3rd party scenarios
Moderator: Arjuna
3rd party scenarios
Speaking on my experience with HttR and looking ahead to CotA, the AA map and scenario editor tools are top notch. It seems that with a little experience and a bit of trial & error a clever designer can make some great scenarios, especially VS the AI using the "scripting" (i hate that word but it's all I can come up with) methods provided by the engine.
My question is why is there so limited an amount of 3rd party scenarios available? I've seen (and downloaded/played) the normandy/st lo/epsom/bastogne/ scenarios. But is that all there is/was[&:]
Even with the limited Allied estabs I would think there would be more stuff out there - like Gold/Juno/Sword beachheads, Caen, Operation Goodwood, even the Sicily-Italian campaigns could be done.
El savior showed with his bastogne scenario that even representing the American GI's with the british estabs is not all that painfull of a gaming experience. (hmm, GI's with lee enfields, carriers, and vickers IS Kinda painfull, but not TOO painfull[;)]) ...especially if you play the german side and can't always view the GI-Tommy equipment.
So hopefully with CotA the closet designers will come out in force to develop some good 3rd party stuff with the early war estabs.
I heard someone may be working on the Arras counterattack. Any more ideas?
Africa comes to mind of course. Norway. Dieppe. Sealion...
My question is why is there so limited an amount of 3rd party scenarios available? I've seen (and downloaded/played) the normandy/st lo/epsom/bastogne/ scenarios. But is that all there is/was[&:]
Even with the limited Allied estabs I would think there would be more stuff out there - like Gold/Juno/Sword beachheads, Caen, Operation Goodwood, even the Sicily-Italian campaigns could be done.
El savior showed with his bastogne scenario that even representing the American GI's with the british estabs is not all that painfull of a gaming experience. (hmm, GI's with lee enfields, carriers, and vickers IS Kinda painfull, but not TOO painfull[;)]) ...especially if you play the german side and can't always view the GI-Tommy equipment.
So hopefully with CotA the closet designers will come out in force to develop some good 3rd party stuff with the early war estabs.
I heard someone may be working on the Arras counterattack. Any more ideas?
Africa comes to mind of course. Norway. Dieppe. Sealion...
simovitch
RE: 3rd party scenarios
ORIGINAL: simovitch
I heard someone may be working on the Arras counterattack. Any more ideas?
Leros 1943 - I've got practically all the oob data and maps for it - ready to be digitized, but I'm a little occupied right now
Greetz,
Eddy Sterckx
RE: 3rd party scenarios
Hooo ha! Leros will be sweet! [8D]
Simovitch - I was working on a Arras scenario for when cota comes out, but I'll be missing some vital estabs so maybe not. Plus I'm working on the west front data design team and will be quite busy upon the release of cota.
As for current mods, you have many good choices:
El Savior's Seven Roads scenario based on the bulge - which you know about
Tukker's got 2 very good Caen scenarios.
I did St. Lo and a quick one on Utah Beach
Plus there are some other good ones - Crossing the Mosel River - Hohenstauffen Holiday - Guns of Navarone.
Simovitch - I was working on a Arras scenario for when cota comes out, but I'll be missing some vital estabs so maybe not. Plus I'm working on the west front data design team and will be quite busy upon the release of cota.
As for current mods, you have many good choices:
El Savior's Seven Roads scenario based on the bulge - which you know about
Tukker's got 2 very good Caen scenarios.
I did St. Lo and a quick one on Utah Beach
Plus there are some other good ones - Crossing the Mosel River - Hohenstauffen Holiday - Guns of Navarone.
RE: 3rd party scenarios
Compared to other games (CM for instance), the number of 3rd party scenarios is limited. I think there are two reasons for this:
-The first reason: making a scenario takes a lot of time, especially if you want to make it historically accurate. The MapMaker and ScenMaker are great tools, and not difficult to use, but researching the battle, making the OOB and the map, it all takes many hours if you want to do it properly. A lot of players are probably put off by this, which is a shame because it is a lot of fun!
