Rzhev-Vyazma area, but no fortifications were built in the plains between Vyazma and Bryansk. Bryansk was an important railroad supply hub, defended by natural defenses and an entrenched Army. The undefended corridor leading to Kaluga (undefended!) was chosen as the main axis of advance.
Further south, General von Manstein divided his AGS in 2 forces. He dispatched General von Bock to Salsk with 2 panzerkorps, 2 Armies and the 2 paras to take control of the Caucasus oil fields near Baku.
That left him fewer troops to attack Voronezh and Stalingrad. The remaining assault forces available were 2 panzerkorps and 2 German Armies backed by 1 AT, 2 artillery units and 2 mot Infantry corps. But 5 veteran Luftwaffe bombers were under his command and the 11th Panzerkorps, operated to Voroshilovgrad from their trip back from Egypt, was a most welcomed reinforcement.
Further south, General von Manstein divided his AGS in 2 forces. He dispatched General von Bock to Salsk with 2 panzerkorps, 2 Armies and the 2 paras to take control of the Caucasus oil fields near Baku.
That left him fewer troops to attack Voronezh and Stalingrad. The remaining assault forces available were 2 panzerkorps and 2 German Armies backed by 1 AT, 2 artillery units and 2 mot Infantry corps. But 5 veteran Luftwaffe bombers were under his command and the 11th Panzerkorps, operated to Voroshilovgrad from their trip back from Egypt, was a most welcomed reinforcement.
La clé est l'état d'esprit
- EarlyDoors
- Posts: 758
- Joined: Sun Dec 16, 2018 10:28 am
- Location: uk
- Contact:
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
May 1942
The Communist Chinese New 4th Army is destroyed and Sian falls leading to a morale drop. China also loses its 10th and 42nd Armies but is able to welcome a new ally as Japan declares war on the USSR and strikes at Vladivostock.
Unaware that their prescence has been detected the US Pacific fleet prepares to invade Samoa. The US do now have level 3 Spying & Intellligence.
Slim arrives to take charge of the defence of India just as the 11th Army north of Bilaspur are destroyed.
The experienced flight crews of RAF Bomber Command are in low morale after their time in Norway and in a low state of readiness their attacks on Bombay and its port are repulsed with losses.
The Communist Chinese New 4th Army is destroyed and Sian falls leading to a morale drop. China also loses its 10th and 42nd Armies but is able to welcome a new ally as Japan declares war on the USSR and strikes at Vladivostock.
Unaware that their prescence has been detected the US Pacific fleet prepares to invade Samoa. The US do now have level 3 Spying & Intellligence.
Slim arrives to take charge of the defence of India just as the 11th Army north of Bilaspur are destroyed.
The experienced flight crews of RAF Bomber Command are in low morale after their time in Norway and in a low state of readiness their attacks on Bombay and its port are repulsed with losses.
- EarlyDoors
- Posts: 758
- Joined: Sun Dec 16, 2018 10:28 am
- Location: uk
- Contact:
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
May 1942 - Western Hemisphere
Germany & Italy declare war on the USA. The convoys were hit last month and a uboat menaces shipping off Newfoundland. US Maritime Bomber and destroyers respond to the threat.
Skirmishes with the Prinz Eugen and Tirpitz or Bismarck off Trondheim lead to the loss of the Free French Light Cruiser Triomphant.
The Soviet force at Riga is assaulted from all sides. Army group centre heads for the Vyazma -> Bryansk gap. USSR anti-tanks guns are refitting and upgrading at Gorky. They are much needed.
Soviet Paratroopers land from across the Caspian Sea and repluse their German counterparts. The railline to Grozny is re-established. Soviets lose 3 Corps, an Engineer and AA unit this month.
Germany & Italy declare war on the USA. The convoys were hit last month and a uboat menaces shipping off Newfoundland. US Maritime Bomber and destroyers respond to the threat.
Skirmishes with the Prinz Eugen and Tirpitz or Bismarck off Trondheim lead to the loss of the Free French Light Cruiser Triomphant.
The Soviet force at Riga is assaulted from all sides. Army group centre heads for the Vyazma -> Bryansk gap. USSR anti-tanks guns are refitting and upgrading at Gorky. They are much needed.
