Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post descriptions of your brilliant successes and unfortunate demises.

Moderator: Gil R.

User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

Yes, I've played many Campaigns before, But finally I have convinced my close minded Yankee brother to turn from the pointless first person shooting games and turn to Tactical Forge of Freedom. He enjoys it so much we are now doing a hot seat game. I'm playing as the Confederates and my brother as the union: Emancipation is allowed as well as European Intervention. Besides that it's an advanced November 1861 set up. Let the war begin as we ride out to glory one final time.



November 3, 1861


I, General Tavelon Martimus stood outside of the war department's office in Richmond. After planning with Generals Lee and A. Sidney Johnston, I developed a strategy to gain our independence. The two men have been given rank of full General, commanding the Army of Northern Virginia, and the scattered forces between the Mississippi and the Appalachians, respectively. I've developed a strategy with the two men. In The West Johnston will have to lie low until we form a Army container. So his five divisions can stay in lower Tennessee, for now. In The Missouri area, Lt. General Sibley will organize a army, to defeat the union forces and then go to Tenn., to reinforce Johnston. In Virginia, Lee has three corps under Lt. Generals Mclaws, Jackson and D. H. Hill.Mclaws is only temporary, until I find a better officer such as Cleburne, Hood, Hampton or, Possibly Gordon. Generally speaking, we decided that we need to deliver a critical blow on the blue clad invader. That said, we need to conserve our troops until that are properly lead and upgraded. In the East, Our army was based at Fredericksburg, Magruder commanding the Army of the Peninsula, and Ewell commanding two divisions in Winchester.
This blow was contemplated, as we built barracks and hospitals as well as academies and camps. We three were confident, that whatever the federals threw at us, we will repulse it. We heard from some scouts in Fredrick that Lincoln chose a commander of all forces, his name was general Octavius Blackstone...Fresh out of West Point. At any rate, we had our new commanders, and we were ready. A hidden strategy was now in motion, and we are prepared to do our duty for our Country, for our God, for home, for our cause. I will shatter this Union into pieces, our troops will defend our homes with honor, And I, General Tavelon Martimus will have the highest honor to carry this out.
ImageImageImageImage
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

November 11, 1861
 
Following my meeting eight days prior, I took a train to Fredricksburg. I didn't serve as a Army commander, more of a staff officer for army of Northern Virginia. I organized supplies, assigned leaders, Ect. One thing I did take part in was the Transfer of Lt. General Jackson. General Lee and I talked about dividing the Army, Only to draw a portion of the Union army so we can strike that Isolated portion. Lee agreed that it was nessecary, and also added that Napoleon would not have won a single battle if he didn't divide his force. So the II corps was shipped to the Shenendoah while Lee stayed with Mclaws and D. Hill at Fredricksburg. Now we both considered that the union would not fall for our trap,but If they did not, Jackson could always attack the small Army of the Shenendoah under union control in Charelstown. Once arriving, General Ewell was ordered that one of his divisions would join Jackson when he arrived.  If the Union did fall for the trap, part of the union army of the Potomac would set out to destroy Jackson, allowing Lee to attack the weakened army.  
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

November 19, 1861
 
I woke up in my tent in Fredricksburg. I fastly dressed, eagerly awaiting my Breakfast I longned for that night. I sat at a table, set up with some other officers. Lee wasn't among them, but Harvey Hill, Edward Johnson, and Laffayete Mclaws were present. While in the middle of a bite of Bacon and sausage, I heard my name. I turned around to see my aide behind me, Colonel Joe Davis.
He delivered a telegram which he handed to me. Obviously since it was urgent enough to disrupt my breakfast, I left the table and walked towards a fence next to my tent while I opened it. It said on the top:
 
Helena, Arkansas, November 18, 1861
 
To General Tavelon R. Martimus, Commander of all armed forces
 From Lt. General Henry Hopkins Sibly, commander of the Dept. and Army of The West
 
