Iron Storm (Scenario 50): Playtest

Post descriptions of your brilliant successes and unfortunate demises.

Moderators: wdolson, Don Bowen, mogami

Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

1/24/42

Post by Alikchi2 »

Well, no guesses, so I'll go ahead and tell. ;p

--

Image
This is the battleship HMS/HMCS Canada, ordered by the government of Chile in 1911 as "Valpraiso". The ship was purchased by the British government, re-named Canada, and served with the Grand Fleet through Jutland. The design is somewhat similar to Iron Duke class, but slightly larger and mounts ten 14" guns instead of the ten 13.5" carried by the Iron Dukes. After the war, she was sold back to Chile. In Iron Storm she is sold to her namesake country and heavily refitted in the 1920s.


Image
The old Iron Duke battleships of the First World War. All except Iron Duke were scrapped due to the Washington Treaty, while Iron Duke served as a training ship through WW2. In Iron Storm, two of the ships in the class, Iron Duke and Benbow, were sold to Canada to get rid of excess ships in the RN, but also to improve the defense of the Commonwealth. There were four in the class, but Canada could not muster the will or the manpower to crew all 4 and the Canada. Again, both ships have been modernized to the extent that is possible with these old hulls.


Image
In Iron Storm, Lexington and Saratoga are converted while under construction from battlecruisers to aircraft carriers, as historical, while the two following ships in their class, Constellation and Constitution, are completed to the original design.


Image
HMS Tiger was Britain's most modern battlecruiser in the First World War and according to some the most handsome ship built for the RN. She was originally to be built as a member of the "Lion" class - however, the new Japanese Kongos were such a step forward that the Tiger was radically redesigned to match them. She fought at Dogger Bank and Jutland, her belt absorbing fifteen 11-inch shells in the latter battle, and continued to serve as part of the RN through the 30s, until she was sold for scrap in 1932. In Iron Storm she is sold to Australia (this was seriously considered at the time) to, again, bolster the defence of the Commonwealth, and renamed HMAS Australia.


Image
The Settsu, completed in 1912, was Japan's first dreadnought battleship, with an all-big-gun armament of twelve 12" guns. She was converted to a target ship under the terms of the Washington Treaty, reboilered in 1940, and finally sunk by US aicraft in July 1945. In Iron Storm, the 1940 work is continued. Intended to provide fire support for amphibious landings, Settsu is rebuilt with updaded machinery and fire control.


Image
Tosa and Kaga - essentially Nagatos with an extra 16" turret aft - were canceled under the terms of the Washington Treaty. Both hulls were nearly complete. Tosa was rebuilt as a target ship and sunk, while Kaga was converted into the aircraft carrier we all know and love. In Iron Storm the ships are completed and Amagi (Akagi's sister ship) converted to the CV role instead.


--

And the turn, as promised. As you say, pretty significant losses on both sides - things are moving fast at the moment..

BTW I have lost a few more ships than are listed, probably because they were scuttled. At least one CL for example..

1/24/42

Today was a day of airstrikes!

The "airfield war" between Moulmein and Bangkok is still attriting both sides. An Oscar/Sally raid over Moulmein encountered no CAP and destroyed a P-40B on the ground. The Flying Tigers had already left for Bangkok, escorting a group of 35 Blenheims. They were met by 22 Oscars, which have been barely keeping an even kill/loss ratio with the AVG. Multiple Blenheims were damaged, but they still managed to destroy several aircraft on the ground.

[center]Image
Sallies on the attack. For some reason we never seem to get as many bombers in the air as they do..[/center]

Meanwhile, a few hundred miles south of Singapore, Nagumo had launched a full strike at the island itself, the first of the war. 230 Japanese carrier-based planes descended upon the city and particularly its airfields. They met a very aggressive anti-aircraft defence and 45 British fighters on CAP! However, the pilots of the Kido Butai are of a different caliber than the IJAAF boys the RAF has encountered so far. Nearly 30 Vals were lost to various causes over the city - the Spitfires proved especially deadly - but the enemy CAP was mostly swept from the skies, allowing our Vals and Kates free runs at the airfields. They report dozens of aircraft destroyed on the ground!

