Cherish/value your opponent!

Gary Grigsby's strategic level wargame covering the entire War in the Pacific from 1941 to 1945 or beyond.

Moderators: Joel Billings, wdolson, Don Bowen, mogami

moses
Posts: 2252
Joined: Sun Jul 07, 2002 3:39 am

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by moses »

ORIGINAL: qgaliana

I still don't see why the japanese can't make an all out drive into the south pacific if they choose to commit resources to it - even in january. Shouldn't the onus be on the allied player to come up with a strategy to take advantage of the long lines of communication?

I would have no problem with an invasion of Numea or any other location given that the game begins with an historical start. On 8 Dec Japan has no carriers in the South Pacific and not a whole lot of naval power. His closest ground forces are in Truk. If he wants to start an unescorted convoy from Truk on Dec 8 and it arrives unmolested at Numea around Christmas then thats my fault for allowing it. But there's a good chance my carriers will sink the whole transport force.

I have issue with the idea of allowing Japan free rein to massivly change their starting deployments using the first turn rules. Usually this is done while insisting, with a straight face, that the allies must stick religiously to their historical deployment.

So yeah now its easy for Japan to do all sorts of ridiculous things
User avatar
Nikademus
Posts: 22517
Joined: Sat May 27, 2000 8:00 am
Location: Alien spacecraft

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Nikademus »

well again, it depends on what Japan does. Me, I simply refine the original Japanese plan to make it more efficient. I may also change a landing site here or there (for example, landing a little farther down the Malaya peninsula.....risking the wrath of the Vildebeast....sometimes it works, sometimes i end up sending valuable BB's back to Japan for repairs)

Given that any decent Allied player is going to be far more efficient (not to mention "active") than any historical ABDA command, I don't have a prob, even if i'm on the receiving end. (My last PBEM GC was as Allies, Japan custom Turn 1 allowed.....I made no move/issued no orders Turn 1....still ended up holding Singers till nearly 5/42 and put my opponent's timetable for SRA occupation hopelessly behind schedule)
qgaliana
Posts: 311
Joined: Wed Apr 27, 2005 7:47 pm

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by qgaliana »

ORIGINAL: moses

ORIGINAL: qgaliana

I still don't see why the japanese can't make an all out drive into the south pacific if they choose to commit resources to it - even in january. Shouldn't the onus be on the allied player to come up with a strategy to take advantage of the long lines of communication?

I would have no problem with an invasion of Numea or any other location given that the game begins with an historical start. On 8 Dec Japan has no carriers in the South Pacific and not a whole lot of naval power. His closest ground forces are in Truk. If he wants to start an unescorted convoy from Truk on Dec 8 and it arrives unmolested at Numea around Christmas then thats my fault for allowing it. But there's a good chance my carriers will sink the whole transport force.

I have issue with the idea of allowing Japan free rein to massivly change their starting deployments using the first turn rules. Usually this is done while insisting, with a straight face, that the allies must stick religiously to their historical deployment.

So yeah now its easy for Japan to do all sorts of ridiculous things

Turn 1 restrictions should be a different issue. But a month or two months, IJN should have plenty of options of where to sail.

Personally I think 4 or 5 preset openings for both sides would make more sense than the huge movement boost on Turn 1. That part I have to agree is easy to abuse.
User avatar
Yava
Posts: 2129
Joined: Fri Jul 21, 2006 10:36 am
Location: Poland/Kolobrzeg

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Yava »

The point is... either you want to enjoy a more or less historical game or you want to play a shooter...
Image
Art by Dixie.
Mike Scholl
Posts: 6187
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 1:17 am
Location: Kansas City, MO

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Mike Scholl »

ORIGINAL: Yava

The point is... either you want to enjoy a more or less historical game or you want to play a shooter...


Actually the real point is that when the Japanese start pushing the "first turn bonus movement" there are no coresponding benifits to the Allies. The Japs went where they went, and didn't go other places, based on what could be done without triggering Allied reaction. A troop convoy sailing to Siam raised tensions, but wasn't a direct threat. Turning it South the last night allowed it to reach the North portion of Malaysia.
But sailing it down the Malasian Coast to land any farther South would have every "alarm bell" going off in Southeast Asia..., and might have triggered an Allied "first strike".

