Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Please post your after action reports on your battles and campaigns here.

Moderator: Joel Billings

User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4771
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by M60A3TTS »

Week 17 12-18 October 1941

The long expected heavy rains have arrived and they cover almost the entire front. Only in the Stalino-Rostov area as well as the Crimea are we seeing moderate rainfall. We also now experience the heavy mud in places that further restrain movement and our truck columns.

It is this week that the Fuhrer declares Operation Barbarossa to be a failure in that the desired outcome of knocking out the Red Army has not come to pass. He expresses frustration at the lack of aggressiveness on the part of Von Rundstedt again, who the Fuhrer maintains should already have seized Rostov. The Fuhrer also says that up in the north, Von Leeb has fallen into the trap of putting his forces into a position of static warfare and subsequently has made a great mess of things. A decision as to whether a command shakeup is in order will be decided at a later date. He goes on to say that the progress of Von Bock and Army Group Center has been adequate but with the diversion from the Moscow axis, only with the capture of Tula and Voronezh will we be able to claim success here. Finally, the Fuhrer maintains that Operation Barbarossa as designed failed primarily because no one but Stalin would have so ruthlessly given up so much land and so many of his people in order to prolong the fight, a fight the Fuhrer maintains is entirely winnable. He says that winning the war in the east is now a matter of will and that the side that falters first in that regard will be vanquished.

One must appreciate that the Fuhrer’s conclusions have been met with more than a few raised eyebrows. It was he who ordered the drawing up of plans to invade the Soviet Union, who heard all the logistical arguments against it, who was briefed on the enormous manpower and industrial potential of the eastern colossus, who was well aware of Stalin’s accomplishments over the years by ruling over a tyrannical police state. Yet it fell to the Fuhrer to give the order to proceed. He subsequently lays none of the deficiencies of Barbarossa at his own feet, only others. We will see if his notion of a contest of wills between our two sides is indeed the deciding element in this conflict, but we still have an army of millions to feed, equip and maneuver. These latter matters in contrast to having an iron will may seem mundane to the Fuhrer, but they are equally vital if we are to have any chance of emerging victorious in this titanic struggle.

The poor ground conditions have halted all operations in the north. In the center despite similar conditions Von Bock scores a considerable achievement as Voronezh is surrounded. That removes 78 IL-2s from Soviet production for each week it remains offline. The Moscow site Is not currently active. 1451 airframes will have been built to date. They have also lost 416 aircraft of this type.

Image

Operations east of Voroshilovgrad continue under limited conditions. Here Rundstedt aims to clear the Russian forces along the west bank of the Don.

Image

In the Crimea, an important achievement as Model’s forces storm Yalta, thereby forcing the garrison of over fifty thousand to surrender and eliminating the last Soviet resistance in the Crimea. The efforts of the Luftwaffe in maintaining a total naval blockade of Yalta was key here. Equally important is the release now of 11th Army and the bulk of Luftflotte 4 for operations along the main front.

Image
Stamb
Posts: 2437
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 1:07 pm

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by Stamb »

may i ask for how long Yalta was isolated?
Слава Україні!
Glory to Ukraine!
User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4771
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by M60A3TTS »

Stamb wrote: Sat May 28, 2022 7:44 am may i ask for how long Yalta was isolated?
Weeks 12-17.
User avatar
xhoel
Posts: 3339
Joined: Sat Jun 24, 2017 7:46 pm
Location: Germany

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by xhoel »

Congrats on that encirclement at Voronezh and on clearing the Crimea. Where do you play on sending the 11th Army now? Will it move to support AGS? Or are you planning on using them to relieve a Panzer Army that you can then keep in reserve?
AAR WITW: Gotterdammerung 43-45
tm.asp?m=4490035
AAR WITE: A Clash of Titans 41-45
tm.asp?m=4488465
WitE 2 Tester and Test Coordinator
User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4771
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by M60A3TTS »

Week 18 19-25 October 1941

Heavy rains and mud have virtually paralyzed all our forces. Army Group North reports no activity and unable to advance. A pair of Russian cavalry divisions were eliminated in the Voronezh pocket, but that was largely the extent of the fighting, save for a pair of isolated battles.

