<t> Yeah, the Mantis save should cover it, but if you need more instances let me know. I was just experimenting to see if it was limited to certain situations (I thought it might be France-only, like some other bugs, or that maybe the pre-existing GB-France war was causing confusion about whether ...

And it also applies to a France-Spain battle (Dutch fleets don't take part), so it seems to be completely across the board.

<t> I set up another test, in which GB got control of Sweden, and the Russia-Sweden war lapsed so Sweden became a fully fledged GB free state. Then got into a naval battle with France. Swedes sailed with the GB fleet, but did not take part in the battle. Also, the Dutch were with the French fleet ...

<t> Playing around with this a bit more, I started a fresh game to see whether maybe something that happened in the previous game created the problem, but it's still happening. Some observations:<br/>
<br/>
Set up all French and Dutch fleets at Toulon.<br/>
<br/>
First GB sent a small blockading ...

Submitted as Mantis 703.

<t> Playing around with 1.08.02, I notice some changes to the way minor fleets are handled, some of which is an improvement, but which may have introduced a bug.<br/>
<br/>
It appears that if you are running a minor that has been DoWed by a major power with which you are not at war, you can no ...

I saw this too. It seems that if you install 1.08 in a separate folder (as per recommendation), the installation doesn't create a save folder, so there's nowhere for the autosaves (or any other saves) to go. However, if you just manually create one, it seems to work.

<t> I don't know the answer, but I can tell you that using your scenario I was able to conquer those states (as France), free them, and build from them. So they're not unable to build across the board, if that helps.<br/>
<br/>
Did you check to see whether Austria is receiving income and manpower ...

<r>
<QUOTE><s>[quote]</s>ORIGINAL: Marshall Ellis<br/>
<br/>
Huh? I'm really confused now???
<e>[/quote]</e></QUOTE>
<br/>
The problem is not just that the game is incorrectly implementing a rule; it's reaching a dead end where you can't escape a battle screen except by alt-ctrl-del.<br ...

<r> <QUOTE><s>[quote]</s>If losses are to be taken and only militia is available, then militia losses should be acceptable regardless of cumulative morale loss. The game should allow this.
<e>[/quote]</e></QUOTE>
<br/>
I believe (though I'm not sure) that the game does *generally* allow this. For ...

<r>
<QUOTE><s>[quote]</s>ORIGINAL: Marshall Ellis<br/>
<br/>
Thanks for the help David!<br/>

<e>[/quote]</e></QUOTE>
<br/>
But N.B. the game is not currently doing any of those things, but leaving an impasse. Is this already on Mantis? I don't have a save for this, but it should be easy to ...

Thanks, David, that makes sense to me.

<t> I was playing the 1792 scenario (which is a blast--thanks Yearworld), and ran into a problem. I don't think it's specific to the scenario, but it's a militia-related problem, and France starts that scenario with lots of militia, so that's probably why I haven't seen it before.<br/>
<br ...

<r>
<QUOTE><s>[quote]</s>ORIGINAL: Cunctator<br/>
<br/>
One question:<br/>
currently the garrisoned depots block enemy's corps movement. Can it be solved please? It can become a major issue as it can be easily abused.<br/>
<br/>
Eia Boardgame rules:<br/>
7.3.2.1: A corps must cease movement ...

<t> In 23 trials, some 50-odd percent of the time there would be no casualties, 34% of the time 1 casualty, and the remaining 13% of the time 2 or more casualties. So it is higher than average, but not especially weird.<br/>
<br/>
2 KIA is definitely an outlier. It would be very time-consuming to ...

Blockading fleet should indeed get the wind gauge.

In the case above, if GB rolled a 1, modified to 2, that would sink 4 Naples ships. Then Naples could roll a 6, for 25%, and sink the 1 GB ship, no?

<t> I set up a test case vs. the AI, with Napoleon vs. Mack, and replayed the battle a number of times. Each battle should count as 2 trials, since each side has a leader. First I tried it 20 times, and had no casualties. Then I tried a further 20, and had 1 casualty. So that's 1 in 80 trials.<br ...

<t> That does sound like a lot. The siege battles shouldn't count, either. If any leader casualties occur during a siege, that would itself be a bug, I think. (Or is it a deviation?)<br/>
<br/>
And if the game's (correctly) not doing leader casualties in sieges, then the denominator is just the ...

<t> There was a thread quite a while back on the 1-in-12 vs. 1-in-36 thing. That was fixed in an early version, but as Mardonius says, it could always get broken again....<br/>
<br/>
More recently there was a thread about the casualties always landing on the senior leader; that's supposed to be ...

<r>
<QUOTE><s>[quote]</s>ORIGINAL: Ted1066<br/>
<br/>
Have either of you taken the time to read the charts? I'm curious, because its pretty clear where only ONE '+1' modifier comes from. In Table 14.9, a defender gets a '+1' to their strat rating IF they are comprised entirely of cav or cossacks ...