General Martimus, I have grevious news to bring you. For on the 14 of November, A brigade of 3,000 men in Westport were attacked by the 23,000 man army of Missouri. I Regret that I did not pull out this lone brigade to saftey in Arkansas. For I heard from The Colonel of he 3rd Missouri, who now commands the brigade, that on the morning of the 14 we were attacked. It was a slaughter: The troops poured in on the outskirts of down, Driving our forces as they had breakfast. The soldiers fled, Many captured. In The town they reorganized under their General. He decided to hold on the road and thought that I was coming to his aid. Since I obviously knew little of this bloodbath, no troops arrived. So the Federals broke their lines and their General was killed. They fled and after two days reached my lines. We suffered seventy precent casualties, 2,147 out of the three thousand. The federals loss nearly none so our sacrafice was in vain. I take the responsibility for not ordering them to report to me, and all further mistakes changed so this will NEVER happen again.
 
Your obiedient servent, Henery Hopkins Sibley
 
I was shocked. While the loss small, it did show the men in blue's resolve. While it wasn't entirely Sibley's fault, more of the Brigade commander for relying on reinforcements that may not come. But Sibley should have been more careful. While not the best manager, he had tons of grand reports on him. More troops will need to be sent to the Trans-Mississippi than I thought, and it will not be an easy action, It will be a grueling fight to the end.
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
jkBluesman
Posts: 797
Joined: Mon Feb 12, 2007 6:48 pm

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by jkBluesman »

Nice start. I am looking forward to read more. Where did you put Longstreet?
"War is the field of chance."
Carl von Clausewitz
User avatar
Gil R.
Posts: 10820
Joined: Fri Apr 01, 2005 4:22 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Gil R. »

I agree. This should be fun to follow. And I believe this would be the first hot-seat AAR for FOF -- certainly the first that I've seen. Great title, by the way.
Michael Jordan plays ball. Charles Manson kills people. I torment eager potential customers by not sharing screenshots of "Brother Against Brother." Everyone has a talent.
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

To JkBluesman
 
Longstreet, being my favorite commander in the civil war, would be my first choice for commander of the I corps (Or the Forces in the West) but I don't have him yet.
 
To Gil
 
Thanks for reading, my first AAR Didn't work out because mid way through game the game broke and I had to Re-install it.
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

Hey, does anyone know how to take screenshots on FOF?
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

November 21, 1861
Fredricksburg, Virginia
 
I was assissting with the placement of the washington Arrtillery batteries of the I corps when a rider came up. It was Joe Davis, my aide.
"General sir, a report from General Jackson!"
"Thank you Colonel, god be with you!"
"And with you sir!"
 
He rode off as I opened up the Telegram.
 
Winchester, Virginia,
November 21, 1861
 
To General Tavelon Martimus, General commanding
From Lieutenant General Thomas Jonothan Jackson, Commander  Of II corps, Army of Northern Virginia
 