The rail connections from Krivoi Rog to the Crimea remain broken. Rail repair units are at work in the area. It has been decided that the best source of supply for the 11th Army remains in the Crimea as well as Kherson and Nikolaev where vessels can still deliver their supplies from the Rumanian port of Constanta. Therefore Model is given orders to remain in this area so as not to further aggravate the already strained supply situation elsewhere.

Image
User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4771
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by M60A3TTS »

Week 19 26 October-1 November 1941
Heavy rains and mud cover the front, bringing almost movement to a halt. No activity in the north, but in the center, Von Bock reports the fall of Voronezh.

Image

Once the ground hardens, Army Group Center will be able to complete the work needed to capture Tula, after which their forces can be refreshed for the long winter ahead.
User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4771
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by M60A3TTS »

Week 20 2-8 November 1941

No change in weather conditions, we remain bogged down.

Image

Image

Image

Image
User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4771
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by M60A3TTS »

Week 21 9-15 November 1941

The ground has finally frozen so we can move once again. In the area of Army Group North, the weather conditions are particularly severe. We have managed to win several victories along the western part of the line. How long this will continue remains to be seen.

Image

At Tula, elements of Panzer Groups 2 and 3 have completed their encirclement.

Image


North of Voronezh, various units are surrounding isolated Russian ones that are attempting to hold their thin screen line.

Image


Along the western bank of the Don, Von Rundstedt is working to clear away numerous Russian units in order to secure a more solid line of defense.

Image


Ground losses

Image


Russian air losses are closing on ten thousand.

Image

We have strong evidence that there is a fast growing mass of men filling the Russian trenches. FHO is under the belief that they are transferring units from their Far East and Transcaucasus commands. They seem to be either increasingly desperate with their situation along our front or are more confident that they have little to fear from Japan and Turkey. Our Foreign Minister has come to this conclusion at least. We are caught on the horns of a dilemma. We must either pause now and build strong winter lines of defense and watch helplessly as our opponents continue to gather strength or we attack and hold down some of their manpower while making the defense lines as adequate as possible, if it even is possible as worsening weather makes digging difficult. The Fuhrer seems inclined on the latter approach while insisting with some truth that no army wins a war on the defensive.

Image
User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4771
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by M60A3TTS »

Week 21 severe weather

Image
User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4771
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by M60A3TTS »

Week 22 16-22 November 1941


Blizzard conditions extend the length of the front from all of Army Group North to the south of Tula.

Image


Despite the harsh weather, motorized units of Hoeppner’s Panzer Group 4 finally achieve a breakthrough along the western portion of the frontline of Army Group North.

Image


From his army group headquarters at Vitebsk, Field Marshal von Bock reports that Gotthard Heinrici’s 43rd Corps has taken Tula and inflicted twenty-seven thousand Russian casualties. With that we have secured all of our strategic objectives for this year.

Image


Meanwhile various units north of Voronezh have formed yet another Russian pocket while completing the destruction of two enemy divisions containing thirteen thousand men.

Army Group South is only involved in minor actions along the Don and have almost entirely eliminated Russian positions on the western bank with a few holdouts around Rostov. Once again the Fuhrer is highly agitated, with von Rundstedt seemingly content to sit in his positions. Meanwhile Rostov is left in Russian hands.

Image


There has been a growing concern as to the capabilities of our tank forces in weather conditions we have previously had little exposure to. Colonel Balck as an OKH member of the Inspectorate of Armored Forces provided an in-depth report that urges us to prepare for major equipment issues when the most extreme changes on the ground as well as temperature arrive. An equipment replacement program for our various armored divisions will need to be in place well before any anticipated offensives in 1942.

