Cherish/value your opponent!

Gary Grigsby's strategic level wargame covering the entire War in the Pacific from 1941 to 1945 or beyond.

Moderators: Joel Billings, wdolson, Don Bowen, mogami

User avatar
DuckofTindalos
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by DuckofTindalos »

Not necessarily... Depends on how you play it...
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
moses
Posts: 2252
Joined: Sun Jul 07, 2002 3:39 am

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by moses »

ORIGINAL: Mike Scholl


No problem with the Japanese Player "going for broke" (as long as he doesn't quit if he doesn't make it). But if this is what he's got in mind, he should start with a scenario 16 varient. The possibilities for shoving a mac truck through the loopholes in the "extended movement" section of the scenario 15 start are just too great. And exploiting a design loophole is not the same thing as beating your opponant with aggressive play.

I agree completely. And why would anyone think differently.

It's like playing a game about the Normandy Invasion and having a German player plant an armored division on each of the invasion beaches. He says "The germans had the divisions in theater, they certainly could have done this had they wanted. There would have been nothing the allies could do about it!!!" Then the same guy would comlain that the game was screwed up because the allies kept getting driven into the sea.

And why only Japan in WITP. The allies certainly had the ability to deploy differently. If Japan can have 5 division en-route to Jahora Bhuru on turn one shouldn't I be able to have my CV's in the PI waiting for his invasion? If Japan can launch 40 simultainious invasions in the first three days shouldn't the allies shouldn't the allies be able to at least shift a few things around?

Again its like a game about Gettysburg with the Union player claiming that he should be able to have his entire army concentrated at Gettysburg at 6AM on day one. Sure they could have gotten there had different decisions been made 5 days earlier. But so what. Its the same thing. Allowing one side to manuver in a vastly different way in the days leading up to the battle but requiring the other side to do the same thing.
User avatar
Sardaukar
Posts: 12869
Joined: Wed Nov 28, 2001 10:00 am
Location: Finland/Israel

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Sardaukar »

Well...I bailed from my first and last PBEM after 40+ days of gameplay. I got utterly and totally frustrated by WitP ZOC/Ground Combat system. Game is supposed to be fun and not a chore...fortunately in my case my opponent understood the issue and we ended the game in good understanding.

I'd get into PBEM again if something would be done with Ground Combat/ZOC/Movement..but not before.
"To meaningless French Idealism, Liberty, Fraternity and Equality...we answer with German Realism, Infantry, Cavalry and Artillery" -Prince von Bülov, 1870-

Image
Mike Scholl
Posts: 6187
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 1:17 am
Location: Kansas City, MO

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Mike Scholl »

ORIGINAL: moses

I agree completely. And why would anyone think differently.

It's like playing a game about the Normandy Invasion and having a German player plant an armored division on each of the invasion beaches. He says "The germans had the divisions in theater, they certainly could have done this had they wanted. There would have been nothing the allies could do about it!!!" Then the same guy would comlain that the game was screwed up because the allies kept getting driven into the sea.



And he'd go through the roof if the Allies splashed ashore at the now undefended Pas de Calais..... What's "good for the goose" also has to be "good for the gander".
User avatar
TommyG
Posts: 273
Joined: Sat Sep 25, 2004 1:51 am
Location: Irvine Ca
Contact:

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by TommyG »

I'm glad to see that it is not just me that complains about scn 15/150 results. Many of my opponents have refused to let me relocate even a single sub on turn 1, while they storm towards Fiji, Nouema, and PM. Add to that the CHS designed invincibility of the A6M and decreased Allied fighter production,and I always lose the entire Soth Pacific above the 18th parallel. If the oponent is good perhaps even India and maybe Northern Oz (well, maybe it is just that I'm not good). Anyway, just once I would like to be able to move my forces to anywhere I want also.
User avatar
ctangus
Posts: 2153
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 11:34 pm
Location: Boston, Mass.

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by ctangus »

ORIGINAL: moses

And why only Japan in WITP. The allies certainly had the ability to deploy differently. If Japan can have 5 division en-route to Jahora Bhuru on turn one shouldn't I be able to have my CV's in the PI waiting for his invasion? If Japan can launch 40 simultainious invasions in the first three days shouldn't the allies shouldn't the allies be able to at least shift a few things around?

I'm mostly an AFB - only recently started playing Japan - but I do think Japan should have more latitude on turn one than the allies. Playing Japan, I'm taking the role of Yamamoto or Nagano and I've been planning my offensive for months - I feel I should be able to re-distribute my forces some. Playing the allies I'm Nimitz taking over from Kimmel - Yikes! Look at what I was just handed! [:)]

That said I think a non-historical turn one by Japan should take into account why Japan didn't invade 30 locations on Dec 7th - namely they didn't want to spoil the surprise of Pearl Harbor. Playing Japan why can't I re-locate my subs? Send the Nagatos instead of the Kongos to cover the Kota Bharu landings in case Force Z shows up? Send a few more troops to Singora & Kota Bharu? Cancel the Legaspi invasion if I don't think it's smart? Send the Combined Fleet, while under radio silence, to Palau to be ready to cover moves in the SRA? I ordered all of the above and playing the allies I wouldn't object to any of it. And I don't think it would spoil the surprise the Japanese achieved in real life.