My dear sir,
I must inform you on my arriving in the Valley, I met with General Stovall,
whose division was in Winchester. After waiting for 12 days, my Cavalry reports that the enemy is not Aproaching, and their troops withrdew to the Army of the Potomac. Seeing that their is little that I can do, I am wondering sir if my presence here is justified. If not, I will march with great haste to join the Army of Northern Virginia. If their is any service I can be here, I am much obliged to see to it.[/align] [/align]Respectfully yours,[/align]Thomas Jonathan Jackson, General commanding[/align] [/align]I folded up the letter and put it in my coat pocket. While I had something in mind for his II corps and was going to do it, I reasoned I talk to Lee first because It's his Army.[/align] [/align]I made it to Lee, after going to his tent and seeing him gone, I found Major Taylor who brought me to the old Man who was with D. H. Hill. I dismounted my horse and entered Hill's tent where I met the two men.[/align]"General Hill, General Lee, pleasure to see you." I read them the Telegram from Jackson and then asked first what Hill thought on the Matter. Hill suggested that he stay in the valley, since it's a days train ride anyhow. Lee seconded Hill's proposal. Then I offered my ideas.[/align]"The entire Union army, Right, center and Left wings of the Army of The Potomac are in camp in Washington. It appears this General Blackstone is not the attacking kind. Since we all agree on that we need to knock a heavy blow on those people early in the War, We need to fight them. But since they are in the forts in Washington that we can't even dream of taking, We must fight in the open."[/align]"But he won't advance." Hill piped up. I looked in Lee's eyes and knew the two of us were thinking the same. [/align]"Since he will not advance, we must draw him out. We tried that in the valley, it failed. We found that they don't care about the valley. But they do care about Maryland, since it's loyalties are ever so wavering. I suggest that Jackson, With Stovall's Valley division, advance north into western Maryland."[/align]Hill was shocked and started to protest about his corps being alone until I cut him off.[/align]"General Hill, I know that, and so does Blackstone. We need to draw out part of his Army and weaken it, then the Main army will smash the remainder Of the Army of the Potomac left behind. Jackson may lose against superior force, but while he's engaged and has their attention, we move to strike The rest of the Army!"[/align]After getting the final orders drafted, It was deided that Jackson will advance with Four Divisions under Major General Richard Ewell, Major General Alexander Lawton, Brigidier General Marcellus Augustus Stovall and[font="trebuchet ms"][font=verdana] Major General Jubal Anderson Early. 41,000 men.[/font]  [font=verdana]Jackson was to advance[/font] [/font][font=verdana]north to Fredrick Area. Avoid heavy casualties but get the Enemies full attention.[/font][/align] [/align]I knew that man was a fighter, but could he fight his own battle? Will they fall for the trap? Will we smash them? And who is this Blackstone? So many questions and so little answers, [/align]It's all in God's hands now...[/align] [/align] 
 
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Gil R.
Posts: 10820
Joined: Fri Apr 01, 2005 4:22 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Gil R. »

ORIGINAL: Jonah

Hey, does anyone know how to take screenshots on FOF?


The easiest way is to hit Control-PrintScreen to copy the image and then go to the free "Paint" program that comes on PC's and paste it there. Save the image as a JPEG and you're ready to go.
Michael Jordan plays ball. Charles Manson kills people. I torment eager potential customers by not sharing screenshots of "Brother Against Brother." Everyone has a talent.
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

Thanka
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

I mean Thanks, hit the A by accident 
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

Bad news...I installed the patch and now my saved game is uncompatible.  Starting a new one: Brother against brother: Southern Steel against he war of northern aggression.
Updates soon, AAR will be posted on same thread.
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

