My D21 attempt

After Action Reports
700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »

'When a man is tired of invading the Soviet Union, he is tired of life.'

Is what Dr Johnson would have said if he had been a wargamer. Probably.

Anyway here is my game so far. We join the action at turn 114, July 22nd 1942.

The Case Blue offensive is over but we have made some significant gains in territory and objectives and much of the summer campaigning season is still left.

Starting with Army Group North, here's the overview:

Image

And a close up of the battle lines:

Image

In my first attempt I was too slow in my advance and was unable to take Leningrad. In my second attempt at the scenario, which is this one, I went like the clappers, got around the city and cut the life road. I also kept all of my Stuka squadrons out of the action except for hitting the Baltic Fleet any time it moved out of port. Having sunk all the Soviet boats the Stukas were then diverted en masse down south to do the same with the Black Sea Fleet.

With no supply at all going in I was able to reduce the defenders with artillery and mop them up. Moping up concluded just before the muddy season. Losses were very light.

I saw no need to advance further here, the terrain is marsh, forest and many rivers, it would just be a slugfest that would cost thousands of rifle squads. No point in attacking where the enemy is strongest unless you have no choice.

We bombard the Soviet lines twice a week with all arty over 100% supply. Ivan always has some juicy orange and occasionally red stacks to aim at. Casualties are in the thirtieth percentile, I estimate the enemy to be losing 2000 squads a week in this sector alone.

The Soviet has given up assaulting this line, all his attacks failed with 100 to 1 casualties or greater.

Army Group Centre (overview)

Image

And a close up of the Moscow sector

Image

Operation Typhoon only managed to get me to 100 km from Moscow, I elected to dig in whilst still strong rather than overextend my thrust and fall prey to the Soviet winter offensive. Consequently Case Blue had two chief objectives: Moscow and the oil fields at Maikop.

As you can see I did manage to bash through to the city centre and the Kremlin. Soviet paras (tough bastards) counterattacked my exhausted troops and drove them out, but were themselves retreated again by fresh German reserves. I was, however, unable to surround the city or push further into the eastern suburbs by the end of the offensive.

This whole sector is now re-supplying. I'm hoping a second push in a few weeks time will clear the remainder of Moscow and its suburbs.

Army Group South:

Overview:

Image

And a close up of the Stalingrad area

Image

I was able to capture Rostov, and convert the rail line that runs like an arrow to the southeast down on into it, prior to the start of Case Blue. Capturing that rail line is essential to capturing Rostov and being able to make a move into the Caucasus, and Ivan knows this and hangs onto it like his balls.

Once that was taken the Soviet front in the south collapsed completely during Case Blue. So I decided to go for broke and attempt a drive on Stalingrad as well as diving south for the oil fields. There is not really enough troops or supply to do both, so it is gamble. I have no idea what sort of strength the Soviets will be able to muster for a winter counter-offensive in this area. If it's a lot then I might be screwed.

Finally, this may look like bugs going after a spill, but it is actually Army Group Caucasus which has achieved its primary objective of capturing Maikop and the oil wells and is now re-supplying before mopping up and moving to defensive positions.

Image

And a close up of the Maikop sector:

Image


One thing I learnt in my first aborted attempt is that you have to pay close attention to the rail lines. Work out which rail lines you are going to need ahead of time and attack to capture them. Planning ahead with regards to the rail and supply is absolutely vital. Otherwise you end up bogged down, low on supply, with Ivan sat on the rail line you need for supply, but you can't shift him because you have no supply. And he gets stronger much faster than you do!

Anyway, thanks for reading, your comments, criticisms and observations are welcome.
gwgardner
Posts: 7150
Joined: Fri Apr 07, 2006 1:23 pm

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by gwgardner »

Great to see the situation so far along. In this scenario do you get increased supply for taking Maikop?

700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »

You get 1 extra point and the Soviet loses 1 point.

I will try to do some updates as I go along.
700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »

Trouble starts in the South already. 32nd Guards Div and associated units attack out of the mountain passes, pushing a regiment of the 299th infantry back 40 km and handing out a beating to 23rd Panzer as it is attempting to establish a beachhead across the river from Krasnodar:

Image

Slightly further west Brandenburger commandos parachute down and capture the port. Rumanian 2nd Security division crosses the Kerch Strait and engages the HQ of the Black Sea Fleet. The HQ is fairly redundant now as the fleet is decorating the bottom of the Black Sea, but they still won't give up without a fight.