Soviet Paratroopers land from across the Caspian Sea and repluse their German counterparts. The railline to Grozny is re-established. Soviets lose 3 Corps, an Engineer and AA unit this month.
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
The weather in AGC was muddy and General von Leeb couldn’t capture Kaluga. No less than 5 Soviet Armies were defending the Central Soviet Front, but their disposition was weird, with too much emphasis given to the Rzhev-Vyazma area. Riga was captured for the second time.
General von Manstein installed his HQ in Rostov, well supplied with a port level 6. After a heavy air attack followed by an artillery bombardment the key city of Voronezh was captured. The fall of this city created a huge gap in the Soviet lines. Not only was Stalingrad threatened from the north, but Saratov, Kuybyshev and Moscow were also now in danger. Our spearhead units already advanced east along the Voronezh-Saratov Road. The Red Army would have a lot of trouble covering all the new threatened areas, not counting with the new Japanese Far East front…
The newly arrived 11th panzerkorps was instructed to cross the Don River together with the AT unit. They will protect the left flank of General von Bock, moving south deeper into the Caucasus, and also menacing the southern approaches of Stalingrad. The main railroad leading to Baku was again cut by a mot Infantry corps.
In a bold move aiming Baku, our paras jumped for a second time this summer. Baku was defended by a recently arrived Soviet Army, but they captured both of Baku´s oil fields even though they finished the turn unsupplied. The siege of Krasnodar began, and an elite German Army entered the Crimean Peninsula.
In India, Japanese forces were almost within reach of Delhi, the Capital being undefended. Calcutta was under siege, but our forces were not well supplied and suffered from low readiness. In China our troops slowly pushed the defenders back step by step…
In the North Sea, German Naval forces surprised a Royal Navy Task Force and managed to sink 2 BBs and 1 CA without loss.
General von Manstein installed his HQ in Rostov, well supplied with a port level 6. After a heavy air attack followed by an artillery bombardment the key city of Voronezh was captured. The fall of this city created a huge gap in the Soviet lines. Not only was Stalingrad threatened from the north, but Saratov, Kuybyshev and Moscow were also now in danger. Our spearhead units already advanced east along the Voronezh-Saratov Road. The Red Army would have a lot of trouble covering all the new threatened areas, not counting with the new Japanese Far East front…
The newly arrived 11th panzerkorps was instructed to cross the Don River together with the AT unit. They will protect the left flank of General von Bock, moving south deeper into the Caucasus, and also menacing the southern approaches of Stalingrad. The main railroad leading to Baku was again cut by a mot Infantry corps.
In a bold move aiming Baku, our paras jumped for a second time this summer. Baku was defended by a recently arrived Soviet Army, but they captured both of Baku´s oil fields even though they finished the turn unsupplied. The siege of Krasnodar began, and an elite German Army entered the Crimean Peninsula.
In India, Japanese forces were almost within reach of Delhi, the Capital being undefended. Calcutta was under siege, but our forces were not well supplied and suffered from low readiness. In China our troops slowly pushed the defenders back step by step…
In the North Sea, German Naval forces surprised a Royal Navy Task Force and managed to sink 2 BBs and 1 CA without loss.
La clé est l'état d'esprit
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
The Imperial General HQ in Tokyo presented to the emperor Hirohito their new plan for the war. The Empire will be held with minimal naval forces and most of the IJN will be transferred to the Atlantic Ocean via the Suez Canal and Gibraltar. Embarked Special Forces will be transported with the Fleet and after capturing Gibraltar they will disembark in hostile undermined enemy coastal cities to be assigned in 1943.
Immediately Admiral Yamamoto recalled Admiral Nagumo from the Palau Islands and ordered him to Batavia and the DEI. He will be the Advance Task Force and will clear a path for the main Fleet that Yamamoto was assembling in Japan.
Not less than 9 subs were attacking British convoy lanes.
Immediately Admiral Yamamoto recalled Admiral Nagumo from the Palau Islands and ordered him to Batavia and the DEI. He will be the Advance Task Force and will clear a path for the main Fleet that Yamamoto was assembling in Japan.
