Convoy system does not work

World in Flames is the computer version of Australian Design Group classic board game. World In Flames is a highly detailed game covering the both Europe and Pacific Theaters of Operations during World War II. If you want grand strategy this game is for you.

Moderator: Shannon V. OKeets

Extraneous
Posts: 1810
Joined: Sat Jun 14, 2008 1:58 am

RE: Convoy system does not work

Post by Extraneous »

ORIGINAL: paulderynck

You state how much you are lending in the same turn it is lent, not the previous turn.

The convoy route owner(s) must adhere to: "If, during production (see 13.6 Production), it is possible for the promised resources (or build points) to be delivered then they must be delivered." Therefore, lends take precedence over transporting other resources, regardless.

Again, if you say a specific resource can be lent versus only announcing the quantity thereof, then provide a rules citation that supports that statement.

The rules for lending and rules for the starting Trade Agreements are the same, so this quote from the FAQ may help you:
Q5.1-2
Q: For at-start Trade Agreements, must the RP and BPs provided by JA, US, GE, and RU come from their respective home countries?

A: No, but they must satisfy rule 5., that is they must be delivered if possible. Example: After Russia has conquered Persia, Russia couldn't give the coastal Persian oil to Germany as part satisfaction of their trade agreement unless there were convoys in position to send them to Germany AND the owner of those transports is allowed, and agrees, to ship them. In all other cases the Russians would instead have to transport the resources by rail from the USSR to Germany directly.

Your example is for "at-start Trade Agreements".
5.1 Trade agreements

Germany-USSR
Japan-USA

It would have been better if you had included this with your example.

5. Lending Stage
Q5.1-5
5.1 Other than the Japan-USA Trade Agreement, are there any penalties for not shipping the appropriate mandatory lendings?

No but you don't have a choice, must means must and if for some reason you can't physically get them there you can't use them yourself. Date 05/07/2007

5. If, during production (see 13.6 Production), it is possible for the promised resources (or build points) to be delivered then they must be delivered.

5.1: Where possible, these resources (or build points) are transported by rail (…). If the recipient cannot provide the convoys, they do not receive the resources (or build points). 05/07/2007


Do you agree "to be delivered" means "you are able to transport it to a usable factory in that step"?

University of Science Music and Culture (USMC) class of 71 and 72 ~ Extraneous (AKA Mziln)
User avatar
paulderynck
Posts: 8494
Joined: Sat Mar 24, 2007 5:27 pm
Location: Canada

RE: Convoy system does not work

Post by paulderynck »

ORIGINAL: Extraneous

Do you agree "to be delivered" means "you are able to transport it to a usable factory in that step"?
In the Production step - yes. Which is why a resource you think you might lend in the Lending step is not necessarily the one you'll deliver - since you must deliver the quantity of the type you promised, if possible.

5. Lending Stage
In this stage, you can announce that you are giving resources and/or lend leasing build points (see 13.6.4 Lend lease) to another major power on the same side this turn.

Which in turn proves you can't designate the location to source a lend when in the lending step, only the quantity and type of the lend. You might have a location in mind, but if that location can't be the source when you get to the Production step, and another location can be, than that's the one that must go.
Paul
brian brian
Posts: 3191
Joined: Wed Nov 16, 2005 6:39 pm

RE: Convoy system does not work

Post by brian brian »

It depends on what the meaning of the word "must" must be.
User avatar
Jagdtiger14
Posts: 1685
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2008 11:58 pm
Location: Miami Beach

RE: Convoy system does not work

Post by Jagdtiger14 »

Or what the meaning of "is", is.
Conflict with the unexpected: two qualities are indispensable; first, an intellect which, even in the midst of this obscurity, is not without some traces of inner light which lead to the truth; second, the courage to follow this faint light. KvC
Post Reply

Return to “World in Flames”