New AAR Keith Vs Ian

Post descriptions of your brilliant successes and unfortunate demises.

Moderator: Shannon V. OKeets

User avatar
TeaLeaf
Posts: 451
Joined: Wed Nov 05, 2014 3:08 pm

RE: New AAR Keith Vs Ian

Post by TeaLeaf »

ORIGINAL: Courtenay

I'm impressed the Allies kept going as long as they did. I would have resigned several turns ago!
Me too [:D]. Loved the dtail!
A few tips for when you swap sides (NOT that I think I am such a great player, but still I may notice a thing or two [;)]):

- First and Foremost: Early War allies must play to put Italians OOS at least in East Africa. This should be a reachable achievement for the allies in the south. If Axis wants to have Gibraltar/Spain, they'll get it (most of the time), but Alexandria should be kept (by putting axis OOS through Eastern Med).

-Allies should NOT let Russian production fall low. As a (sort of) rule of thumb, Russia needs production as if none of their factories/resources were lost. What they loose should be replaced by the Wallies (roughly).

-Allies must invade in force, so that Germans do not dare to think of counterattacks (which brings me to the last point);

- Axis have been extremely lucky with their dice. They repelled the allied invasions with attacks as low as +4. I personally think the axis took too much risks but got away with it, this time. Could easily have gone the other way around.

Thing to note with the last point: Each allied invasion looked rather weak, so in that perspective I can understand Germans thinking about counterattacking, although not at +4. What do I consider an invasion in force? My current Allied invasion of France counts 10 Allied corps and 6 divisions, with 9 more corps and 10 divisions waiting in transports/AMPHs for next impulse. Maybe a bit more than optimal, but to get an idea...

Curious about next AAR.
User avatar
Zecke
Posts: 1329
Joined: Fri Jan 14, 2005 10:50 pm
Location: Hitoeton

RE: New AAR Keith Vs Ian

Post by Zecke »

interesting AARR; without not so may BAGS (of soldiers); i always thought that the big mistake of Germans in the road to MOSKOW was not to take care of the russians soldiers caught and change his main,,give food, clothes, etc...: by that time; they also wanted (the russians prisioners at KURKS) a conqueror to tell some words to STALIN..............
Epsilon Eridani


Post Reply

Return to “After Action Report”