-The second reason: after doing a couple of scenarios, Dave recruits you for one of his Data Design Teams, so you're no longer a 3rd party[:)]
-The first reason: making a scenario takes a lot of time, especially if you want to make it historically accurate. The MapMaker and ScenMaker are great tools, and not difficult to use, but researching the battle, making the OOB and the map, it all takes many hours if you want to do it properly. A lot of players are probably put off by this, which is a shame because it is a lot of fun!
-The second reason: after doing a couple of scenarios, Dave recruits you for one of his Data Design Teams, so you're no longer a 3rd party[:)]
RE: 3rd party scenarios
ORIGINAL: tukker
Compared to other games (CM for instance), the number of 3rd party scenarios is limited. I think there are two reasons for this:
-The first reason: making a scenario takes a lot of time, especially if you want to make it historically accurate. The MapMaker and ScenMaker are great tools, and not difficult to use, but researching the battle, making the OOB and the map, it all takes many hours if you want to do it properly. A lot of players are probably put off by this, which is a shame because it is a lot of fun!
I would encourage everyone to just have a go. Do something completely hypothetical. Forget doing something historical. Just experiment with designing a playable scenario using the forces and maps already provided. Just having the sides enter from a different map edge and with different objectives and reinforcement schedules can make for a completely new experience. It's heaps of fun. I wish I had more time for it myself, instead of bug hunting.[:)] So have a go.
-The second reason: after doing a couple of scenarios, Dave recruits you for one of his Data Design Teams, so you're no longer a 3rd party[:)]
True there is that![;)]
RE: 3rd party scenarios
Yes it is labor intensive - the map I am doing right now has taken on a life of it's own. to get it historically accurate to grog standards you are basically re-drawing almost every detail of the topo entirely. But it is fun!
But making a truly accurate map in CM was a similar, time consuming ordeal, and it was extremely rare. Especially compared to the number of scenarios produced. The scale of CM lends itself to taking more liberties with map accuracy, and the designer can cut some corners. And most CM'ers didn't care if the map was topographically accurate, which is strange to me based on the level of minutia taken on at the BFC forums.
Like CM another obstacle with HttR may be the availabilty of accurate topo to the average Joe. But like Arjuna says there is alot you can do without historical maps. I was very suprised to see that only a handful had been done, because the game is rather popular (for good reason.)
But making a truly accurate map in CM was a similar, time consuming ordeal, and it was extremely rare. Especially compared to the number of scenarios produced. The scale of CM lends itself to taking more liberties with map accuracy, and the designer can cut some corners. And most CM'ers didn't care if the map was topographically accurate, which is strange to me based on the level of minutia taken on at the BFC forums.
Like CM another obstacle with HttR may be the availabilty of accurate topo to the average Joe. But like Arjuna says there is alot you can do without historical maps. I was very suprised to see that only a handful had been done, because the game is rather popular (for good reason.)
simovitch
-
Real and Simulated Wars
- Posts: 453
- Joined: Tue Aug 05, 2003 9:11 pm
- Contact:
RE: 3rd party scenarios
This is a great topic.
Personally, I think that the biggest irony is that the venue by which I would share non-historical scenarios (forums and wargaming sites) is the very thing that stops me from making and publishing them. I just can't avoid the spine chills at the thought of some history-savy fellow pointing out that this or that forest is too wide and 100 meters off center or that the amount of tanks that company has is incorrect. Yikes! If you think about it, even if you explicitly anounce that the scenario is entirely hypothetical, somebody would come after you with "there is no chance on earth that these two divisions would collide".
I miss the times when I was 9 years old and arranged my army men for a quick battle in the playroom table. Scenario description: Germans vs British. That's it! I have better toys now, but in comparison far less enjoyment. Those dammned books!
Cheers,
EDITED: It's called growing up, I guess. [;)]
Personally, I think that the biggest irony is that the venue by which I would share non-historical scenarios (forums and wargaming sites) is the very thing that stops me from making and publishing them. I just can't avoid the spine chills at the thought of some history-savy fellow pointing out that this or that forest is too wide and 100 meters off center or that the amount of tanks that company has is incorrect. Yikes! If you think about it, even if you explicitly anounce that the scenario is entirely hypothetical, somebody would come after you with "there is no chance on earth that these two divisions would collide".
