Cherish/value your opponent!

Gary Grigsby's strategic level wargame covering the entire War in the Pacific from 1941 to 1945 or beyond.

Moderators: Joel Billings, wdolson, Don Bowen, mogami

User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: viberpol
ORIGINAL: castor troy

hmm, how do you think Noumea OR Canton would be properly defended two or three weeks after the war started? From Noumea to Johnston Island there are perhaps 250 av all together!

While it wasn´t really smart to attack KB I can also understand your opponent when finding it strange also. [8|] In the game you can bypass thousands of miles to invade some places deep in the southern Pacific. Take every island there and after two months you begin to attack the SRA. That´s not possible in real life but it´s the best way in the game... [8|]

Castor, the funny thing is I did not conquer Noumea.
I don't think I would, eventually.

I had 4 JAP Divisions engaged at Manila, rest of my assault was on Malaya -- heading Singapore... as "proper" as it should be ;)
All INF reinforcements I got landed at Mersing to cut out the withdrawing Allies.
How on earth could I get AND HOLD Noumea attacked with a single (52nd.. I think.. with changed HQ from HIsland HQ) division and several Japanese marine NLFs?
AND this was mod! My opponent had several French units and IND divisions trasfered to Malaya, Lightnings adn Davointine D520 from the early game.. etc.
ORIGINAL: herwin

Definitely ahistorical and not logistically supportable. The closest fleet base was Truk, and that was 2000 miles away. No land-based air cover. The invasion fleet would have taken several weeks to load and get there. Exactly zero chance of surprise. It wasn't until Rabaul was taken and some airbases established in the Solomons that Suva and Noumea were vulnerable to anything more than a random raid.
Of course, I'm speaking as a naval analyst, not a gamer.


And herwin, I invaded Luganville and Etafe the week before -- having even the air CAP over my transports.
And it was a surprise -- how can I explain Lightnigs strafing my CV's?
He didn' expect KB to be there? Underestimate the power of my surface TFs and morale of my night trained crew? [:D] And last, but not least, gave the wrong orders.. [;)]

Ok, but this thread is not on assesing the strategy, but to point out how important is a solid opponent :)

okay, you didn´t take Noumea. You took Luganville and Efate... [8|] Completely different... [8|] As said before, if he goes toe by toe with his three carriers against KB then that isn´t surprising that all what he brought is sunk. If he quits because of this then it´s a shame. If he quits because he loses bases in the south Pacific within a month after PH then it´s different. As Herwin pointed out it´s just not possible in real life to bypass thousands of miles of enemy territory. In the game you can because you know that those dozens of enemy bases you bypassed aren´t doing you any harm.

That´s something you should discuss earlier. Even if you might lose the surprise factor, he can´t do anything about it anyway... even if he knows you would go after New Caledonia within the first couple of weeks.

I´m experiencing the same at the moment against John 3rd as he took New Caledonia without trouble (only one BF present) but he got a bloody nose further east when I sunk 2CVs and one CVL against no damage on my side. You can´t be everywhere at once as IJN but you can bring the complete KB to rule the place where it is present. For me it isn´t a problem if my opponent goes to India, the South Pacific, Austrailia,.... but there are many people who consider that "a problem".

Just explain me how on earth New Caledonia, Fiji, Canton,.... would have been conquered in real life two or three weeks after PH...
User avatar
viberpol
Posts: 858
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2005 3:16 pm
Location: Global village, Poland, EU

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by viberpol »

ORIGINAL: castor troy

(...) but he got a bloody nose further east when I sunk 2CVs and one CVL against no damage on my side. You can´t be everywhere at once as IJN but you can bring the complete KB to rule the place where it is present. For me it isn´t a problem if my opponent goes to India, the South Pacific, Austrailia,....

Just explain me how on earth New Caledonia, Fiji, Canton,.... would have been conquered in real life two or three weeks after PH...

