Questions for first time and repeat customers

Prepare yourself for a wargaming tour-de-force! Conquest of the Aegean is the next generation of the award-winning and revolutionary Airborne Assault series and it takes brigade to corps-level warfare to a whole new level. Realism and accuracy are the watchwords as this pausable continuous time design allows you to command at any echelon, with smart AI subordinates and an incredibly challenging AI.

Moderator: Arjuna

MarkShot
Posts: 7442
Joined: Sat Mar 29, 2003 6:04 am

Questions for first time and repeat customers

Post by MarkShot »

For first time customers ...
If COTA is the first Panther Games product which you have purchased, then would you please be so kind as to respond to the following questions. (If you have yet to purchase COTA but are waiting for the boxed version or intend to purchase it soon, then feel free to respond.)

(1) How did you become aware of COTA?

(2) What led to your decision to purchase COTA?

(3) Why hadn't you previously purchased RDOA or HTTR?

(4) Prior to the purchase did you try the old RDOA demo that can still be found on the Net for download?

(5) How would you characterize your PC gaming interests?

(6) Prior to your purchase had you previously purchased other Matrix Games offerings?

Thank you for your time.

For first time customers and prior customers of RDOA and HTTR ...
I have gotten the impression over the years that the Mini-Guide AARs have helped to sell more than a few copies of these games. Of course, promoting the games was certainly one of the intentions of the Mini-Guides.

My question as I think about future games like BFTB is ...

Would a more polished AAR have been more effective at promoting the game? Some examples of more polished:
- 10-20 page downloadable PDF.
- Higher quality graphics; not just screen shots/MS paint.
- More structured, better written, less rambling and stream of conciousness.
- A more careful integration of game feature presentation alongside a walkthrough of a sample gaming session.
- A document that more reflected a professional marketting brochure than the musings of a beta tester.

Or would something such as the above had left you skeptical as to the true value of the game in the sense that it would have appeared too much like a creation of the publishers public relations department (focusing on hype as opposed to substance)? (For example, the COTA Mini-Guide included give and take discussion between community and the developer and acknowledgement and highlighting of bugs in the code base currently under development.)

Another thing we have discussed in terms of promoting products is the use of 3-5 minute multi-media tutorials illustrating some of the basic aspects of the game: giving orders, micro/macro-managing, following the action, ... What do you think of that idea?

I am asking these questions, because I see the biggest hurdle for this engine is getting more people interested in trying it. Over the years, it has been rare for customers to come back and say they were really dissappointed with what they had purchased. I suppose there are some who did purchase a game, but never really grasped the game play. (This was another thing that motivated the Mini-Guides.) For the most part, once purchased I think the engine gives a very good accounting of itself. The challenge is how to reach that point.

Thank you for your time.
2021 - Resigned in writing as a 20+ year Matrix Beta and never looked back ...
AlexB
Posts: 43
Joined: Mon Nov 07, 2005 1:50 pm
Location: Antwerp

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by AlexB »

(1) I met Sterckxke at a wargame fair where he gave a demo.
(2) Sterckxke and his demo.
(3) Didn't know they existed. Thought I would wait for COTA expecting HTTR to be dated with COTA having new features.
(4) No, did not try demo.
(5) I'm into first person shooters (CoD2, SoF2, looking forward to Ghost Recon: AW), an RPG like Guild Wars. I really got into COTA via my interest in board games...
(6) No, this is my first Matrix gme, I think.
User avatar
Llyranor
Posts: 217
Joined: Sat Apr 29, 2006 4:33 am
Location: Montreal, Canada

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by Llyranor »

1) I only recently got into wargames after trying out the TC2M demo. I was checking out the Wargamer forums, and in one thread about AI, someone mentioned HTTR in the same breath as TC2M. Needless to say, curiosity piqued, I looked into it and found the RDOA demo.

2) Again, the RDOA demo. Had I not played the demo, I'm pretty sure I wouldn't bought either COTA or HTTR. Though, if I hadn't informed myself on the series beforehand and learnt about its features and how to play it, I might not have been hooked on the demo.