<Edit>
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

November 3, 1861
Richmond, Virginia
&nbsp;
After going over documents and such I finnaly reorganized the Confederate army. I first ordered the building of camps in Atlanta, Norfolk, Richmond, Petersburg and Lynchburg. In Nashville, Chattonooga and Knoxville I build Academies. In New Orleanes and Charelston I ordered the building of Mints and in Savannah a Horse farm is built. Meanwhile I reorganize the Department of Northern Virginia. General Joesph Johnston is sent out to Memphis to take command of Department number two, and have Leonidas Polk as his Second. Beareguard is sent out to be second in command to A. Sidney Johnston.&nbsp; General Robert Edward Lee, who I was meeting with earlier at dinner, was given command of the forces in the Soverign state of Viginia. The Aquia District has been Renamed the I corps, with Lt. James Longstreet at it's head. Currently consisting of two divisions, one of Infantry under Major General Lafayete Mclaws and a Cavalry division under Major genral J.E.B Sturat. The valley district is renamed the II corps and given to Lt. General Jackson. It comprises of three divisions: His old division under Major general Robert Rodes, the Army of the northwest , under Major General J. Wallker, now reinforced to four brigades. The Army of southwest Virginia under John Floyd was sent to A.S. Johnston's army and the Army of the Peninsula under Major General Magruder went to the II corps. Lt. General Holmes was sent to the Department of the James at drewey's bluff and Lt. General D. H. Hill took his place. Ben Huger was sent to the department of Fredricksburg, and his division went to Major General Richard Anderson. The second division, III corps went to Jubal Early. Finnally Major General Humphrey Marshall and his small Army of Kenewha went to Richmond to be Reinforced by new brigades. A new division was created and soon will be attached to the A.N.V., as will Marshall's. This constiuted the Army of Northern Virginia. In&nbsp;The west, A.S. Johnston's Army of Central Kentucky was reinforced by the army of East Tennessee, Army of Southwest Virginia and Bragg's Army of Pensacola. More brigades were organizing to join the weakened army. In Memphis, Polk's army, now under Joe Johnston, was reinforced with Lovell's department number one, and the two divisions under Sterling Price from&nbsp;Missouri. This left that area empty,&nbsp;but there were no union troops there anyhow. More brigades were being mustered to reinforce the three armies, New divisions were in the making as well as corps to go out west. The Army was set, And I,&nbsp;General Tavelon Martimus will destroy any&nbsp;union soldier that stains the confederacy. WE march off to war as the soldiers of Lee's army file out&nbsp;towards Fredricksburg...&nbsp;
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

November 12, 1861
Fredricksburg, Virginia
&nbsp;
Lee, D.H.Hill, Longstreet and I sat around a table disscussing the plans for the campaign. It seemed obvious that we should attempt to take part of the Army of the Potomac at a time. The Army of the potomac Center&nbsp;under George Meade, supposevly, with around 34,000 men, who were encamped in Deleware. The Army of the Potomac Right was 36,000 men and Encamped near Washington DC, under J.F. Reynolds. Finnaly the army of the potomac Left was 51,000 under Hancock and near Fredrick. Jackson's corps was ordered to rendevous here in Fredricksburg, for our army was too small to be scattered. The man least enthusiastic was James Longstreet, who only had 21,000 men in two divisions, and one of them only cavalry, under Stuart. The concentration was inperitive in order to be able to beat the enemy. Reports came in that Kentucky has joined the CSA, a brilliant feat. Some corps were in forming, to be sent out west, something Vital. In the far west, it was heard that the union army withdrew to&nbsp;Illinois, another&nbsp;Victory for us. Sterling Price stated
"The men are extatic! Our homes now liberated! Let us trod on our old ground that has so long been polluted by the invader!" While Missouri isn't&nbsp;my immiediete concern, in the fuetre it will be an idea. Currently, two new divisions have been created but we still&nbsp;need the troops in them, they will&nbsp;be for reinforcing&nbsp;the I and III corps. After seeing to these details I went back through the mud and into my tent, there is a battle coming, and I know it...&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

November 29, 1861
Fredricksburg, Virginia
 
The battle of Port Royal
 
At around 8:00, a courier rode up to me.
"General Martimus, the enemy is aproaching!"
"Where? How many?" I asked as I was buttoning my coat.
"General Reynold's Army of the Potomac Right, 34,600, Marching towards our flank near Port Royal."
"Where is the II corps?" I asked, obviously needing the largest formation in our army.
"Not here sir,"
Blast, that meant I would have to fight the battle with the III and I corps alone.
"Notify Longstreet and Lee to bring their forces in the Port Royal region on the defensive. Order the Garrison troops under Huger to Rendevous..." I looked at the map.
"...Here. Where is Hill's corps?"
"General Early's division is at Rapohonack Station, but Hill and Anderson's division are at Fredricksburg."
"Okay. Tell Early to come with all haste and we'll meet them soon."

