ORIGINAL: showboat1
Wasn't there an old pre-Harpoon game called North Atlantic 86 that covered the convoy war in the event of a European War? I would love an updated Harpoon or something that covered that genre. I have played the most recent updated Harpoon, but something that is more turned based to make it PBEM playable would be better. Something like a PacWar meets War in Russia. Covering the land and air and naval side of a 1980's European War would be a great game.
Grigsby's North Atlantic '86 (1982) is a blast - played it a lot 4-5 years ago on an apple emulator when i only had a DX2/66. it has pretty much the entire North Atlantic with a big convoy war involving resupplying UK/Iceland to keep the airbases there alive, otherwise they get captured. not near as realistic as the SimCan games, but the map is on screen so no dry-erase markers on a map! but both games are easier to play than harpoon because the player controls task forces, not individual ships or the weapon systems. and turn based makes a perfect PBEM possibility!
SimCan's fifth eskadra and seventh fleet did come with 2 big foldout maps and a big pile of counters so you could play out the game visually, but i don't think i ever used them in that way - i just drew the map on graph paper, laminated it, and used a dry erase marker on it. but the map looks great hanging on the wall as a poster! i'm sure the next simcan game matrix does will be a WW II naval game (hopefully involving the north atlantic convoy war), but after that i'm crossing my fingers for strategic modern naval combat!