[center]Image
The carrier strike.[/center]

A second strike, launched from Kota Bharu, arrived over the city a few hours later. They met only 9 fighters on CAP out of the original 45. They were brushed aside, and 150 level bombers were free to make their runs.

Code: Select all

 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Day Air attack on Singapore , at 22,51
  
 Japanese aircraft
 A6M2 Zero x 54
 D3A2 Val x 90
 B5N2 Kate x 92
  
 Allied aircraft
 Hurricane IIb x 25
 Spitfire Vb x 20
  
 Japanese aircraft losses
 A6M2 Zero: 6 destroyed, 1 damaged
 D3A2 Val: 23 destroyed, 44 damaged
 B5N2 Kate: 8 destroyed, 17 damaged
  
 Allied aircraft losses
 Hurricane IIb: 15 destroyed
 Spitfire Vb: 12 destroyed
 Wellington III: 5 destroyed
 LB-30 Liberator: 4 destroyed
 Blenheim IF: 2 destroyed
 Beaufort I: 1 destroyed
 Hudson I: 1 destroyed
  
  
 Allied ground losses:
 97 casualties reported
  
 Airbase hits 18
 Airbase supply hits 7
 Runway hits 116
 Port hits 4
 
 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Day Air attack on Singapore , at 22,51
  
 Japanese aircraft
 A6M2 Zero x 50
 G3M Nell x 47
 G5N Liz x 44
 Ki-43-Ib Oscar x 17
 Ki-21-II Sally x 29
 Ki-48-I Lily x 30
 Ki-46-II Dinah x 1
  
 Allied aircraft
 Hurricane IIb x 4
 Spitfire Vb x 5
  
 Japanese aircraft losses
 A6M2 Zero: 1 destroyed
 G3M Nell: 20 damaged
 G5N Liz: 1 destroyed, 12 damaged
 Ki-43-Ib Oscar: 1 destroyed
 Ki-21-II Sally: 1 destroyed, 9 damaged
 Ki-48-I Lily: 8 damaged
  
 Allied aircraft losses
 Hurricane IIb: 12 destroyed
 Spitfire Vb: 8 destroyed
 Hudson I: 2 destroyed
 Beaufort I: 3 destroyed
 Wellington III: 2 destroyed
 Buffalo I: 1 destroyed
 LB-30 Liberator: 1 destroyed
  
  
 Allied ground losses:
 48 casualties reported
  
 Airbase hits 14
 Airbase supply hits 6
 Runway hits 113
 
 

In the Philippines a similar "alpha strike" was launched at Manila, which has been more or less untouched since the December raids. Bettys and Nells from San Marcelino targeted the port, hitting at least two ships, while a follow-up Army attack on the naval base and airfield was even more succesful, putting multiple bombs into transports, an AS, and the Dewey Dry Dock.

Finally, in the far south, CarDiv 1 (Akagi and Kaga) made a high-speed run throughout the night in an attempt to catch the badly damaged battleship Valiant and battlecruiser Van Brakel. Instead, they found the same cruiser force that had so badly mauled our landing at Tarakan only a few days ago. Although not quite within range for their torpedoes, the Kates scored multiple hits with 250kg bombs - the most important of which penetrated De Ruyter's magazine, destroying the ship!

[center]Image
De Ruyter takes a hit.[/center]

All in all we destroyed more than 170 aircraft today. Not bad!
User avatar
Captain Cruft
Posts: 3741
Joined: Wed Mar 17, 2004 12:49 pm
Location: England

RE: 1/24/42

Post by Captain Cruft »

Not bad! My giddy aunt ... The RAF in Malaya has been all but wiped out. /me sobs into his tea.

Interestingly enough, you can see the Valiant and Van Brakel on the screenshot above. They are the green Allied TF hidden by the cloud. Phew!

I'm really on the backfoot now.
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

RE: 1/24/42

Post by Alikchi2 »

Oh so THAT'S where those two went! Only one hex away! You lucky dog... [:D]

I have to admit I was very pleased with the Singapore raid results. I've been very leery of the flak and fighters but the damage inflicted was well worth it. After the previous failed attempt at clawing my way onto the peninsula this is a very good feeling.

