Defend Luzon 2028

[Nikel]

Could not wait for a revised version

Retried with the same settings, Normal and 1500 $.

This time placed carefully the subs in the western but allowed zone.



Short AAR:

While the subs were approaching, changed the WRA of the destroyers SM-6 missiles, so that they could shot down ASW helos. The intention was to help the subs attack.

Unfortunately the E-7A guides them and gets too near of the Red fighters, was shot down. Not sure this behavior of a strategic AC is WAD.

The tactics of the subs approaching the convoy laterally and from the rear, that I learned in TBlakey's Greenland scenario, was also very useful this time

If you are lucky, the subs alone can infiltrate the convoy and sink enough of the amphibious force to trigger the strategic victory message. I had to replay 3 times a save to finally succeed without losing any sub.

All the F-22s, F-35s and B-52s remained landed along the gameplay. It was completely different this time. They are not needed to win in the Normal setting.

While I was too busy with the subs operation, the Red side continued the attack on Luzon and managed to destroy the 2 destroyers, facilities and support AC, but they lost.



- Add a more specific Anti Shahed weapon?

- The invasion force has no troops embarked, that would sum a few losses to the red side when those ships are sunk, and also add a lot of immersion to the scenario

- Attached is the lua history file of this 2nd test that seems different.

AS OF: 12-Mar-28 19:08:18

SIDE: RED
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------
6x GJ-11 Sharp Sword UCAV
8x H-6K Badger
1x Il-78M Midas
7x J-15T Flying Shark [Su-33 Copy]
2x J-16 Flying Shark [Su-30MKK Copy]
1x J-20A Fagin
3x Su-30MKK Flanker G
1x Type 048 Daguan [88 Xu Xiake]
1x Type 054 Jiangkai I [525 Manshan]
1x Type 056A Jiangdao II [625 Bazhong]
4x Type 072A Yuting II [981 Dabie Shan]
1x Type 920 Anwei [866 Daishan Dao]
8x WZ-7 Soaring Dragon UAV
3x WZ-8 UAV
2x Z-18J Bat
7x Z-9C Haitun [AS.565SA]
2x Z-9DF Haitun


EXPENDITURES:
------------------
1x 130mm China H/PJ-38 HE
1x 30mm China H/PJ-14 [Type 1130, 500 rnds]
20x AKF-98A
65x CH-AA-10 Abaddon [PL-15]
32x CH-SSC-13 Splinter [CJ-100, Conventional]
48x CH-SSC-9 [CJ-10]
16x CH-SS-NX-13 [YJ-18, SS-N-27 Sizzler Copy]
18x CSS-18 [DF-26, Submunitions]
18x CSS-18 [DF-26, Submunitions] RV
6x CSS-18 Mod 1 [DF-26B, 1200kg Conventional]
6x CSS-18 Mod 1 [DF-26B, 1200kg Conventional] RV
24x CSS-2 Mod 1 [DF-3A, 480kg Conventional]
24x CSS-2 Mod 1 [DF-3A, 480kg Conventional] RV
8x CSS-5 Mod 4 [DF-21C, 2000kg Conventional]
8x CSS-5 Mod 4 [DF-21C, 2000kg Conventional] RV
6x CSS-X-24 [DF-27, 500kg HE Conventional]
6x CSS-X-24 [DF-27, 500kg HE Conventional] RV
6x DF-10A [CJ-10A Mod]
97x Generic Active Directional Sonobuoy
20x Generic Chaff Rocket
2x Generic Chaff Salvo [4x Cartridges]
106x Generic Passive Directional Sonobuoy
67x HHQ-9B
1x HQ-10 [FL-3000N]
14x HQ-16A [SA-17 Semi-Copy]
30x Shahed-136
10x YJ-21 [250kg HE]
10x YJ-21 [250kg HE] RV
2x Yu-11
4x Yu-11 ASROC
13x Yu-7



SIDE: BLUE
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------
1x A/C Hangar (2x Small Aircraft)
2x Ammo Pad
1x AvGas (150k Liter Underground Tank)
1x Building (Control Tower)
2x DDG 125 Jack H. Lucas [Arleigh Burke Flight III]
1x E-3G Sentry
1x E-7A Wedgetail
1x EA-37B Compass Call
4x FIM-92E Stinger MANPADS
2x MH-60R Seahawk
4x Patriot M901
1x Radar (AN/FPS-117)
1x Radar (ELM-2288ER AD-STAR)
1x RC-135S Cobra Ball
1x RQ-180 UAV
1x Typhon TEL
1x Typhon TEL
2x Vehicle (AN/MPQ-65)
1x Vehicle (Battery Operations Center, AFATDS)
1x Vehicle (BOC Support Vehicle)


