Yet another MCNA oddity - 17-lb guns in 1941?

Yogi Yohan · Post by **Yogi Yohan** » Sun Apr 14, 2002 2:24 pm

In the One Last Try scenario of MCNA my forces are being fired upon by 17-pounder AT guns. This would be about 2 years before they came into service. Unless there were prototypes of this gun tested in Tobruk (but I doubt there were even prototype 17-pounders at this time), something's clearly wrong here.

Wild Bill · Post by **Wild Bill** » Tue Apr 16, 2002 12:27 am

I'd very much like to check that for you Yogi. They really should not be there. Do you remember in which battle you saw them?

Wild Bill

Don Doom · Post by **Don Doom** » Tue Apr 16, 2002 2:01 am

Originally posted by Yogi Yohan
In the "One Last Try scenario" of MCNA.

I believe it is this one, I don't remember seeing this listed though, could be I am just blind.

Supervisor · Post by **Supervisor** » Tue Apr 16, 2002 2:16 am

That was a big help Don, I think what WB was referring too was which battle option, but then again I could be just dumb too.LOL:D

Yogi Yohan · Post by **Yogi Yohan** » Tue Apr 16, 2002 3:35 am

I'm not 100% certain, but I think it was "no option", I choose that for most battles.

Maybe if I knew what options were available, I'd remember.

There were no Italian forces present and Rommel came to pay a visit.

Redleg · Post by **Redleg** » Tue Apr 16, 2002 8:55 am

It wasn't one of the 17 lb howitzers, was it?

Yogi Yohan · Post by **Yogi Yohan** » Tue Apr 16, 2002 11:07 am

No, definitely 17 lb AT-guns. I didn't even know there was such a thing as a 17-lb howitzer. Don't you mean 18-lb howitzers?

Wild Bill · Post by **Wild Bill** » Tue Apr 16, 2002 8:48 pm

One last try...Okay, I'll take a look Yogi, and see what is going on here. THanks for the update..17 pounders would be deadly against Mk. IIs and IIIs, for sure!

WB

Yogi Yohan · Post by **Yogi Yohan** » Fri Apr 19, 2002 3:12 am

Originally posted by Wild Bill
One last try...Okay, I'll take a look Yogi, and see what is going on here. THanks for the update..17 pounders would be deadly against Mk. IIs and IIIs, for sure!

WB

Oh Wild One, I have found the offending AT guns. They are in scenario file scen313.dat.

Wild Bill · Post by **Wild Bill** » Fri Apr 19, 2002 7:28 am

I looked Yogi, and cannot find them in my files. I see a lot of 2 Pounders, 18 and 25 Pounders, but no 17 Lb AT gun. I'm sending you a graphic of the OOB for the British in "A Last Try."

They are just not there for me.

Wild Bill

Big T · Post by **Big T** » Sun Apr 21, 2002 2:47 am

Originally posted by Wild Bill
I looked Yogi, and cannot find them in my files. I see a lot of 2 Pounders, 18 and 25 Pounders, but no 17 Lb AT gun. I'm sending you a graphic of the OOB for the British in "A Last Try."

They are just not there for me.

Wild Bill

Hi WB,
I've been following this thread with interest, since I think I am close to the same place as yogi, but anyway, I went and check my scen313.dat file (WAWEd) and ALSO found the 2 17lbers in there (units J0 and J1).

I can email you the file if you like.

Wild Bill · Post by **Wild Bill** » Sun Apr 21, 2002 10:12 am

I could have missed them. J0 - J!...Looking now

J0 and J1 in my game are 25 Pdr Howitzers. This is puzzling indeed.

Wild Bill
================

Wild Bill · Post by **Wild Bill** » Wed Apr 24, 2002 9:15 pm

I downloaded your file, Big T, but for some reason it removed key files from my Windows File Manager after I tried to use the file.

I would recommend that no one else try to download this until we find out what the problem is. Thanks anyway, Big T.

Wild Bill

Wild Bill · Post by **Wild Bill** » Wed Apr 24, 2002 9:16 pm

Yogi, send me a jpg file with these 17 pdrs highlighted on the map. That would help me a lot.

Wild Bill

Big T · Post by **Big T** » Thu Apr 25, 2002 8:47 pm

Originally posted by Wild Bill
I downloaded your file, Big T, but for some reason it removed key files from my Windows File Manager after I tried to use the file.

I would recommend that no one else try to download this until we find out what the problem is. Thanks anyway, Big T.

Wild Bill

Whoa! Dunno how that happened WB!?! Sorry about any trouble it caused you. I'm certain that my computer is virus free, (but i'm checking now anyway).

One thing I was wondering was if we could individually change the 17lbrs to 25's using WAWEd, I'm hesitant to change it since it's part of the MEGA camp

DaveConn · Post by **DaveConn** » Fri Apr 26, 2002 6:31 am

FWIW, my MCNA scen313.dat file also shows two 17 lb AT guns. File is 209 KB, dated 4/18/01 at 11:01 PM.

Wild Bill · Post by **Wild Bill** » Fri May 03, 2002 4:43 pm

It is evident that we have two scenarios in circulation. On reviewing my records after the computer virus disaster, it appears that the original scenario did include 2 17 pounders, an error on the part of the designer.

We caught this and replaced them with two 25 pounder guns. Somehow, and I have no idea how, the original got into the final MCNA copy instead of the revised one.

It is the only answer to this dilemma. That being the case, the only thing we can do is to offer the revised scenario in a new patch for MCNA players who have not yet reached this point.

I apologize for this happening. And I do appreciate the keen eye of you gamers in discovering this. I see that you live by the adage, "Know your enemy!"

Wild Bill

DaveConn · Post by **DaveConn** » Tue May 07, 2002 9:28 pm

Talk about poor timing: It wasn't until last night that I realized this thread pertained to the very scenario I was playing. Then, suddently, I found myself under fire by a 17lb ATG. Yikes! Fortunately I had smoked the area pretty well, and lost only a halftrack before I took the gun out; but I am now wondering where the other one is!
--Dave

Yet another MCNA oddity - 17-lb guns in 1941?

Yet another MCNA oddity - 17-lb guns in 1941?

Re: Yet another MCNA oddity - 17-lb guns in 1941?

I'll take a look

Re: I'll take a look

I Can't Find them

Re: I Can't Find them

Problematic Download

A Picture is worth...

Re: Problematic Download