Andy Mac v PZB This time India will Stand !!!!
Moderators: wdolson, MOD_War-in-the-Pacific-Admirals-Edition
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
They are rolling crushing all opposition in open terrain you need a well dug in Division massive airpower edge or forts to stop tanks in open country.
If I can take Darwin quickly this will be a good start to the 4th 6 month period.
If I can take Darwin quickly this will be a good start to the 4th 6 month period.
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
What units comprising the AA group ?
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
3 US Cst AA Regts and an Australian LAA Regt
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
Shouldn't they go with any escort ?
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
They were supposed to be spotted early and bombed as a nasty surprise but he never bothered with recon 
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
Tactic noted in the "Big Nasty Book of Tricks"
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
I had 100 x 40mm AA guns ready for low flying sallys and they never came....
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
Katherine falls and my Armour is pressing on.
The Light Horse Troopers and the 2/11th Armoured Car boys have been detached to try and recapture Wyndham and Derby.
The lead Bde of 2nd Aus Div is crossing the Moutnains towards Broome about 160 miles away now.
All across the front the advance is on but I am hitting empty air....
PZB has done it again he must have evacced weeks ago this is the 3rd time he has pulled out in the nick of time....
Bloody annoying but he is very very good
The Light Horse Troopers and the 2/11th Armoured Car boys have been detached to try and recapture Wyndham and Derby.
The lead Bde of 2nd Aus Div is crossing the Moutnains towards Broome about 160 miles away now.
All across the front the advance is on but I am hitting empty air....
PZB has done it again he must have evacced weeks ago this is the 3rd time he has pulled out in the nick of time....
Bloody annoying but he is very very good
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
Darwin recovered next phase is in the works the fleet is massing in the <CENSORED>
More to follow when I am fully ready.....
More to follow when I am fully ready.....
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
p.s. my plan is nearly set I am just waiting for the last few elements of the OOB to arrive
7th Fleet will be leading the assault with a number of carriers I will outline my fleet composition when I am finally ready
The plan will involve 20+ Carriers, 10= BB's, 50+ Cruisers, (Only 70 Destroyers I am light on DD's which is a worry for subs), 30 subs, and 300 transports with 7 - 8 Divs assault loaded.....
7th Fleet will be leading the assault with a number of carriers I will outline my fleet composition when I am finally ready
The plan will involve 20+ Carriers, 10= BB's, 50+ Cruisers, (Only 70 Destroyers I am light on DD's which is a worry for subs), 30 subs, and 300 transports with 7 - 8 Divs assault loaded.....
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
That is A LOT of stuff....I hope PzB should not prepare any of his traps !!!
- castor troy
- Posts: 14331
- Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
- Location: Austria
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
Andy,
I´ve got a little discussion with PzB about flak effect in his AAR as we noticed heavy flak losses when he bombed Comilla at 23000ft which is more than surprising to me as I had dozens of attacks in my PBEM against bases with 150 3.7 inch flak at 11000ft and the enemy had a 2% loss rate on average. May I ask how many heavy flak guns you´ve got at Comilla (the medium/small ones can´t reach that alt anyway)? I won´t give the exact numbers to PzB, we´re just curious how it can be so different to the results in my PBEM.
I´ve got a little discussion with PzB about flak effect in his AAR as we noticed heavy flak losses when he bombed Comilla at 23000ft which is more than surprising to me as I had dozens of attacks in my PBEM against bases with 150 3.7 inch flak at 11000ft and the enemy had a 2% loss rate on average. May I ask how many heavy flak guns you´ve got at Comilla (the medium/small ones can´t reach that alt anyway)? I won´t give the exact numbers to PzB, we´re just curious how it can be so different to the results in my PBEM.
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
I will take a look tonight but I do have a lot of my best AA units at Comilla
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
252 x 3.7" AA Guns (all Mk II other than 8 x Mk VI's)
164 x 40mm
6 Radar Sets and lvl 4 forts
164 x 40mm
6 Radar Sets and lvl 4 forts
- castor troy
- Posts: 14331
- Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
- Location: Austria
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
ORIGINAL: Andy Mac
252 x 3.7" AA Guns (all Mk II other than 8 x Mk VI's)
164 x 40mm
6 Radar Sets and lvl 4 forts
thanks
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
I try to never use a base for 4E bombers unless its well protected and it must have forts to protect the AA guns if its in the open - open ground unfortified AA gun = bad idea especially if they are in base forces.....
My plan is progressing I estimate 10 - 15 days before I will be ready I am just drawing some veteran pilots out of training command to give my Carrier Sqns the killer edge.