EXPENDITURES:
------------------
1x 20mm/100 Mk15 Phalanx Blk 1B Burst [300 rnds]
1x ADC Mk2 Mod 0 Torpedo Decoy
2x ADC Mk2 Mod 3 Torpedo Decoy
2x ADC Mk3 Mod 1 Torpedo Countermeasure
2x ADC Mk4 Mod 1 Sonar Jammer
2x Generic Chaff Salvo [5x Cartridges]
41x MIM-104F Patriot PAC-3 ERINT
49x MIM-104F Patriot PAC-3 MSE
24x Mk214 Sea Gnat Chaff [Seduction]
12x Mk234 Nulka
44x Mk48 Mod 7 ADCAP CBASS
6x Mk59 Mod 0 Floating Decoy
12x RIM-161C SM-3 NTW Blk IB
6x RIM-161E SM-3 NTW Blk IIA
36x RIM-162A ESSM
84x RIM-174A ERAM SM-6 Blk IA
13x RIM-174A ERAM SM-6 Blk IB
24x RIM-66M-5 SM-2MR Blk IIIB
96x THAAD C-2 CEC
16x UGM-109I Tomahawk Blk IV MMT [Multi-Mission]
3x UGM-109J Tomahawk Blk Va MST



SIDE: BLUE DECOY
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: Civilian
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------
1x Commercial Tanker - Large Range 1 [75,000t DWT]


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: Civilian
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: Biol
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: BLUE HUMINT
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: BLUE HUMINT N
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------

[Nikel]

Another one


v21 tested on B1892, outside of the editor. Settings: Hard and 1000 $. This is the most difficult, but you can get 4 subs! 2 Seawolfs and 2 Virginias, they are deadly.

0 spent on Fighters and bombers, as commented I think they have not enough weapons, but perhaps in hard mode there are more air launched weapons?

A lot spent in ADs and radars.

Some capabilities bought this time, the balloon has CEC capability and a good radar, but too slow.



Short AAR: Retried again the winning subs strategy, this time the Wolfpack formed by 4, infiltrating the Red Amphibious Group and defenses laterally and from the rear. E-7A and drone lost again guiding the missiles (CEC capability) to degrade the ASW helos, still there were quite a few trying to hunt the Blue subs, but were unsuccessful. Perhaps they need some subs protecting the convoy from Blue subs?



Comments:

- Add names to the units, destroyers, subs. Right now only the class is displayed.

- Civilians became hostile when lunched the wolfpack attack in a mission, not sure why. There are 2 civilian sides, why?

- Lua history file of this testing attached. One of the errors probably related with the capability Hack UAV, I could not deploy it.

- Removed the comment above of the wide of the bars, it was the size of the window in my laptop, too small.

- Also the size of the window was causing me problems selecting the capabilities, I thought it was a bug, but no

- More Sats in this setting, one of the Chinese and and one American in the same trajectory. Not sure it is a bug.

BSW.gif (3.06 MiB) Viewed 129 times

CS.gif (8.65 MiB) Viewed 129 times

R.gif (3.82 MiB) Viewed 125 times

AS OF: 12-Mar-28 14:18:00

SIDE: RED
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------
14x GJ-11 Sharp Sword UCAV
10x J-15T Flying Shark [Su-33 Copy]
2x Type 048 Daguan [88 Xu Xiake]
1x Type 052DL Luyang III Mod [156 Zibo]
1x Type 054 Jiangkai I [525 Manshan]
1x Type 056A Jiangdao II [625 Bazhong]
3x Type 071 Yuzhao [998 Kunlun Shan]
1x Type 072 Yantai
3x Type 072A Yuting II [981 Dabie Shan]
1x Type 076
2x Type 903A Fuchi [889 Taihu]
1x Type 920 Anwei [866 Daishan Dao]
3x WZ-7 Soaring Dragon UAV
3x WZ-8 UAV
2x Z-18F Sea Eagle
3x Z-18J Bat
2x Z-20F
17x Z-9C Haitun [AS.565SA]
2x Z-9DF Haitun


