Suggestion wish list

[carll11]

ORIGINAL: Oberst_Klink

ORIGINAL: timmyab

I would like the regimental artillery to be marked as artillery on the nato counters. I've lost count of the times I've accidentally moved these units to their doom in previous titles in this series.

the 13.Kp (heavy weapons) got a small A on the counter. However, you can look through the available smallgfx counters and change it to your liking. That's one of the features I love abut Vic's games - modding friendly.

Klink, Oberst

Thats editing I dont normally do.....so, if I did do I have to do it to every single unit that requires it or can I make a 'mass' selection?

[Oberst_Klink]

You can easily edit it in the models library.

Klink, Oberst

[Jagger2002]

Ok having played a fair number of hours now, here is I think a fairly useful wish list item. I think a road traffic overlay would be very useful. Basically an overlay of all roads showing by color the current percentage of road traffic vs total road traffic allowed on the road before traffic jams. So with a quick look, I would have a visual image of the traffic loads on each road. We can basically get that information now but it involves calling up the hex info box for each hex. I think that a traffic overlay would be a very useful game aid.

[loutro]

I would like a hot key that shows which units still have unused Action Points. In the full campaigns, you can lose track of who you have moved and who you have not moved. And invariably, you can miss moving whole divisions. Or that could just be my ADHD.

[Khanti]

Small "feature"
Please add +1 recon point for those BMW R75 motorbikes. They seems useless.
I know I can edit it myself, but it could be done for others as well.
Also +1 recon for Jeeps will be cool.

[Oberst_Klink]

ORIGINAL: Khanti

Small "feature"
Please add +1 recon point for those BMW R75 motorbikes. They seems useless.
I know I can edit it myself, but it could be done for others as well.

It's easy, see below. I decided, for test purposes, to give the Jeep, Kübelwagen and the BMW a value of 10; Armoured Cars a value of 5.

Klink, Oberst

[Khanti]

I don't like concept when vehicles have lower HP vs. infantry. They are so fragile now. Attacking with Stugs against infantry with few bazookas is a waste of vehicles. Mostly irreplaceable because replacements are scarce.
Maybe bad luck, but it occurs often...

[Oberst_Klink]

ORIGINAL: Khanti

I don't like concept when vehicles have lower HP vs. infantry. They are so fragile now. Attacking with Stugs against infantry with few bazookas is a waste of vehicles. Mostly irreplaceable because replacements are scarce.
Maybe bad luck, but it occurs often...

... hence one has to suppress and flush those pesky bazooka equipped GIs (or the PzF | RPzB 54 (Panzerschreck) Landers) out. Running into them without infantry support in urban or wooden areas is a killer, like it was historically.

As for the replacements, you can tweak them. I got a list me and Rob 'Hawkeye' Kunz used to determine the average replacement rates that were available for the 30 days of the battle somewhere.

Klink, Oberst

[Jagger2002]

I don't like concept when vehicles have lower HP vs. infantry. They are so fragile now. Attacking with Stugs against infantry with few bazookas is a waste of vehicles. Mostly irreplaceable because replacements are scarce.
Maybe bad luck, but it occurs often...

IMO, in most cases an assault should not be launched until defense readiness has been substantially worn down by ranged fire. Artillery is the primary force for wearing down defense but armor including Stugs are very useful using 1 hex ranged fire. Move your armor adjacent to the target hex and hit them with ranged fire prior to the main assault. Tanks adjacent to the target hex will also increase the recon level of the hex which increases the effectiveness of both artillery and the tank fire. Once the defense readiness drops substantially, then comes the tank/infantry assault to take the position at hopefully acceptable losses. And from a one hex range, armor is not in much danger from infantry, infantry ATGs and artillery. Although if enemy armor is in the area and can quickly reinforce the defense, they can hit and hurt your armor. That is a risk.