Not less than 9 subs were attacking British convoy lanes.
La clé est l'état d'esprit
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
Was that Norwegian campaign really worth it? Looks to me more like a big sink for Allied resources.
- EarlyDoors
- Posts: 758
- Joined: Sun Dec 16, 2018 10:28 am
- Location: uk
- Contact:
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
Well so far 95%+ of the UK-> USSR convoys have got through, Royal Navy has taken more losses than I'd like but they are not defeated. Norway based Luftwaffe has no HQ and is in low supply but does have technological fighter edge.
Diplomatically UK 'wasted' 250mpps on Finland but forced Axis to respond with ?350mpps?
Bomber Command forgo targets in France. The second Strategic Bomber was purchased with a view to middle east but that front collapsed before it could arrive.
The only extravagance was Anderson HQ for about 350mpps.
Other than that I believe the strategic value was worth it.
The threat is in Ukraine/Caucasus.
- EarlyDoors
- Posts: 758
- Joined: Sun Dec 16, 2018 10:28 am
- Location: uk
- Contact:
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
June 1942
China's 54th Army is destroyed and Kweichow occupied but at cost to the Japanese 17th Korean Army who are destroyed in a counter-attack and the key town re-occupied. To the north, L Corps are destroyed.
Pago Pago hit by battleship bombardment, LRAT assault and US special forces land on Samoa.
Axis Raiders disrupt merchant shipping in the Bay of Bengal although I suspect their motive is to reduce supply of the defenders of Calcutta who are receiving logistics from across the marsh.
Indian 2nd Garrison at Alhamabad is lost but a Ghurka regiment arrives in the Capital Delhi. India is under lots of pressure. RAF Bomber Command re-arms and is joined by US Strategic Bombers.
China's 54th Army is destroyed and Kweichow occupied but at cost to the Japanese 17th Korean Army who are destroyed in a counter-attack and the key town re-occupied. To the north, L Corps are destroyed.
Pago Pago hit by battleship bombardment, LRAT assault and US special forces land on Samoa.
Axis Raiders disrupt merchant shipping in the Bay of Bengal although I suspect their motive is to reduce supply of the defenders of Calcutta who are receiving logistics from across the marsh.
Indian 2nd Garrison at Alhamabad is lost but a Ghurka regiment arrives in the Capital Delhi. India is under lots of pressure. RAF Bomber Command re-arms and is joined by US Strategic Bombers.
- EarlyDoors
- Posts: 758
- Joined: Sun Dec 16, 2018 10:28 am
- Location: uk
- Contact:
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
June 1942 - Battle for the Convoys
Canade lost 86 mpps last turn. US destroyers steam north east towards the contact area.
As mentioned, last month the Royal Navy lost the Battleships Rodney and Duke of York, and the heavy cruiser Norfolk to combined air and sea attack off Norway. They chase and sink the Battle Cruiser Scharnhorst towards Narvik.
Canade lost 86 mpps last turn. US destroyers steam north east towards the contact area.
As mentioned, last month the Royal Navy lost the Battleships Rodney and Duke of York, and the heavy cruiser Norfolk to combined air and sea attack off Norway. They chase and sink the Battle Cruiser Scharnhorst towards Narvik.
-
- Posts: 441
- Joined: Wed Jan 22, 2020 6:17 am
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
Enjoying AAR from both sides, good job.
This would not look as perilous for allies, if they were ready for some big counterpunch in an important location. But judging on Allied spending, there won't be anything like this anytime soon. This sub strategy is an interesting one, but it costs 1000+ MPP's and doesn't yield fast results. Momentum is on Axis side and it's probably not the best way to slow it down. Same in the Atlantic, RN should be winning, but it's not and must deal with those annoying subs. That's a sign that's something went wrong on strategic level.
I suppose that many tactical setbacks could add up. Especially RN lost so many ships vs Germany, that it had to put precious resources in theather, where UK should rule. Many UK ships/planes have no upgrades etc. generally Churchill doesn't have a good game and UK's play is often be or not to be for a whole match.
