Iron Storm (Scenario 50): Playtest

Post descriptions of your brilliant successes and unfortunate demises.

Moderators: wdolson, Don Bowen, mogami

Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

12/18/41-12/19/41

Post by Alikchi2 »

Excellent writing guys..interesting to see what the Japanese will try now

We've entered a quiet period while I get my act together ... the blame falls to me, I severely underestimated the Brits! And I designed the damn scenario!

Here's a quick two-day update.

12/18/41-12/19/41

The waters off Malaya have finally quieted again - in fact, after the 16th and 17th, the last few days have been positively peaceful in comparison. Only one small Lily raid was launched on the 18th, and the 19th saw absolutely no action in the theatre at all.

On a sadder note - despite the valiant efforts of the crew of the Ise, the flooding could not be overcome and she sunk in port on the 19th. That brings our tally for losses in this operation to four CVL, two BB, one CA, and one DD.

On the ground the situation was much less quiet. Yamashita had ordered a dawn shock attack on the 17th; believing that British reinforcements were sure to be on the way, he realized it was essential to capture the airfield before they arrived.

The attack - 2 partial divisions against two Commonwealth (Indians and New Zealander) brigades, with artillery support - was not a success. Although much ground was gained, the enemy fought hard and contained us. We suffered heavy losses and disruption in the process.

[center]Image
Captain Morinama is one of the few high-ranking officers remaining in the hard-fighting 18th Division.[/center]

We will just have to hold out and wait for reinforcements to arrive.

Much of the action has shifted to the Philippines. We captured Tuguegarao today (the 19th) and we expect Lingayen to fall to the 65th Brigade tomorrow. Meanwhile, further Japanese troops land in the south, at Legaspi, and our "southern pincer" should be ready to march north towards Naga and Manila within a reasonable amount of time.

[center]Image
Japanese troops (unit classified) wade ashore at Legaspi.[/center]

American air attacks have been intensifying, although they still remain sporadic and ineffective. On the 18th, several B-17s and 35 P-40Es from Manila - that must be nearly their entire remaining force! - attacked our troopships unloading off Legaspi and scored a few hits. Arizona Maru was torpedoed by S-37 on the 18th, while the same sub managed to sink Anzan Maru today. Our PCs are not so hot at this ASW thing.

Finally, the enemy is intensifying efforts to deny Kuching airbase to us. A heavy bombardment of the field by Exeter and her fast group (we must sink that ship!) inflicted 118 hits on the runway, not to mention destroying hundreds of tons of supplies and many aircraft on the ground. Kuching may have to be evacuated until Singapore is neutralized - it's hard to support without risking expensive naval assets that we don't have!

Elsewhere the Pacific is devoid of combat - for now. Hmmm.. the Dutch have been awfully quiet lately.
User avatar
Captain Cruft
Posts: 3707
Joined: Wed Mar 17, 2004 12:49 pm
Location: England

RE: 12/18/41-12/19/41

Post by Captain Cruft »

There have been more British successes. I'll let Adm Alikchimoto fill you in though :)

The only thing I will say is that I just lurv Allied Damage Control. It's virtually impossible to get your ships sunk!
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

Little preview thing

Post by Alikchi2 »

Yes I'm definitely missing DC - I might have been able to save Ise if only I could contain the flooding. C'est la vie...

At this point I think I have putput Repulse out of action for anywhere between a week and a month (depending on system damage), taken Illustrious out of the equation (again, depending on repair time), and only moderately damaged Valiant, Formidable and Furious. Not a great ratio, but it's a start. [;)]

===

I'll have another two-day update later today (I need to get some sleep, it's 5:37 AM here) - but the news is:

Air operations stepped up in the Philippines - the reduction of Manila begins. Remainder of the FEAF must be attrited - the B-17s are starting to hit things.
Ground troops advance in the Philippines as well.
Further damage dealt to Kuching airbase by Dutch and British bombers - particularly Wellingtons.
Stalemate at Brunei, Wake, and Kota Bharu.
Terauchi confers with Yamamoto - plans are made for Malaya.
56th and 3rd Division retraining in Indochina for the relief of the 18th and 34th divisions.
I-boats off the West Coast begin to make their presence known.
Japanese plans in the Celebes/Ambon area will be discussed too.