[Stelteck]

Do not worry about loosing armored vehicules, due to lack of fuel, the less armored vehicule you have, the happier [:D]

[Jagger2002]

IMO, in most cases an assault should not be launched until defense readiness has been substantially worn down by ranged fire. Artillery is the primary force for wearing down defense but armor including Stugs are very useful using 1 hex ranged fire. Move your armor adjacent to the target hex and hit them with ranged fire prior to the main assault. Tanks adjacent to the target hex will also increase the recon level of the hex which increases the effectiveness of both artillery and the tank fire. Once the defense readiness drops substantially, then comes the tank/infantry assault to take the position at hopefully acceptable losses. And from a one hex range, armor is not in much danger from infantry, infantry ATGs and artillery. Although if enemy armor is in the area and can quickly reinforce the defense, they can hit and hurt your armor. That is a risk.

PS: Don't put German armor in the open in line of sight if the Americans have clear weather. Even in overcast weather, they need a lot of flak protection. So one hex range is best from defensive terrain or in open if misty or precip weather or much close range flak protection.

[Stelteck]

ORIGINAL: Jagger2002

PS: Don't put German armor in the open in line of sight if the Americans have clear weather. Even in overcast weather, they need a lot of flak protection. So one hex range is best from defensive terrain or in open if misty or precip weather or much close range flak protection.

Allied air is deadly even in overcast weather, your flak advice is important. I had an air raid that cost me 12 panther !! And another one 7 Pz IV.

[carll11]

Did I add we need a 'overrun rule'. [:@]

I have started the 'Big One' and, not done with turn 3 completed I have already ran across 5, that 5 instances wherein 10-trucks, 1 bazooka guy, 5 rear guard guys, one AT gun etc. force me to use an arty units ( or 2) or another unit attack to wipe them out, IF I dont
they head for a cross road etc.

IF I were doing this to a human opponent it would be called 'gamey'.....[:'(]

[Oberst_Klink]

ORIGINAL: carll11

Did I add we need a 'overrun rule'. [:@]

I have started the 'Big One' and, not done with turn 3 completed I have already ran across 5, that 5 instances wherein 10-trucks, 1 bazooka guy, 5 rear guard guys, one AT gun etc. force me to use an arty units ( or 2) or another unit attack to wipe them out, IF I dont
they head for a cross road etc.

IF I were doing this to a human opponent it would be called 'gamey'.....[:'(]

I once saw an overrun or similar message in the battle planner. Road blocks and leftovers in urban areas can be nasty and certainly should not be able to resist a full regimental attack.

It should be addressed for sure.


OT: 1200 on the 16th, St. Vith scenario, some good progress. Never ever waste the 18.VG.Div to attack the 422nd; just cut them off and mop them up with rear-area troops created with one of the 2 corps HQs.

Klink, Oberst

[nikdav]

ORIGINAL: carll11

Did I add we need a 'overrun rule'. [:@]

I have started the 'Big One' and, not done with turn 3 completed I have already ran across 5, that 5 instances wherein 10-trucks, 1 bazooka guy, 5 rear guard guys, one AT gun etc. force me to use an arty units ( or 2) or another unit attack to wipe them out, IF I dont
they head for a cross road etc.

IF I were doing this to a human opponent it would be called 'gamey'.....[:'(]

Seems to hear Peiper's screams at Stavelot " Damned engineers !!! "

[nikdav]

Many times what you see is not the full real enemy force, only what your recon see !

[Khanti]

I'd like to have hotkey for "next available unit" for cycling through available units with movement points still
Or there is that hotkey somewhere...[&:]

[Khanti]

I don't like the idea of "war against trucks". Every time artillery shells, it hits truck-like equipment. I've checked values in editor. All trucks have 30 points as ranged targets. I suggest adding some 10-20 points to infantry types.

[ernieschwitz]

ORIGINAL: Khanti

I don't like the idea of "war against trucks". Every time artillery shells, it hits truck-like equipment. I've checked values in editor. All trucks have 30 points as ranged targets. I suggest adding some 10-20 points to infantry types.

Where did you see the favorites table? I can see there is a favorites tries table, but I have yet to locate the favorites table, where you can actually see what artillery, as ranged weapons, want to hit.

[Khanti]

Ernie,
Trooptype Editor
Trooptype Libraries
Ranged Target Mod table

It's called "TargetChance%" in individual unit window in game