Across the Rapahanock, on the south side, Anderson's division was dug in, to their right was the woods and to their left was a large hill called Turkey Knob. Lee planned to have Anderson bear the brunt of the federal assault, and the rest of the army will fall on the federal right, once R.H. Anderson draws them in past the Rapohanock with their backs to the river. The battle opens up, and on Anderson's imiediate front, the union mass Samuel Hentzilmans heavy division. Anderson forms his six brigades into line of battle, The washington Arrtillery, the Virginia brigade, the Hampton's legion, the Texas brigade, the Georgia brigade and the Florida brigade. On Anderson's right, the division of Nathanial P. Banks advances, spear headed by the Iron Brigade. Anderson sends the Georgians refusing his flank. Hentzilman's line surges foward and charges, Anderson rides up and down the line urging the men on, even Lee himself get's near the action. The musket's blaze and HentZilman's charge falls apart, he then pulls back across the Rapohannock. To the right, Banks and the Iron brigade are locked in a deathmatch against the Georgians, who hold firm. To the Confederate Left, Fritz John Porter brings his division around Turkey nob to flank Anderson. The collumn halts as the action shifts back to the center. The union under Hentzilman advance again with fixed bayonets and charge across the river. Anderson orders to fire and ripples of musketry are heard along the battle. Hentzilman's assault is slowing down but he is fully engaged. On the Right, Banks gathers his men and leaves the Iron brigade on the flank and brings the rest of his men into Hentzilman's assault. To the Left, John F. Reynolds, the union army commander, brings his troops in collumn of fours around Turkey Knob Hill. Suddenly, Longstreet's attack begins and Ben Huger's garrison Virginians, McLaws Georgians and South Carolinians as well as mississipians fall on Porter's division before they can form into line of battle. With a rebel yell, the Confederates surge foward and the union line collapses. The First volley brought John Reynolds from his Horse and the second sends his brigade into flight. Mclaws rallies his men onward and Porter's entire division is routed, and Hunderds of Prisinors taken. In The center, Hentzilman and Banks Bayonet charge to try to win the day. The charge ends at the muzzles of Anderson's division and some canister breaks the yankee invader. General E. Kirby was wounded in the charge and General Launman was hit seriously, so three generals on the other side hit. R.H. Anderson siezes the moment and leads his division foward in a counter attack. Union defenders fire a shot and Run down the hill, raising hands in surrender. D. H. draws his saber out and brings the men in advance. Banks on the Confederate right tries to get out while he can. On the left, McDowell takes command of the army and brings his reserve division fowaed against Longstreet's assault. Longstreet is temporaily stalled as McDowell and Porter organize a resistance. Finnaly, Jubal Early's Louisianians and Georgians arrive and charge McDowell's Flank, and smash it. J. E. B. Stuart brings his three cavalry brigades in a saber charge that sends Porter Fleeing, but at the Height of the Charge the gallent Stuart is hit in the arm. Longstreet brings Mclaws men in a charge and sends the union fleein in confusion, the union right crumbled. Anderson's Texas brigade charges and smashes bank's division. The entire union army was in flight and in between to oncoming forces, but amazingly escapes the clutches of Lee and make it safely back in a disorganized rout to washington D. C.
The battle was a splendid victory, the union lost 12,648 men and the confederates lost a mere 4,081 for the victory. The leaderless union army lost 33% cassualties, a third of their number.
The victory showed somethings about the officers, in the I corps-
Lt. General James Longstreet, commander,
A brilliant officer, the flank attack perfect. Completely justifies promotion.

Major general Laffayete Mclaws, division commander- A great officer, led the attack spearhead. Fully capable for divisional command and higher assignment. A superb officer.
         
Major general JEB stuart- A great officer that has an aggresive personality. His charge broke the enemies lines, he will be missed during his recovery.

Lt. General D. H. Hill, commander III corps-A great officer, his defense of Turkey knob with three to one odds was magnificent. A combat officer, should definitly be rewarded with his defense. Excpecting great things to come.

Major General R. H. Anderson, divisional commander- Anderson's defense was superb. A great combat officer, Anderson is the rising star of the confederate army. Anderson's service is outstanding and should be considered for high command.