Our casualties to date:
Men 345,436
--Killed 89,422
--Missing and presumed captured 1,552
--Wounded/injured/disabled 254,462

Historical (per Halder’s diary of 17 Nov 41)
Men 699,726
--Killed 147,871
--Missing 29,230
--Wounded 522,625


Manpower pool:
Germany 438,677
Rumania 103,533
Hungary 94,935
Generic 163,696
Other 38,444
User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4771
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by M60A3TTS »

Week 23 23-29 November 1941

Snowfall across almost the entire front except for the Crimea and the area close to Rostov.

All of the army group commanders have strongly advised a halt in all offensive operations as we are clearly running out of time before the Russian winter takes hold. The Fuhrer remains firm that von Leeb continue to press his attacks along the western flank. Too much time was wasted in the fruitless pursuit of gains in the east, so It is now imperative to keep the Russians off balance along this front.

Image


Of even greater surprise is even as von Bock report reports the capture of Lipetsk, further demands by the Fuhrer are made for reconnaissance in the direction of Tambov! This responsibility falls to 10th Panzer Division of von Vietinghoff’s 46th Motorized Corps. General Fischer of 10th Panzer managed to get within roughly 33 kilometers west of the city when it became apparent it was defended. The divsion then fell back to the west with that mission accomplished.

Image
User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4771
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) ON HOLD MSAG welcome

Post by M60A3TTS »

This game is on indefinite hold until the issue dealing with replacing damaged equipment is resolved.

Unfortunately, this may be several weeks from what I'm gathering. Thanks to those following so far. Will update as soon as the status changes.
Veterin
Posts: 503
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2022 9:27 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by Veterin »

are you able to link the post outlining the supply issue? thanks!
User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4771
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by M60A3TTS »

Veterin wrote: Sat Jun 25, 2022 11:34 pm are you able to link the post outlining the supply issue? thanks!
https://www.matrixgames.com/forums/view ... 7&t=385075
User avatar
EwaldvonKleist
Posts: 2388
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2016 3:58 pm
Location: Berlin, Germany

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by EwaldvonKleist »

I hope the issue isbresolved quickly, I enjoy following this game. Good detailed AAR as always @M60.
jasonbroomer
Posts: 724
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2022 5:55 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by jasonbroomer »

+1
User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4771
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by M60A3TTS »

The game remains on hold currently, but we are on turn 31, so there is a little room for more reporting.


Week 24 30 November-6 December 1941

Conditions of snowfall persist across the front extending as far south as the area between Kharkov and Stalino.

Image

The forecast for the coming week is that blizzard conditions will sweep in from the east. Accordingly, it is now clear that the real Russian winter is almost upon us.

Image

Offensive operations cease across the front, save for a pair of minor attacks in the east. Many ground commanders are already raising serious concerns about the amount of ground they are required to defend as well as the limited fortifications that have been constructed but that cannot be helped. We have driven the Russians back this far, and in their weakened state the Fuhrer is confident of our lines holding owing to the high morale of the army. Fears of a Napoleonic retreat have no basis in fact. The troops of the Ostheer are well led, organized and no doubt confident in final victory.

North

Image


Center

Image

Image


South

Image


OOB

Image


Ground Losses

Image


Destroyed Units

Image


Air losses

Image

The Gen QM reported 21,087 tons of supplies delivered to the ground forces. If this can be sustained, we should be in good enough shape.

Rail network

Image
User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4771
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by M60A3TTS »

Week 25 7-13 December 1941


Blizzard conditions extend well to the west as predicted.

Japan’s attack on the United States has been followed by our own declaration of war. We already hear from our sources in Britain that Churchill is now certain of an Allied victory. Apparently this was sufficient for the Fuhrer to call senior officers in for a discussion where he outlined several points.
  • Our U-Boats now have freedom of action at last to go after the Atlantic convoys. This cannot but help in reducing the flow of goods to Britain and North Africa. Almost certainly this will affect Murmansk convoys as well.

    America’s industrial potential grossly overrated, particularly in the short term. Here the shortcomings of democratic government become all too clear. The businessmen who furnish the weapons of war are motivated solely by profit margins, and not patriotism. The mobilization of their industry in the last war was sadly lacking. Their railroads were so mismanaged that a national takeover was necessary. The need of the French and British to equip and arm many American troops that arrived in France was well documented.