I will need to organise 7th Fleet very carefully as its probably going to be outnumbered.
10 Fleet Carriers (7 USN 630 aircraft, 3 RN 165 aircraft)
4 Light Carriers (120 Aircraft)
12 Escort Carriers (360 Aircraft)
Total just under 1200 aircraft.
The fleet is assembling well back from the front but my main concern is provinding allied level escorts %'s for my TF's
TF7.1 - 2 x Fleet, x 1 Light Carrier
TF7.2 - 2 x Fleet, x 1 Light Carrier
TF7.3 - 2 x Fleet, x 1 Light Carrier
TF7.4 - 1 x US Fleet and 3 RN Fleet Carrier
TF7.5 - 4 Escort Carrier
TF7.6 - 4 Escort Carriers
TF7.7 - 4 Escort Carriers (Replenishment)
3 x Assault Convoys
2 x Troop Convoys
2 x Supply Convoys
24 x Sub TF's
2 x Fuel Convoys
My plan is progressing I estimate 10 - 15 days before I will be ready I am just drawing some veteran pilots out of training command to give my Carrier Sqns the killer edge.
I will need to organise 7th Fleet very carefully as its probably going to be outnumbered.
10 Fleet Carriers (7 USN 630 aircraft, 3 RN 165 aircraft)
4 Light Carriers (120 Aircraft)
12 Escort Carriers (360 Aircraft)
Total just under 1200 aircraft.
The fleet is assembling well back from the front but my main concern is provinding allied level escorts %'s for my TF's
TF7.1 - 2 x Fleet, x 1 Light Carrier
TF7.2 - 2 x Fleet, x 1 Light Carrier
TF7.3 - 2 x Fleet, x 1 Light Carrier
TF7.4 - 1 x US Fleet and 3 RN Fleet Carrier
TF7.5 - 4 Escort Carrier
TF7.6 - 4 Escort Carriers
TF7.7 - 4 Escort Carriers (Replenishment)
3 x Assault Convoys
2 x Troop Convoys
2 x Supply Convoys
24 x Sub TF's
2 x Fuel Convoys
- castor troy
- Posts: 14331
- Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
- Location: Austria
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
ORIGINAL: Andy Mac
I try to never use a base for 4E bombers unless its well protected and it must have forts to protect the AA guns if its in the open - open ground unfortified AA gun = bad idea especially if they are in base forces.....
My plan is progressing I estimate 10 - 15 days before I will be ready I am just drawing some veteran pilots out of training command to give my Carrier Sqns the killer edge.
I will need to organise 7th Fleet very carefully as its probably going to be outnumbered.
10 Fleet Carriers (7 USN 630 aircraft, 3 RN 165 aircraft)
4 Light Carriers (120 Aircraft)
12 Escort Carriers (360 Aircraft)
Total just under 1200 aircraft.
The fleet is assembling well back from the front but my main concern is provinding allied level escorts %'s for my TF's
TF7.1 - 2 x Fleet, x 1 Light Carrier
TF7.2 - 2 x Fleet, x 1 Light Carrier
TF7.3 - 2 x Fleet, x 1 Light Carrier
TF7.4 - 1 x US Fleet and 3 RN Fleet Carrier
TF7.5 - 4 Escort Carrier
TF7.6 - 4 Escort Carriers
TF7.7 - 4 Escort Carriers (Replenishment)
3 x Assault Convoys
2 x Troop Convoys
2 x Supply Convoys
24 x Sub TF's
2 x Fuel Convoys
other than the reason of having a higher chance to see "coordinated carrier strikes" is there a reason to have that many carrier TFs? With the great new feature of having the possibility to attack ships from several TFs in a hex with one strike it won´t matter much to spread out the carriers (other than the ac number and coordination die roll).
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
Co ordination is king take no chances....
My troops are all prepped and follow on forces are positioned and ready I will begin loading in 10 - 15 days and be ready to put boots on the ground by 15th October 1944 - the day the tide turns and the long march to Tokyo begins.....
My troops are all prepped and follow on forces are positioned and ready I will begin loading in 10 - 15 days and be ready to put boots on the ground by 15th October 1944 - the day the tide turns and the long march to Tokyo begins.....
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
ORIGINAL: Andy Mac
Co ordination is king take no chances....
My troops are all prepped and follow on forces are positioned and ready I will begin loading in 10 - 15 days and be ready to put boots on the ground by 15th October 1944 - the day the tide turns and the long march to Tokyo begins.....
Pretty sure it's just a typo, but you are planning to have boots on ground on 15th October 1943 yes?

Image courtesy of Divepac
RE: Pheonix from the Flames
[:D][:D] no I meant 43