All tomorrow. [8D]
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

12/20/41-12/21/41

Post by Alikchi2 »

Slight delay - here we go.

Another few quiet days. Don't worry, things are happening behind the scenes.

12/20/41-12/21/41

The 20th started off with a torpedo hit by I-22 off the West Coast. AK William Luckenbach was struck, and I-22 deftly evaded the depth charge pattern laid by destroyer MacDonough. The Americans surely have more escorts than that... ? We certainly aren't complaining.

Much of the action has been over Kuching, which is still shut down as an airbase. Blenheims, Wellingtons and Martins have kept it closed and are keeping the damage level constant. The destruction of Admiral Komatsu's destroyer division earlier this month has prevented us from flying in engineers or support troops and what few we have are having trouble just keeping the damage level constant.

[center]Image
A heavily damaged Zero, victim of a Wellington raid on the 20th.[/center]

We have not been completely unsuccessful on the air front though. On th 20th we re-launched our aerial campaign in the Philippines in earnest - 47 Nells, 25 Betties and 22 Lizzies, escorted by 38 Zeroes, made a daylight attack on Manila, from which most of the anti-shipping strikes had been launched. Nearly a dozen Warhawks were destroyed in the air or on the ground and bombing results were encouraging. We intend to continue this campaign until the Americans are spent...

[center]Image
Cavite Navy Yard burns fiercely after a Japanese air raid.[/center]

On the ground we make further advances. Lingayen fell to the troops of the 65th Brigade on the 19th, while Jolo Island became Japanese on the 20th. Support troops are also finally arriving, meaning that our Army and Navy planes can now keep up constant pressure against the Americans. San Marcelino is already getting the daily attention of our Lilies and Anns.

With the RAF and Royal Navy in Singapore protecting Norwestern Borneo and Sumatra, the western route to Java is choked shut - at least until we can neutralize Singapore and re-open Kuching. Operations are being considered in the Celebes-Ambon area in order to take advantage of the probable shift of RN and RNN assets to the Malaya area. Invasions should begin within the week in this operational zone. A few battleships and seaplane carriers should do well enough here to protect us from the Dutch.

[center]Image
The Dutch battlecruiser Van Brakel, prior to her 1933 refit. German built, 27 knots, eight 13.8"/45 guns - we shall be wary of her and her two sisters.[/center]

We hope that this quiet period persists until we are ready for another major operation.
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

The RNN

Post by Alikchi2 »

Just for you guys - A primer on the RNN in Iron Storm!

[center]Image

The Royal Netherlands Navy in the NEI
[/center]

In Iron Storm, the Dutch have had a bit more luck with their Navy than in our timeline. Several new ships are available.

Most notable are the battlecruisers Wilem Warmont and Van Brakel. These ships are of German design and armed with 13.8" guns. Anchored in Soerabaja, they are the pride of the Dutch Navy. De Zeven Provincien, the first of the class, is currently serving in the Mediterranean fleet under Admiral Harwood (a joint Dutch - Free French - Royal Navy effort in this now peaceful theatre).

Also new is one new cruiser of the Java class - Celebes - and two cruisers of the Eendracht class. Historically, the Eendrachts were completed by the Germans after the Dutch surrender and used by them. In this timeline, the Dutch manage to finish them off just in time.

Several new Dutch destroyers are available as well.


[center]====================================[/center]


[center]De Zeven Provincien class Battlecruiser

Image
De Zeven Provincien (1914), Wilem Warmont (1914), Van Brakel (1915)
[/center]

By 1910, the Netherlands was surrounded by nations scrambling to build Dreadnoughts at an ever faster rate. The British, the Germans, and (worryingly) the Japanese were all in threatening positions. The Navy resolved to get a few capital ships of their own.

