ORIGINAL: witpqs
The gaminess that people talk about with respect to the Mersing landing on turn 1 has to do with prior warning that the British would have had due to active Allied search.ORIGINAL: Cap Mandrake
ORIGINAL: sprior
The Aussies aren't in Mersing in this scenario. Maybe we can use the Netties to sink the RN and bring down the BBs at Singora to provide surface coverage. There are Zeroes at Soc Trang that might provide LRCAP.
Wow, didn't know the Aussie brigade isn't at Mersing. That is tempting.
I do think the two BB's plus the 4 CA force in separate taffy's could cover the Mersing landing. If Force Z reacts you get a daytime battle of roughly matched forces plus the CA's to stand by in case Force Z wins. It also does not seem gamey to land there on turn 1 if you send two strong SCTF's.
If Force Z goes South or SW it seems they always get away unless you stir up the mix with carriers.
Yes, I see your point. Probably an extra 12 hrs of travel in the real world for 15 kt transports to get to Mersing although the transports heading for the Malaysian Peninsula were spotted prior to Dec 7 in real life. They just weren't sure what the Shinto Boys were up to.