I miss the times when I was 9 years old and arranged my army men for a quick battle in the playroom table. Scenario description: Germans vs British. That's it! I have better toys now, but in comparison far less enjoyment. Those dammned books!
Cheers,
EDITED: It's called growing up, I guess. [;)]
RE: 3rd party scenarios
chelco,
You bring up some valid points. But if some grog-nut (and you know who you are) wants to dispute the historical accuracy of a hypothetical scenario IMHO he is setting himself up for a whole new level of ridicule and [8|] from the greater majority of gamers.
There have been more than a few discussions on the CM boards (for instance) about what qualifies as a historical scenario. The jury is still out as I recall, but the common consensus focused on stating your assumptions and liberties in the briefing. i.e. "the map is from mapquest", or, "Im assuming the recon battalion was at full strength" etc. I have seen the term "based on a historical situation" used for scenarios designated as "Historical" and that caveat was sufficient (for me.)
I agree though if there is some joe-gamer-guy who spends more time verifying the accuracy of a scenario than actually playing it (excepting of course the staff, and the ddt's who should darn well get it right) then let them wallow in their own brew of self-induced hate - I should know because I did just that for some of the ardennes scenarios that came with CMBO. But hey, that's exactly what got me going to produce and post my own historically accurate (IMHO) scenarios for CM! (I kept the criticism to my self though)
I didn't think I would enjoy the hypothetical scenarios in HttR, but I just finished playing "battle for the bridges" last night and it was a hoot!
cheers
You bring up some valid points. But if some grog-nut (and you know who you are) wants to dispute the historical accuracy of a hypothetical scenario IMHO he is setting himself up for a whole new level of ridicule and [8|] from the greater majority of gamers.
There have been more than a few discussions on the CM boards (for instance) about what qualifies as a historical scenario. The jury is still out as I recall, but the common consensus focused on stating your assumptions and liberties in the briefing. i.e. "the map is from mapquest", or, "Im assuming the recon battalion was at full strength" etc. I have seen the term "based on a historical situation" used for scenarios designated as "Historical" and that caveat was sufficient (for me.)
I agree though if there is some joe-gamer-guy who spends more time verifying the accuracy of a scenario than actually playing it (excepting of course the staff, and the ddt's who should darn well get it right) then let them wallow in their own brew of self-induced hate - I should know because I did just that for some of the ardennes scenarios that came with CMBO. But hey, that's exactly what got me going to produce and post my own historically accurate (IMHO) scenarios for CM! (I kept the criticism to my self though)
I didn't think I would enjoy the hypothetical scenarios in HttR, but I just finished playing "battle for the bridges" last night and it was a hoot!
cheers
simovitch
RE: 3rd party scenarios
Well in fact my favorites from HTTR are the hypothetical ones - Mook Right Hook, Teror of the Tyne Tees, Deelen Option. The best scenarios are those where both sides get to club and preferably where there is an element of surprise. There are few historical cases where the forces are so balanaced that both sides get the opportunity to attack and hindsight ruins the element of surprise. However, in a hypothetical scenario the designer can achieve both.
What really matters in the end is whether you enjoyed the creative process of making the scenario and the fun of playing it both for yourself and for others. As with life the secret of success is 100% commitment ( to the process ), 0% attachment ( to the outcome ). Have fun.[:)]
What really matters in the end is whether you enjoyed the creative process of making the scenario and the fun of playing it both for yourself and for others. As with life the secret of success is 100% commitment ( to the process ), 0% attachment ( to the outcome ). Have fun.[:)]
-
Real and Simulated Wars
- Posts: 453
- Joined: Tue Aug 05, 2003 9:11 pm
- Contact:
RE: 3rd party scenarios
Soooo, Dave: how much time do we have available to create these hypothetical HttR scenarios before our interest suddenly shifts to some other upcoming similar game?
Just teasing. Take your time folks. [:)]
Just teasing. Take your time folks. [:)]
RE: 3rd party scenarios
ORIGINAL: Chelco
Soooo, Dave: how much time do we have available to create these hypothetical HttR scenarios before our interest suddenly shifts to some other upcoming similar game?