The Dutch originally wanted a larger number of smaller ships. However, Germany offered to subsidize the cost of these ships and the extra cost of docking and repair facilities in the Netherland East Indies. A few British newspapers cried foul - some went so far as to claim that they were actually for Germany's home account. The Kaiser, often his own worst enemy in these situations, claimed in a bombastic speech that they indeed were intended for the High Seas Fleet as replacements for cruisers lost in the Pacific. Following the outbreak of war, the ships were seized and renamed; Stein, Ziethen and Graf Spee respectively. They were returned after the peace settlement when the Dutch were compliant with handing over the former Kaiser to Allied authorities.

The ships are powerful and well armed with 8 13.8"/45 guns. A tough torpedo bulkhead is a mark of the design, as well, which is capable of 27 knots. All three ships were rebuilt in 1933 and could be considered rough equivalents to the rebuilt Fusos of the IJN. At the time of Pearl Harbor, De Zeven Provincien is serving in the Mediterranean as the Dutch contribution to the joint Allied fleet under Admiral Harwood. She would soon be diverted homewards through the Suez Canal.


[center]Eendract class Light Cruiser

Image
Eendracht (1939), Kijkduin (1940)
[/center]

Eendracht and Kijkduin were designed and built to replace the Java, Celebes and Sumatra. Eendracht has served the East Indies for nearly all of her career, while Kijkduin was nearly captured on her slip in 1940. Completed in Britain to Dutch standards, Kijkduin went on to serve in the Mediterranean, sinking two Italian destroyers and ramming a U-boat! After Italy's surrender, she transferred to Soerabaja, her combat experience adding significantly to the Dutch Navy there.
User avatar
51st Highland Div
Posts: 347
Joined: Sat Jul 23, 2005 1:30 pm
Location: Glasgow,Scotland

RE: De Zeven Provincien

Post by 51st Highland Div »

I take it the Dutch naval forces have a good experience level then ? Be interesting to see how they would fair up against the IJN soon [:D]
https://i.ibb.co/SRBTPGK/hmsglasgowmatrix.jpg
______________________________________________

The beatings will continue until morale improves....

Banner thanks to RogueUSMC
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

RE: De Zeven Provincien

Post by Alikchi2 »

Their experience levels still aren't too hot, but the big guns certainly make up for it. [X(]

I had considered doing a few modifications to the ML-KNIL - like adding Fokker G.Is, for example - but I decided that a) it wasn't realistic, more of a novelty really and b) my job is hard enough already!

We certainly shall find out how they do.. the troop transports are loading up in Palau. I am going to update with the 22nd soonish!
User avatar
Terminus
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: De Zeven Provincien

Post by Terminus »

ORIGINAL: Alikchi

I had considered doing a few modifications to the ML-KNIL - like adding Fokker G.Is, for example - but I decided that a) it wasn't realistic, more of a novelty really and b) my job is hard enough already!

That'll be something for the next patch![;)]
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

IS 2.0 Fluff

Post by Alikchi2 »

That'll be something for the next patch! [;)]

Perhaps! [:D]

Actually, I do plan to release a 2.0 version within 6 months or so.

Changes I'm considering are:

1) Updating the IJN pilot pool and growth to Nik's scenario specs (with permission, of course)

2) Perhaps some changes to the Dutch air force - Fokker G.Is is a thought. Although I still believe it to be unrealistic.

3) The largest change: A reworking of the Washington Treaty in Iron Storm.

A "special clause" will be proposed that allows some nations to complete construction of ships already building. The end result within the spectrum of the game is a few more battleships and battlecruisers all around and some slight differences in all corners. However the game balance is unaffected - the new additions are essentially equal in number, if not in quality, and the carrier balance will remain the same.

