ORIGINAL: Lowpe
The fighter bomber fleet:
In this game Japan has made and will continue to make a large investment in fighter bombers. Currently there are 8 Sentai and 2 Chutai, with no more growth anticipated until 1943 starts and I fail to get auto victory or not.
The A model will be the primary anti bomber FB.
The C model will be more specialized in strafing both ships and ground targets but primarily ground.
The Randy will replace both models on the front lines and extra Nicks will either go kamikaze (no more than 1 squadron) or late game reserve.
I am trying a new to me tactic of LRCAP enemy bases likely to see air transport with Nick A. So for nothing, but I am only doing Chungking. I have hopes of catching something in the Aleutians I think (although, there I will use the A6M3a).
The Nick C primary attribute I like is the use of the Nick D engine rather than the Ha35.
I'm interested to see how that works out for you, as the Randy airframes are such a mixed bag IMO.
The Randy A is an absolute necessity for the late game IMO. The superb max altitude and solid armament, durability and armour make it a great anti-bomber and high CAP fighter. Plus it's classed as a fighter so the majority of IJA squadrons can convert to it.
The Randy B I just can't like. Besides the slightly better armaments package and speed I'm hard pushed to see the improvement between the Nick C and Randy B.
The Randy C I want to love. It would be perfect if only the radar arrived a little earlier, but without the radar it's hard to sell over a less effective but more accessible airframe like the Nick NF.
Regarding Nicks as kamikaze airframes, there are a fair few of late-war IJA ten plane training squadrons that arrive using Nate B models that are mapped to upgrade to the Nate A. The Nate A is classed as a fighter-bomber, so it's possible to convert them to the Nate A model and then to Nicks for kami duty. I would absolutely say that there's a role for them here, given how twin-engine planes tend to have a better time getting through CAP and flak than single-engine types. At any rate it can help to distribute the load of kami aircraft losses in the late game. Kami squadrons can also be told to perform CAP, but I've never tested if they actually do so.