What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
Moderators: wdolson, MOD_War-in-the-Pacific-Admirals-Edition
What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
Howdy! I am curious what most think is "Kosher" or fair in terms of Japanese Air Unit expansion. I am specifically thinking of IJN units, which are the ones that can be re-sized.
If you press things to the max, you can re-size all DB, TB, and Zero units to 81 planes by loading it onto Akagi for a turn. That would make the IJN Air truly large, including some pretty nasty IJN Fighter units if PDUs are ON (they are OFF, however, in the game I am currently playing). Floatplanes can all be expanded to 24, the capacity of Chitose/Chiyoda.
I think that's excessive (81 planes!), however, so here is what I have done or plan to do.
--Limit floatplane units to 12 planes max
--I am moving some CL floatplane units off CL in order to expand to 9 planes
For CV Units:
--Expand all CVE fighters (only 3 planes initially) to 18
--Expand LBA IJN air units to 36 planes max (unless they are already there of course)
--Make sure all CVs have max airgroups (Ryujo, for example, only starts with 24 planes)
Does that sound fair? What are some self-imposed limits others place on IJN air expansion?
PS: As Allies, I typically expand some units to CVE-size, and remove some of the TBF units. That's about it.
If you press things to the max, you can re-size all DB, TB, and Zero units to 81 planes by loading it onto Akagi for a turn. That would make the IJN Air truly large, including some pretty nasty IJN Fighter units if PDUs are ON (they are OFF, however, in the game I am currently playing). Floatplanes can all be expanded to 24, the capacity of Chitose/Chiyoda.
I think that's excessive (81 planes!), however, so here is what I have done or plan to do.
--Limit floatplane units to 12 planes max
--I am moving some CL floatplane units off CL in order to expand to 9 planes
For CV Units:
--Expand all CVE fighters (only 3 planes initially) to 18
--Expand LBA IJN air units to 36 planes max (unless they are already there of course)
--Make sure all CVs have max airgroups (Ryujo, for example, only starts with 24 planes)
Does that sound fair? What are some self-imposed limits others place on IJN air expansion?
PS: As Allies, I typically expand some units to CVE-size, and remove some of the TBF units. That's about it.
- Jorge_Stanbury
- Posts: 4345
- Joined: Wed Feb 29, 2012 12:57 pm
- Location: Montreal
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
My personal "fair" standard, playing against the AI was:
- Float planes up to 24 ... but keep all cruisers and AVs with its organic airgroup.
Japan really needs better air cover
- Carrier planes up to 27 ... Taiyo size
keep organic airgroups in its own carrier; resize as needed
- no LBA resize
- Float planes up to 24 ... but keep all cruisers and AVs with its organic airgroup.
Japan really needs better air cover
- Carrier planes up to 27 ... Taiyo size
keep organic airgroups in its own carrier; resize as needed
- no LBA resize
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
Remember, there's a flip side to expanding all those IJN air groups - you'll drain the pilot pool just that much sooner.
In my DBB-C PBEM, I started with 1700 IJN pilots, and (in early Oct, 42), only have 212 in the pool. So, at this rate, not too long into 43, my pool will be empty. I've done a moderate amount of resizing - most Jakes to 20 or 24, and a few other groups. But I could have done much more.
Admittedly, my IJN air has been very busy since the start, and also this is my first time playing the Empire (thus there just might have been greater losses than if I really knew what I was doing!).
But still, come 1943, I will be finding out what happens when the pool runs out of pilots (probably not a good thing).
In my DBB-C PBEM, I started with 1700 IJN pilots, and (in early Oct, 42), only have 212 in the pool. So, at this rate, not too long into 43, my pool will be empty. I've done a moderate amount of resizing - most Jakes to 20 or 24, and a few other groups. But I could have done much more.
Admittedly, my IJN air has been very busy since the start, and also this is my first time playing the Empire (thus there just might have been greater losses than if I really knew what I was doing!).
But still, come 1943, I will be finding out what happens when the pool runs out of pilots (probably not a good thing).
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
Are you training pilots? Dedicate some units to training and cycle the untrained pilots through them.
I haven't played Japan, but from what I've read from experienced players, most of the time you can keep your pool of trained reserves up by training the green pilots coming out of basic training.
As Allies, I keep US bases full of units doing full time training. I keep a lot of units in NZ, Australia, and India training too. Early on I usually don't have enough aircraft to go around, but by mid-42 I usually have the units filled out with max aircraft and max pilots training at 100%. I don't release them to the pools until their overall experience reaches at least 50 and the specific area skills in the 60-70 range.