The benefit here for the British is that several old Royal Navy battleships are sold to Australia and Canada to get rid of excess ships in the RN, but also to bolster the defence of the Commonwealth. You will see the battlecruiser Tiger in Australian hands as HMAS Australia, while for Canada:
HMS Iron Duke -> HMCS Dominion
HMS Benbow -> HMCS Ontario
HMS Canada -> HMCS Canada

[center]Image

Image

Image

[/center]

The usefulness of these old, slow (even slower than the R-class!) ships is up in the air, but there's nothing wrong with more battleships to play with, eh?

Of course it doesn't all go the Empire's way - the "special clause" of the Washington treaty means that the Americans get to finish USS Constellation and Constitution as Lexington-class battlecruisers. These are fast and powerful ships but ... the armor leaves something to be desired. Also, the USS Washington - the fourth Colorado-class battleship building in the 20's - is completed.

[center]Image[/center]

The California and Maryland class battleships were scheduled to be rebuilt in the mid-late 1930's but the work was deferred - with the much larger Japanese fleet in this timeline, perhaps the rebuilds will go on.

Finally, Japan will benefit from the extra building room as well. Tosa is not sunk as a target, and Kaga remains unconverted to a carrier - these Tosa-class battleships were basically improved Nagatos with an extra 16" turret. The loss of Kaga as a carrier is compensated by the other battlecruiser of the Akagi class being converted - Atago.

[center]Image

Image
[/center]

4)A few "what-ifs" for the USAAF. Confronted with enemy heavy bombers (G5N Liz) and a deadlier IJAAF, they might have pushed forward development of aircraft that were not considered in reality.

Thanks to CanisD for the images, and the Washington Treaty clause thought.
User avatar
Terminus
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: IS 2.0 Fluff

Post by Terminus »

Don't forget that the War Plan Orange mod will be out at some point...
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

IS and WPO

Post by Alikchi2 »

That'll definitely keep me busy - I'm not treading on TankerAce's feet with the G3s and 18" SoDaks!

I'm definitely going to play WPO, it looks fantastic. So perhaps you'll have to wait until next summer for IS 2.0. [:D]
User avatar
Terminus
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: IS and WPO

Post by Terminus »

It's definitely interesting to beta it...[8D]
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

RE: IS and WPO

Post by Alikchi2 »

Lucky git!
User avatar
Terminus
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: IS and WPO

Post by Terminus »

We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
User avatar
Terminus
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: IS and WPO

Post by Terminus »

BTW, you're talking about having the Atago as a carrier; where does that leave the heavy cruiser of the same name?
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

RE: IS and WPO

Post by Alikchi2 »

BTW, you're talking about having the Atago as a carrier; where does that leave the heavy cruiser of the same name?

She'll still be built, but the Japanese will have to give her a different name - I had Kumano and Suruga in mind.
User avatar
Terminus
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: IS and WPO

Post by Terminus »

Well, there's already a Kumano, so it'll have to be Suruga.
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

RE: IS and WPO

Post by Alikchi2 »

Agh, I had forgotten, thanks. Suruga it is.

I'd already encountered this problem with the Japanese newbuilds - it can be confusing. One of them is named Amagi, instead of a carrier that was not built in Iron Storm. A few other similar problems like this - it got extremely confusing when I hit destroyers - but everything is legitimate Japanese and there are no repeats. [:)]
User avatar
Terminus
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: IS and WPO

Post by Terminus »

Yeah, I guess there's only so many xxxxKazes...[;)]
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

12/22/41-12/23/41

Post by Alikchi2 »

Well Terminus I actually did hit the end of the line at one point! The Kairyu is a standardised 23,000ton fleet carrier type built inplace of Soryu and following Japanese CVs. There was capacity for so many that I ran out of names for them.

But, here's another update -

12/22/41-12/23/41

The past two days have been somewhat maddening.

The British and Dutch are gradually stepping up their aerial activity in Southeast Asia. On the 22nd strikes were launched at Bangkok, Ban Don, and Kuching, plus light bombing and army co-operation attacks on the Japanese foothold in Malaya.

