ORIGINAL: Canoerebel
You didn't do this on purpose, but in your lengthy post with quotes attributed and unattributed, readers will assume that I'm the author of unattributed quotes embedded amongst quotes attributed to me. Please make your posts accurate and clear.
ORIGINAL: obvert
ORIGINAL: Canoerebel
I've spent the better part of an hour trying for the right way of saying I disagree with a number of posts today from both ends of the political spectrum. I haven't solved the Gordian knot and have erased every effort thus far. Suffice to say race shouldn't play a part in how we look at every single thing, always dividing rather than bringing together. We Americans are sharply divided on many issues, and with cause, but all parties of good faith are welcome at the table of discussion. None should be asked to leave.
As I've stated this all had do with a post about how some hospitals and medical facitilities are struggling with the lack of income and extra costs associated with the pandemic, and how that has hit and may continue to hit less privileged communities more. Potentially with consequences as big as hospitals closing.
https://www.ft.com/content/3bbb4f7c-890 ... 8a3e3fbd33
Others picked up on this area in the quote I picked out ...
---------------
Initial data suggests the disease has had a disproportionate impact on communities of colour. In New York, black and Latino people are twice as likely to die as white people. At One Brooklyn, the group has seen a high rate of hospitalisation among its coronavirus-positive patients. “Our community has been very significantly affected,” says Brown. “There is a reality that many of the hospitals that serve low-income communities of colour have the least amount of resources . . . Any public health crisis will uncover inequalities.”[/color]
... and ran with that for a while, and it's actually been interesting to work through that discussion. We don't need to shy away from race if all are okay with discussing their position on it in relation to these issues, but I think where we have failed occasionally is to stay relevant to the issues at hand.
Some of my posts have diverged in order to clarify that privilege and race are factors in relation to this discussion. I was particularly impressed with some forumites' personnal experiences around race, regardless or some initial flippant comments that came out. (Thanks Hans, MakeeLearn and RangerJoe)
What remark or remarks did I make that was flippant?
Some of those questions mean that some people struggle to get ahead that much harder than others, regardless of intent, inspiration, gratitude or opportunity.
That also has some effect on access to health care, education about nutrition, financial access to higher quality food and lifestyle, and other factors both cultural and economical that could be having an effect on the disproportionate number of black and brown people in the US (and elsewhere, like the UK) suffering and dying from this pandemic.
I have noticed the many of your comments seem directed at people without responding to them particularly by quoting posts or naming those people. You have also made many posts that seem very off-topic and lead to more "opinion shaming" in spite of your comment that "all parties of good faith are welcome at the table of discussion. None should be asked to leave."
Or did you only mean "all Americans?"
Some examples from today:
ORIGINAL: Canoerebel
If we manage to get even limited insight, that'll still be immeasurably more than we'll get from a select few.ORIGINAL: Canoerebel
(Geez, we need to qualify everything to mollify the perpetually offended.)ORIGINAL: Canoerebel
Ranger Joe, I hope my comment about canines and felines was sufficiently clear that you didn't think my "perpetually offended" caveat was aimed at you. It wasn't. It was aimed at the perpetually offended.
Is everyone "welcome at the table, really?"
I ask again, and please be specific, "What remark or remarks did I make that was flippant?"
I say that everyone is welcome at the table. If I don't care for your attitude or remarks, I will ignore you.
As far as healthcare outcomes, high blood pressure has been proven to start in children. I could even point out the baseball player whose records helped to prove this. That may be genetic but it could also be diet related. That can be socioeconomic but it could also be cultural.