USSR defense is quite strange. There are almost no forts deep in the country, seems engies were caught with pants down. There were also some tactcal mistakes (forts on Dnieper were empty?). But at the same time, USSR is far away from collapse, German units are not that many, and quite dispersed. On the other hand, not a fan of this Finland campaign, so many good USSR units there.
Taifun is tactically superior and it seems he knows engine better. But at the same time, with such a style of play one straight punch in vulnerable place would derail axis game probably. But to do this you have to preapre beforehand, and Allies are way behind schedules.
I'd say 70:30 in axis favour by now, interesting to see how will it go.
This would not look as perilous for allies, if they were ready for some big counterpunch in an important location. But judging on Allied spending, there won't be anything like this anytime soon. This sub strategy is an interesting one, but it costs 1000+ MPP's and doesn't yield fast results. Momentum is on Axis side and it's probably not the best way to slow it down. Same in the Atlantic, RN should be winning, but it's not and must deal with those annoying subs. That's a sign that's something went wrong on strategic level.
I suppose that many tactical setbacks could add up. Especially RN lost so many ships vs Germany, that it had to put precious resources in theather, where UK should rule. Many UK ships/planes have no upgrades etc. generally Churchill doesn't have a good game and UK's play is often be or not to be for a whole match.
USSR defense is quite strange. There are almost no forts deep in the country, seems engies were caught with pants down. There were also some tactcal mistakes (forts on Dnieper were empty?). But at the same time, USSR is far away from collapse, German units are not that many, and quite dispersed. On the other hand, not a fan of this Finland campaign, so many good USSR units there.
Taifun is tactically superior and it seems he knows engine better. But at the same time, with such a style of play one straight punch in vulnerable place would derail axis game probably. But to do this you have to preapre beforehand, and Allies are way behind schedules.
I'd say 70:30 in axis favour by now, interesting to see how will it go.
- EarlyDoors
- Posts: 758
- Joined: Sun Dec 16, 2018 10:28 am
- Location: uk
- Contact:
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
June 1942 - USSR
Riga is overcome and Army Group Centre push on towards Moscow blasting an Army out of Kaluga.
Army Group South B take Voronezh.
And Army Group South A cut the Astrakhan -> Grozny railline again then paratroopers make a suicide drop onto the Baku oilfields knocking out Soviet production.
3 Corps are lost and the light cruiser Chevrona Ukraina that had attracted the attention of the luftwaffe after blocading supply at Rostov.
Powerful groups in Turkey call on their country to join the axis and Italy launches the Roma battleship
Riga is overcome and Army Group Centre push on towards Moscow blasting an Army out of Kaluga.
Army Group South B take Voronezh.
And Army Group South A cut the Astrakhan -> Grozny railline again then paratroopers make a suicide drop onto the Baku oilfields knocking out Soviet production.
3 Corps are lost and the light cruiser Chevrona Ukraina that had attracted the attention of the luftwaffe after blocading supply at Rostov.
Powerful groups in Turkey call on their country to join the axis and Italy launches the Roma battleship
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
Thanks, Marcinos, for following! I was missing your always interesting comments! When do we play again
?
I agree with you in your analysis. The US Navy investment in subs was a strange decision. Also, those British destroyers should have been all updated with at least antisub tech. I was happy with all those Soviets units in Finland, Stalin needed them badly in Stalingrad!
Admiral Yamamoto sailed south from home waters with the IJN Combined Fleet. Nagumo’s Advance Task Force attacked one of the remaining USS subs. Our Intelligence Office in Tokyo reports that 3-4 US subs may still be operating the Pacific (4 sunk).
In the AGC area of operations the Soviets have place their commanding General in an exposed position, leading his troops too forward from the town of Vyazma. General von Leeb targeted this HQ and attacked the army defending the hex south of Vyazma (by the way not fortified). Shortly afterwards General Timoshenko was captured, later commenting to his interrogators: “the war is lost, to continue this struggle is pointless!”
. Undefended Kaluga town was also captured.
The Soviet entrenched at Bryansk are defending themselves courageously and their position is hampering our advance. To help deblock the situation General Rommel was transferred to AGC, arriving to Smolensk rail station, after spending a few weeks relaxing in the Bavarian Alps. The Fuhrer promised to send additional reinforcements for the advance towards Moscow. Now that the Soviet Central Front is leaderless Moscow should fall in short notice.
