Early Allied CV loss

Gary Grigsby's strategic level wargame covering the entire War in the Pacific from 1941 to 1945 or beyond.

Moderators: Joel Billings, wdolson, Don Bowen, mogami

rubisco
Posts: 179
Joined: Mon Aug 06, 2007 5:37 pm

Early Allied CV loss

Post by rubisco »

I'm currently in a PBEM game as the Japanese. Currently in mid-Jan 1942. My opponent risked his carriers and I've sunk three of them for no loss. My opponent has surrendered because of this.

Was he right to do so? Can the Allies still fight on without those carriers?
User avatar
viberpol
Posts: 858
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2005 3:16 pm
Location: Global village, Poland, EU

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by viberpol »


I had similar experience once...

Check this thread out: tm.asp?m=1421090&mpage=1&key=&#1421324

In my opinion, loosing even 5 carriers should not make any Allied player to quit.
The 42 is for Allies to play hit & run, they just need to get used to looses.

The sunk carriers will eventually respawn for Allies in no time at all...
Somehow, sometimes it's even BETTER for Allied player to lose CVs -- because it means more Essex class carriers sooner.
Przy lackim orle, przy koniu Kiejstuta Archanioł Rusi na proporcach błysł
Yamato hugger
Posts: 3791
Joined: Tue Oct 05, 2004 5:38 am

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by Yamato hugger »

Well, giving up points is never a good thing. The Essex isnt that much better than the Yorktown / Lex classes that its worth giving up over 300 points apiece for [;)]
User avatar
viberpol
Posts: 858
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2005 3:16 pm
Location: Global village, Poland, EU

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by viberpol »

ORIGINAL: Yamato hugger

Well, giving up points is never a good thing. The Essex isnt that much better than the Yorktown / Lex classes that its worth giving up over 300 points apiece for [;)]

OK, I mean not just just loosing them...
Loosing them before 43 in clever fight that is to blunt the Japanese KB
and having a loooong played marriage-like PBEM in mind (perspective).
Przy lackim orle, przy koniu Kiejstuta Archanioł Rusi na proporcach błysł
rubisco
Posts: 179
Joined: Mon Aug 06, 2007 5:37 pm

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by rubisco »

The decisive carrier battle came about because my KB was covering landings in the South Pacific. With the loss of the US carriers, there was no longer any need to provide air cover for my landings. KB could be split up and sent raiding all over the map and I could have taken more risks with more dispersed landings.

As far as I can see, this is the immediate effect of these losses - the Japanese player can accelerate his timetable.
User avatar
Feinder
Posts: 7206
Joined: Wed Sep 04, 2002 7:33 pm
Location: Land o' Lakes, FL

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by Feinder »

Should he surrender?  Maybe.  Maybe not. 
 
I've been in a worse boat, and have come back a long way.  But it's taken litterally 2 years real time.  That's a long time.  I'm glad I've stuck with it, I've learned a lot.  But for many, it would be considered a collossal waste of time.
 
I see nothing wrong with an opponent conceeding.  Whether it's an Allied player that conceed if all 5 CVs are sunk, or if it's a Japanese player that conceeds because KB goes down in May (yes, -THAT- happens a lot too). 
 
It's FUN to be Japan and beat the snot out of somebody.  And that goes on for 6 months to a year of REAL time.  Again, I get tired of Japanese players casting stones at Allied opponents who wish to surrender, because (if they're new), they're just a likely to surrender if the hammer were to fall on them.  Not because Allied players or any different that Japanese ones.  It's the fact that you're talking about 30 minutes to 3 hours of your time, EVERY NIGHT, for 2 years, before there's any semblence of balance again.  That's a lot of time to dedicate to an enima.
 
My guess is, he's new, and you probably are too.  Most veteran players will only take a "for the duration" game, that is spelled out in advance.  If y'all spoke/wrote and indicated this "was for the long run", no auto-victory, keep at it! - Then no, your opponnent should not surrender.  You both committed beforehand to stay the course.  But if there was no explicit "Play to the end!", then no, there is no problem with your opponent surrendering.  But that's the very reason many players who have "endured" several games, will not take games vs. newer players, because they are more likely to surrender.  I'm going to say again, I don't have a problem with conceeding.  But if often takes somebody to have played for a while, to actually appreciate things that get into 1943 (with or without your carriers).