Kido Butai was able to "sneak" undetected across the untravelled waters of the North Pacific..., but it (or any military TF sailing farther South) would have run into civilian traffic and air search, again triggering response. In the game the Japs can make all kinds of moves that would have been detected days before the war begins with NO chance of any Allied counter-action. This is what turns the historical start into a gamey shooter..., the game provides no "consequences" for driving a bulldozer through the loopholes in "1st turn suprise".
herwin
Posts: 6047
Joined: Thu May 27, 2004 9:20 pm
Location: Sunderland, UK
Contact:

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by herwin »

ORIGINAL: Mike Scholl

ORIGINAL: Yava

The point is... either you want to enjoy a more or less historical game or you want to play a shooter...


Actually the real point is that when the Japanese start pushing the "first turn bonus movement" there are no coresponding benifits to the Allies. The Japs went where they went, and didn't go other places, based on what could be done without triggering Allied reaction. A troop convoy sailing to Siam raised tensions, but wasn't a direct threat. Turning it South the last night allowed it to reach the North portion of Malaysia.
But sailing it down the Malasian Coast to land any farther South would have every "alarm bell" going off in Southeast Asia..., and might have triggered an Allied "first strike".
Not 'might have'--would have. The British had already sent troops north across the border before Pearl and were seriously thinking about attacking the convoy.

Kido Butai was able to "sneak" undetected across the untravelled waters of the North Pacific..., but it (or any military TF sailing farther South) would have run into civilian traffic and air search, again triggering response. In the game the Japs can make all kinds of moves that would have been detected days before the war begins with NO chance of any Allied counter-action. This is what turns the historical start into a gamey shooter..., the game provides no "consequences" for driving a bulldozer through the loopholes in "1st turn suprise".

The KB had orders to sink any snoopers, and Halsey had orders to attack the KB if he could find it. Kimmel was surprised because the KB took a really long chance.
Harry Erwin
"For a number to make sense in the game, someone has to calibrate it and program code. There are too many significant numbers that behave non-linearly to expect that. It's just a game. Enjoy it." herwin@btinternet.com
User avatar
Yava
Posts: 2129
Joined: Fri Jul 21, 2006 10:36 am
Location: Poland/Kolobrzeg

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Yava »

ORIGINAL: Mike Scholl

ORIGINAL: Yava

The point is... either you want to enjoy a more or less historical game or you want to play a shooter...


Actually the real point is that when the Japanese start pushing the "first turn bonus movement" there are no coresponding benifits to the Allies. The Japs went where they went, and didn't go other places, based on what could be done without triggering Allied reaction. A troop convoy sailing to Siam raised tensions, but wasn't a direct threat. Turning it South the last night allowed it to reach the North portion of Malaysia.
But sailing it down the Malasian Coast to land any farther South would have every "alarm bell" going off in Southeast Asia..., and might have triggered an Allied "first strike".

Kido Butai was able to "sneak" undetected across the untravelled waters of the North Pacific..., but it (or any military TF sailing farther South) would have run into civilian traffic and air search, again triggering response. In the game the Japs can make all kinds of moves that would have been detected days before the war begins with NO chance of any Allied counter-action. This is what turns the historical start into a gamey shooter..., the game provides no "consequences" for driving a bulldozer through the loopholes in "1st turn suprise".

Why should there be any coresponding benefits to the Allies? The PH attack is as it should be (the results vary on the dice rolls however the bulldozer "sneaked" to PH and started the whole mess) My point is that you can put up some nice fight against the Japs if the JIN player is making some moves that are somehow connected with the history. It's "nice" ,thanks to the game mechanics which allows such behaviour, to land 2000 miles behind enemy lines and grab some free "outposts" and sink the whole US Navy just for the fact that it dared to stand against the KB in January 1942... (The US Navy example is just to show that some Allied players like to lose their ships in funny ways[;)]) I know that the game allows plenty of weird stuff, I'm just trying to imply like some other people here that this game is not just pure mechanics( which allows to do this or that) but a II WW based strategy game... (this single phrase should answer the "coresponding benefits" problem, Mike)[;)]
Image
Art by Dixie.
Sonny II
Posts: 443
Joined: Fri Jan 12, 2007 2:05 pm

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Sonny II »

Play scenario 16 if you don't want hyper moves on the first turn.
Mike Scholl
Posts: 6187
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 1:17 am
Location: Kansas City, MO

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Mike Scholl »

ORIGINAL: herwin
The KB had orders to sink any snoopers, and Halsey had orders to attack the KB if he could find it. Kimmel was surprised because the KB took a really long chance.