General von Manstein opted to avoid a frontal attack towards Stalingrad. Instead, he cut the railroads supplying the big city, isolating the whole Stalingrad Front and most probably General Zhukov inside.
He attacked Kotelnikovo from the south damaging the defending infantry corps and the heavy tank.
What would Stalin do? Will he order his troops to stay put and don’t move in order not to lose their entrenchment? (Remember this game is about readiness and entrenchment) or will he order a general counterattack or a general withdrawal? Difficult decision to take. I think that I would leave the troops where they are, Stalingrad being an Industrial Center and providing good supply.
Importantly, 2 new AT units detrained at Morozovsk. The elite German Army left the Crimea due to low supply.
In AGS A area of operations von Bock captured Grozny, isolating the Soviet paras and opening the road towards Baku. We needed to rescue our out of supply paras near the Baku oilfields ASAP.

I agree with you in your analysis. The US Navy investment in subs was a strange decision. Also, those British destroyers should have been all updated with at least antisub tech. I was happy with all those Soviets units in Finland, Stalin needed them badly in Stalingrad!
Admiral Yamamoto sailed south from home waters with the IJN Combined Fleet. Nagumo’s Advance Task Force attacked one of the remaining USS subs. Our Intelligence Office in Tokyo reports that 3-4 US subs may still be operating the Pacific (4 sunk).
In the AGC area of operations the Soviets have place their commanding General in an exposed position, leading his troops too forward from the town of Vyazma. General von Leeb targeted this HQ and attacked the army defending the hex south of Vyazma (by the way not fortified). Shortly afterwards General Timoshenko was captured, later commenting to his interrogators: “the war is lost, to continue this struggle is pointless!”

The Soviet entrenched at Bryansk are defending themselves courageously and their position is hampering our advance. To help deblock the situation General Rommel was transferred to AGC, arriving to Smolensk rail station, after spending a few weeks relaxing in the Bavarian Alps. The Fuhrer promised to send additional reinforcements for the advance towards Moscow. Now that the Soviet Central Front is leaderless Moscow should fall in short notice.
General von Manstein opted to avoid a frontal attack towards Stalingrad. Instead, he cut the railroads supplying the big city, isolating the whole Stalingrad Front and most probably General Zhukov inside.
He attacked Kotelnikovo from the south damaging the defending infantry corps and the heavy tank.
What would Stalin do? Will he order his troops to stay put and don’t move in order not to lose their entrenchment? (Remember this game is about readiness and entrenchment) or will he order a general counterattack or a general withdrawal? Difficult decision to take. I think that I would leave the troops where they are, Stalingrad being an Industrial Center and providing good supply.
Importantly, 2 new AT units detrained at Morozovsk. The elite German Army left the Crimea due to low supply.
In AGS A area of operations von Bock captured Grozny, isolating the Soviet paras and opening the road towards Baku. We needed to rescue our out of supply paras near the Baku oilfields ASAP.
La clé est l'état d'esprit
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
Our subs sunk more than 200 MPPs last turn, damaging seriously the British economy.
The Soviets are getting a steady supply of MPPs. The plan is working. The UK is left with very few MPPs to work around.
The Soviets lost this turn about 2100 MPPs! That is about the same TOTAL amount of MMPs that they received via convoys during the whole war (2026 MPPs).
By July 3rd the Axis have naval parity with the Allies. The Soviets are down to 48 units and Germany 83 buying only a few more garrisons.
The Soviets are getting a steady supply of MPPs. The plan is working. The UK is left with very few MPPs to work around.
The Soviets lost this turn about 2100 MPPs! That is about the same TOTAL amount of MMPs that they received via convoys during the whole war (2026 MPPs).
By July 3rd the Axis have naval parity with the Allies. The Soviets are down to 48 units and Germany 83 buying only a few more garrisons.
La clé est l'état d'esprit
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
For the first time Germany lost more MPPs than the economy could provide...