I did notice the LB-30s, and I certainly don't expect the RAF to roll over and play dead after one airstrike.. we still have to work our way down the whole peninsula, after all. :)

Probably the same aircraft are showing up in the DEI now. I shudder to think ..
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

1/25/42-1/27/42

Post by Alikchi2 »

Another terse post!

1/25/42-1/27/42

Our big naval war has sort of shuddered to a halt over the last few days - no major combats on the seas, for once! What has been happening? PT boats and submarines. They're doing quite well against convoys running through the western Philippines, actually, on their way to Legaspi, Davao, Tarakan, Manado, etc. Only one ship has sunk outright so far (carrying a bit of the 19th Mixed Bde, en route to Cagayan) but several others look like they might not make it to Formosa.

[center]Image
Argh.[/center]

The air war has been mostly supporting ground units, but on the 26th the RAF launched another big attack with, as far as I can tell, most of the planes that they have left. :P Buffalos escorted various Blenheims and Hudsons (about 65 in all) on a raid to Kota Bharu. Of course the little tubby ones went down in droves but the bombers did an impressive job of destroying yet even more airplanes on the ground. I have a base force unloading at Singora now, actually, so I should be able to diversify soon... Still, the RAF is not dead. Yet.

On the 27th, today, they attempted a repeat. Cost them more AC than it did me, but attrition is still bad.

I am fairly pleased with how we are doing on the ground. At Clark, successive deliberate attacks on the 25th and 26th brought the forts down to zero. 100,000 Japanese now face 15,000 American and Filipino troops. It won't be long now.. (although I should have waited on the 27th; got 0-1). The garrisons at Tarakan and Manado are still stubborn (if it takes 3 SNLF units to capture every worthless hole Dutch base, I'll lose the war!). Oh, and the offensive in Burma began! 55th Division crossed over the river into Moulmein and auto-shock attacked and, wow, managed to achieve 1-1 odds and bring the forts down to zero! 4th Mixed Regiment will probably follow up tomorrow. Another division (33rd I think? From Shanghai) will be dealing with Tavoy before we march on Rangoon.

At Alor Star:

Code: Select all

Ground combat at Alor Star
  
 Japanese Deliberate attack
  
 Attacking force 85803 troops, 678 guns, 49 vehicles
  
 Defending force 8720 troops, 45 guns, 23 vehicles
  
 Japanese assault odds: 2 to 1 (fort level 5) 
  
 Japanese Assault reduces fortifications to 4
  
  
 Japanese ground losses:
 532 casualties reported
 Guns lost 16
 Vehicles lost 1
  
 Allied ground losses:
 355 casualties reported
 Guns lost 10
 Vehicles lost 2

They're stubborn, but they shouldn't last too long. My units are pretty fatigued from marching.
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

More bits and pieces

Post by Alikchi2 »

Map of the Southern Area as of 1/28/42:

[center]Image[/center]


The "Buffalo Aces" of Kota Bharu:

[center]Image[/center]
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

Impromptu update

Post by Alikchi2 »

A quick and impromptu update before I go to bed. The date is January 30th, 1942.

Clark Field is on the verge of falling to a 3-division force. In the south, 2 divisions + support (50,000 troops) have arrived at Manila and confront an equal number of American imperialists and their Filipino lackeys. Once Clark has been taken both armies will unite at Manila.

In Malaya we are still grinding away. Alor Star is holding on - just barely, it should only last a few more days. Dive bombers are proving particularly useful. Two divisions have arrived in Taiping which means the enemy in Northern Malaya is effectively cut off - fighting has only begun here (support units still traveling over the mountain trails) but if we can take the base quickly, thousands of enemy troops could be encircled and destroyed.

This is my first game as Japan, and I am having some fuel problems. Palau and Saigon ran dry particularly quickly, which is partially why the Celebes/Ambon drive has petered out. This should change within a few days... Speaking of this area, Tarakan should fall soon. I have unloaded reinforcements (two small Naval infantry units) and if the damn stubborn Dutch don't give in then I have a mixed brigade in the pipeline! Heesh.