I'd call it a calculated risk. The Japs had had one of their civilian ships take KB's route in November..., and it reported no vessels or patrols encountered. Small wonder given the rigors of North Pacific weather in the winter season, but there was always an outside chance. If I remember correctly KB also had orders to turn back if it was sighted before a certain point.
Mike Scholl
Posts: 6187
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 1:17 am
Location: Kansas City, MO

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Mike Scholl »

ORIGINAL: Yava
Why should there be any coresponding benefits to the Allies? Thanks to the game mechanics which allows such behaviour, to land 2000 miles behind enemy lines and grab some free "outposts" and sink the whole US Navy just for the fact that it dared to stand against the KB in January 1942...


For the reasons I mentioned. The "bonus move" does not take into account the need to avoid being spotted or have some plausable "cover story" for the activity. I agree with SONNY that scenario 16 is the best way to get a historical start..., but I agree with you that it's more fun for the Japanese player if he can have some of the flexibility of scenario 15. I just feel that the "flexibility" needs to take into account the real life limitations the Japanese faced. There were a lot of things they couldn't do without "tipping their hand" to all and sundry. They couldn't "read the rules" and KNOW what limitations the "game" was going to put on their opponants. Just look at some of the losses they expected to take in the opening campaigns..., they had no way of knowing just how easy their opening moves were going to prove in reality. We do..., so some rational limitations in exploiting that knowledge are generally a good idea unless you and your opponant have agreed in advance to play it "wild and wooly and no holds barred". It's a matter of just how silly you want to let the play to get.
User avatar
Yava
Posts: 2129
Joined: Fri Jul 21, 2006 10:36 am
Location: Poland/Kolobrzeg

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Yava »

All in all I think we are pointing out the same thing... some rational limitations should be implied if you don't want to end up playing a "silly" game...[:)]
Image
Art by Dixie.
User avatar
TommyG
Posts: 273
Joined: Sat Sep 25, 2004 1:51 am
Location: Irvine Ca
Contact:

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by TommyG »

I think Viperpol is being too hard on his opponent. This is a very long game. It is unreasonable to expect someone to continue playing day after day for more than a year if he is not enjoying what he is doing. You have taken his most enjoyable assets; the CVs and CAs. I have played 18 WitP PBEM games, starting the day it was released. I have asked for do-overs or restarts when I did something stupid and lost my CVs (remember Joe?) and I have given restarts when an opponent lost all his CVs to bad luck/weather/sortie max/ or whatever. The games that are the best are the ones where both sides get in licks. When one side dominates completely, whether me or my opponent, I lose interest. Take the victory and move on. At least he was man enough to quit. Several times I have had a big-mouth forum guru just disappear with out a word when things did not go his way.
Mike Scholl
Posts: 6187
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 1:17 am
Location: Kansas City, MO

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Mike Scholl »

ORIGINAL: TommyG

I think Viperpol is being too hard on his opponent. This is a very long game. It is unreasonable to expect someone to continue playing day after day for more than a year if he is not enjoying what he is doing. You have taken his most enjoyable assets; the CVs and CAs. I have played 18 WitP PBEM games, starting the day it was released. I have asked for do-overs or restarts when I did something stupid and lost my CVs (remember Joe?) and I have given restarts when an opponent lost all his CVs to bad luck/weather/sortie max/ or whatever. The games that are the best are the ones where both sides get in licks. When one side dominates completely, whether me or my opponent, I lose interest. Take the victory and move on. At least he was man enough to quit. Several times I have had a big-mouth forum guru just disappear with out a word when things did not go his way.