The Allies have supply to burn and Japan doesn't. As Japan you're robbing peter to pay paul, but making sure you keep the reserve pool full of trained pilots is important for the long term health of the Japanese cause. In the real war, Japan's fortunes started declining rapidly when their skilled pilots started to run out and they didn't have a training program to replace them.
Bill
I haven't played Japan, but from what I've read from experienced players, most of the time you can keep your pool of trained reserves up by training the green pilots coming out of basic training.
As Allies, I keep US bases full of units doing full time training. I keep a lot of units in NZ, Australia, and India training too. Early on I usually don't have enough aircraft to go around, but by mid-42 I usually have the units filled out with max aircraft and max pilots training at 100%. I don't release them to the pools until their overall experience reaches at least 50 and the specific area skills in the 60-70 range.
The Allies have supply to burn and Japan doesn't. As Japan you're robbing peter to pay paul, but making sure you keep the reserve pool full of trained pilots is important for the long term health of the Japanese cause. In the real war, Japan's fortunes started declining rapidly when their skilled pilots started to run out and they didn't have a training program to replace them.
Bill
WIS Development Team
- Jorge_Stanbury
- Posts: 4345
- Joined: Wed Feb 29, 2012 12:57 pm
- Location: Montreal
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
And actually one of the main reasons for resizing squadrons as Japan is, of course, to have more pilot training. Remember FPs can train almost any skill
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
ORIGINAL: wdolson
Are you training pilots? Dedicate some units to training and cycle the untrained pilots through them.
I haven't played Japan, but from what I've read from experienced players, most of the time you can keep your pool of trained reserves up by training the green pilots coming out of basic training.
As Allies, I keep US bases full of units doing full time training. I keep a lot of units in NZ, Australia, and India training too. Early on I usually don't have enough aircraft to go around, but by mid-42 I usually have the units filled out with max aircraft and max pilots training at 100%. I don't release them to the pools until their overall experience reaches at least 50 and the specific area skills in the 60-70 range.
The Allies have supply to burn and Japan doesn't. As Japan you're robbing peter to pay paul, but making sure you keep the reserve pool full of trained pilots is important for the long term health of the Japanese cause. In the real war, Japan's fortunes started declining rapidly when their skilled pilots started to run out and they didn't have a training program to replace them.
Bill
I train pilots like crazy; especially with PDU OFF, you have alot of obsolete plane types hanging around, and a Nate is as good as a Frank when it comes to honing your dogfighting skills.
Japan also has a number of restricted air units that are particularly good for this, though almost all Japanese air can be bought eventually
I just want to make sure I am not overdoing it on IJN expansion.
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
You can resize to 81, then divide the unit and keep one on board while the other two act as training units.
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
ORIGINAL: sanch
Remember, there's a flip side to expanding all those IJN air groups - you'll drain the pilot pool just that much sooner.
In my DBB-C PBEM, I started with 1700 IJN pilots, and (in early Oct, 42), only have 212 in the pool. So, at this rate, not too long into 43, my pool will be empty. I've done a moderate amount of resizing - most Jakes to 20 or 24, and a few other groups. But I could have done much more.
Admittedly, my IJN air has been very busy since the start, and also this is my first time playing the Empire (thus there just might have been greater losses than if I really knew what I was doing!).
But still, come 1943, I will be finding out what happens when the pool runs out of pilots (probably not a good thing).
Not to mention extra air support needed, and extra supplies to fly missions, and many extra supplies for larger upgrades and more replacements to fill out the unit.
- MrBlizzard
- Posts: 636
- Joined: Mon Apr 16, 2012 7:34 pm
- Location: Italy
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
I act very similar to you:ORIGINAL: Q-Ball
Howdy! I am curious what most think is "Kosher" or fair in terms of Japanese Air Unit expansion. I am specifically thinking of IJN units, which are the ones that can be re-sized.
If you press things to the max, you can re-size all DB, TB, and Zero units to 81 planes by loading it onto Akagi for a turn. That would make the IJN Air truly large, including some pretty nasty IJN Fighter units if PDUs are ON (they are OFF, however, in the game I am currently playing). Floatplanes can all be expanded to 24, the capacity of Chitose/Chiyoda.
I think that's excessive (81 planes!), however, so here is what I have done or plan to do.