Image
700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »

Where AGS joins AGC we are rolling up the Soviet MLR from the south, surrounding and destroying as we go.

Image

Only problem is that whilst this slow-moving operation takes place a new Soviet MLR is rapidly forming 50 Km to the East.

Note that the new Soviet MLR sits along the line of the North/South railroad.
Jukipo
Posts: 593
Joined: Thu Dec 10, 2015 12:18 pm

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by Jukipo »

How much have you taken losses so far? How much do you have heavy rifle squads assigned? Tanks?
700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »

ORIGINAL: Jukipo

How much have you taken losses so far? How much do you have heavy rifle squads assigned? Tanks?

Heavy rifle squads: lost 69K, assigned 39K and 359 on hand

Tank losses (all types) 2.6K about 500 on hand including 24 Mk1 Tigers! My favourite tank. None are assigned to units yet though.

Aircraft (all types) lost circa 5K - but have over 2K aircraft on hand

I don't know if that is good or bad.

I've tried to keep casualties low with all aircraft on Air superiority or combat support (I halted interdiction once the Soviet air force recovered).

Used lots of massed artillery in attacks and have not fought any battles I did not need to.

However I haven't broken the back of the Red Army like you had at this point, they are still a force to be reckoned with. I suppose that does add an element of suspense to the game.

I've made more than a few mistakes, I'll probably have another go at some time in the future with the latest version and see if I can't do better.
700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »

Ready to resume operations around Moscow. I need to clear the rest of the city so that I am not defending right on the Kremlin come the winter and I also need to take pressure off my weak front line to the north. So an attack is planned with the Gross Deutschland Div and four other panzer divs driving up behind Moscow and linking with the SS Wiking Div and other units which will attack north east out of their prepared positions. Objective: to pocket the Soviet forces in and around Moscow and destroy them.

I estimate 5 weeks (10 turns). After that we will dig in and recover supply before the mud arrives.

Image
700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »


After the first few days of attack we have broken through the Soviet front line. 2 enemy divisions an arty unit, a tank brigade and 2 headquarters were surrounded and eliminated. The infantry were unable to crack the lines on their own so the panzers had to assist the breakthrough, accompanied by barrages from Nebelwerfers. I like nebelwerfers.

Annoying though as it means the panzers have to burn supply before they even get moving. The enemy have defence in depth, which is no surprise. This has to be done, though, as if they recapture Moscow they regain all the benefits they lost in terms of production, supply and rail capacity when it was captured. So that cannot be allowed to happen.

The Soviets have the initiative at the moment, hopefully it will swing back shortly and I will get back-to-back turns. That will help speed things along.

Image
700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »

The Krasnodar sector down in the Caucasus becomes more worrying. The arrival of the fresh 14th Panzer division stabilises the situation but then more Soviet divisions come out of the mountains and attack again. I wasn't expecting to have a fight of this magnitude in this area and there are not enough troops or supply. Rail repair has been diverted to Krasnodar but it will be a couple of weeks before the supply situation there improves noticeably.

I did not want to make the same mistake the Germans did historically and so I have committed all my mountain divisions to this sector. The last of them (a Hungarian div) arrives by rail this turn.

This is the situation before I move. Krasnodar is in the blue circle, arrows show the direction of Soviet advance.

Image

Also concerning is the situation to the North East where the drive on Stalingrad has stalled. Although we are across the river in force we do not have the units or supply to continue the advance, and Soviet resistance, previously almost non-existent, is stiffening rapidly.

Consequently I order in my remaining reserves to the beachhead. They are all Rumanian divisions but are all fully rested and supplied. The railhead made good progress and will be at the river in week. Then we can press on. Capturing Stalingrad will reduce Soviet production (as does capturing any major city) and cut the Volga traffic which gives further penalties (although I can't recall exactly what off the top of my head).

Image
Jukipo
Posts: 593
Joined: Thu Dec 10, 2015 12:18 pm

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by Jukipo »

Heavy rifle squads: lost 69K, assigned 39K and 359 on hand

Tank losses (all types) 2.6K about 500 on hand including 24 Mk1 Tigers! My favourite tank. None are assigned to units yet though.

Aircraft (all types) lost circa 5K - but have over 2K aircraft on hand

I don't know if that is good or bad.

I've tried to keep casualties low with all aircraft on Air superiority or combat support (I halted interdiction once the Soviet air force recovered).