3) I never even knew they existed until the aforementioned. In hindsight, I should have purchased HTTR as soon as the RDOA demo convinced me to support PG. I guess I didn't want a '3-yr old game'.

4) As I said, this was the driving force behind my purchasing the game.

5) I'm not affiliated to any specific genres per say, only to quality games, eg. not dumbed down. I used to be big on RPG/TBS/FPS/RTS, though wargames are quickly becoming my favorite genre.

6) I still haven't purchased anything from Matrix outside of PG at this point.
User avatar
06 Maestro
Posts: 3997
Joined: Tue Oct 11, 2005 10:50 pm
Location: Nevada, USA

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by 06 Maestro »

1. The “Coming Soon” section at Matrix Forums.
2. The description and AAR for COTA in the forum.
3. I read reviews which painted an un-interesting /un-playable game for me.
4. No.
5. Strictly of military interest.
6. Yes.
Banking establishments are more dangerous than standing armies.

Thomas Jefferson

User avatar
wodin
Posts: 10709
Joined: Sun Apr 20, 2003 3:13 am
Location: England
Contact:

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by wodin »

ORIGINAL: 06 Maestro

1. The “Coming Soon” section at Matrix Forums.
2. The description and AAR for COTA in the forum.
3. I read reviews which painted an un-interesting /un-playable game for me.
4. No.
5. Strictly of military interest.
6. Yes.

Blimey who the hell wrote that!

User avatar
06 Maestro
Posts: 3997
Joined: Tue Oct 11, 2005 10:50 pm
Location: Nevada, USA

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by 06 Maestro »

ORIGINAL: wodin
ORIGINAL: 06 Maestro

1. The “Coming Soon” section at Matrix Forums.
2. The description and AAR for COTA in the forum.
3. I read reviews which painted an un-interesting /un-playable game for me.
4. No.
5. Strictly of military interest.
6. Yes.

Blimey who the hell wrote that!

I read mutiple reviews on the game (HTTR) on different sites. Not all were unfavorable, but there were enough references to a "click fest" to keep me away.



Banking establishments are more dangerous than standing armies.

Thomas Jefferson

User avatar
JudgeDredd
Posts: 8362
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2003 7:28 pm
Location: Scotland

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by JudgeDredd »

Well, each to his own...but I wouldn't say this game was a click fest. In fact with realistic and painfully realistic orders delay, it's anything but as orders have to be plabnned well in advance, meaning anticipating what the enemy (be them AI or human) is up to.
 
Anyway...sorry Mark...back on topic.
Alba gu' brath
User avatar
wodin
Posts: 10709
Joined: Sun Apr 20, 2003 3:13 am
Location: England
Contact:

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by wodin »

"CLICK FEST". This game is so far removed from a click fest.
Agema
Posts: 158
Joined: Mon Jan 17, 2005 8:40 pm

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by Agema »

'Click fest' is what you'd call a mass-market RTSs like C&C or Warcraft. That's a terrible review.

Finding reliable reviewers is very tricky: the world, and especially the net, is full of people who both have personal tastes that they spout ahead of objective criticism, and also insufficient knowledge of a subject to make an objective decision even if they were inclined.
Real and Simulated Wars
Posts: 453
Joined: Tue Aug 05, 2003 9:11 pm
Contact:

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by Real and Simulated Wars »

Click fest? Hmmm. Do you remember who wrote the review, or where did you read it?

A complaint about the Panther engine I read more o less frequently from grogs is that they don't like to just sit and "watch the battle" as oppossed to give a command (BTW clicking on it) to every unit before unleashing a turn.

User avatar
simovitch
Posts: 5871
Joined: Tue Feb 14, 2006 7:01 pm

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by simovitch »

ORIGINAL: Chelco

A complaint about the Panther engine I read more o less frequently from grogs is that they don't like to just sit and "watch the battle" as oppossed to give a command (BTW clicking on it) to every unit before unleashing a turn.

