Cost too much?

dudalb_slith · Post by **dudalb_slith** » Thu Jul 21, 2011 12:03 am

ANd Fantasy Wars is available for around Ten Bucks at Good Old Games...Heaven's gift to retro gamers.

Strategiusz · Post by **Strategiusz** » Thu Jul 21, 2011 12:47 pm

But FW is unfriendly to strategists 3D game.

GaryChildress · Post by **GaryChildress** » Thu Jul 21, 2011 4:34 pm

ORIGINAL: lparkh

There is a quite good fantasy version of Panzer General out there called Fantasy Wars. But a Star one would be fun.

Funny you should mention it but there was a "Star General" version of Panzer General. I bought it in the bargain bin but never really played it.

I go with the person who compared PC to a tank of gas or a dinner date. I've seen much more expensive games out there and consider $40 a bargain. Dinner lasts a few minutes. A tank of gas lasts maybe a week. But PC will last a lot longer.

But I do respect the OPs opinion. If I weren't currently employed I'd be complaining about the price of games in the bargain bin right now. It aint easy to be a gammer on a shoe string budget.

VPaulus · Post by **VPaulus** » Thu Jul 21, 2011 5:21 pm

ORIGINAL: Gary Childress

But I do respect the OPs opinion. If I weren't currently employed I'd be complaining about the price of games in the bargain bin right now. It aint easy to be a gammer on a shoe string budget.

I'm currently unemployed without any kind of social protection because I was an employer (in my country employers don't have any kind of social protection), and yet I was one of those beta testers who answered to the price poll that wouldn't mind to pay $50 for a PG reboot. You can call me crazy being in the sad situation as I am now, but this at least is making me not getting depressed and helping me in keeping me focus.

flybynight · Post by **flybynight** » Fri Jul 22, 2011 5:11 pm

Sorry but I agree with the OP... they charged too much for a game that is way subpar, I can't play it for the fact of the very crappy icons.. either they point left or right.. come on guys you can do better than that!!

Go Play Open General.. and see how an Panzer General port should be done!!!!

Note to Devs.. go play some Open General, patch your game, then maybe we can talk!!

IainMcNeil · Post by **IainMcNeil** » Fri Jul 22, 2011 5:15 pm

I'm assuming you don't have the game

The only people who have really said anything bad about the game are fans of PG who have not played the game but don't want to see their favourite game challenged. If you give it a deeper look you'll see why it's the fastest selling game we've ever released and the reviews are incredible. If you just look at the screens you wont see the depth and detail the game has and the sheer fun it is to play.

flybynight · Post by **flybynight** » Fri Jul 22, 2011 5:36 pm

ORIGINAL: Iain McNeil

I'm assuming you don't have the game

For sure have the game.... and really feel like its not worth the $40 USD.... after playing Open General (thats Free btw) this game is a serious step back!!

Razz1 · Post by **Razz1** » Fri Jul 22, 2011 5:40 pm

The direction of units change according to the direction they last moved to. Pretty neat eh?
Icons are much better than PG or open General.

You can not even go to work for one week with 40 dollars in Gasoline. It's also less than 4 meals considering it's 10 to 12 bucks for a meal now a days.

I suppose there is a reason they call you flyby night.

LarryP · Post by **LarryP** » Fri Jul 22, 2011 5:45 pm

I think flybynight is the same poster as the OP. Beefing up his\her own original post.

dorjun driver · Post by **dorjun driver** » Fri Jul 22, 2011 6:38 pm

Sounds like a Chewlies gum representative to me.

flybynight · Post by **flybynight** » Fri Jul 22, 2011 7:45 pm

ORIGINAL: LarryP

I think flybynight is the same poster as the OP. Beefing up his\her own original post.

NOT!!!!

And I am sure happy u guys think you got your $ worth!! But I do not!!

Again maybe after a patch or two and they beef up the unit animations, make the maps look a little better, this might be worth the 40 bucks they are asking for!

Razz1 · Post by **Razz1** » Fri Jul 22, 2011 8:59 pm

Funny! ^

LarryP · Post by **LarryP** » Fri Jul 22, 2011 9:17 pm

ORIGINAL: flybynight

ORIGINAL: LarryP

I think flybynight is the same poster as the OP. Beefing up his\her own original post.

NOT!!!!