Major General Jubal Early-Great officer, drove his men beyond impossible limits to the field. Great officer, possibly not the tactical one but definitly a great officer.

Brigadier General Ben Hugar, commander of the department of the Rapohanock- A poor officer at best, should never take field command. His service was slow and non-commital.

General Robert E. Lee- America's greatest war hero, can I say more.

That's the battle, additionly, two new divisions have been created and will report to the I and III corps to strengthen their ranks.

God be with you all!  

Image
Attachments
the_gray_c..nches_lg.jpg
the_gray_c..nches_lg.jpg (110.74 KiB) Viewed 688 times
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

December 3, 1861
Fredricksburg, Virginia
&nbsp;
After the victory at Port Royal, The Army of northern Virginia rejoices. Moving out of Fredricksburg to meet Jackson's II corps in the valley, I stay behind to see some last details here. Brigadier General Ben Huger is in command of this department, consisting of four brigades.&nbsp;During my stay here a fifth brigade came by as did the Army's newest addition, Major General Harry Heth's division, made&nbsp;up of Marshall's old command. This three brigade division of 7,000 men reports to D.H.Hill in his third corps. In the meantime, another division is being made to add a new division to Longstreet's I corps. In the west, a new corps has been made to go into the army of Tennessee.&nbsp;Back east, It appears the Army of the Potomac is on the move. Our scouts report that Hancock and Meade's armies are moving into Grafton with&nbsp;92,000 men.&nbsp;Lee musters his army near&nbsp;Lexington. In Fredricksburg, the union army under Nathanial P. Banks, taking over for the wounded Reynolds, marches&nbsp;to the Rapohannock and crosses near&nbsp;Kelly's ford to bring his Army between&nbsp;Lee and Richmond. With this news I ride as fast as&nbsp;my&nbsp;mare could go to&nbsp;Fredricksburg to gather a force there. A North Carolinian brigade,&nbsp;en route to join Lee's Army, stops there to Join Huger's 'Army of&nbsp;the North'. Huger musters 11,600 men to try to stop Banks in a battle that will shape the Nation.
&nbsp;
Battle of Kelly's ford
&nbsp;
Huger digs in, with one Brigade in Fort&nbsp;Johnston on the far left in a salient, followed by a Garrison unit and then the North Carolinians under Colonel George&nbsp;Van Graff. Another Garrisson unit with Huger in direct command is positioned on the Right, with the far right anchored by more Garrisson troops. Huger and the two right brigades 'Designated the Right wing under Colonel&nbsp;Josiah Smith of the 44th VA. Regiment' form at a tree line before&nbsp;a clearing. The other three brigades are deep in the woods in the left wing under Colonel Van Graff. The Battle begins when Porter brings his division to assault Fort Johnston. His brigades surround the fort and put it under siege. THe defenders hurl everything they have down but still can't beat them back. These are Army of the Potomac veterans, wanting revenge after their&nbsp;defeat. More to come later&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

Battle of Kelly's ford part two
 
McDowell brings foward his division to support Porter but gets entangled in the woods fighting The North Carolinians. Splinters fly off trees and hitting the men all over who are already getting killed by musketry. Sam Hentzilman brings his division foward against the our right. His men, already at the flank race out of the treeline shouting
"Reynolds! Remember Reynolds!"
Nearly seven thousand men charge into Huger's line. On the far right, Banks personnaly leads the attack at hugers rear. Slamming into his unprotected rear, his men flee. Banks brings up the Iron brigade and they smash into the confederate right. Surrounded and confused, that confederate brigade surrenders. To the left, Hentzilman rallies his men as they scrable against huger's tired troops. Huger Bayonet charges but loses half his strength as the corpses litter the woods. To the left, Mc Dowell leads the bayonet charge that eizes fort Johnston and the panicking garrison surenders. Huger rallies his men and they flee south to the north Anna river. Banks has won his Victory. The confederates get out the best they can but still, it's a rout. Huger lost 4,567 men, over half of them are captured. Banks lost around 1,367. The Fifth U.S. Infantry inflicted over one thousand casualties, and will be rewarded. The Iron Brigade was nearly as good, inflicting 1,234 casualties. 
Huger unfouretenetly was not one of them, this poor commander in charge of a poor command will be punished.
Banks proved to be a powerful foe on the field with great Tactis, Solid judgment and stout leadership. Irwin Mcdowell, Sam Hentzilman and Franz Sigel too were amazing opponets.

