ORIGINAL: Alby
Damn Hoosiers!
[:D][:D][:D]
[;)]
FFFFRRRRAAAAANNNNKKKKLLLLIIIIINNNN Indiana.........[:D]
Moderator: MOD_SPWaW
ORIGINAL: Alby
Damn Hoosiers!
[:D][:D][:D]
[;)]

ORIGINAL: junk2drive
I'll take French Lick and y'all can have the rest.
arizona west coast

Personal messages clog the forum with irrelevant informations. This particular discussion has sparked a large number of responses, of course, but these things could be done in a proper public thread.HUH?
whats so sensitive in the topic that cant be seen in public?
Ya lost me
Hey Bill thought I should ask you...sent you an email but thought i would post here too since my email is acting up as of late.
.....This is a public forum after all.
ORIGINAL: Svennemir
Goblin, you're missing my point. Public forums are for things of public interest. Sure anyone can post anything, but if everyone does so it will degrade the quality of the forums. Please be responsible.

ORIGINAL: Svennemir
Goblin, you're missing my point. Public forums are for things of public interest. Sure anyone can post anything, but if everyone does so it will degrade the quality of the forums. Please be responsible.
the redoing of some SPWAW Campaigns would not be of public interest in the SPWAW Forum?
once again...ya lost me
Why not use an instant messaging service if time is such an important factor?One - getting hold of WB via PM is next to impossible. Alby knew this. Same with email, although Alby also has a problem with his email on top of that. Since WB somewhat regularly checks the forums, his reason to post was sound. Remember, he is also on a time sensitive project.
I'm not saying that ONE PARTICULAR post is degrading the forum. I'm saying that the concept of people using the forum for all their Private Messaging needs will degrade the forum, and therefore such activity should be avoided.Two - Within forum rule limits, he can post what he likes, can he not? He did not break a rule, and got some valuable input, plus got to enjoy a thread with his friends. How is that degrading this forum? Any forum should be fun, and no poster should have to worry about getting jumped when he posts something he thinks should be posted.
Then the thread could have a proper topic, such as 'An open letter to Wild Bill concerning ....', thus inviting to review and discussion. Anyway I don't mean to officially complain that this one particular thread should conform to so-and-so. My initial post was not an attack, it was a suggestion. Once again, why is my suggestion that PMs be used for their logical (and only) application such a taboo? Do I have to wrap it in excuses before it is not considered offensive?Three - What constitutes public interest? Would, say, people posting to a thread constitute interest in a topic? If so, his qualifies...
ORIGINAL: FlashfyreSP
Why not use PM? Because that message system only applies to the two individuals, the sender and receiver. No option for others to "join in" with suggestions or comments. As this discussion involves reworking existing scenarios, the community at large may in fact be interested in the subject, and may indeed have suggestions for which ones to rework. Private Messaging is just that...PRIVATE. Since this is not a "super-secret cabal" of people trying to mess things up for everyone, why should Alby's message be considered "private" or "secret"?
Besides, why are you so "uptight" over the way this forum is used? It is, and has always been, a public forum for the discussion and enjoyment of all things SPWAW. This isn't some professional website or rigidly-controlled and moderated political discussion board, it's the equivalent of the local bar for us SPWAW'ers. Chill out and just ignore any of these threads that you don't approve of.



ORIGINAL: Wild Bill
Well, nice to be the center of controversy! I've missed that a lot [:D]
I can understand concern about the forums becoming a spot for some private chit-chat that might be of little interest to others. In truth, however, I think most folks enjoy "listening in" on a private conversation. C'mon, now, admit it!
Then there is an air of "family" here, so that we tend to deal with one another on a more personal level.
There was, I think, enough public announcement in this post to warrant a public hearing. Alby is revamping some of my campaigns for the latest version of SPWAW which is admirable and deserves my and perhaps our thanks.
It is a time consuming job. I haven't had the time to do it. I appreciate Alby's efforts and have total confidence in his abilities.
So I have to defend this particular post, not because it is related to me, but because it deals with the game that brought us all here.
I think if he had asked about my health, my love life, or my financial well being, it might be interpreted as personal. I am in relatively good health, my love life is great and I'm as poor as ever.
Oops, got personal [;)].
One more thing... there have been times when I have used the forum for a personal note requesting someone's response, whom I could not reach any other way. I do that rarely but it is nice to have this avenue to do such things.
And if we prefaced the title with "Personal-" it would probably be read more than most of the others.
Wild Bill
=========================