It couldn't IRL. But this is what I am saying. This is a GAME.
I am not ready to ask my opponent, 'come on, I am going to land in LA next turn. Can I?? [:D]
Stating house rules like
"December -- you can only land in DEI"
"January -- you can only land in New Guinea nad Rabaul"

THIS makes no sense!
It's booooring. [>:] It's like reading the same book thousand times..
Where is the place for innovation? New strategy? Changing the fate of world? [;)]

And it is like you said -- "he got a bloody nose further east".
I expect my Allied opponent does the same, understands the history, "OK, my main target during first 2-3 months is to avoid confrontation and bleeeeeeeed the Japanese opponent."
Everywhere!. No matter this is Suva or Canton.


Bite, hit and run, get the usage of my mistakes, strenghtening the defences.. and bleeed me to death... till mid '43 when the wheels of history change..
or
surrender,
acknowledging that he has been defeated [&o]
Przy lackim orle, przy koniu Kiejstuta Archanioł Rusi na proporcach błysł
Sonny II
Posts: 443
Joined: Fri Jan 12, 2007 2:05 pm

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Sonny II »

Take it as a victory and look for your next opponent.


Giving up when you consider the game lost is smarter than the Japanese were IRL after '44. Who needs the misery of a hopeless game? Use the time you would have "wasted" on a game where you are not having fun and get into a game more to your liking.

Mike Scholl
Posts: 6187
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 1:17 am
Location: Kansas City, MO

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Mike Scholl »

It's a game..., but it's supposed to be a game of the Second World War in the Pacific Theatre. For it to be that, you need to accept a few limitations. As a player, you know a LOT more about your opponant's deployment and situation than the Japanese ever did. And you know a lot more about how the "combat system" works than the Japanese planners did---their loss estimates were much higher than actually occurred.

While it's true that both sides have 20-20 hindsight, only the Japanese are really able to take advantage of it as they have the initiative when the game begins. So including some "historical limitations" on just how far they can "push the envelope" based on the player's superior knowledge of the situation is hardly asking for your hands to be tied. If you want to go all out, just post an ad for a player who wants to play the game "wild and wooly" with "no holds barred"---there are a number out there. But just be sure that you make it plain up front that that's what you are looking for.....
User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: viberpol
ORIGINAL: castor troy

(...) but he got a bloody nose further east when I sunk 2CVs and one CVL against no damage on my side. You can´t be everywhere at once as IJN but you can bring the complete KB to rule the place where it is present. For me it isn´t a problem if my opponent goes to India, the South Pacific, Austrailia,....

Just explain me how on earth New Caledonia, Fiji, Canton,.... would have been conquered in real life two or three weeks after PH...

It couldn't IRL. But this is what I am saying. This is a GAME.
I am not ready to ask my opponent, 'come on, I am going to land in LA next turn. Can I?? [:D]
Stating house rules like
"December -- you can only land in DEI"
"January -- you can only land in New Guinea nad Rabaul"

THIS makes no sense!
It's booooring. [>:] It's like reading the same book thousand times..
Where is the place for innovation? New strategy? Changing the fate of world? [;)]

And it is like you said -- "he got a bloody nose further east".
I expect my Allied opponent understands the history, "OK, my main target during first 2-3 months is to avoid confrontation and bleeeeeeeed the Japanese opponent."
Everywhere!. No matter this is Suva or Canton.


Bite, hit and run, get the usage of my mistakes, strenghtening the defences.. and bleeed me to death... till mid '43 when the wheels of history change..
or
surrender acknowledging that he has been defeated [&o]


You are correct, it´s game... But the reason you started the thread is to blame your opponent. And all I´m saying is if he´s quitting because he made a bad move with his carriers then shame on him. If he´s quitting because of landings at places that it was impossible to land in real life then don´t blame him...

And it has nothing to do with a new strategy... Taking empty places isn´t a "good strategy" it´s just something that´s easily possible in THE GAME. [;)]

For me it´s okay if my opponent goes for those places. If he wants to land everywhere on the map, IN THE GAME, then be it. If you play an opponent who considers this gamey then you should accept that. Perhaps you should have achieved first what the Japanese conquered first (THEY HAD REASONS WHY THEY CONQUERED THE SRA) and THEN think about going further....