    American soldiers have no prospect of landing on the continent until 1943 at the very earliest. By then matters in the east will have been decided. Stalin has already played his trump card in trading space for time. He will not have that luxury in 1942, it will be stand and fight or see his country overrun. Next year the Fuhrer has no doubts that the war in the east will be won.

    Consequently, once matters are decided in Russia, our transfer of troops to the west will present the western allies with a fait accompli. With Germany as the undisputed master of Europe, Roosevelt will pressure Churchill into granting favorable terms for peace. Our relations with Japan and the ability to act as go between in a separate peace settlement may also factor into negotiations.
Activity this week across the front was extremely quiet. A couple Russian attacks in the area of Army Group North.
Supply tonnage to the troops down significantly, to 17,461 tons. Trains in many places either immobilized or operating at a greatly reduced rate due to extreme weather. Soldiers in front line units are kept constantly busy clearing the roads of snow for the supply trucks to get through. Many commanders asking where the winter clothing that had been promised will arrive. The situation already becoming difficult, and priority must remain to ammunition, replacement weapons, etc. The troops will have to rely on local remedies until the supply situation improves.

Troops disabled rose this week primarily due to weather conditions from roughly 8,000 to 9,800.

Army Group end strength (campaign start in parens)

North
Men 683,413 (701,339)
Guns 6,572 (6,542)
AFV 741 (812)

Center

Men 965,916 (1,120,713)
Guns 10,134 (10,836)
AFVs 1,316 (2,445)

South
Men 763,071 (941,020)
Guns 7,523 (8,677)
AFVs 946 (1,066)

Antonescu
Men 644,763 (639,585)
Guns 6,261 (5,612)
AFVs 41 (252)

Losses
Killed: 96,224
Captured: 1,840
Wounded/disabled 282,988

Historical Losses
Killed: 162,799
Missing, presumed captured: 32,484
Wounded / disabled 579,795

Soviet losses
Killed: 539,745
Captured: 1,670,045
Wounded/disabled: 617,339
Nowi Ribak
Posts: 71
Joined: Sun Oct 30, 2011 11:58 am
Location: Austria, Europe

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by Nowi Ribak »

this is a great AAR, I very much appreciate your storytelling, so thank you very much for your effort



North is very tricky, lovely to see how ambivalent and different the Leningrad game plays out ... imo its basically impossible to take Leningrad against a dedicated and somewhat experienced SOV player, so no shame there

Center - well played, I dont understand how you can supply Voronezh, but hats off to a great campaign in the center

South - the Krim campaign was executed to near perfection, very rare, very proficient
the rest is very well done, but oc explained by SOVs defence in the north and the botched Center counterattack

SOV # are acceptable, except for Leningrad he probably cant carry a meaningful offensive. If you can supply your forces through the worst of the 41' winter he is in real trouble
User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4771
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

Re: Express to Valhalla GC41 M60 (Axis) vs MSAG (Sov) MSAG welcome

Post by M60A3TTS »

Nowi Ribak wrote: Thu Jul 21, 2022 8:41 pm this is a great AAR, I very much appreciate your storytelling, so thank you very much for your effort



North is very tricky, lovely to see how ambivalent and different the Leningrad game plays out ... imo its basically impossible to take Leningrad against a dedicated and somewhat experienced SOV player, so no shame there

Center - well played, I dont understand how you can supply Voronezh, but hats off to a great campaign in the center

South - the Krim campaign was executed to near perfection, very rare, very proficient
the rest is very well done, but oc explained by SOVs defence in the north and the botched Center counterattack

SOV # are acceptable, except for Leningrad he probably cant carry a meaningful offensive. If you can supply your forces through the worst of the 41' winter he is in real trouble
Thanks for the feedback. I am not expecting big things from Voronezh, but 1k to 1.5k tons of supplies will do.
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”