EXPENDITURES:
------------------
1x 130mm China H/PJ-38 HE
1x 30mm China H/PJ-14 [Type 1130, 500 rnds]
2x 30mm Gsh-30-1 Burst [30 rnds]
4x 30mm/65 H/PJ-13 Burst [400 rnds]
75x CH-AA-10 Abaddon [PL-15]
8x CH-AA-9 [PL-10]
1x China Towed Acoustic Decoy
10x CH-SS-22 [DF-17, 500kg Conventional]
10x CH-SS-22 [DF-17, 500kg Conventional] RV
12x CH-SSC-13 Splinter [CJ-100, Conventional]
24x CH-SSC-9 [CJ-10]
30x CSS-18 [DF-26, Submunitions]
30x CSS-18 [DF-26, Submunitions] RV
12x CSS-2 Mod 1 [DF-3A, 480kg Conventional]
12x CSS-2 Mod 1 [DF-3A, 480kg Conventional] RV
13x CSS-X-24 [DF-27, 500kg HE Conventional]
13x CSS-X-24 [DF-27, 500kg HE Conventional] RV
75x Generic Active Directional Sonobuoy
12x Generic Chaff Rocket
8x Generic Chaff Salvo [4x Cartridges]
2x Generic Flare Rocket [Single Spectral]
4x Generic Flare Salvo [4x Cartridges, Single Spectral]
76x Generic Passive Directional Sonobuoy
52x HHQ-9B
25x HQ-10 [FL-3000N]
32x HQ-16A [SA-17 Semi-Copy]
75x Shahed-136
2x YJ-21 [250kg HE]
2x YJ-21 [250kg HE] RV
2x Yu-11
2x Yu-11 ASROC
5x Yu-7



SIDE: BLUE
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------
1x E-3G Sentry
1x E-7A Wedgetail
1x RQ-180 UAV
2x THAAD C-2 - CEC


EXPENDITURES:
------------------
20x 12.7mm/50 MG Burst [10 rnds]
171x 127mm/62 Mk186 HE-MOFN [Mk64 HiCap Body, Mk437 Fuse]
640x 127mm/62 Mk187 HE-MFF [Mk64 HiCap Body, Mk419 Fuse]
5x 20mm/100 Mk15 Phalanx Blk 1B Burst [300 rnds]
10x 25mm/75 Bushmaster Mod 2 Burst [12 rnds]
1x ADC Mk2 Mod 0 Torpedo Decoy
2x ADC Mk2 Mod 3 Torpedo Decoy
2x ADC Mk3 Mod 1 Torpedo Countermeasure
2x ADC Mk4 Mod 1 Sonar Jammer
4x FIM-92E Stinger RMP Blk I
1x Generic Chaff Salvo [5x Cartridges]
51x MIM-104F Patriot PAC-3 ERINT
5x MIM-104F Patriot PAC-3 MSE
72x Mk48 Mod 7 ADCAP CBASS
12x RIM-161C SM-3 NTW Blk IB
10x RIM-161E SM-3 NTW Blk IIA
84x RIM-174A ERAM SM-6 Blk IA
40x RIM-174A ERAM SM-6 Blk IB
22x RIM-66M-5 SM-2MR Blk IIIB
148x THAAD C-2 CEC
48x UGM-109I Tomahawk Blk IV MMT [Multi-Mission]
24x UGM-109J Tomahawk Blk Va MST



SIDE: BLUE DECOY
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: Civilian
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: Civilian
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: Biol
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: BLUE HUMINT
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: BLUE HUMINT N
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------

[blu3s]

Civilians became hostile when lunched the wolfpack attack in a mission, not sure why. There are 2 civilian sides, why?

Mmm what type of mission?

There are two civ sides because they have different functions and different postures

There are subs protecting the convoy but there's a huge gap in tech between US and PLA, maybe I need to limit the purchase to one sub only

Yeah, window needs to be as wider as possible.

[Nikel]

OK, it was not the mission, but me

Inadvertently marked one of the merchants near the Chinese group as hostile, and so all of them became red. Perhaps the civilian sides should not have the collective responsibility ticked?


Are there Red subs around the convoy? Blue subs do not detect any while attacking. There are torpedos, I thought they all came from surface escorts.


No, please If you limit the blue subs purchase, the fun is gone. How to win then? I think you cannot win with the fighters and bombers right now because a 2nd wave is not possible.

And the anti-ship land platforms are useless, they are destroyed before the Chinese ships are on range. At least on my first try. The HIMARS have more range but cause little damage.


Regarding the loses of CEC ACs, should they have this risky behavior? They guide the missiles automatically too near of the danger zone. In this case the missile was avoided, but I lost them always this way.