If you want to know just exactly how not fun it is to play as Allies for 2 year with no assets (actually, if he's only lost 3 CVs, its not THAT bad), get your opponnets password, DO NOT OPEN HIS TURN, and post in the opponents wanted forum to see if anyone wants to resume the game.
 
This is not personal towards you.  If you and your opponent agreed to a "for the duration game", then no he shouldn't surrender.  But if there was no explict indications, and esp if either of you are new, then no, there is no problem with conceeding.
 
-F-
"It is obvious that you have greatly over-estimated my regard for your opinion." - Me

Image
rubisco
Posts: 179
Joined: Mon Aug 06, 2007 5:37 pm

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by rubisco »

ORIGINAL: Feinder

Should he surrender? Maybe. Maybe not.

...snip...

This is not personal towards you. If you and your opponent agreed to a "for the duration game", then no he shouldn't surrender. But if there was no explict indications, and esp if either of you are new, then no, there is no problem with conceding.

-F-

I completely respect my opponent's right to surrender.

I was after a feel for how difficult my opponent's task would have been from there onwards, since I've no idea how hard an Allied game would be vs a human without those carriers.

When I asked whether my opponent was "right" to quit I didn't mean morally right - I meant was it the right choice given the difficulties he would encounter. The question was about his strategic judgment and not his morals!

You did answer my question though, so thank you.
Mike Scholl
Posts: 6187
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 1:17 am
Location: Kansas City, MO

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by Mike Scholl »

ORIGINAL: rubisco

I'm currently in a PBEM game as the Japanese. Currently in mid-Jan 1942. My opponent risked his carriers and I've sunk three of them for no loss. My opponent has surrendered because of this.

Was he right to do so? Can the Allies still fight on without those carriers?


If you had no "agreement" to actually play the game, he's excused. Otherwise, he's a crying whimp and a bit of a fool. The "fool" is for giving you the opportunity to sink his CV's for no loss---if he's going to fight that early he needs to do it where he can get some support. But as his losses will be replaced, and his strength continually increased..., he's a sniveler for bailing out just because he screwed up. He made the mistake, he should be willing to live and fight on with the consequences.

I have exactly the same regard for Japanese players who want to "run rampent for a year", then quit if they can't get an "auto-victory". Forget the silly "victory points" and play like you were actually fighting the real war...., with no "do-overs" available for either side.
User avatar
ctangus
Posts: 2153
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 11:34 pm
Location: Boston, Mass.

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by ctangus »

Yes, it is possible to come back despite losing 3 allied CVs early. I've done that though it's been a tough fight. (Against viberpol who posted in this thread earlier - and he just gave me another spanking. [:(])

Anyway, in other games I've had a couple opponents surrender to me. While I would have liked to continue those games (I was winning afterall [;)]) I'm also not interested in playing someone if my opponent will suffer months of misery. Personally I'd like an opponent to keep on despite a bad day or two - we'll both have those - but if the writing's on the wall I'm willing to accept a surrender.

User avatar
RUPD3658
Posts: 6921
Joined: Wed Aug 28, 2002 2:25 am
Location: East Brunswick, NJ

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by RUPD3658 »

I can respect his decision but I think may players quit when they feel then can no longer win. PBEM is a journey, not a destination.

I am playing Japan in 10/44 vs a very good Allied opponant. The best I can acahieve at this point is a draw but the real fun is in the play. Little things like sneaking a tanker through the Allied blockade or doing a hit an run raid on an isolated base are just as satifying for me at this point as winning a CV battle.

Also, a major set back makes you try new things. Out of nessessity, I have learned many a trick I will use in my future PBEMs
"The difference between genius and stupidity is that genius has limits"- Darwin Awards 2003

"No plan survives contact with the enemy." - Field Marshall Helmuth von Moltke
[img]https://www.matrixgames.com/forums/upfi ... EDB99F.jpg[/img]
User avatar
Oleg Mastruko
Posts: 4534
Joined: Sat Oct 21, 2000 8:00 am

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by Oleg Mastruko »

Whenever someone surrenders after early setback (usually the Allied player) I see it as Japanese doctrine and war "philosophy" being actually true in this parallel universe we call game. Indeed, after some bitch slapping weak western democracies would see the light and give up, bowing before unstoppable spirit of the Japanese warriors!
 