Perhaps the nastiest event on the 22nd was the straying of our empty transports (they had been carrying 4th Independent Brigade) far too close to Malaya. The commander apparently disregarded RAF airpower and steamed his ships directly into Beaufort range while on the way back to Hainan. (Read: Alikchi forgot to set his retirement settings for this particular convoy.) As a result five of his transports received a torpedo each for his trouble. Nothing has sunk yet but it's still rather aggravating.

[center]Image
Kuroshio Maru gets strafed.[/center]

However, we have landed the 4th on the Kra Isthmus - at Ban Don. Already they are marching south to secure our in southern Thailand and prevent any British advances. Singora is only covered by a tank regiment at the moment.

The last two days have seen a continuation of hte Manila raids - with an ever-decreasing number of bombers due to damage and casualties. (The 22nd saw 44 Nells, 25 Betties and 18 Lizzies, whereas on the 23rd we were able to launch 38 Nells, 22 Betties, and only 7 Lizzies. The Lizzies, it seems, are especially vulnerable to flak .. )

The raids have been purportedly successful, sort of. Lots of P-40Es have been shot down or destroyed on the ground and the airfield has been beaten up a bit. However the constant flak and the lack of rest has pretty much put out our pilots, so we shall pause for a few days.

[center]Image
Betties traveling towards Manila.[/center]

In the meantime the enemy has been active on his own. Kuching, at this point, is no longer an active airbase. Very early in the morning on the 23rd, every modern ship in the Dutch fleet showed up and bombarded the base into oblivion, followed by a squadron of British ships that finished the job. Throughout the rest of the day British and Dutch bombers kept up the pressure and we are at 99 runway damage. The results:

Code: Select all

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Naval bombardment of Kuching, at 27,56
  
 Japanese aircraft
 no flights
  
 Japanese aircraft losses
 A6M2 Zero: 3 destroyed
 Ki-32 Mary: 2 destroyed
 H6K4 Mavis: 1 destroyed
 G3M Nell: 2 destroyed
  
 Allied Ships
 DD Noordbrabant
 DD Dordtrect
 DD Ijseelmer
 DD Van der Heyden
 DD Vlieland
 CL Kijkduin
 CL Eendracht
 CL De Ruyter
 BC Van Brakel
 BC Wilem Warmont
  
 Japanese ground losses:
 932 casualties reported
 Guns lost 8
  
 Airbase hits 4
 Airbase supply hits 5
 Runway hits 78
  
 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Naval bombardment of Kuching, at 27,56
  
 Japanese aircraft
 no flights
  
 Japanese aircraft losses
 G3M Nell: 1 destroyed
 A6M2 Zero: 1 destroyed
  
 Allied Ships
 DD Kimberly
 DD Kingston
 DD Jackal
 DD Jaguar
 CA Berwick
 CA Cornwall
 CL Hobart
 CL Sheffield
 DD Hereward
 DD Gallant
  
 Japanese ground losses:
 270 casualties reported
  
 Airbase hits 15
 Airbase supply hits 6
 Runway hits 212
  
 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

We've managed to fly in engineers, but it's going to take a while to repair the field and it doesn't look like the enemy is going to grant us the respite necessary. And just to add insult to injury, the Royal Navy group sunk I-165 on the way back to Singapore! Grrr...

The British bombing Bangkok - Blenheims escorted by Buffalos from southern Burma - have been targeting the port, where BatDiv 1 has gone into hiding. On the 23rd their accuracy was exceptional despite being attacked by our Nates - 3 hits were scored on Inaba, igniting minor fires but not doing any major damage, while 6 bombs struck Harima, knocking out two 3.9" DP turrets.

Finally, a more frightening note. CarDiv 5 (Soryu and Donryu have continued to loiter outside Wake to prevent any American reinforcement attempts while our own reinforcements are on the way. Unfortunately the Americans have noticed this and subs have been vectored in - today USS Pompano actually hit Donryu with a spread of torpedoes, but they failed to detonate!

The rest of the Kido Butai is still on the move. You'll know when they've reached their destination. [;)]

[center]Image
Akagi leads the fleet westward.[/center]
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”