We're still fighting over Moulmein in Burma, and my Sallies still don't want to fly.

Over in the western Pacific I have one operation going, which Cruft should spot in the next turn or two (if he hasn't already). Things are moving in general.

Still, this game hinges on Singapore. Many of the aircraft have left Malaya (well, some, at least - I encountered two squadrons of Spitfires over Batavia for example). The RN has left for sure. My one worry is just how tough the ground units will be - and whether the place has been reinforced. Hmmm..

Expect a full update either tomorrow or the next day. Oh, and if anyone has any questions about Iron Storm, this game in particular, or, well, anything - feel free to ask. [:)]
User avatar
Terminus
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: Impromptu update

Post by Terminus »

How happy are you with the performance of all the new IJN, British and Dutch naval units? And I'm not talking from the standpoint of the gamer, but from the standpoint of the Iron Storm designer. Are they doing what you expected them to do?

BTW, not to be pedantic (or maybe EXACTLY to be pedantic), I fell over another small error in the DB. This time, it's the Mighty Hood:

Image

Seems a bit excessive to put that much armour on a .50 AAMG position. Especially as it's only on the port side![;)]
Attachments
pic_56.jpg
pic_56.jpg (73.26 KiB) Viewed 498 times
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

RE: Impromptu update

Post by Alikchi2 »

Thanks again Terminus! [8D] Cruft actually caught that one too - the armour value should be for one of the Hood's anachronistic torpedo mounts on page 2. On the other hand maybe the crew of that Browning decided to wear armour-plated suits ..

I am very pleased with how all the naval units are working out, actually. The only errors have been minor ship-data ones (like the two you have pointed out). On the whole, the new ships are functioning just as I expected! :) And they certainly are fun toys to play with.

The battle between the Dutch BC Wilem Warmont and the rebuilt Fuso + Yamashiro illustrated the new classes well, actually, and everything worked perfectly. At least for me, Cruft might say otherwise. [;)]

User avatar
Terminus
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: Impromptu update

Post by Terminus »

Another question, brought on by the data for the Hood. How did you come up with the weapons? I mean, the 4x2 15-inchers are no problem, but the secondary armament doesn't "rhyme" with what I've read elsewhere.
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
User avatar
String
Posts: 2661
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:56 pm
Location: Estonia

RE: 1/23/42

Post by String »

ORIGINAL: Captain Cruft

Nice ships :) I have no idea what any of them are though lol.

--
We have had significant action since the last report. Sadly it has not gone in the Allies favour. No more major sinkage though thankfully.

I'll let the boss fill you in. In the meantime here is the shipping report:

Code: Select all

 Type	Allies	Japan
 ----	------	-----
 
 AK	 32	 11
 AP	  3	 18
 TK	  8	  0
 MSW	  6	  4
 ML	  3	  0
 PC	  3	  2
 PG	  4	  2
 SS	  6	  5
 
 DD	 23	  5
 CL	  7	  0
 CA	  0	  1
 CS	  0	  1
 BB	  2	  2
 CVL	  0	  4
 CV	  1	  0
 
That is a lot of destroyers sent to the bottom, mainly in surface combat. Ouch.

Another point worth mentioning is that 4 of the 6 Allied sub sinkings were due to air action. For some reason there was one turn a while back where virtually every Jap plane on search got a "HIT".


Well think of it that way, that was a luck roll that the japs expended and will be lacking when it comes to the first big carrier battle. Fragmented strikes ahoy! [:D]
Surface combat TF fanboy
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

RE: 1/23/42

Post by Alikchi2 »

Another question, brought on by the data for the Hood. How did you come up with the weapons? I mean, the 4x2 15-inchers are no problem, but the secondary armament doesn't "rhyme" with what I've read elsewhere.

I got the data off of the HMS Hood Association's site (http://www.hmshood.com/).. I think it is correct. Perhaps I implemented it wrong. What problems do you see in particular? (What data are you looking at?)

String: You jinxed me [X(]

Sorry about the lateness everyone, I've been lazy. So you get a special update!