Of course, it wasn't like that in real war, but if some Allied player wants to play the role of weak demoralised westerner in the game, why not? That was THE idea behind Japanese aggression - they knew they could not out-produce the US but they believed the Allies would simply give up after some ass kicking. So if that indeed happens in the game - fine.
 
And there's the issue of auto victory, which is sometimes, in case of really big Allied losses, simply inevitable.....
User avatar
ny59giants
Posts: 9902
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 12:02 pm

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by ny59giants »

It is mid-4/42 as the Allies in a CHS PBEM game and I have lost 2CV's, 4BB/BC's, and a few CA's as I left the 2 CV TF's around Suva too long. [:(] We are playing 2 day turns (if it was 1 day turns, I would have lost less than half to date). I look at it as a learning experience and plan to go until the war ends (no auto victory to end the game).

I agree with others and say that you need to define what happens when either side loses it's CV's early. I get my 2 CV's back in mid-43, but will have 4 CV's plus the British CV's to play with until then. [:D]
[center]Image[/center]
User avatar
skrewball
Posts: 305
Joined: Sun Dec 10, 2000 10:00 am
Location: Belgium

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by skrewball »

Since we as a species do we step down from a challenge? Things didn't go your way? Boo-Hoo...you stick it out and turn the tables. Just because 3 carriers were sunk, he gives up? I would be pissed. Can you imagine if our government adopted that strategy in WWII? "Oh noes...the Japs kicked our butts at Pearl and in the Phils, we should just surrender they are too tough for us". [:D]
"Some people spend an entire lifetime wondering if they've made a difference. The Marines don't have that problem."
Knavey
Posts: 2565
Joined: Thu Sep 12, 2002 4:25 am
Location: Valrico, Florida

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by Knavey »

It can be done without CVs on the allied side...of course, that also is dependent on how skilled you are at exploiting his weakness.  In a TEAM game with Feinder, the Allied CVs became artifical reefs in March 42...several of them.  It took me 6 months to nurse the survivor back to health. 
 
It also took our opponents 6 months to make a mistake with KB...and then they became an set of artifical reefs by wandering too close to a pair of mutually supporting airfields.  My LBA had a field day when they went an island too far.
 
Unfortunately, it looks like one of our IJN players is having serious health problems and so we will probably not get to ever see the outcome of that game, but still, I did consider it worth sticking around for.  Without those CVs, you sure figure out how to use your other units.
x-Nuc twidget
CVN-71
USN 87-93
"Going slow in the fast direction"
User avatar
viberpol
Posts: 858
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2005 3:16 pm
Location: Global village, Poland, EU

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by viberpol »

ORIGINAL: RUPD3658

PBEM is a journey, not a destination.

This is nice RUPD3658 [:D]
Przy lackim orle, przy koniu Kiejstuta Archanioł Rusi na proporcach błysł
User avatar
ChezDaJez
Posts: 3293
Joined: Fri Nov 12, 2004 7:08 am
Location: Chehalis, WA

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by ChezDaJez »

Yes, it is possible to come back despite losing 3 allied CVs early.

Well, consider that the US lost 4 carriers before 1943 IRL (Lex, Yorktown, Wasp, Hornet) and things seemd to have turned out alright.

As far as the game goes, my opponent, Andy managed to lose Lex and Enterprise in the first few days of war. The only result being that I was able to move a bit more freely during the early months. Given the amount of 4Es the allies receive in the stock game, he hasn't really needed his carriers anyways.

Chez
Ret Navy AWCS (1972-1998)
VP-5, Jacksonville, Fl 1973-78
ASW Ops Center, Rota, Spain 1978-81
VP-40, Mt View, Ca 1981-87
Patrol Wing 10, Mt View, CA 1987-90
ASW Ops Center, Adak, Ak 1990-92
NRD Seattle 1992-96
VP-46, Whidbey Isl, Wa 1996-98
Big B
Posts: 4642
Joined: Wed Jun 01, 2005 5:41 pm
Location: Cali
Contact:

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by Big B »

ORIGINAL: ChezDaJez
Yes, it is possible to come back despite losing 3 allied CVs early.