THe battle was over, but the one benifit it was that now the union armies are divided and now can be beaten in detail.

Image
Attachments
confederat..risoners.jpg
confederat..risoners.jpg (181.65 KiB) Viewed 687 times
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

January 3, 1862,
Fredricksburg Virginia
&nbsp;
I just finished a nice long sleep, one of the first in the last few weeks. Since the last battle in December not much has happened, in fact there was a brief
solemnization of the holiday through the army's chaplins. In Virginia I just finished my latest Council with President Davis, General Samuel Cooper, Secretary of war Judah Bengiman, General Joesph Johnston, General R.E.Lee and General A.S. Johnston. It was decided that this war needed a battle that could change the war, obviously, but we needed to first see to our army. While I was down there I saw A.P. Hill's new division as well as Brigades for Pickett's division and for another division being created. The ANV was reorganized and reinforced, now numbering 111,000 men. Additonly, all units in all confederate forces since November have had a re done system. Instead of Goverment units and federal units, it went to the state level. For example, the old 138th Infantry is now the Fifth Virginia brigade. With the signing of the Brigade act, something I recommended, the army now has brigades mustered from states and for their contributions, we upgrade them, give them new weapons, give them a unique flag and a name such as the 9th South Carolina infantry. Additionly, the Goveners now get Camps and telegraph offices. This boost the morale of the people and strength of the army as we swiftly incorporate all of our forces into the three principal armies. Lee's ANV, Joe Johnston's Army of Mississippi, (Formally Department number two) and A. Sidney Johnston's Army of Tennessee (Formally army of Central Kentucky.) This ground breaking victory we need will need to happen once we have enough troops. In the AOT, there are no corps yet and only have five understrength divisions, according to A.S. Johnston. In the AOM Joesph Johnston says there are only five understrength divisions as well. REinforcements continue to come. Currently we can get 13,000 men via camps, which soon enough will provide but we need corps containers. News came that the Northerners under General Blackstone have adopted the corps system, Having the I-IV corps under Generals Rosecrans in Kentucky, Keyes and Banks in Hancocks army of the potomac a new IV under James McPherson in the making. They also made a new army, Of the Ohio. That should be something to watch out for. While all of us in the meeting agree to mass our troops in the main army, we want to create two new corps strength departments in the Shenendoah and Richmond, Another Army would be good, to be put in Arkansas. It is decided that the AOM is to wait until Grant loses many men attacking Fort Henery, that seems to be drawing nearer every day. The AOT will advance on Ohio and Indiana once fully strengthed and the ANV will remain on the defensive in Fredricksburg, now that Banks and the union forces have passed through. [/align]&nbsp;[/align]According to scouts, J.F. Reynolds is back in command, an idication that both Blackstone and Lincoln have their full confidence in him. The AOP Right, Left and center advanced south to Kenewha last week, maybe trying to threaten the Tenn.-Virginia RR near abingdon. Not much more was discussed, FOR THE SOUTH!&nbsp;[/align]
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
User avatar
Jonah
Posts: 154
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:13 am

RE: Brother against Brother: An AAR

Post by Jonah »

I don;t mean to complain, but is anyone reading this? I hate typing to find my work for no purpose? (Fun work, but work none the less...)
“Duty is ours, Consequences are God’s.”

-Lieutenant General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”