Strategic Update - 2/5/42

[center]Image[/center]

- Southeast Asia:

The battle in Malaya is still raging. Japanese troops have broken through the New Zealander and Indian defences at Alor Star, forcing the Allies back to Georgetown, while two other Japanese divisions have begun the assault on Taiping, in an attempt to cut off and destroy Commonwealth forces in the northern peninsula. At Kuantan, 54,000 Japanese troops face off 10,000 Allies.

[center]Image
Troops of the 56th Division advancing near Kuantan, 2nd February 1942[/center]

The air war over Malaya has been equally intense. The RAF in Malaya does not want to die. Recently (the 3rd of February) it launched a large daylight attack with its Blenheim bombers against Kuching naval base, scoring multiple hits on light cruisers and the battleship Haruna. Although Haruna only took superficial damage, light cruisers Agano, Otawa, and Yodo have been heavily damaged (between 20 and 50 SYS) and will have to be repaired elsewhere.

However the air war is still mostly in our favor. Today (the 5th) a large attack was again launched at the airfields of Singapore, specifically targeting the bombers that had been wreaking havoc on Kota Bharu airfield at night. (These aircraft now include American A-20B Bostons - the Americans are arriving!) The raid was a complete success, as shown by the image below..

[center]Image
Someone forgot to hide the Blenheims![/center]

Finally, the advance in Burma is picking up speed. Moulmein has been captured, the Allied defenders retreating towards Rangoon. The airbase there is already established and should begin operating shortly. When Tavoy falls we will be free to use our total force (two divisions and one brigade, plus two parachute regiments and supporting units) against Rangoon and Mandalay. The air war in this theatre has quieted down (the AVG seems to have vanished), but there is still fighting. Most notably another new American unit showed up today - B-25s bombing our new airfield at Moulmein! Hmmm...

- The Philippines:

Progress here has been sure and steady. With the fall of Clark Field, our full efforts can be concentrated against Manila. 16th Army advancing north from Naga already has the city under siege, while 14th Army at Clark solidifies its position. Once we have repaired the airbase and rested our troops, 14th Army will move south to finish the job (leaving behind a small screening force across from Bataan, of course).

In Mindanao we are struggling. Cagayan is stubbornly held by several ragtag Filipino units against two full Japanese brigades! We have had no luck so far even with continual air support from Betties based at Legaspi. Still, we will continue whittling away.

The PT boats are still being an active nuisance! Two APs received torpedoes this turn alone. Argh..

[center]Image
Note: There are lots of TFs (both enemy and Glorious Japanese) here, but I have edited them out.[/center]

- ABDA:

Tarakan has fallen. (Finally.) The base force destined for it has not arrived yet, however, so it is temporarily semi-useless. Still, at least we aren't struggling!

The situation at Manado is looking brighter, as well. The Dutch must be running out of ammunition - or the will to use it. A deliberate attack brought down another fort level. We will take the base if we have to use an entire Mixed Brigade to use it! (Hint, hint..)

With the arrival of a fuel shipment at Palau, the full carrier group has sortied - Akagi, Kaga, Toryu, and Kuroho. This should be enough to brush away any meddling Westerners.

[center]Image
KNIL troops at Manado with a captured Japanese flag.[/center]

- Southwest Pacific:

The battle for Rabaul has begun. Covered by Soryu and Donryu (both ships still marked by the scars of the battle against the American carriers) and other ships, troops of the South Seas Detachment have begun landing on New Britain. Farther north, Japanese naval infantry have begun engaging a small Australian force defending Kavieng.

[center]Image
Australian troops in hastily constructed trenches on the Rabaul perimeter.[/center]

- Central Pacific:

All quiet.. for now. We don't consider the Americans to be much of a threat at this stage, with the Enterprise sunk and most of their battlefleet out of the war. We are free to concentrate on the west.

====

So, all in all, things are going well. I'll feel much more comfortable about my position in the SRA once Manado and Tarakan have been fully established as airbases. Moulmein fell much quicker than I expected, as did Clark and Naga. Malaya is going as well as can be expected, really.

