Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

This new stand alone release based on the legendary War in the Pacific from 2 by 3 Games adds significant improvements and changes to enhance game play, improve realism, and increase historical accuracy. With dozens of new features, new art, and engine improvements, War in the Pacific: Admiral's Edition brings you the most realistic and immersive WWII Pacific Theater wargame ever!

Moderators: wdolson, MOD_War-in-the-Pacific-Admirals-Edition

User avatar
Lokasenna
Posts: 9304
Joined: Sat Mar 03, 2012 3:57 am
Location: Iowan in MD/DC

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by Lokasenna »

ORIGINAL: Colonel Mustard

To play devil's advocate here (or maybe just stir up trouble [;)]....While the result seems a bit out of whack at first blush, here's my take on it:

The submarine attacks the routine (automatic?) convoy. He is able to make the contact because the sub has a highly skilled, aggressive commander (more likely if this was a PBEM/human Japanese player). He hits his target, and the escort counterattacks. Two hits with a depth charge is not enough to sink a sub in this game. I've had subs take 4-5 hits and not be forced to the surface. I do think subs are a little too sturdy, but it is what it is. However, in this case, the sub comes up, but not critically damaged or nearly sinking. Once on the surface, the sub starts its diesel engines and finds itself with superior maneuverability vs. AKs, superior firepower (torps and 5.5 inch guns vs. 3 inch), and superior gunnery. The convoy ship commanders are probably all bottom-of the barrel if set up by the automatic system, or not specifically assigned by the Allied player. What is a highly skilled, aggressive sub commander to do?

The answer is probably not "run away." As always, there are a lot of specifics we don't know about the battle, but I think there's a lot of room for this to be a reasonable result.

Any other thoughts on this?

Those are my thoughts as well. Not necessarily realistic, but given what I know about the game engine (and especially the commanders point that you brought up), I don't think the result is entirely unreasonable.

If any kind of heavier escort had been present (say, a DD), with the changes in commander quality and sheer weight of armament that entails, the sub would've been sunk on the surface in pretty short order.
User avatar
LoBaron
Posts: 4775
Joined: Sun Jan 26, 2003 8:23 pm
Location: Vienna, Austria

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by LoBaron »

Your description comes close Colonel Mustard.

Anyways, that such events are the result of a slightly flawed routine is a nobrainer. About every vet who posted in this thread knows it, even those with a lack of humor. [;)]

The result is partly because of the way torp firing sequences are implemented in surface engagements (pretty similar to guns), and partly because of the extreme exp/skill/agg delta of civilian ship crews
and commanders to the sub crew/commanders.

In addition I strongly suspect this issue got more prominent with the introduction of the split torp tube system (during one of the early patches) that allowed a sub to fire a lot more individual salvoes
than what the game was initially designed for. A classic drawback of stuffing one hole in the system while opening one on the other end.


But TBH I kinda like such rampages, it keeps the players honest when setting up convoys, because they need to consider adding one or the
other surface combatant for such occasions. With a DE/PF or DD in a convoy that stuff does not happen.

Problem solved, and convoy setups get a bit more realistic.

Image
Insano
Posts: 228
Joined: Thu Jul 23, 2009 6:01 am
Location: Joplin, Missouri

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by Insano »

realistic or not - that was fun!
User avatar
ny59giants
Posts: 9902
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 12:02 pm

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by ny59giants »

I just had my Allied DDs within a Bombardment TF get two hits on a RO sub forcing it to the surface. Instead of dealing with the DDs, she was hit at least 6 times by 8" shells from CA Exeter. Of course she sank. [:D]
[center]Image[/center]
Cpt Sherwood
Posts: 837
Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2005 12:27 am
Location: A Very Nice Place in the USA

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by Cpt Sherwood »

I do change all of my US and Brit merchant captains. Both countries have lots of good captains available. I feel a captain with about 50 or so ratings will command better than one with 15 ratings.
“Luck is what happens when preparation meets opportunity.” ― Lucius Annaeus Seneca
User avatar
crsutton
Posts: 9590
Joined: Fri Dec 06, 2002 8:56 pm
Location: Maryland

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by crsutton »

Of course it is out of whack. But who the hell here does not enjoy the ride? [;)]
I am the Holy Roman Emperor and am above grammar.