I didn't expect you to admit it. Saying what you did though, I'm sure of it now. [:D][:'(]

jjoshua · Post by **jjoshua** » Fri Jul 22, 2011 9:48 pm

Sounds like it is the same dude to me....just playing his childish games. This guy is nothing but a professional "Spam" disturbance. Upset that nobody is taking his side of things.

I am not the best strategist gamer by a long sight, but this game is absolutely great...easy to learn the mechanics on, but definitely takes time to master. My hats off to the folks who made it.

Thank you. : < )

JWW · Post by **JWW** » Sat Jul 23, 2011 2:22 am

I agree with LarryP and jjarredd.

flybynight · Post by **flybynight** » Sat Jul 23, 2011 3:05 am

This guy is nothing but a professional "Spam" disturbance.

Trust me I am not the same poster as the OP (and I have key code for game to prove it!!)

I still stand by my this is not $40 buck game!! Not when as I said before, There is Open General out there with all the Tons of user added content!

Again come on.. for the most part static Icons?? If I move north, at least point the icon to the north!

The only plus I can say for this game over Open General, is it has the nice splash and info screens in High Rez, and the fact you can set your Rez to 1920X1080.

But again I am sorry, If I am moving a large force to the north, I want my icons to point to the north, and when in battle point to the unit they are fighting, not just either left or right! Guess you guys can live with that.. but after years of playing wargames.. for something to come out in 2011.. and have such limited animations, honsitly if old school game counters where used in this game.. it just might have worked!

And sure I maybe spaming!! but I sure hope a Dev or two will read this.. again as mentioned before: go play some Open General.. get some ideas and make this game have the potential it really should have.

jjoshua · Post by **jjoshua** » Sat Jul 23, 2011 3:55 am

Then why did you buy it?...Didn't you look at the screen shots. Obviously you could see the graphics before you bought it. You could see which direction the units were pointed and such.

I am quite sure that the Developers are aware of your complaints.

Your entitled to your opinions, I will give you that, but come on....I am more than sure that you or I could never accomplish one thousandth of a game that these folks did. It seem they really put alot of effort, money and time into giving us a great game. hell I still enjoy the first risk game that came out, and those graphics are stoneage.

Be thankful that there are people who continue to make games for us. Appreciation will go far when acknowledged; and I am quite sure they will do upgrades and improvements down the road to pacify you and the other nay-sayers.

Tape a compass to your pc screen, then you will see north all the time. Im am more than sure that Rommel didn't aim his tanks due north every night before he bedded down.

Kinda lame don't you think!

flybynight · Post by **flybynight** » Sat Jul 23, 2011 4:34 am

Tape a compass to your pc screen, then you will see north all the time. Im am more than sure that Rommel didn't aim his tanks due north every night before he bedded down.

Kinda lame don't you think!

LOL too funny.. you know I may be dissing the game.. but I have not dissed a user here.. so err kinda of lame for your kinda of lame don't you think??

Speaking of Rommel... Look up Patton Versus Rommel published by EA years ago (many years ago) .. I've been playing these type of games for years and years so I've earned my right to post when I think a game is not up to par!! And even more so when it comes to this subject of games..

Want to go back in years even more?? Search for a game called Tanktics by Avalon hill, ran it on a TRS-80, and it came with a game board and the program will tell you where to place the counters.

So a game comes out.. says it's better and updated as quoted " brings it up to 21st century standards and to a whole new generation of gamers"

And I find it's not even better than an open source project (again other than it runs full screen and the high res info screens)

So yes.. 40 bucks of my hard earned money (that as someone said could fill up a gas tank) has not been spent well, and could have in fact been used better in the gas tank!!!

Obsolete · Post by **Obsolete** » Sat Jul 23, 2011 4:55 am

Tape a compass to your pc screen, then you will see north all the time. Im am more than sure that Rommel didn't aim his tanks due north every night before he bedded down.

I...am... so.... confused....

Rood · Post by **Rood** » Sat Jul 23, 2011 5:45 am

ORIGINAL: flybynight[...]If I am moving a large force to the north, I want my icons to point to the north, and when in battle point to the unit they are fighting, not just either left or right![...]

And...that is...it?
Your only point of criticism?

There is no flanking in this game so what you get is just a visual display, if you want more candy then go to your mum and bang your little fist on the table MUMMMAAAH I WANT MY CANDY...

Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?

RE: Cost too much?