Gads... that's been in the back of my mind as well. Hopefully the Ardennes/HttR scenario I'm doing will transcend the impending shift. It's based on the LVIII PZ Korps drive from Samree to Hotton, Dec. 20-23. I will try to post some screenies of the map soon.[8D]
Need some playtesters as well in a few weeks.
simovitch
RE: 3rd party scenarios
There might just be something similar coming up in BFTB[:D]
Pieter
Pieter
RE: 3rd party scenarios
ORIGINAL: tukker
There might just be something similar coming up in BFTB[:D]
Yeah, but BFTB is not a few weeks away.
Simovitch, keep it up. I'm ready to playtest. It's not that I know anything about the game or the Ardennes Offensive though. But new and original scenarios are always fun. [;)]
Cheers,
JeF.
Rendez-vous at Loenen before 18:00.
Don't loose your wallet !
Conquest Of The Aegean Web Development Team
The Drop Zone
Don't loose your wallet !
Conquest Of The Aegean Web Development Team
The Drop Zone
- Error in 0
- Posts: 247
- Joined: Sun Jul 18, 2004 9:54 pm
RE: 3rd party scenarios
I considered doing a for Norway, but gave it up, First all, it was a humiliating moment in Norways history, and not interesting in any particular military sense! Narvik may be the exception. Second, no naval units in HTTR... Pretty vital in this scenario. Thirdly, not possible to define new units(?) and finally the height model was too limited (?).ORIGINAL: simovitch
Africa comes to mind of course. Norway. Dieppe. Sealion...
Well, it was a long time ago, and I reasoned it like that. Might as well be laziness
JT
RE: 3rd party scenarios
ORIGINAL: tukker
There might just be something similar coming up in BFTB[:D]
Yes, I know. Im practicing my skills on HttR for when that one comes out.


JeF, Thanks for the offer to playtest. I'll email you the beta version when It's ready.
cheers
- Attachments
-
- hottoncapture.jpg (198.99 KiB) Viewed 559 times
simovitch
-
Real and Simulated Wars
- Posts: 453
- Joined: Tue Aug 05, 2003 9:11 pm
- Contact:
RE: 3rd party scenarios
That's a hell of a good looking map. Congrats. Looking forward for the release.
RE: 3rd party scenarios
ORIGINAL: Chelco
That's a hell of a good looking map. Congrats. Looking forward for the release.
Looking at the map one wonders what idiot thought you could drive a panzer division through it
Greetz,
Eddy Sterckx
-
Real and Simulated Wars
- Posts: 453
- Joined: Tue Aug 05, 2003 9:11 pm
- Contact:
RE: 3rd party scenarios
I'm totally ignorant on the Ardennes Campaign. But I know that a panzer drive through the Ardennes back in 1940 was very successfull. Conditions changed for later Ardennes Campaign, though.
RE: 3rd party scenarios
I know BFTB isn't a few weeks away, and I'm all for 3rd party scenarios. I just thought it was funny that Simovitch was working on exactly the same battle that I've been doing for BFTB. Simovitch, keep up the good work, and when you get to the playtesting stage: don't hesitate to mail me the files, I'll be more than happy to have a look at them.
Pieter
Pieter
RE: 3rd party scenarios
ORIGINAL: tukker
I know BFTB isn't a few weeks away, and I'm all for 3rd party scenarios. I just thought it was funny that Simovitch was working on exactly the same battle that I've been doing for BFTB. Simovitch, keep up the good work, and when you get to the playtesting stage: don't hesitate to mail me the files, I'll be more than happy to have a look at them.
Pieter
Tukker, I will be glad to send it off when It's ready. Same battle huh! Theoretically speaking, Im on the WF DDT as well, although Bil has not given me any duties as of yet - So I used my spare time on this HttR scenario. I know the Maps are done for BftB, and there is probably not much for me to do at this point for the team[:(]
It would be interesting to know how my map compares with yours[:D]
simovitch