Used lots of massed artillery in attacks and have not fought any battles I did not need to.

However I haven't broken the back of the Red Army like you had at this point, they are still a force to be reckoned with. I suppose that does add an element of suspense to the game.

I've made more than a few mistakes, I'll probably have another go at some time in the future with the latest version and see if I can't do better.

Here are my losses on turn 114:
HRS: lost 65K, assigned 41.5K
Tanks: lost 2.2K
Aircraft: lost 6.3K

Looks like you have lost little more ground troops. You are going to have more interesting fall than I did. I played a little too well, the game became too easy and not interesting anymore.

If I’m playing this scenario again, I’m going to try historical approach: all out assault to Moscow November 1941.
700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »

No plan survives first contact with the enemy and the offensive around Moscow is no exception. Soviet resistance is stiff. Worse still force proficiency check is failed after the first combat round and then the Soviets counter-attack, re-capturing NE Moscow. A brigade of 12th Panzer division, which was supposed to be on reserve to prevent such an event, failed to mobilise. The brigade commander is charged with dereliction of duty and placed under close arrest. A counter attack is quickly organised to retake the lost area. (Circled)

Meantime the thrust behind the Soviet line is also thrown back. (arrow 'S'). We attempt to counter attack to the North from a more easterly position where the defence appears weaker (arrow 'A')

Image

I have 5 days leave from work, starting today, hopefully I will be able to play through to the Fall in the next few days and we will see how interesting it gets.
User avatar
larryfulkerson
Posts: 42545
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2005 9:06 pm
Location: Tucson, AZ,usa,sol, milkyway
Contact:

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by larryfulkerson »

Really cool. Keep going....please.
Naughty Grandma Has the Bank Manager by the Balls… LITERALLY!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fBeUBBeqkhI
700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »

I want to pinch out this bulge in the Soviet lines but I have no panzers available. 80% of the armour is north around Moscow and the rest is down south. Infantry attacks are being made at the corners of the salient but it is slow progress.

Image

At Moscow, two weeks into the offensive, we have finally made progress, despite multiple Soviet counterattacks, some of which were successful. Ivan still has plenty of fight left in him!

The attempt to surround the remaining sector of the city still in Soviet hands proved costly. Ivan had a 305mm railroad gun and eight (!) armoured trains in there which took some killing. Bombardment from heavy mortar 'Dora' and a railroad gun made little impact. SS Wiking assaulted taking heavy casualties and was withdrawn to replace. After repeated attacks by tanks and motorized infantry, and every artillery and aircraft asset within range, the last of the trains is destroyed and eastern Moscow is surrounded.

Image

I expended all remaining on this final redoubt, it finally crumbled in the last combat round. That will conclude offensive operations in this sector, the artillery is out of ammo and almost all panzer divisions are below 20% supply. Objectives have been attained although at a price.

The duplicate 6th Panzer Div has shown up. I will have to disband the old one I suppose.

****

AGS:

The advance stalls. Not enough troops, not enough supply. I was pushing it attempting 3 major offensives I think and have spread myself too thin. Here is the situation east of the Don River:

Image

If we can get our breath back here it may still be possible to push on. Soviet 7th Guards Army has appeared on the scene and is giving us some problems. I have one fresh panzer division left in AGS and it is on the way. There is a signpost up ahead: 'Stalingrad 40Km!'

In the Caucasus a corps of mountain divisions will attack south through the Pseashkha (don't attempt to pronounce it!) Pass in attempt to cut the coastal road and railroad on the other side of the range. This will cut supply lines to the Soviet troops fighting to the North East and will hopefully make rolling them up easier. If we can get through the pass. A brigade of heavy artillery is following them up in case a strongpoint is encountered.

Image


Ironically as the main offensive finishes the initiative changes and the Axis play twice. If that had happened a turn earlier it would have made operations much easier and less costly. As it is I get a breather turn before Ivan counterattacks.
700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »

Turn 117

The Soviets limited themselves to bombardments thankfully. They have stripped their lines in some places to cover other areas which I'm taking as a good sign. They don't appear to have the weight to launch a serious counter-offensive. Yet.

Everyone is taking supply. AGN launches a small offensive to cut rail supply to Soviet units facing the Finns east of Lagoda. All of AGN's units are fresh and reporting full ration strength and 150% supply. They go through Ivan like butter and the key RR junction is captured.

Elsewhere it is re-supplying and mopping up.