In real life you have most likely to take all those "historical" objectives first. In the game you can take ALL places 10000 miles "behind the front" and then kill of everything that´s now cut off from the rest of the world -> everything would then be all south east asia... [8|]

In the game this is like playing Nazi Germany invading Russia and taking first Moscow then Stalingrad, Kiev,.... something Hitler would have surely liked. A exaggeratedly example but that´s what you do in the Pacific.

Again, not everything the game makes possible must a player like. Like others and me said, that´s something you should discuss earlier. And that doesn´t mean attack LA in December, Canton island in Jannuary.... [8|]
Mike Scholl
Posts: 6187
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 1:17 am
Location: Kansas City, MO

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Mike Scholl »

ORIGINAL: Sonny II

Take it as a victory and look for your next opponent.


Giving up when you consider the game lost is smarter than the Japanese were IRL after '44. Who needs the misery of a hopeless game? Use the time you would have "wasted" on a game where you are not having fun and get into a game more to your liking.


So as soon as you've had all your "fun" as the Japanese, you should just quit? Sounds a lot like the reverse of the coin that viberpol is complaining about.
User avatar
DuckofTindalos
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by DuckofTindalos »

Yeah... That only works when you're playing the AI.
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
User avatar
viberpol
Posts: 858
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2005 3:16 pm
Location: Global village, Poland, EU

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by viberpol »

Again, not everything the game makes possible must a player like. Like others and me said, that´s something you should discuss earlier. And that doesn´t mean attack LA in December, Canton island in Jannuary....

Castor, as I said we set the rules, we played 3 months in previous PBEM, all landings were according to the rules.
Let's cut this story here because it ceased to make sense.

ORIGINAL: castor troy
In the game this is like playing Nazi Germany invading Russia and taking first Moscow then Stalingrad, Kiev,.... something Hitler would have surely liked. A exaggeratedly example but that´s what you do in the Pacific.

Here, you are wrong. Hitler DID NOT WANT to get Moscow first!
He was convinced by his generals to do that. He agreed on their "dreams" Moscow should be the first priority target and Russia would surely surrender. But Siemion Timoshenko writes "If Nazis would get Moscow, that would be a great disaster, but this could not destroy our [Russian] general strategic plan (...) there is only oil that matters".
After the first winter, Hitler understood his mistake. Walter von Brauchitsch -- the general in command of all land forces in Russia -- was forced to resign, Hitler decided he would himself take control of the army.
And in Spring '42 he set the new target -- Caucascus oil -- South of Russia.

Can you see? The flexibility.
Clever biting, but not with "hands off" in frenzy shock -- the more islands, the better, faster, farrer... it's not fair. I agree with you.
JapaneseFanboys speak up.
If you started the invasion in Noumea. When did it happen?
Przy lackim orle, przy koniu Kiejstuta Archanioł Rusi na proporcach błysł
User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: viberpol



Here, you are wrong. Hitler DID NOT WANT to get Moscow first!
He was convinced by his generals to do that. He agreed that Moscow should be the first priority target.
After the first winter, he understood his mistake, Walter von Brauchitsch -- the general in command of all land forces in Russia -- was forced to resign, Hitler decided he would tak control over army.
And in Spring '42 he set the new target -- oil -- South of Russia


My example wasn´t what Hitler wanted, or what should be invaded.... It was a comparison what you do in your GAME and what´s the same in a GAME about WWII in Eastern Europe. You CAN´T take Moscow before you have taken POLAND..... Do I make myself clear? Now think about your game...

If everything met your rules then I don´t understand why your opponent complains about it then... [8|]
User avatar
viberpol
Posts: 858
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2005 3:16 pm
Location: Global village, Poland, EU

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by viberpol »

ORIGINAL: castor troy

You CAN´T take Moscow before you have taken POLAND..... Do I make myself clear?