On a project note, the scenario has been converted to the 4.0 version of Andrew Brown's map (thanks Andrew!) which means I can begin working on bringing it up to CHS 1.06 standards and then implementing the new additions and bugfixes. A new website, manual, and easier installation package are in the works for 2.0, as well. Should be worth your time! [8D]
User avatar
TheElf
Posts: 2800
Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 1:46 am
Location: Pax River, MD

RE: 1/23/42

Post by TheElf »

A well timed update Al! I was looking for your thread (Not in boldprint) so that I might poke you in the side, figuratively of course.[;)] Been having Iron Storm withdrawals.

Now what will I do when Singapore falls?[:'(]
IN PERPETUUM SINGULARIS SEDES

Image
User avatar
Terminus
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: 1/23/42

Post by Terminus »

ORIGINAL: Alikchi
Another question, brought on by the data for the Hood. How did you come up with the weapons? I mean, the 4x2 15-inchers are no problem, but the secondary armament doesn't "rhyme" with what I've read elsewhere.

I got the data off of the HMS Hood Association's site (http://www.hmshood.com/).. I think it is correct. Perhaps I implemented it wrong. What problems do you see in particular? (What data are you looking at?)

Same source (hmshood.com), but there are two discrepancies in my view. The first are the 4-inch Mk XVI's, which you seem to have defined as triple turrets, where they should have been doubles (The heading "turrets" in the editor should be read "number of barrels per mount"). The second is the same with the .50 AAMG's, which were quad-barrel mounts.

It seems to have been a case of having the correct data (we're both looking at the same source), but feeding it to the editor wrong.
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

2/6/42

Post by Alikchi2 »

A well timed update Al! I was looking for your thread (Not in boldprint) so that I might poke you in the side, figuratively of course. Been having Iron Storm withdrawals.

Now what will I do when Singapore falls?

Awh, shucks [:D] I'll try and update this a bit more regularly, promise!

I may start up another playtest AAR once IS 2.0 is out. It will not move as quickly as this one, however, because I'd like to get my CHS game with Cruft started up again. Maybe someone else would be interested in doing an AAR.. :)
Same source (hmshood.com), but there are two discrepancies in my view. The first are the 4-inch Mk XVI's, which you seem to have defined as triple turrets, where they should have been doubles (The heading "turrets" in the editor should be read "number of barrels per mount"). The second is the same with the .50 AAMG's, which were quad-barrel mounts.

It seems to have been a case of having the correct data (we're both looking at the same source), but feeding it to the editor wrong.

I see - erm, whoops! Another thing to be fixed.

Hood is looking just a bit dodgy in general, isn't she? :P I actually may be delaying her arrival in IS 2.0 (I'll be looking critically at all Commonwealth and Japanese ship reinforcement rates). It's possible that I will have her show up around March '43 after her proposed refit ( http://www.hmshood.com/ship/history/Lar ... fit42.html - 5.25" DP guns, anyone?).

In any case -

2/6/42

Still grinding away!

Today saw more heavy air action over Burma and Malaya, the main event being the second full-blast attack on Singapore in as many days! The city burns; our Sally pilots aren't the best at navigation. Intelligence reports that the large Chinese segment of the population is already rioting..

Our target is not the civilian population, however. What few planes remained in the air above Singapore were again swatted away today - our Zeroes are doing particularly well against Spitfires - and the bombers were free to make their runs. Two dozen A6M2s swept down and strafed the remaining visible aircraft. Singapore has been wiped out, with nearly 100 aircraft destroyed in two days.

One thing we should note is that the Tojo has entered into full production! After encouraging reports from the experimental unit in China (and a bit of preliminary work in Japan, assisted by the Navy's design bureau), enough aircraft have been produced to begin equipping front-line units. First to receive the new aircraft is the 64th Figher Chutai, operating out of Alor Star. The 64th will "ease into" its new aircraft by continuing the same missions that it participated in when it flew Oscars - close escort of the Sonias and Marys that have been so devastatling successful in silencing Commonwealth artillery lately.

[center]Image
12.7mm rounds are loaded into the aircraft of Major Taniguchi.[/center]

A bit farther north, our newly established airbase at Moulmein came under attack from American Liberators and Mitchells, who did very little damage, but were not significantly slowed by our Oscars. The same explanation applies to our Sally counterstrike at Akyab.