La clé est l'état d'esprit
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
Good summary though I think its probably more like 90-95% in axis favor and the USSR is going to collapse faster than you think. I still think it is pretty much over by the end of 1942.Marcinos1985 wrote: ↑Thu Sep 08, 2022 8:06 am Enjoying AAR from both sides, good job.
This would not look as perilous for allies, if they were ready for some big counterpunch in an important location. But judging on Allied spending, there won't be anything like this anytime soon. This sub strategy is an interesting one, but it costs 1000+ MPP's and doesn't yield fast results. Momentum is on Axis side and it's probably not the best way to slow it down. Same in the Atlantic, RN should be winning, but it's not and must deal with those annoying subs. That's a sign that's something went wrong on strategic level.
I suppose that many tactical setbacks could add up. Especially RN lost so many ships vs Germany, that it had to put precious resources in theather, where UK should rule. Many UK ships/planes have no upgrades etc. generally Churchill doesn't have a good game and UK's play is often be or not to be for a whole match.
USSR defense is quite strange. There are almost no forts deep in the country, seems engies were caught with pants down. There were also some tactcal mistakes (forts on Dnieper were empty?). But at the same time, USSR is far away from collapse, German units are not that many, and quite dispersed. On the other hand, not a fan of this Finland campaign, so many good USSR units there.
Taifun is tactically superior and it seems he knows engine better. But at the same time, with such a style of play one straight punch in vulnerable place would derail axis game probably. But to do this you have to preapre beforehand, and Allies are way behind schedules.
I'd say 70:30 in axis favour by now, interesting to see how will it go.
- EarlyDoors
- Posts: 758
- Joined: Sun Dec 16, 2018 10:28 am
- Location: uk
- Contact:
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
July 1942
China's experienced 2-star Youth Army defending the Kweichow mine is destroyed.
A battered Indian Army withdraws from Agra behind the Ghurkas entrenching in Delhi. Allied Bomber Command ready to strike is grounded by the untimely arrival of the Indian monsoon.
As mentioned, both the US and Canadian convoys were hit heavily last month.
HMS Beehive an MTB that had stumbled into a uboat is sunk together with the destroyer HMS Montgomery. A Carrier Group with the Battleship HMS Prince of Wales is repulsed in its attacks against a German battleship at Trondheim.
China's experienced 2-star Youth Army defending the Kweichow mine is destroyed.
A battered Indian Army withdraws from Agra behind the Ghurkas entrenching in Delhi. Allied Bomber Command ready to strike is grounded by the untimely arrival of the Indian monsoon.
As mentioned, both the US and Canadian convoys were hit heavily last month.
HMS Beehive an MTB that had stumbled into a uboat is sunk together with the destroyer HMS Montgomery. A Carrier Group with the Battleship HMS Prince of Wales is repulsed in its attacks against a German battleship at Trondheim.
Last edited by EarlyDoors on Fri Sep 09, 2022 7:12 am, edited 1 time in total.
- EarlyDoors
- Posts: 758
- Joined: Sun Dec 16, 2018 10:28 am
- Location: uk
- Contact:
Re: Taifun (Axis) v EarlyDoors (Allies)
July 1942 - USSR
Army Group Centre attacks and destroys Timoshenko's HQ at Vyazma. The Kremlin thought he was exposed but mis-calculated that he would survive an attack thanks to a protecting Army to the south. With an exposed corps to the north of Bryansk and no defenders at Moscow it seemed bait to distract from the main goal. The outcome was worse than hoped but at least there now some units at Moscow.
AGS B envelop Stalingrad. Zhukov falls back eastwards.
Grozny falls to the 2 Panzer Armies of AGS A. The 7th FSJ paratroopers are destroyed and the oil fields of Baku re-taken.
Army Group Centre attacks and destroys Timoshenko's HQ at Vyazma. The Kremlin thought he was exposed but mis-calculated that he would survive an attack thanks to a protecting Army to the south. With an exposed corps to the north of Bryansk and no defenders at Moscow it seemed bait to distract from the main goal. The outcome was worse than hoped but at least there now some units at Moscow.
AGS B envelop Stalingrad. Zhukov falls back eastwards.
Grozny falls to the 2 Panzer Armies of AGS A. The 7th FSJ paratroopers are destroyed and the oil fields of Baku re-taken.