BTW: It could have been possible.[:D]

Germany tried (and Stalin feared it a lot!) to make the alliance with Poland and invade Russia.
Only because of our [Polish] deeply rooted hatred towards Germans based on sad history it didn't happen. (There was also another stratedy by Rydz Smigly and General Command of the Polish Army: they planned a "preventive" war in 30's, but quickly, in late 30's it appeared to be impossible as Nazis got stronger)[:(]
Przy lackim orle, przy koniu Kiejstuta Archanioł Rusi na proporcach błysł
User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: viberpol
ORIGINAL: castor troy

You CAN´T take Moscow before you have taken POLAND..... Do I make myself clear?

BTW: It could have been possible.[:D]

Germany tried (and Stalin feared it a lot!) to make the alliance with Poland and invade Russia.
Only because of our [Polish] deeply rooted hatred towards Germans based on sad history it didn't happen. (There was also another stratedy by Rydz Smigly and General Command of the Polish Army: they planned a "preventive" war in 30's, but quickly, in late 30's it appeared to be impossible as Nazis got stronger)[:(]


Don´t you want me to understand me or can´t you understand me? [8|]
User avatar
viberpol
Posts: 858
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2005 3:16 pm
Location: Global village, Poland, EU

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by viberpol »

ORIGINAL: castor troy

Don´t you want me to understand me or can´t you understand me? [8|]

Oh, chill out, I am just teasing you.
/no hard feelings we're all a happy witp addicted community/[:)]

I understand you but do not agree with you.
For me invading Bombay while not taking Burma is the good example.
Islands. Islands are separated by water. Water is a "no mans land" [:D]
Every isle can be invaded only for a unit to starve there.. [:D]
No problem.
Only taking a leap frog jumps over mass land continents is not, never, ever possible.
Przy lackim orle, przy koniu Kiejstuta Archanioł Rusi na proporcach błysł
User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: viberpol

ORIGINAL: castor troy

Don´t you want me to understand me or can´t you understand me? [8|]

Oh, chill out, I am just teasing you.
/no hard feelings we're all a happy witp addicted community/[:)]

I understand you but do not agree with you.
For me invading Bombay while not taking Burma is the good example.
Islands. Islands are separated by water. Water is a "no mans land" [:D]
Every isle can be invaded only for a unit to starve there.. [:D]
No problem.
Only taking a leap frog jumps over mass land continents is not, never, ever possible.


So you are really serious about taking islands in real life that are tens of thousands of miles deep in the south Pacific when you don´t take the SRA first? Or Rabaul, the Solomons... ? Invasions 5000 miles away from your next major base? [8|]

Then you will have to really wonder why the US did that thing called island hopping in real life and not landed 20 divisions right in the Tokyo area, let´s say on the 7th December 1943. IN REAL LIFE THIS ISN´T POSSIBLE! IN THE GAME I CAN DO THAT TO YOU! And there´s nothing you can do about that. I take my carriers, put my divisions on some ships with 2.000.000 supply and fuel and land them next to Tokyo. The next turn 200 Corsairs that came by CVEs will fly Cap and you can watch me taking one base after another.

Then you will tell me that this is ahistorical? No? What would you think if I told you that it´s a game? [8D]

I DON´T HAVE PROBLEMS WITH THOSE EARLY JAPANESE OVER THE TOP LANDINGS EVERYWHERE ON THE MAP! And I don´t go right on the home islands 1/44 even if I could do it.

But your opponent obviously had problems with those landings. At least this is what he said. I also think he has more problems with losing his carriers.

But for sure - this time is the last time I will say that- those landings are only possible in the GAME. They have nothing to do with a genius strategy. In real life such things are IMPOSSIBLE. The more those things happen in one game the more the game get´s near command & conquer where you don´t go for oil but for TIBERIUM.... [8|]
User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: viberpol




I understand you but do not agree with you.
For me invading Bombay while not taking Burma is the good example.
Islands. Islands are separated by water. Water is a "no mans land" [:D]
Every isle can be invaded only for a unit to starve there.. [:D]
No problem.
Only taking a leap frog jumps over mass land continents is not, never, ever possible.