--Limit floatplane units to 12 planes max
--I am moving some CL floatplane units off CL in order to expand to 9 planes
For CV Units:
--Expand all CVE fighters (only 3 planes initially) to 18
--Expand LBA IJN air units to 36 planes max (unless they are already there of course)
--Make sure all CVs have max airgroups (Ryujo, for example, only starts with 24 planes)
Does that sound fair? What are some self-imposed limits others place on IJN air expansion?
PS: As Allies, I typically expand some units to CVE-size, and remove some of the TBF units. That's about it.
Leave CA that have 2 FP groups with just one and expand the other to 9.
Expand FP squadron to 27 only if they can split in 3 (else expand to 9).
Expand the LBA navy planes to max 36.
Blizzard
-
mind_messing
- Posts: 3394
- Joined: Mon Oct 28, 2013 11:59 am
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
I went all out in terms of IJN re-sizing. All the fighter squadrons that can be resized are now 81 planes, a good number of the floatplane squadrons are sized 20 and a couple of dive and torpedo bomber squadrons have been bulked up too.
The wonderful thing about floatplanes is that they can train just about any skill. ASW, NavS, NavB, LowNav and even Air. The only thing they can't train is NavT and Trans.
As sanch said, you'll run out of pilots in the pool before anything else, so you can focus on quality over quantity.
Putting 81+ EXP pilots into TRACOM becomes more important as a means to get access to rookies quicker and get them trained and in the pool quicker.
The wonderful thing about floatplanes is that they can train just about any skill. ASW, NavS, NavB, LowNav and even Air. The only thing they can't train is NavT and Trans.
As sanch said, you'll run out of pilots in the pool before anything else, so you can focus on quality over quantity.
Putting 81+ EXP pilots into TRACOM becomes more important as a means to get access to rookies quicker and get them trained and in the pool quicker.
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
I have done the same.
I have extended all possible IJN TB and DB units. Then trained then in low naval and low attack. Which increase there defense level faster then Fighter pilots. Some reach 70 very fast. Then I convert them to fighter pilots. Their survivability rate increased more then I expected. With 50 attack rate then don't kill too much but they don't die like flies. An if they get kill their attack level jumps 5 to 10 points immediately.
Contrary to common belief I think extending groups also help in terms of Heavy Industry expenditure a lot. Instead of paying HI in training system you extract them when they are baby and train them. combining bomber and fighter pools you have more then enough reserve for enlarged groups.
And also I discovered a good side effect maybe a glitch. When you extract 10 experience level pilots check them. some have extremely high attributes. For example I have a patrol group with 90 to 70 naval search points. With 20 exprience. They are very valuable.
I have extended all possible IJN TB and DB units. Then trained then in low naval and low attack. Which increase there defense level faster then Fighter pilots. Some reach 70 very fast. Then I convert them to fighter pilots. Their survivability rate increased more then I expected. With 50 attack rate then don't kill too much but they don't die like flies. An if they get kill their attack level jumps 5 to 10 points immediately.
Contrary to common belief I think extending groups also help in terms of Heavy Industry expenditure a lot. Instead of paying HI in training system you extract them when they are baby and train them. combining bomber and fighter pools you have more then enough reserve for enlarged groups.
And also I discovered a good side effect maybe a glitch. When you extract 10 experience level pilots check them. some have extremely high attributes. For example I have a patrol group with 90 to 70 naval search points. With 20 exprience. They are very valuable.
"Unless a nation's life faces peril, war is murder."
"Sovereignty is not given, it is taken."
"After having lost their lives on this land they have become our sons as well."
Mustafa Kemal
"Sovereignty is not given, it is taken."
"After having lost their lives on this land they have become our sons as well."
Mustafa Kemal
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
Getting back to Q-Ball's original question on what is fair regarding resizing air groups, I think it depends on how you think the game should be played. If you are an advocate of "purely historical simulation", then probably resizing isn't the way to go. But if your limitation is to not engage in "gamey exploits", then I see nothing wrong with resizing air groups since the ability to do so is explicitly included in the game code. If you fall into the latter camp, as other posters have noted, resizing does come at a cost. The impact on pilot pools is one. Another is that if you resize some of your CV fighter groups to boost CAP, you loose the offensive punch of the missing DB and TB groups. So resizing is a matter of tradeoffs IMHO, and whether it's "fair" or not depends on how you prefer to play the game.
- ny59giants
- Posts: 9902
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 12:02 pm
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
I re-size only to the same size of pre-existing IJN air groups. So, most Zeros can go up to 36 or 42. If you're going to allow Japan to go up to 81, then the Scenario needs to edited to allow more Allied groups to re-size. The Allies have very few groups from their Replacement CVE that can re-size. The rest of USN air groups have no way to do so.