You make some good points..., and if both sides are willing then a re-start is a decent option. But being too generous to you Allied opponant is just encouraging him to do stupid things in hopes that one might work. I almost always ask to play the Allied side, but I do so knowing I'm going to get pounded on during the first year of play in all likelyhood..., and that if I take my CV's out to "play" with Kido Butai in the early going I have an excellent chance of losing them. If I do so it's my own silly fault and not my opponants..., so why should I ask him for a "do over"? If he wants to offer one, that's a different story..., but players should be able to live with the consequences of their own foolishness. Those "big-mouth forum guru's" you mention are a perfect example. They play "fast and loose" and if it doesn't go their way they just stop playing.

I tend to see a PBEM game as a "contract" between the parties involved. For one thing. if you approach the game from the view that you are going to have to play it out to conclusion you are less likely to try hair-brained, risky schemes because you know that you will be living with the results for hundreds of turns. Tends to produce a more rational game.
User avatar
jwilkerson
Posts: 8272
Joined: Sun Sep 15, 2002 4:02 am
Location: Kansas
Contact:

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by jwilkerson »

remember Joe?

Yup.

WITP Admiral's Edition - Project Lead
War In Spain - Project Lead
User avatar
denisonh
Posts: 2083
Joined: Fri Dec 21, 2001 10:00 am
Location: Upstate SC

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by denisonh »

Well said
ORIGINAL: Mike Scholl

ORIGINAL: TommyG

I think Viperpol is being too hard on his opponent. This is a very long game. It is unreasonable to expect someone to continue playing day after day for more than a year if he is not enjoying what he is doing. You have taken his most enjoyable assets; the CVs and CAs. I have played 18 WitP PBEM games, starting the day it was released. I have asked for do-overs or restarts when I did something stupid and lost my CVs (remember Joe?) and I have given restarts when an opponent lost all his CVs to bad luck/weather/sortie max/ or whatever. The games that are the best are the ones where both sides get in licks. When one side dominates completely, whether me or my opponent, I lose interest. Take the victory and move on. At least he was man enough to quit. Several times I have had a big-mouth forum guru just disappear with out a word when things did not go his way.


You make some good points..., and if both sides are willing then a re-start is a decent option. But being too generous to you Allied opponant is just encouraging him to do stupid things in hopes that one might work. I almost always ask to play the Allied side, but I do so knowing I'm going to get pounded on during the first year of play in all likelyhood..., and that if I take my CV's out to "play" with Kido Butai in the early going I have an excellent chance of losing them. If I do so it's my own silly fault and not my opponants..., so why should I ask him for a "do over"? If he wants to offer one, that's a different story..., but players should be able to live with the consequences of their own foolishness. Those "big-mouth forum guru's" you mention are a perfect example. They play "fast and loose" and if it doesn't go their way they just stop playing.

I tend to see a PBEM game as a "contract" between the parties involved. For one thing. if you approach the game from the view that you are going to have to play it out to conclusion you are less likely to try hair-brained, risky schemes because you know that you will be living with the results for hundreds of turns. Tends to produce a more rational game.
"Life is tough, it's even tougher when you're stupid" -SGT John M. Stryker, USMC
User avatar
TommyG
Posts: 273
Joined: Sat Sep 25, 2004 1:51 am
Location: Irvine Ca
Contact:

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by TommyG »

The obvious solution is a game registry where players register their game and report the outcome. It would provide accountability for the bozos who disappear without a word and give a player a public victory when an opponent does want to surrender/quit. It would also be a reference source for checking out future opponents. If a guy always tries to invade Alaska in Jan 42 and quits when it doesn't work out, then at least you could know that going in. I'm sure this has been discussed a thousand times, but I don't remember the thread.
User avatar
Feinder
Posts: 7206
Joined: Wed Sep 04, 2002 7:33 pm
Location: Land o' Lakes, FL

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Feinder »

While most would accuse me of being an AFB (*shrug*); I’ll play devil’s advocate for a player that would normally play Japan…
 
If you’re playing for the sheer enjoyment of the game, where vps don’t matter, then probably nobody is going to resign in a huff, and there’s point to tracking the game.
 
But if Japan wants to -win- (magnified by a ladder type scenario that you describe), Japan is encouraged, if not compelled to try strategies that are “dubviously historically possible” to win the game.  Japan cannot play a historically realistic (or time-tabled) game.
 