Well, consider that the US lost 4 carriers before 1943 IRL (Lex, Yorktown, Wasp, Hornet) and things seemd to have turned out alright.

As far as the game goes, my opponent, Andy managed to lose Lex and Enterprise in the first few days of war. The only result being that I was able to move a bit more freely during the early months. Given the amount of 4Es the allies receive in the stock game, he hasn't really needed his carriers anyways.

Chez
This is an interesting question, that many have answered satisfactorily above.
I would consider one wrinkle to add to the psychological mix. In the stock game, the Death Star effect of the KB is unrealistic and demoralizing. So I can see Allied players giving up hope if they loose all their CVs in 42(with no corresponding Japanese losses).
But also in the stock game - the Allied player gets many more 4E's than ITRW. So if the Allied player finds himself in a fix, but the Japanese player wishes to carry on the game - I would suggest that the Allied player should continue, but it must be understood at that point that there are no more "house rules" governing unrealistic use of Allied 4Es, nor anything else.

My 2c
User avatar
crsutton
Posts: 9590
Joined: Fri Dec 06, 2002 8:56 pm
Location: Maryland

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by crsutton »

No absolutely not, do not give up the game. Losing three carriers is a hurt but does not mean a loss.
 
I just recently loss five american carriers with the other crippled in the shipyard. However, it is 10/42 and my stragetic position is not too bad with me holding PM and Lunga and having good positions in China and Burma. I wanted to give up but my opponent who is a nice guy convinced me to play on.
 
As said earlier, the points don't matter and unless you are playing for money. It is really just a game. Just like I hadto you will learn to play well (Ok, better) and adjust your expectations in playing from an disadvantaged position. Losing three carriers for the Americans does not make it hopeless. As you get to late 1942, KB no matter how strong, will begin to become less important due to the power of you LBA and submarines. Just be careful and let him have his fun for a while.
 
If you have been saving turns, one option might be to back up the game a few days and replay. Your opponent can either take a complete victory and give you a mulligan for that one battle or you can just continue playing both games for grins. There is never anything bad about having another game going[:D]
I am the Holy Roman Emperor and am above grammar.

Sigismund of Luxemburg
User avatar
crsutton
Posts: 9590
Joined: Fri Dec 06, 2002 8:56 pm
Location: Maryland

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by crsutton »

Don't give up. You have not lost by far and you are not playing for money are you? You will both have fun and continue to learn. This is a no brainer. If you want and have saved your turns, you can back up the game a few turns and play two games at once. One with the loss of the carrirer and call the other one a mulligan.

Sorry, I see I double posted.

I am the Holy Roman Emperor and am above grammar.

Sigismund of Luxemburg
User avatar
Apollo11
Posts: 25476
Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Zagreb, Croatia
Contact:

RE: Early Allied CV loss

Post by Apollo11 »

Hi all,
ORIGINAL: Oleg Mastruko

Whenever someone surrenders after early setback (usually the Allied player) I see it as Japanese doctrine and war "philosophy" being actually true in this parallel universe we call game. Indeed, after some bitch slapping weak western democracies would see the light and give up, bowing before unstoppable spirit of the Japanese warriors!

Of course, it wasn't like that in real war, but if some Allied player wants to play the role of weak demoralised westerner in the game, why not? That was THE idea behind Japanese aggression - they knew they could not out-produce the US but they believed the Allies would simply give up after some ass kicking. So if that indeed happens in the game - fine.

And there's the issue of auto victory, which is sometimes, in case of really big Allied losses, simply inevitable.....

Look who's back (with Adele Stephens)... [8D]


Leo "Apollo11"
Image

Prior Preparation & Planning Prevents Pathetically Poor Performance!

A & B: WitW, WitE, WbtS, GGWaW, GGWaW2-AWD, HttR, CotA, BftB, CF
P: UV, WitP, WitP-AE
Post Reply

Return to “War In The Pacific - Struggle Against Japan 1941 - 1945”