You can´t be serious... And if you would really be in charge of any nations Army you wouldn´t be anymore after coming up with such thoughts.

How would you pull off that sort of adventure? Take three divisions with 20 ships of supplies and then take Bombay? And further? Take India?

You know what happened to the DAK and all those Italian troops in North Africa? And you are aware what it means to not have a secure line of supply? If Rommel would still be alive and would participate here he would certainly laugh about your comment about "water being no mans land".

User avatar
viberpol
Posts: 858
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2005 3:16 pm
Location: Global village, Poland, EU

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by viberpol »

Castor, I do not understand why did you pick up a role of a devil's advocate? [:)]

Let me rephrase it.
What I am saying is:
THE GOOD EXAMPLE OF STH THAT SHOULDN'T BE DONE IS TAKING BOMBAY WITHOUT TAKING A LAND SUPPLY COMMUNICATION ROUTES.

Invading far SE islands and leaving my forces separated and starving is a suicide.
Again: agreed with you it is not a good strategy to have my army starve.

But I did it like it should be done:
PHI, Malaya, Borneo, (rest/preparations for rest of SRA), Nauru, Tarawa, Shortlands (omitted Rabaul), Tulagi, Luganville, Etafe, invaded Noumea.

Strategy? I'd say "proper"
Possible IRL? hardly, but -- yes, IF someone wants to take the risk
According to the house rules? yes
Fun: no, because someone screwed up his orders and pushes a RESET button...

But, I can live with it. I am not even angry now. Let's make love not war [8D]

Przy lackim orle, przy koniu Kiejstuta Archanioł Rusi na proporcach błysł
User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: viberpol

Castor, I do not understand why did you pick up a role of a devil's advocate? [:)]

Let me rephrase it.
What I am saying is:
THE GOOD EXAMPLE OF STH THAT SHOULDN'T BE DONE IS TAKING BOMBAY WITHOUT TAKING A LAND SUPPLY COMMUNICATION ROUTES.

Invading far SE islands and leaving my forces separated and starving is a suicide.
Again: agreed with you it is not a good strategy to have my army starve.

But I did it like it should be done:
PHI, Malaya, Borneo, (rest/preparations for rest of SRA), Nauru, Tarawa, Shortlands (omitted Rabaul), Tulagi, Luganville, Etafe, invaded Noumea.

Strategy? I'd say "proper"
Possible IRL? hardly, but -- yes, IF someone wants to take the risk
According to the house rules: yes
Fun: no, because someone screwed up his orders and pushes a RESET button...

But, I can live with it. I am not even angry now. Let's make love not war [8D]


I´m not advocating for anyone. All I did is saying that in real life it wouldn´t be possible to take those islands if you don´t take all other ("historical") objectives first. If you done that, hey, everything is fine... How someone can do that in three weeks is another question. Not just if that would be possible in real life but also how this is possible in the game.

Example: Reasonable for me would be: Taking Rabaul, go down the Solomons, take Southern New Guinea. If this is under control then perhaps thinking about going for the New Hybrids then New Caledonia. And of course the key bases (Rabaul, Lunga,...) should have some forces on it. And they shouldn´t be just conquered with a single construction battailon with 5 av - only possible in the game.

If you can take all those places one after another, garrison them and then go on for the next target and this all within 3 or 4 weeks then I don´t have any problem. Though for me there´s still the question how should all of this happen in one month?
User avatar
ctangus
Posts: 2153
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 11:34 pm
Location: Boston, Mass.

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by ctangus »

ORIGINAL: castor troy

I´m not advocating for anyone. All I did is saying that in real life it wouldn´t be possible to take those islands if you don´t take all other ("historical") objectives first. If you done that, hey, everything is fine... How someone can do that in three weeks is another question. Not just if that would be possible in real life but also how this is possible in the game.