Exactly. The AA engine is the anticlickfest
simovitch

MarkShot
Posts: 7442
Joined: Sat Mar 29, 2003 6:04 am

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by MarkShot »

So, are first time buyers lurking or are the majority here repeat customers. (I sure hoped that we were pulling in new customers.)
2021 - Resigned in writing as a 20+ year Matrix Beta and never looked back ...
User avatar
06 Maestro
Posts: 3997
Joined: Tue Oct 11, 2005 10:50 pm
Location: Nevada, USA

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by 06 Maestro »

ORIGINAL: Chelco

Click fest? Hmmm. Do you remember who wrote the review, or where did you read it?




I'm afraid not, but the reviews were the reason I never tried HTTR-to each his own. In any event, I'm very pleased with COTA; it's the most realistic ground combat game I've ever seen.
Banking establishments are more dangerous than standing armies.

Thomas Jefferson

User avatar
pvthudson01
Posts: 457
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 8:33 pm
Location: Chicago
Contact:

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by pvthudson01 »

ORIGINAL: MarkShot

If COTA is the first Panther Games product which you have purchased, then would you please be so kind as to respond to the following questions. (If you have yet to purchase COTA but are waiting for the boxed version or intend to purchase it soon, then feel free to respond.)

(1) How did you become aware of COTA?

I tried the Arnhem demo a looooong time ago but didn't like it too much. I skipped HTTR and saw that COTA was released on the front page of the matrix site when buying some other games. I like the look of the game now better than the older ones, and I thought at first it was battle for Crete only then i saw it covered all the other battles in Greece and Malta hypothetical

(2) What led to your decision to purchase COTA?

AAR's and the upgraded interface and content from the older versions. Also I was tired of Market Garden etc etc. i also like the company support in terms of questions being answered

(3) Why hadn't you previously purchased RDOA or HTTR?

Didn't like the way they played and didnt like the only demo you guys had. Need more demos! 99% of the games I try in demo I end up getting. Im going out on a limb here.

(4) Prior to the purchase did you try the old RDOA demo that can still be found on the Net for download?

yes I hated it

(5) How would you characterize your PC gaming interests?

Wargaming and MMORPG playing. If I am not refighting WW2 I am playing World of Warcraft

(6) Prior to your purchase had you previously purchased other Matrix Games offerings?

A ton of them. I own about 8-9 Matrix Games

Thank you.

---

For those of you who are repeat customers, I don't mean to make you feel ignored. However, I just assume that most of you were pleased with HTTR and were eager to get the next installment.
Matrix Member since 2003!
MarkShot
Posts: 7442
Joined: Sat Mar 29, 2003 6:04 am

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by MarkShot »

Added some questions for you repeat customers as well. :)
2021 - Resigned in writing as a 20+ year Matrix Beta and never looked back ...
Jensen76
Posts: 16
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 8:32 pm

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by Jensen76 »

(1) How did you become aware of COTA?

Reading the Matrix forums.

(2) What led to your decision to purchase COTA?

I liked the concept and got the impression that COTA would feature a nice campaign mode.

(3) Why hadn't you previously purchased RDOA or HTTR?

Hadn't really heard of them before and when I finally did COTA was already on the horizon...

(4) Prior to the purchase did you try the old RDOA demo that can still be found on the Net for download?

No.

(5) How would you characterize your PC gaming interests?

Wargames and simulations.

(6) Prior to your purchase had you previously purchased other Matrix Games offerings?