Sigismund of Luxemburg
panzer cat
Posts: 165
Joined: Sun Oct 02, 2011 10:28 am
Location: occupied Virginia

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by panzer cat »

Yes it is exciting, but I've never had a sub escape.
jmalter
Posts: 1673
Joined: Tue Oct 12, 2010 5:41 pm

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by jmalter »

that's a few doughty warriors onboard I-21. usually when a sub is forced to surface, she's toast - already too badly damaged to launch torps or fire shells effectively. sanch has given us snaps from his movie, would be interesting to learn I-21's day/night ratings, & her commander's stats.
User avatar
LoBaron
Posts: 4775
Joined: Sun Jan 26, 2003 8:23 pm
Location: Vienna, Austria

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by LoBaron »

ORIGINAL: ny59giants

I just had my Allied DDs within a Bombardment TF get two hits on a RO sub forcing it to the surface. Instead of dealing with the DDs, she was hit at least 6 times by 8" shells from CA Exeter. Of course she sank. [:D]


Long ago in an AAR far away.... [:D]



Image


This sub torpedoed the Repulse on her way to bombard batavia ..

Sub attack near Oosthaven at 46,97

Japanese Ships
SS I-165, hits 4

Allied Ships
BC Repulse, Torpedo hits 1
CL Dauntless
DD Inconstant
DD Isis

SS I-165 launches 4 torpedoes at BC Repulse (one torpedo hits amidships)
I-165 diving deep ....
DD Inconstant fails to find sub, continues to search...
DD Inconstant fails to find sub, continues to search...
DD Inconstant attacking submerged sub ....
DD Inconstant cannot establish contact with SS I-165
DD Inconstant fails to find sub, continues to search...
DD Inconstant attacking submerged sub ....
SS I-165 eludes DD Inconstant by hugging bottom
SS I-165 forced to surface!
BC Repulse firing on surfaced sub ....
Sub slips beneath the waves


Was an epic battle. Several times it looked like the sub would escape, then finally forced to surface and
hit in the face by a salvoe from Repulse.
Image
User avatar
Cribtop
Posts: 3890
Joined: Sun Aug 10, 2008 1:42 pm
Location: Lone Star Nation

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by Cribtop »

I agree this stuff is borked, but rare enough not to be irritating.

I had a similar battle in my game with Cuttlefish where I-9 tangled with a convoy near Perth. She wreaked havoc once surfaced, but not as much as happened here. However, the plucky sub did live to tell the tale in that instance, which was awesome.
Image
sanch
Posts: 429
Joined: Sat Oct 30, 2004 7:55 am

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by sanch »

ORIGINAL: dr.hal
I AGREE! That skipper deserves the "Order of the Rising Sun"!!!!!

But it will be a posthumous award!

To answer a couple other points ...

It's a PBEM game - October, 1942; DBB C.

And no, it had never even occurred to me that I should replace xAK captains. Oh joy, another click-fest!

And the xAK that scored the sinking hit - its day experience went from 15 to 55. I'll keep this one around for a SCTF, or at least an invasion convoy.
User avatar
LoBaron
Posts: 4775
Joined: Sun Jan 26, 2003 8:23 pm
Location: Vienna, Austria

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by LoBaron »

And no, it had never even occurred to me that I should replace xAK captains. Oh joy, another click-fest!

I would never ever waste time and PP to exchange skippers of civilian ships.
Image
User avatar
DivePac88
Posts: 3119
Joined: Wed Oct 08, 2008 9:50 pm
Location: Somewhere in the South Pacific.

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by DivePac88 »

And no, it had never even occurred to me that I should replace xAK captains. Oh joy, another click-fest!

Don't do it man... waste of PP's and good captains can't dodge torpedoes any better than bad captains can. [:-]
Image
When you see the Southern Cross, For the first time
You understand now, Why you came this way
User avatar
Gunner98
Posts: 6003
Joined: Fri Apr 29, 2005 12:49 am
Location: The Great White North!
Contact:

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by Gunner98 »

Just had the opposit happen - RO-67 follows a convoy into shallow water (Apr 43) - not a good move

Submarine attack near Deboyne Islands at 102,135

Japanese Ships
SS RO-67, hits 27, on fire, heavy damage

Allied Ships
xAK Henry J. Raymond
DE Austin
xAK William S. Young, Shell hits 1
xAK Walter Reed
xAK Owen Summers
xAK Matthew P. Deady