Example: Reasonable for me would be: Taking Rabaul, go down the Solomons, take Southern New Guinea. If this is under control then perhaps thinking about going for the New Hybrids then New Caledonia. And of course the key bases (Rabaul, Lunga,...) should have some forces on it. And they shouldn´t be just conquered with a single construction battailon with 5 av - only possible in the game.

If you can take all those places one after another, garrison them and then go on for the next target and this all within 3 or 4 weeks then I don´t have any problem. Though for me there´s still the question how should all of this happen in one month?

I'll throw in my 2 cents again.

BTW, I've been playing Arkadiusz (viberpol) for over a year now & I certainly consider him an honorable opponent. He doesn't try to abuse game mechanics & we've been able to discuss & settle the few differences we've had. My major complaint against him is that he's too skillful, particularly at surface combat. (Either that or I suck at it. [:D]) We're up to August '43 now, I'm a long way from Tokyo, and he's still putting up a good fight. How dare he try to do better than the Japanese did in real life! [:'(] I'm doing ok in CBI but I'm far behind historical in South Pac/SW Pac. [:(]

Is invading Noumea early gamey? I mostly play allies but I'd say no - it's not gamey but risky. Even in early Jan '42 Noumea could be reinforced by an Aussie or Kiwi brigade. That would be enough to hold off a unit or 3 of naval infantry. Sure, the Japanese could bring two divisions there, but then those divisions aren't in the SRA - that would open up a chance to hold Java. The supply lines to Noumea would be long & open to counterattack once KB leaves the area. In one game I lost both Canton Island & Noumea in the first week of the war. I had Canton back by mid-Feb & could have had Noumea back by then if I'd paid more attention to my sigint.

IMO the allied player here simply couldn't stomach the losses.
Cuttlefish
Posts: 2454
Joined: Wed Jan 24, 2007 5:03 am
Location: Oregon, USA

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Cuttlefish »

ORIGINAL: ctangus


IMO the allied player here simply couldn't stomach the losses.

Leaving aside the questions of historical versus game possibilities, I think ctangus may be right. The psychiatric profession doesn't recognize SACLS (Sudden Aircraft Carrier Loss Syndrome) but they probably should. Losing aircraft carriers early in the war can be a real psychological blow. There are players who can shrug as their cruisers and destroyers are sunk. They will laugh as they lose a fully laden troop convoy. They will jest as their infantry divisions are surrounded and destroyed. But if they lose a couple of carriers they are plunged into depression.

Logic doesn't have a lot to do with it. As the Japanese player you know that your carriers are eventually doomed anyway. As the Allied player you know that you will someday have more carriers than you know what to do with. But there is something about a one sided carrier defeat that pushes some buttons.

I agree with the idea of deciding with your opponent ahead of time what kind of game you are looking for. But I also agree with the topic of the thread - an opponent who will continue to give you a good game even when things look bleak is one to be valued.
Image
User avatar
ctangus
Posts: 2153
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 11:34 pm
Location: Boston, Mass.

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by ctangus »

ORIGINAL: Cuttlefish

The psychiatric profession doesn't recognize SACLS (Sudden Aircraft Carrier Loss Syndrome) but they probably should.

LOL - is that in DSM-IV? [:D] If it is, maybe I can apply for some disability payments... Then I might be able to play WITP full-time...
Sonny II
Posts: 443
Joined: Fri Jan 12, 2007 2:05 pm

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Sonny II »

ORIGINAL: Mike Scholl

ORIGINAL: Sonny II

Take it as a victory and look for your next opponent.


Giving up when you consider the game lost is smarter than the Japanese were IRL after '44. Who needs the misery of a hopeless game? Use the time you would have "wasted" on a game where you are not having fun and get into a game more to your liking.


So as soon as you've had all your "fun" as the Japanese, you should just quit? Sounds a lot like the reverse of the coin that viberpol is complaining about.


Its a game. If you don't enjoy playing it then quit.
However, if you continue to quit when you have a disappointing turn you will soon run out of PBEM opponents.
Post Reply

Return to “War In The Pacific - Struggle Against Japan 1941 - 1945”