In the Caucasus the mountain corps continues its advance through Unpronounceable Pass. No opposition is encountered:


Image

Hopefully the Soviet defence in that area consists solely of that corps HQ unit. But I doubt it.

**

Stalingrad Sector:

A Soviet strongpoint in badlands terrain causes problems. The Panzers cannot get into it and the only German infantry div on hand attacks on the bounce and is repulsed with a bloody nose. Meanwhile 7th Guards army grows larger. We have missed the opportunity for a smash and grab on Stalingrad, the enemy just has too many troops here now.

22 Panzer arrives from the Caucasus, but it has burnt much of its supply on the march, and having to bash through some small Soviet units to reach the beachead. On the plus side the railhead is now only 30km from the front lines.

We carpet bomb the Soviets in the badlands with around 200 Stukas and low level bombers, combined with the railroad artillery firing right from the railhead. The Soviets evaporate.


Image

Do I rail more Panzer divisions down from Moscow and re-inforce here or continue with my plan to pinch off the large Soviet salient south of Moscow? I like a game that gives me these sort of decisions. It's difficult. Once you commit you can't go back.


South of Rostov operations commence to mop up a handful of Soviet units still in the area. Their road and rail supply was long since cut. Most are surrounded and destroyed but this group had a bridging unit and elected to go swimming on one of the lakes:


Image

Over 80 squads with all sorts of artillery and AT guns, horse teams, the lot. Our artillery was out of ammo so low-level bombers and stukas were called in. Everything except the bridging unit goes to the bottom of the pond.

I have 48 Tiger tanks ready to go, but none assigned. Not sure when that will happen but a fresh battalion of Tigers would be real handy right now.
DanNeely
Posts: 305
Joined: Tue Oct 18, 2005 1:05 am

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by DanNeely »

What's your supply look like south of that pass? The road doesn't go through, so I'd expect it to be hideously low, if Elmer has any fight in him you're going to be hurting fast.
Did you ever see history portrayed as an old man ... weighing all things in the balance of reason?
Is not [it] an eternal, imploring maiden, full of fire, with a burning heart and flaming soul, humanly warm and humanly beautiful?
--Zachris Topelius
700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »

I've got a supply unit with them. For what that's worth. But you're right, it's a raid not an offensive. If they can sit on the rail line for a week or two I'll be able to clean up the Soviets in the northwest end of the mountain range. And I have fresh Italian mountain troops ready to cross the Kerch straights and push down the coastal road from the west.

Low proficiency, I know, but they should have enough in them to do the job if the Soviets cannot re-supply.

Got to take some chances in order to get an edge and keep it. Otherwise it is going to be 'Slugfest '43' and I don't want that. So far it has worked...
700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »

Damn it all!

Image

NKVD divisions appear in time to block the route through the mountains.

Dan was right about the supply. North side of the pass: 13, South side: zero

The first of the Italian divisons cross the straits and take up positions on the other side. More are to follow. Perhaps this will unhinge the defence instead? I need to get this area cleaned up quickly to free up more troops to go NE to Stalingrad. There's maybe 12 more turns before the mud arrives.

Image
700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »

Front Lines Turn 120

M Moscow
L Leningrad
S Stalingrad
R Rostov
K Krasnodar

Northern sector

Image

Southern sector

Image

700851McCall
Posts: 172
Joined: Sun Jan 07, 2018 8:07 am
Location: Staffordshire, England.

RE: My D21 attempt

Post by 700851McCall »

0600 hrs at a Soviet airbase 40km to the west of Stalingrad. The pilots and ground crew are sitting down to a hearty breakfast of blinis and vodka. At once there is a noise like a runaway freight train going over their heads. A split second later 240mm and 280mm shells begin falling on the base. The blast blows in the windows of the mess hall and sucks the air from their lungs.

Ten minutes later the squadron CO arrives back. He has spent the night with his mistress at a nearby dacha There is nothing left of the several hundred personnel and 96 aircraft that were under his command except some scattered pieces of fuselage and still-smoking craters in the ground. The entire unit has been obliterated.

He protested the order to move his squadron so close to the front. There were rumours that the Germans had moved long range artillery into the sector. But he was over-ruled. He drags his Nagan M1895 pistol from its holster and shoots himself in the head. His lifeless body topples to the ground beside his jeep. Such is war.

Image

(It did take 3 bombardments to destroy the whole unit; some artistic license is involved. But you can't beat an airfield strike with artillery. It rarely happens and needs to be savoured when it does).
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”