Hypothetically ('cause I wouldn't do it), if I was going to invade JB, Kendari, Amboina, Soerabaja, Rabaul, Lunga, Canton Island and French Frigate Shoals all in the first three days of war I'd offer first turn surprise off and unlimited orders for the allies.

Maybe there's too large a grey area. Probably no WITP player would agree 100% on what would be feasible on Dec. 7th. I suppose one advantage to a Dec. 8th start for the Japanese player is there'd be no chance of being accused of gameyness on turn one.
anarchyintheuk
Posts: 3958
Joined: Wed May 05, 2004 7:08 pm
Location: Dallas

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by anarchyintheuk »

ORIGINAL: TommyG

IMHO nothing could be more historical than for the Japanese player to go for an immediate victory. After all, Japan never planned on invading Iowa, all they wanted was to humiliate a morally inferior culture and dictate the peace terms. So, trying out an innovative new tactic should be encouraged. And, if it succeeds and the Japanese player does capture the entire South Pacific, India, Northern Oz and Alaska, all before June 42; then he should be applauded and his opponent should be allowed to surrender without being ostracized.

True, but the first turn as planned was the IJN/IJA plan for an immediate victory. They just weren't able to refine it based upon an evaluation of an exact-to-the-number-of-men-and-aircraft allied oob or the av value of defenders at a base like we can.
Mike Scholl
Posts: 6187
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 1:17 am
Location: Kansas City, MO

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Mike Scholl »

ORIGINAL: ctangus
I'm mostly an AFB - only recently started playing Japan - but I do think Japan should have more latitude on turn one than the allies. Playing Japan, I'm taking the role of Yamamoto or Nagano and I've been planning my offensive for months - I feel I should be able to re-distribute my forces some. Playing the allies I'm Nimitz taking over from Kimmel - Yikes! Look at what I was just handed! [:)]

That said I think a non-historical turn one by Japan should take into account why Japan didn't invade 30 locations on Dec 7th - namely they didn't want to spoil the surprise of Pearl Harbor. Playing Japan why can't I re-locate my subs? Send the Nagatos instead of the Kongos to cover the Kota Bharu landings in case Force Z shows up? Send a few more troops to Singora & Kota Bharu? Cancel the Legaspi invasion if I don't think it's smart? Send the Combined Fleet, while under radio silence, to Palau to be ready to cover moves in the SRA? I ordered all of the above and playing the allies I wouldn't object to any of it. And I don't think it would spoil the surprise the Japanese achieved in real life.

Hypothetically ('cause I wouldn't do it), if I was going to invade JB, Kendari, Amboina, Soerabaja, Rabaul, Lunga, Canton Island and French Frigate Shoals all in the first three days of war I'd offer first turn surprise off and unlimited orders for the allies.

Maybe there's too large a grey area. Probably no WITP player would agree 100% on what would be feasible on Dec. 7th.


You are talking about the kind of reasonable and rational discussion and agreement that could make a scenario 15 start worthwhile. Problem is that not all Japanese players WANT to be reasonable and rational. That's why it's so important to discuss at length with a potential opponant just how you and he view playing the game. No matter what your preference, there is someone out there to match your tastes..., it's just a matter of finding them. Problems arise when the two of you are seeking different experiances.
User avatar
ctangus
Posts: 2153
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 11:34 pm
Location: Boston, Mass.

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by ctangus »

ORIGINAL: Mike Scholl

You are talking about the kind of reasonable and rational discussion and agreement that could make a scenario 15 start worthwhile. Problem is that not all Japanese players WANT to be reasonable and rational.

Undoubtedly true. I expect that could be said about some allied players also. Though IMO most grogs who are enough into wargaming to take on WITP are more often than not honest folks who at least try to play fairly. I've noticed a few exceptions (IMO) but they seem relatively rare.
That's why it's so important to discuss at length with a potential opponant just how you and he view playing the game. No matter what your preference, there is someone out there to match your tastes..., it's just a matter of finding them. Problems arise when the two of you are seeking different experiances.

Yep. And once that's established there should also be some room for discussion once the game starts. Even if mostly in agreement, who's going to agree completely how this game should be played? It's too massive - I think all of us have slightly different opinions on what's fair or not. Personally I want to fight hard and win, but I'd rather give a mulligan than p1ss off my opponent.
Mike Scholl
Posts: 6187
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 1:17 am
Location: Kansas City, MO

RE: Cherish/value your opponent!

Post by Mike Scholl »

ORIGINAL: ctangus
Yep. And once that's established there should also be some room for discussion once the game starts. Even if mostly in agreement, who's going to agree completely how this game should be played? It's too massive - I think all of us have slightly different opinions on what's fair or not. Personally I want to fight hard and win, but I'd rather give a mulligan than p1ss off my opponent.


Absolutely. You can't possibly anticipate every contingincy that might arise...., but you can get enough of a "feel" for each other to know if it's just something you didn't discuss, or if he's trying to stretch the agreement.
Post Reply

Return to “War In The Pacific - Struggle Against Japan 1941 - 1945”