No, Drex posted the above quote concerning Holst's Mars, Bringer of War(from his Planets suite).Originally posted by AbsntMndedProf:
Bing posted:
Then how about Holst's Mars music? If this isn't war music then I don't know what is.
Interestingly enough, Holst finished Mars; Bringer of War, and it was first performed in the same year that the First World War broke out, 1914.
Eric Maietta
I think many discerning people saw a major conflict in the making in 1914 and before. I did research on that some years ago - a lot of research, matter of fact. I came to a simple conclusion: Europeans wanted their dirty war, they wanted it pretty badly despite all the talk to the contrary. They were aching to start one - I also came away from the research convinced that if Germany had not marched first, it could as easily have been France. Just a sidebar and no, I don't know how that got into a discussion of war movie music.
Oh ... someone wrote that I revealed a background in "classical" music. I don't classify it that way. Many great musicians, including Verdi and Debussey, have said there are only two kinds of music: Good and bad. Charbrier made a great joke on that statement, but you kinda have to know composers and eras to get it.
This really IS drifting off topic, so I will cut that out right now.
Bing