Crown of Glory, War in the Pacific.
User avatar
henri511
Posts: 83
Joined: Thu Jun 08, 2006 5:30 pm

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by henri511 »

I read about COTA on forums here and on Usenet. I bought about 5 wargames in the past month (COTA, TOAW3, SC2, TFB, BII, BIN), the most recent being TOAW3 and I bought COTA yesterday. If a wargame is any good at all, I will buy it. My philosophy is that if I play a game for a week, I figure I have gotten my money's worth.[8D]

It was clear from the start that I would buy this game because of the quality of HTTR, so the producers should be encouraged. I hesitated for TOAW3 because although I bought 3 versions of TOAW, I was not too crazy about the complexity of the game.[X(]

I don't like clickfests and I don't like scenarios with too many units. I wish someone would make a computer wargame of "The Russian Campaign" which, according to a poll a couple of years ago, was the most popular wargame ever. This boardgame had fewer than 100 units, but I played it for years.[:'(]

I am encouraged by the COTA documentation mentioning maneuver warfare and the boyd cycle; it remains to be seen how well these concepts apply to this game, because so far no game has managed to simulate this well.[8|]

Henri
James Sterrett
Posts: 1619
Joined: Wed Jul 07, 2004 4:03 am

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by James Sterrett »

I am encouraged by the COTA documentation mentioning maneuver warfare and the boyd cycle; it remains to be seen how well these concepts apply to this game, because so far no game has managed to simulate this well.[8|]

Very well - if you turn on orders delays; and it works better the closer you get to "painfully realistic" orders delays.

Delays in execution of orders means that forces cannot react instantly.

As a result, if Side A's plan rocks side B off-balance, Side B's orders are out of touch with the situation - and if Side A's plan is good, Side A is giving orders that will exploit this situation further, putting B into a deteriorating spiral.

It's hard to make it happen effectively, though. It takes a good plan to pull it off, including a solid understanding of enemy reactions and the limitations of your own forces.


IMO, some of COTA's best scenarios pit the Germans, trying to break out across the map, against a much smaller force of Allied troops trying to delay them. (First Clean Break is a good small example.) The delaying forces have a difficult task - and when they do their job right, cause the attacking forces no end of trouble as small units hold up large columns only to run away before the hammer can be brought upon them. If the attack can generate momentum, however, the delaying force turns into a discombobulated mess of troops trying desperately to get back in front of the attack.... whomever is forced to be reactive will lose.
User avatar
henri511
Posts: 83
Joined: Thu Jun 08, 2006 5:30 pm

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by henri511 »

It might be a nice idea to illustrate the Boyd cycle with a learning scenario where one side would have much faster responses than the other, for instance the Germans vs Russia at the start of the Blitzkrieg, when due to lack of communications and impossible orders, the Soviets found it mostly impossible to respond or worse, felt forced to attempt to follow impossible orders that had little to do with the real situation.

In this scenario,. the soviets would be given a much larger force with the slowest response time possible and bad orders to start, whereas the Germans would be given "no delay". The German objective would be to cut off the supplies of the soviets, pocket them and annihilate them. Because it takes a while in the game for lack of supplies to have a significant effect, the scenario would probably have to last a few days, and the unit count would have to be relatively small, given that it would be a learning scenariio.

At the present time, the orders delay seems mostly related to how well the original plan was conceived, which is OK, but it would be nice if it could be illustrated to also work in a dynamic manner as it does in the real world. Of course in such a case, one side has to have the advantage in orders delay unless the player ability is higher for one side.

Henri

The Boyd cycle in boxing: "I feinted to the left, feinted to the right, jabbed a couple of times with my left to raise his arms, then rammed him in the belly with a right, and the first thing that he knew, I was flat on my back!"[8|]
Banquet
Posts: 1190
Joined: Thu Aug 22, 2002 9:04 pm
Location: England

RE: Questions for first time customers

Post by Banquet »

MarkShot,

With regards to you question to prior customers.  I find your AARs perfect as they are.  I don't think they need better graphics or labels.  Personally I prefer to read them on the forum.  I am less inclined to download a PDF document..  but others might appreciate that they can read it offline.

The two things I find are most likely to put people off the series is the fact that it's real time and that it isn't designed to micromanage units.  I think a multimedia presentation of some sort that demonstrated how well the AI handles things (Battalion HQ orders and such) and also how easy it is to take command of a company would help.  A voice track describing the various gameplay aspects would be good.  It would show non believers how well the system works.


Post Reply

Return to “Conquest of the Aegean”