<t> Don't know if this is just me it is interesting how if you add the point sub totals together they don't seem to match the total points. If I had to guess (assuming I did my sums right of course) it looks like the points under scoring appear to reflect FOW whilst the total seems to reflect actual ...

<t> Just wanted to say what a great AAR you've put together the perfect accompaniment to my morning coffee [:)]. Going to miss it when you finish.<br/>
<br/>
Only one thing please, please can you deal with those 2 Japanese bases opposite shanghai they are a blemish on an otherwise spotless China ...

<t> Just wondered if you have any assault shipping in the Malaya area? You have many units already prepped at 100% why not try an amphibious invasion based out of Johre Bahru under heavy CAP rather than a crossing? Obviously Japanese players avoid this in 42 due to the big CD unit there but John is ...

<r> <QUOTE><s>[quote]</s>
<B><s>[b]</s>Battle of Sumatra:<e>[/b]</e></B> Two IJ divisions attacked (shock) the surviving Allied support unit stack west of Sabang. Most of them surrendered. The last few units will undoubtedly follow suit tomorrow, bringing and end to the campaign 8.5 months after D ...

<t> Hi,<br/>
<br/>
Just wanted to chime in to say what an amazing AAR this is (although I'm sure my boss would disagree if he knew how often I end up checking it [:)])<br/>
<br/>
Congrats on the initial stages of Roller Coaster fingers crossed the rest of the operation goes as smoothly. I was ...

<t> Thanks heliodorus! So far I've taken around 2.6M prisoners with the lowest number of units destroyed in a turn being 25 so perhaps you are right that I have over done it some what on the pockets [:)]<br/>
<br/>
Hopefully as you say I will start to run into heavier resistance over the coming ...

<t> I'm playing as the Axis under version 1.08.08. I've set the AI settings to 109 for everything and avoided any use of HQ Build ups.<br/>
<br/>
At the end of turn 11 my spearheads are 2-3 hexes from Leningrad and Moscow and 8 or 9 from Rostov. Basically it appears 80-90% of the AI's OOB is ...

<t> I've been using the Sillyflower model (or my poor imitation of it anyway [:)]) against the AI. The poor AI cannot seem to cope. Whilst a human would be leery of placing units in front of a combination of infantry and fuelled up panzers the AI can't seem to help itself [:D]<br/>
<br/>
Anyway ...

Thanks bobo useful to know! I only just found the toggle that switches the reinforcements / withdrawals to view air groups [:)]. Playing as the axis it was a bit of a shock to see how many groups leave! At least if they are going to leave they can take some of the junk with them.

When an air unit withdraws will its planes be added to the pool or are they lost for good?

<t> Your opponent really doesn't believe in flank security does he [:)] Nice moves cutting off those spearheads! At the very least that is going to start getting inside his head and perhaps make him more cautious which would be a minor victory in its own right.<br/>
<br/>
From my (limited ...

Thanks morvael think I understand now [:)]

<t> It was only turn 3 so I'm fairly sure it wasn't fatigue or supply. <br/>
<br/>
Is there an increasing chance of losing morale the higher you are above national morale or is there a set threshold which you pass where there is a chance that your morale decreases eg does the check only occur if ...

<t> I'm playing the AI as the axis under version 1.08.07. On turn 3 I noticed for some reason that all my starting infantry divisions with a morale of 90 had been reduced to 89. None of them had any defeats against their name or were out of supply. <br/>
<br/>
Is this just a case where high morale ...

Woops sorry wrong forum [&:]

Thanks for the responses to my probably inane questions [:D] I'm sure I'll come up with some more this game is a monster!

I noticed reading Sillyflowers AAR that he reduced the TOE % of various units heavy art, inf with morale of 70. Is this normal practice for the axis player and if so what groups of units are normally modified and by how much?

Thanks Mehring. Your luck with computer crashes sounds like mine [:)]

Does anybody have a list or a link to a list of Soviet industry so that I can be lazy and not have to check out every Soviet city?

As the axis player is there a way to see in the interface how many Soviet HI, Armaments, Factories etc you have destroyed or is it a matter of recording it manually turn by turn?

Great AAR Sillyflower! As well as being a great read I have learnt so much. Appreciate the effort you've made to explain the "why" of what you do.

One request if I may would it be possible to show a screenshot(s) of your various fronts with the rail map displayed?