PBEM

[Mus]

How did France manage to siege a province they didnt start their movement in (Bosnia)? Sieges are supposed to happen before movement, not after.  My turn 20 shows Grand Armee I starting turn 20 in Illyria.  Is that FOW?  Were they actually in Bosnia already?  Very weird.

That is about the only unexpected thing to happen for me this turn.

[IronWarrior]

Good catch, Mus. Grande Armee I did indeed start the turn in Illyria. According to the in-game appendix under movement sub phases, sieges should occur before movement.

Either: I once again am not comprehending the manual; it's a bug; the garrison was too small/opposing force too large for the garrison to be considered an "opposing" force; or a combination of any of these.

Seems like this situation may have happened before, although I'm not certain.

[Kingmaker]

HiHi

You are right Bill, it happened at Marseilles, 1 Militia on 1.7 moral v's Russian army on " a hell of a lot higher moral [:)]", so probably your guess the garrison was too small/opposing force too large for the garrison to be considered an "opposing" force; has the right of it.

All the Best
Peter

[Kingmaker]

HiHi

Russias T21 orders sent in.

All the Best
Peter

[Mus]

If it isnt a bug the possibility ought to be discussed in the manual or appendix. Thats all. Not a huge deal. I just hadnt ever seen that happen before.

One possibility that struck me was that "Force Marching" might in certain circumstances count as the beginning of a new movement? I dont know, I do wish certain areas of the rules were a bit more fleshed out though.

[barbarossa2]

Swedish turn is almost in!

[barbarossa2]

Sweden T21 is now in.

[Kingmaker]

HiHi

Russias T22 orders sent in.

All the Best
Peter

[barbarossa2]

I need a lawyer.  I want a binding decision on a course of action I will take from a "neutral" judge of our house rules before I send my turn in. [:D]
 
Whose decision will we accept?

[Mus]

I vote for me.  Turkey has least to gain from issues that far North.

[Mus]

Hey Im still in there at -900 Morale, lol.

[Matto]

You or your country ? [8D]

[barbarossa2]

How about if Mus and Matto decide... and if they can't agree together, then... damn... .  I wish I could keep the question confidential.  Hmmmm...

[Franck]

Don't make to much fuss about that single house rule... Many things went ''wrong'' this game (ie everyone loosing 600 glory because of me!). I guess people will have a better feel of the game after this and we will restart once the patch is out!

[barbarossa2]

LOL... yeah.  I will  just play.  And I will appoint Franck as the interpreter of any actions which occur as a result.  Is that okay with everyone?

[Mus]

On house rules, hopefully they will be less necessary next game, but if a disagreement arises this turn it will only provide fodder for discussion in establishing house rules for next game.  So since this game is so messed up in the Glory department I say the more problems arise probably the better

[barbarossa2]

Sweden Turn 22 in.  Surprise!  LOL

[Mus]

This better be good with all the build up.
 
[:D]

[barbarossa2]

Mus, for the Ottoman Empire, it will be but a ripple in a pond.  For Sweden, it will make headlines for two months. 

[Mus]

Hmm.  So how many victory points do all those powers have on you?