SS RO-67 is sighted by escort Gad Zuks time to Dive
RO-67 bottoming out .... (Oh bugger, things are going from bad to worse)
DE Austin fails to find sub, continues to search... maybe just maybe...
DE Austin attacking submerged sub ....Drat and double drat!
SS RO-67 forced to surface! man the guns!
DE Austin firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK William S. Young firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Walter Reed firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Owen Summers firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Matthew P. Deady firing on surfaced sub ....
DE Austin firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK William S. Young firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Walter Reed firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Owen Summers firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Matthew P. Deady firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK William S. Young firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Walter Reed firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Owen Summers firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Matthew P. Deady firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK William S. Young firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Walter Reed firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Owen Summers firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Matthew P. Deady firing on surfaced sub ....
DE Austin firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK William S. Young firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Walter Reed firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Owen Summers firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Matthew P. Deady firing on surfaced sub ....
DE Austin firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK William S. Young firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Walter Reed firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Owen Summers firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Matthew P. Deady firing on surfaced sub ....
DE Austin firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK William S. Young firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Walter Reed firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Owen Summers firing on surfaced sub ....
xAK Matthew P. Deady firing on surfaced sub ....
Sub slips beneath the waves
Que the somber music!


I don't follow the animations in game but this was a bad day for RO-67 and a good day for my convoy!

B
Check out our novel, Northern Fury: H-Hour!: http://northernfury.us/
And our blog: http://northernfury.us/blog/post2/
Twitter: @NorthernFury94 or Facebook https://www.facebook.com/northernfury/
Cpt Sherwood
Posts: 837
Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2005 12:27 am
Location: A Very Nice Place in the USA

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by Cpt Sherwood »

ORIGINAL: LoBaron
And no, it had never even occurred to me that I should replace xAK captains. Oh joy, another click-fest!

I would never ever waste time and PP to exchange skippers of civilian ships.

Rarely would it cost any PPs to change them. I can usually find a free exchange. I feel the crew will
gain experience faster that way and maybe be able to spot the sub before it can fire.
“Luck is what happens when preparation meets opportunity.” ― Lucius Annaeus Seneca
User avatar
Sardaukar
Posts: 12869
Joined: Wed Nov 28, 2001 10:00 am
Location: Finland/Israel

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by Sardaukar »

ORIGINAL: Cpt Sherwood

ORIGINAL: LoBaron
And no, it had never even occurred to me that I should replace xAK captains. Oh joy, another click-fest!

I would never ever waste time and PP to exchange skippers of civilian ships.

Rarely would it cost any PPs to change them. I can usually find a free exchange. I feel the crew will
gain experience faster that way and maybe be able to spot the sub before it can fire.

Might save some Victory Points...but..I frankly lack patience for that! [:D]
"To meaningless French Idealism, Liberty, Fraternity and Equality...we answer with German Realism, Infantry, Cavalry and Artillery" -Prince von Bülov, 1870-

Image
User avatar
guytipton41
Posts: 351
Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2011 4:01 am
Location: Houston, TX

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by guytipton41 »

ORIGINAL: Cpt Sherwood

ORIGINAL: LoBaron
And no, it had never even occurred to me that I should replace xAK captains. Oh joy, another click-fest!

I would never ever waste time and PP to exchange skippers of civilian ships.

Rarely would it cost any PPs to change them. I can usually find a free exchange. I feel the crew will
gain experience faster that way and maybe be able to spot the sub before it can fire.

Hi Cpt Sherwood,

What do you mean by a free exchange? I just fooled around with some merchant ship captains and I didn't notice any changes that were free.

Cheers,
Guy
User avatar
LoBaron
Posts: 4775
Joined: Sun Jan 26, 2003 8:23 pm
Location: Vienna, Austria

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by LoBaron »

There is no 0 PP commander exchange. Check the top row when highlighting a new commander, it will always read at least '1'.

The cost/benefit calc simply does not hold for civilian ships. Before you start doing this rather check the escorts. Your chances of changing the outcome of engagements improve dastically when focusing there (DE, PF, YP, PC, PG, YMS, AM, SC, PB,....).

If an xAK gets Under attack it usually doesn't matter much if driven by a 20 or 50 nav skill skipper, it is toast with a high probability. And if you want to change enough to make a (tiny at best) difference, you spend so many PP that you could buy out a division instead.
Image
User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by castor troy »

changing xAK/xAP skippers is both a waste of time and a waste of pp
LeeChard
Posts: 1117
Joined: Wed Sep 12, 2007 12:24 pm
Location: Michigan

RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle

Post by LeeChard »

That was a monument to detailed posting!
Post Reply

Return to “War in the Pacific: Admiral's Edition”