I am pretty sure it has. In the above post, I had opened both games and looked at the combat planners and saw the units selected change as I clicked on them. IN TOAW III, the first unit/formation remained the primary formation and the other units/formations cooperation reflected against the first ...

My purpose with wanting to use the cooperation is to encourage command and control. I want to encourage players to keep forces together within a command rather that just throwing units all over the map. I see players massing formations of artillery in unrealistic deployments to create super barrages ...

General,

I will try to get you better information.

Regards,
Mark

Selecting a unit in the battle planner simply shows you the cooperation level of the other units in the battle planner relative to the unit you selected. So yes, flag colors will change because they are being compared against the selected unit. The display of cooperation flags gives you the ...

General Lemay,

I think what you are saying and what I am hearing are not the same. Having looked at the rules on cooperation, it indicates that formation cooperation affects the units in both the attack and defense. The misleading rule statement is on page 48, rule 8.6.1 where it indicates "The ...

I guess that I remember it wrong.

Apologies, I know that I have addressed this before, but I want to make sure that I understand this correctly. Cooperation penalties are applied to all elements in the battle. So, the elements of a formation with the most severe cooperation level penalizes the entire attacking force.

Hence, the ...

The Russian Revolution has begun!

7 October 1917 4 November 1917 2 December 1917 6 January 1918

Back to the strategic situation. As you can see the Western Front has not changed very much. Although, it has been bloody.

3 June 1917 1 July 1917 5 August 1917 2 September 1917

26 June 1915 10 July 1915 Sorry folks, I am missing about 12 saved game turns after this. So, there will be a missing group of pictures.

1 May 1915 15 May 1915 29 May 1915 12 June 1915

6 March 1915 20 March 1915 3 April 1915 17 April 1915

Beginning week of 6 February 1915 Beginning week of 20 February 1915

Beginning week 2 January 1915 Beginning week 16 January 1915 Beginning week 30 January 1915

Begin week 5 December 1914 Begin week 12 December 1914 Begin week 19 December 1914 Sorry, but I am missing the file for the last week of 1914.

Begin week 07 November 1914 Begin week 14 November 1914 Begin week 21 November 1914 Begin week 28 November 1914

Begin 10 October 1914 Begin 17 October 1914 Begin 24 October 1914 Begin 31 October 1914

Ammann is correct. Note, the pictures are from 1914 and if you look at the strategic pictures, you will see that France did not go down. We are now in late 1917 and the Entente is killing Germans/Bavarians by the train load in France. More pictures to follow.

I have downloaded the game to a portable drive. But, when I try to run it on a computer without the game (i.e. work), I get the steam message. Do I have to put steam on the portable drive?

Regards,
Mark

Golden,

I realize that you may not think it is needed and that I am not just grasping the impact of simultaneous movement. However, my argument is not about whether the C&C and Reorg should be a factor as much as I am pointing out that it is not scalable with the various scenario length of game ...