On the ground, the situation is more or less the same as yesterday. An attack on Kuantan was beaten back by the Commonwealth defenders, while we should begin deliberate attacks at Rabaul and Kavieng tomorrow.

===

Here's a look at Japanese battleships in the Pacific. Attrition has been heavy as you can see here.. Ise and Hyuga were sunk months ago by British Beauforts.

[center]Image[/center]
User avatar
Terminus
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: 2/6/42

Post by Terminus »

I see - erm, whoops! Another thing to be fixed.

Hood is looking just a bit dodgy in general, isn't she? :P I actually may be delaying her arrival in IS 2.0 (I'll be looking critically at all Commonwealth and Japanese ship reinforcement rates). It's possible that I will have her show up around March '43 after her proposed refit ( http://www.hmshood.com/ship/history/Lar ... fit42.html - 5.25" DP guns, anyone?).


The thing is, as they ask on the site, would the Hood have been taken out of action for that long, in the middle of a war?

Hmm, with the Italians and the major Axis surface fleet in Europe gone, she just might have, but still, the UK shipyards would probably have had other priorities...
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
Andy Mac
Posts: 12578
Joined: Wed May 12, 2004 8:08 pm
Location: Alexandria, Scotland

RE: 2/6/42

Post by Andy Mac »

I think you may want to look at FAA replacement rates for aircraft as well.

Cruft's Naval Air was a little fragile given the committment of so many RN Carriers more replacements would surely be available. Perhaps give one of the Sqns Seafires and up the other naval fighter/torpedo bomber replacement rates.

Any chance (just for a litte added fun) that the RAF could get a Mossie or Lancaster Sqn in place of an existing sqn or perhaps as early replacement's.

I would also consider giving the RAF a small recon sqn

Andy
User avatar
Terminus
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: 2/6/42

Post by Terminus »

That's a good point. It was a bit of a surprise to me when Cruft pulled out his flattops.

Perhaps you could swat two birds with one stone, and equip the RAF Photo Recce Unit with PR Mossies?
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
Alikchi2
Posts: 1786
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 9:29 pm
Contact:

RE: 2/6/42

Post by Alikchi2 »

The thing is, as they ask on the site, would the Hood have been taken out of action for that long, in the middle of a war?

Hmm, with the Italians and the major Axis surface fleet in Europe gone, she just might have, but still, the UK shipyards would probably have had other priorities...

It's a difficult question. I think that, with the condition of Hood as it was, SOMETHING had to be done. At least by Spring 42. It's possible that I may just slightly refit her (as is postulated later on the site - more AAA, a few other minor additions).

She wouldn't me much use in 44 or 45, anyhow. Post-WWI strategy for the Brits was for the fast battleships (Hood, the projected G3s, KGVs, etc) to blast off to Singapore in the case of any major attack and hold the fort until major fleet units could arrive. This is generally outmoded in the face of carriers, but with the Mediterranean out of the equation you won't see the across-the-board collapse of Imperial strategy in Iron Storm that you did in real life.

This is why I am going to be changing the deployments of RN ships in 2.0.
User avatar
Terminus
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: 2/6/42

Post by Terminus »

Looking forward to it, Alikchi-san!
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
User avatar
TheElf
Posts: 2800
Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 1:46 am
Location: Pax River, MD

RE: 2/6/42

Post by TheElf »

ORIGINAL: Alikchi
A well timed update Al! I was looking for your thread (Not in boldprint) so that I might poke you in the side, figuratively of course. Been having Iron Storm withdrawals.

Now what will I do when Singapore falls?

Awh, shucks [:D] I'll try and update this a bit more regularly, promise!

I may start up another playtest AAR once IS 2.0 is out. It will not move as quickly as this one, however, because I'd like to get my CHS game with Cruft started up again. Maybe someone else would be interested in doing an AAR.. :)

Why not put your talents to use doing the only CHS AAR? We really need one.
IN PERPETUUM SINGULARIS SEDES

Image
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”