[center]
[/center]
[/center]RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
ORIGINAL: ny59giants
I re-size only to the same size of pre-existing IJN air groups. So, most Zeros can go up to 36 or 42. If you're going to allow Japan to go up to 81, then the Scenario needs to edited to allow more Allied groups to re-size. The Allies have very few groups from their Replacement CVE that can re-size. The rest of USN air groups have no way to do so.
This has been my practice in order to make them interchangeable with the ones that can't resize freely until 1944 or 1945.
Also note that an 81-plane unit can be split into 3x27 "Sentai"-sized units.
Really, training 108 pilots at once is nice. Still, I think I've only done that with one unit. I'm just not seeing the need.
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
In a pbemail game as the Allies I do expand a lot of units but within reason. I like to have some spare carrier fighter groups so I will expand some of the marine units but not larger than the 36 allowed for a fleet carrier. I don't like the fighter torpedo bomber mix on CVEs either so I use single groups on CVEs but never expand them beyond 24. Ark, my regular opponent follows the same practice. After our last campaign, I discovered that he has created some super sized training groups and I was a little offended. However after some reflection I came to the conclusion that it did not matter. I had no trouble fighting the Japanese air force and it was a scen 2 campaign. As long as it is for training it was OK.
I am the Holy Roman Emperor and am above grammar.
Sigismund of Luxemburg
Sigismund of Luxemburg
- Chickenboy
- Posts: 24648
- Joined: Fri Jun 28, 2002 11:30 pm
- Location: San Antonio, TX
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
ORIGINAL: Q-Ball
Howdy! I am curious what most think is "Kosher" or fair in terms of Japanese Air Unit expansion. I am specifically thinking of IJN units, which are the ones that can be re-sized.
If you press things to the max, you can re-size all DB, TB, and Zero units to 81 planes by loading it onto Akagi for a turn. That would make the IJN Air truly large, including some pretty nasty IJN Fighter units if PDUs are ON (they are OFF, however, in the game I am currently playing). Floatplanes can all be expanded to 24, the capacity of Chitose/Chiyoda.
I think that's excessive (81 planes!), however, so here is what I have done or plan to do.
--Limit floatplane units to 12 planes max
--I am moving some CL floatplane units off CL in order to expand to 9 planes
For CV Units:
--Expand all CVE fighters (only 3 planes initially) to 18
--Expand LBA IJN air units to 36 planes max (unless they are already there of course)
--Make sure all CVs have max airgroups (Ryujo, for example, only starts with 24 planes)
Does that sound fair? What are some self-imposed limits others place on IJN air expansion?
PS: As Allies, I typically expand some units to CVE-size, and remove some of the TBF units. That's about it.
Hi Q-ball,
My personal tact is to expand (and then split) FP groups for naval search, pending the approval of my partner. One of the larger CS works well for this.
I have no issue with resizing existing IJNAF groups to fill capacity on existing CVs or customizing the organic airgroups as you see fit (more TBs: less DBs for example).
Personally, I would consider resizing all IJN units to 81 and then splitting them (or using them in their maximized state) gamey. Particularly since I'm receiving the benefits of PDU on and the enhanced OOB of scenario 2, this just seems over the top against another player.

-
JocMeister
- Posts: 8258
- Joined: Wed Jul 29, 2009 10:03 am
- Location: Sweden
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
I think you need to discuss that with your opponent. Also keep in mind that if you go bananas so can your opponent...
Personally I would say all things needs to be done in moderation in this game or things tend to go haywire.
Personally I would say all things needs to be done in moderation in this game or things tend to go haywire.

RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
As an AFB, this thread makes me a bit queasy.
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
Just for the record I do not resize at all except for AGs on CVs. And then I leave them there. [:)]
RE: What's Kosher in Japanese Air Expansion?
I would say you should definitely check with your opp, just to make sure it is something each player is ok with. and watch out how things can work together. In my current game, the opp also pushed research in navy fighters to that by July 42 he had maxed out size groups operating A6M8s. So in CBI now I am facing probably 500 late war fighters. It has made any type of air war in Burma impossible. I am not saying it is wrong, but it is something you should definitely check with your opp to make sure it is the type of game they want, as jocmeister pointed out, pushing the game engine can really create game styles that some players aren't interested in. Some people are historical gamers and some aren't, neither is better than the other, but they are different.








