ACW - Opinion about purchase
Moderator: Pocus
ACW - Opinion about purchase
Seeing the question pop up - "Should I buy this game?". The simple answer is YES. BoA was good, but ACW feels like you are commanding armies in the war.
In my opinion the atmosphere, level of detail, style of play, artwork and strategic options are excellent. Though as in all games of this scope there are a few things here and there I would change if I was the designer, but that's my personnel preferences creeping in.
I expect ACW will be on my hard drive for years alongside TOAW, WiTP and the still satisfying Diablo II.
Daniel
In my opinion the atmosphere, level of detail, style of play, artwork and strategic options are excellent. Though as in all games of this scope there are a few things here and there I would change if I was the designer, but that's my personnel preferences creeping in.
I expect ACW will be on my hard drive for years alongside TOAW, WiTP and the still satisfying Diablo II.
Daniel
Daniel
- aristoteles
- Posts: 22
- Joined: Tue Jul 26, 2005 6:06 pm
- sol_invictus
- Posts: 1959
- Joined: Tue Oct 02, 2001 8:00 am
- Location: Kentucky
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
Yeah, these guys seem intent on developing a steady stream of top notch games. I am really looking forward to NC as well as VoN. Vive la France![&o]
"The fruit of too much liberty is slavery", Cicero
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
AACW is a must buy
McClellan asked, "What troops are those fighting in the Pike?"
Hooker replied, "[Brigadier] General Gibbon's brigade of Western men."
McClellan stated, "They must be made of iron."
Hooker replied, "[Brigadier] General Gibbon's brigade of Western men."
McClellan stated, "They must be made of iron."
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
I bought Forge of Freedom and really could not get into it. I felt like there was no excitement or true control. I found it to be too abstract. I wonder if anyone else can help me compare how this is better. Thanks
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
There was today a really nice review posted on the Wargamer by Will Trotter. Very impressive game. I'm sold.
An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile- hoping it will eat him last
- Winston Churchill
- Winston Churchill
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
Saratoga CV-3
One of 3 U.S. pre-war carriers to survive WWII
Awarded 7 battle stars
Torpedoed on two separate occasions
Hit by 6 bombs, holed twice, on 2-17-45
Sunk at Bikini Atoll, '46, after enduring 2nd A-Bomb test
She was a tough Lady!
One of 3 U.S. pre-war carriers to survive WWII
Awarded 7 battle stars
Torpedoed on two separate occasions
Hit by 6 bombs, holed twice, on 2-17-45
Sunk at Bikini Atoll, '46, after enduring 2nd A-Bomb test
She was a tough Lady!
- hurtzDonut
- Posts: 39
- Joined: Sat Jan 08, 2005 2:00 pm
- Location: Indiana
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
Bill Trotter says this is a very good game! Nuff said!
"Invader blood marches through my veins, like giant radioactive rubberpants" Invader Zim
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
I'm enjoying it immensely................
[;)]
[;)]
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
I have to echo the sentiments above. Excellent game.
And the support by AGEOD is simply unrivalled in the business!
(Pocus: typo on my company name, message edited [:)] ).
And the support by AGEOD is simply unrivalled in the business!
(Pocus: typo on my company name, message edited [:)] ).

"Life is tough, it's even tougher when you're stupid" -SGT John M. Stryker, USMC
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
Will probably buy this, but not until I can get a hard copy as well. No more just buying downloads for me.
Favoritism is alive and well here.
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
ORIGINAL: denisonh
I have to echo the sentiments above. Excellent game.
And the support by AGEOD is simply unrivalled in the business!
(Pocus: typo on my company name, message edited [:)] ).
Your quick POCUS! Didn't even give me time to make my own correction! There is an example of the responsiveness and attention to detail that is representative of "AGEOD's" support!

"Life is tough, it's even tougher when you're stupid" -SGT John M. Stryker, USMC
-
- Posts: 1059
- Joined: Sun Dec 03, 2006 1:08 pm
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
ORIGINAL: Twotribes
Will probably buy this, but not until I can get a hard copy as well. No more just buying downloads for me.
I am curious, Twotribes, why you say this? I have had bought only one download and had certain problems. Others swear by it. What is your experience?
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
I lose or don't keep my order number and my cards change. I have about 4 games I can't play now because all I did is buy the download. I will in the future only buy both.
Favoritism is alive and well here.
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
ORIGINAL: Twotribes
I have about 4 games I can't play now because all I did is buy the download.
Didn't Erik say he would sort it for you if you e-mailed Matrix with your details?
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
Yes but in the future I will avoid the problem by making sure I buy hard copy as well as download.
Favoritism is alive and well here.
- goodwoodrw
- Posts: 2665
- Joined: Mon Feb 14, 2005 12:19 pm
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
G'day all, I have had this game since early June and played it almost every day since. It is one of those, "just one more turn games", and you find yourself well into the small hours of the morning, before giving it up. An example of this was the other day, when had decided to take Richmond, unfortunately things didn't go to plan, but was determine to take Richmond before going to bed. So over many turns I created a new army, several corps and many divisions, and systematically took control of every region surrounding Richmond and cutting its defending army's supply. I then assaulted the capital and crushed a sizable CSA army. How pleasing. I was happy, Lincoln was happy, but my wife was really pissed when I put my cold feet on her when finally crawled into bed. [:D]
I have bought several games this year from matrixgames, some really have disappointed me, some have been ok, but none have grabbed me the way AACW have.
Why? Well briefly, but not necessarily in order, the map simply beautiful, the graphics in general are great. love the unit representations. The strategy in depth but simple. I enjoyed playing this game even when I didn't have a clue what I was doing. Great manual explains the game well, and great support from the devs, they listen they consider they change. Finally because of it historic flavour, I have learnt a lot more about the ACW since I have had this game, because of the characters and places, I have constantly referred to Wikipedia and other search engines to gain as much info as I can on the diferent characters, places, events and battles. IMHO this game is worth every buck u pay for it.
I have bought several games this year from matrixgames, some really have disappointed me, some have been ok, but none have grabbed me the way AACW have.
Why? Well briefly, but not necessarily in order, the map simply beautiful, the graphics in general are great. love the unit representations. The strategy in depth but simple. I enjoyed playing this game even when I didn't have a clue what I was doing. Great manual explains the game well, and great support from the devs, they listen they consider they change. Finally because of it historic flavour, I have learnt a lot more about the ACW since I have had this game, because of the characters and places, I have constantly referred to Wikipedia and other search engines to gain as much info as I can on the diferent characters, places, events and battles. IMHO this game is worth every buck u pay for it.
Formerly Goodwood
RE: ACW - Opinion about purchase
ORIGINAL: Twotribes
I lose or don't keep my order number and my cards change. I have about 4 games I can't play now because all I did is buy the download. I will in the future only buy both.
What I do is download, then burn the file to a cd. I then tape on it the serial number cut from the confirmation e-mail. The license agreement does allow you to make a backup cd, so there's nothing improper here.
An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile- hoping it will eat him last
- Winston Churchill
- Winston Churchill