RCEC2.gif (8.22 MiB) Viewed 109 times

[blu3s]

Regarding the loses of CEC ACs, should they have this risky behavior? They guide the missiles automatically too near of the danger zone. In this case the missile was avoided, but I lost them always this way.

Mmm I don't remember seeing that behavior while playing the scenario, is the E-7 assigned to a mission?


Yes, the RED subs are assigned to "screen" the convoy, but screening it's not really a thing in CMO atm, maybe I can place some fixed acoustic sensors in order to give RED a chance to defend against subs but not sure what the detections look like, I'll need to check.

Yes, you can win only with aircrafts, in fact is kind of easier than winning with subs (just use F-35s haha). And yes, the Himars and Typhon launchers are more useful in the ASuW role at the moment due the thin ABM defense.

[Nikel]

No mission for the drone/E-7A.

Do I create a bug report?


Well, the first try was with 12 F-35s armed with anti-radiation AGM-88G and 24 F-22s with StormBreakers, and then the B-52s with LRASMs.

And it was not enough for the Red AAW escort, it could have worked if I had mounted a 2nd wave, I think.

[blu3s]

Mmm if it's not assigned might be WAD but feel free to create a ticket if it feels weird, I'd put it into a support mission.

Yep, use F-35s with AARGM and SDB-II (24/32 AC), keep the F-22 mainly for Air to Air and you should be good to go. Also you'll need to shape a bit the defenses, take down their AWACS, use non-kinetic effects etc.

[Nikel]

OK, bug report created.

https://forums.matrixgames.com/viewtopi ... 9#p5290319

[Nikel]

One more


v21 tested on B1892, outside of the editor. Settings: Hard and 1000 $. Again the most difficult.

This time 0 spent on subs. A lot of F-35s bought, 144

A lot spent in ADs and radars and some capabilities.



Short AAR: Pure air attack this time. I was not aware that the Joint Strike Missile was anti-ship and even less of the range

- 1st wave 72 F-35s with JSMs.

- 2nd wave 72 F-35s, that were armed first with the poor StormBreakers by error. Rearmed for the 2nd wave with JSMs. The error was not that bad, only 4 tankers available for 144 F-35s is not a good idea.

- 3rd wave, the remnants of both that could be rearmed with the limited magazines available of JSMs, 26 F-35s in total.

This was enough to get the strategic victory, however as you can see below 642 JSMs were required to defeat the impressive ADs of the Chinese naval group and the air escorts.




Comments:

- IMO not easier to win this way than with the subs. Besides this requires more time and the Red side can do nasty things in this extra time available for them.

- CMO slowdowns with so many JSMs in the air.

- HUMINT enemy units spotted. I was going to suggest some mobile Marine units available to destroy them. However there suffered losses, not sure how. There is also this in the lua history file, is it a problem?

UNIT: Inf Sec (Recon) not in REDUNITS

- One Lua fuse exception on the screen. I think it is the cause of CMO slowdown when playing the last hours of the scenario, when the Red side caused widespread No Comms trouble. Printed many times in the Lua History file attached.

09-09-2026 12:34:38!!!WARNING!!! EXCEPTION FUSE REACHED (x20 exceptions) FOR : -- Bv1.10 Beta - Build 1892 -- [string "CachedChunk"]:551: attempt to index a nil value (field 'JammingArea') -- Scen : Defend Luzon -- DB : -- Exception: [string "CachedChunk"]:551: attempt to index a nil value (field 'JammingArea')
Stack Trace: at NLua.Lua.ThrowExceptionFromError(Int32 oldTop)
at NLua.Lua.CallFunction(Object function, Object[] args, Type[] returnTypes)
at NLua.LuaFunction.Call(Object[] args)
at sti7w5Qwn5BsWqaadWN3.Cvw11DVDImG(Object , Object[] , sti7w5Qwn5BsWqaadWN3 )
at Command_Core.LuaUtility.DoString_Optimized(Lua lua, String chunk, String chunkName)
at Command_Core.Lua.LuaSandBox.RunScript(String str, Boolean RunInteractively, String script, String fullPath)
at Command_Core.EventAction_LuaScript.Execute(Scenario thescen, SimEvent theEv)
Call Stack & Error details:
Error at 101316:

AS OF: 12-Mar-28 14:59:36

SIDE: RED
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------
16x GJ-11 Sharp Sword UCAV
1x Il-78M Midas
4x Inf Sec (Recon)
11x J-15T Flying Shark [Su-33 Copy]
1x Su-30MKK Flanker G
1x Type 048 Daguan [88 Xu Xiake]
2x Type 052DL Luyang III Mod [125 Cangzhou]
3x Type 054A Jiangkai II [599 Anyang]
3x Type 055 Renhai [101 Nanchang]
1x Type 056A Jiangdao II [625 Bazhong]
3x Type 071 Yuzhao [998 Kunlun Shan]
2x Type 072A Yuting II [981 Dabie Shan]
1x Type 076
1x Type 903A Fuchi [889 Taihu]
1x Type 920 Anwei [866 Daishan Dao]
12x WZ-7 Soaring Dragon UAV
3x WZ-8 UAV
3x Z-18F Sea Eagle
3x Z-18J Bat
4x Z-20F
17x Z-9C Haitun [AS.565SA]
4x Z-9DF Haitun


EXPENDITURES:
------------------
3x 130mm China H/PJ-38 HE
17x 30mm China H/PJ-14 [Type 1130, 500 rnds]
23x 30mm Gsh-30-1 Burst [30 rnds]
33x 30mm/65 H/PJ-13 Burst [400 rnds]
253x CH-AA-10 Abaddon [PL-15]
27x CH-AA-9 [PL-10]
10x CH-SS-22 [DF-17, 500kg Conventional]
10x CH-SS-22 [DF-17, 500kg Conventional] RV
80x CH-SSC-13 Splinter [CJ-100, Conventional]
24x CH-SSC-9 [CJ-10]
12x CSS-2 Mod 1 [DF-3A, 480kg Conventional]
4x CSS-2 Mod 1 [DF-3A, 480kg Conventional] RV
12x CSS-X-24 [DF-27, 500kg HE Conventional]
12x CSS-X-24 [DF-27, 500kg HE Conventional] RV
11x Generic Active Directional Sonobuoy
4x Generic Chaff Rocket
9x Generic Chaff Salvo [4x Cartridges]
173x Generic Flare Rocket [Single Spectral]
3x Generic Flare Salvo [4x Cartridges, Single Spectral]
32x Generic Passive Directional Sonobuoy
334x HHQ-9B
169x HQ-10 [FL-3000N]
106x HQ-16A [SA-17 Semi-Copy]
60x Shahed-136
2x YJ-21 [250kg HE]
2x YJ-21 [250kg HE] RV
24x YJ-91 [Kh-31P, ARM]



SIDE: BLUE
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------
1x A/C Hangar (2x Large Aircraft)
1x A/C Hangar (2x Medium Aircraft)
2x A/C Hangar (4x Very Large Aircraft)
1x Ammo Bunker (Surface)
1x Building (Airport Terminal)
1x Building (Uplink Relay Station)
1x Building (Very Large Leadership Compound)
1x DDG 125 Jack H. Lucas [Arleigh Burke Flight III]
1x E-3G Sentry
1x E-7A Wedgetail
1x EA-37B Compass Call
8x F-35A Lightning II
1x HELIOS Jammer
4x KC-46A Pegasus
1x MH-60R Seahawk
1x RC-135S Cobra Ball
1x RQ-180 UAV
1x Structure (Power Station - Coal)


EXPENDITURES:
------------------
3x 20mm/100 Mk15 Phalanx Blk 1B Burst [300 rnds]
3x 25mm GAU-22/A Equalizer Burst [30 rnds]
72x AIM-120D AMRAAM P3I.4
4x AN/ALE-70 FOTD
10x AN/ALE-70(V)/T-1687 Expendable Decoy
12x Generic Chaff Salvo [5x Cartridges]
1x Generic Flare Salvo [3x Cartridges, Dual Spectral]
642x Joint Strike Missile (JSM)
48x MIM-104F Patriot PAC-3 ERINT
2x MIM-104F Patriot PAC-3 MSE
8x RIM-161C SM-3 NTW Blk IB
12x RIM-161E SM-3 NTW Blk IIA
32x RIM-162A ESSM
84x RIM-174A ERAM SM-6 Blk IA
38x RIM-66M-5 SM-2MR Blk IIIB
101x THAAD C-2 CEC



SIDE: BLUE DECOY
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: Civilian
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: Civilian
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: Biol
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: BLUE HUMINT
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------



SIDE: BLUE HUMINT N
===========================================================

LOSSES:
-------------------------------


EXPENDITURES:
------------------