If Japanese player is conservative or even plays “a historical type game”, given the pace of WitP, Japan -will- eventually lose (I seriously doubt anyone would dispute that, but who knows).
 
So that leaves…
If a Japanese player is aggressive in 1942, this is probably his only real chance to trigger auto-victory in 1943.  Not that he will win in 1943 (all or nothing strategies tend to be exactly that, all or nothing).  But knowing that he can’t -win- by conservative, if he wants to -win-, he’s actually compelled to actually pursue some of the more “dubvoiusly historically possible” strategies that many Allied players loathe so much.

Certainly, Japan can’t be penalized for taking his only real chance at victory.
 
Cause and effect...
 
A Japanese player just doing what any player wants to do (win), opens aggressively.  The Allied player –must- respond to some degree, or he –will- get steam-rolled.  “Sir Robin” only keeps you alive for so long.  An aggressive Japanese player knows you’re pulling back, he needs the vps to win, he will do everything he can push you into that Jutland that is the decisive battle.
 
Pushing for Jutland as Japan, isn’t wrong, it’s what you need to do to win.
Running from Jutland as Allies isn’t wrong, it’s an option to maybe keep you alive (long enough to attrit).
Or even running into Jutland as Allies isn’t wrong, because if it’s 50-50, why –not- take those odds, and win yourself (Japan is pushing for Jutland, why not oblige?).
 
So it’s a situation that feeds itself.
 
With “a friendly game”, folks pay more than lip-service to “who cares about vps”.  The loser can be losing horribly, and not resign, because nobody is playing for vps, and it’s just the pure fun of the game.  If we swallow our piety, -most- of us in PBEM are playing to win.  Vps –are- important.  Auto-victory –is- important.  And that’s what feeds aggressive strategies.
 
-F-
"It is obvious that you have greatly over-estimated my regard for your opinion." - Me

Image
User avatar
TommyG
Posts: 273
Joined: Sat Sep 25, 2004 1:51 am
Location: Irvine Ca
Contact:

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by TommyG »

IMHO nothing could be more historical than for the Japanese player to go for an immediate victory. After all, Japan never planned on invading Iowa, all they wanted was to humiliate a morally inferior culture and dictate the peace terms. So, trying out an innovative new tactic should be encouraged. And, if it succeeds and the Japanese player does capture the entire South Pacific, India, Northern Oz and Alaska, all before June 42; then he should be applauded and his opponent should be allowed to surrender without being ostracized. The tough call is in drawing the line between the opponent who has clearly lost the game and the situation described above where only a battle has been lost. A player who has lost a queen and a rook in the opening should turn over his king. A player who loses a pawn should keep on trucking.
Mike Scholl
Posts: 6187
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 1:17 am
Location: Kansas City, MO

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Mike Scholl »

ORIGINAL: TommyG

IMHO nothing could be more historical than for the Japanese player to go for an immediate victory. After all, Japan never planned on invading Iowa, all they wanted was to humiliate a morally inferior culture and dictate the peace terms. So, trying out an innovative new tactic should be encouraged. And, if it succeeds and the Japanese player does capture the entire South Pacific, India, Northern Oz and Alaska, all before June 42; then he should be applauded and his opponent should be allowed to surrender without being ostracized. The tough call is in drawing the line between the opponent who has clearly lost the game and the situation described above where only a battle has been lost. A player who has lost a queen and a rook in the opening should turn over his king. A player who loses a pawn should keep on trucking.


No problem with the Japanese Player "going for broke" (as long as he doesn't quit if he doesn't make it). But if this is what he's got in mind, he should start with a scenario 16 varient. The possibilities for shoving a mac truck through the loopholes in the "extended movement" section of the scenario 15 start are just too great. And exploiting a design loophole is not the same thing as beating your opponant with aggressive play.
User avatar
Swayin
Posts: 331
Joined: Sat Jan 27, 2007 6:05 pm
Location: Bellingham, WA

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Swayin »

2 or even 3 CVs vs KB = bringing a knife to a gunfight
The Beatings Will Continue Until Morale Improves

Image
Post Reply

Return to “War In The Pacific - Struggle Against Japan 1941 - 1945”