Russia41 strategy questions

Advanced Tactics is a versatile turn-based strategy system that gives gamers the chance to wage almost any battle in any time period. The initial release focuses on World War II and includes a number of historical scenarios as well as a full editor! This forum supports both the original Advanced Tactics and the new and improved Advanced Tactics: Gold Edition.

Moderator: Vic

Post Reply
jjdenver
Posts: 2480
Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2007 11:07 pm

Russia41 strategy questions

Post by jjdenver »

Hi

I'm new to the game and am trying the Russia 41 scenario - playing as Russia. I'd like to get a few strategy pointers from ppl more experienced w/ the game.

The soviets start out w/ a 2-tier HQ system. Stavka on tier 1, every other HQ on tier 2 directly under Stavka. Is there any reason to modify this structure? For example I could put all of the HQ's that start w/ no troops attached under another HQ so there would be a 3-tier structure. Would this have any advantage/disadvantage and would another approach be better?

Some soviet HQ's start out w/ no troops attached. Should new units be built using political points to fill out these HQ's w/ units subordinate to them? Would the political points be better spent on research instead of building new units? Or should units be transferred from other HQ's to these empty HQ's?

Some soviet HQ's start out w/ no units attached and are in major cities (i.e. Minsk, Kiev, etc). Should these be left as "fortress" units in the city w/o any units attached instead of retreated to have other units attached?

There are a lot of Soviet units on the frontline with what seem to be valuable formations (artillery, flak, light tanks, etc). What's the best way to get them out? There doesn't seem to be much strategic movement capacity for the Soviets at start - I can SR a few units out using Stavka as the moving HQ but other than that can only take out a very few formations (3 or 4 I think).

Each Soviet HQ start out with one city producing for it and Stavka starts out with 4 cities producing for it. Should every city be funneled to Stavka or is it wise to have each HQ w/ a dedicated city producing for it?

How much political point production should the Soviets be doing at start? And should Stavka cities be doing it?

If a city is left dedicated to an HQ what type of production would be wise to set it to? Supplies? Trucks? Staff? Infantry? Is there any type of production that should be left to Stavka vs another type that should be for the frontline HQ's?

Is it smart to have dive bombers and fighters in the same air units? If the unit intercepts will the dive bombers be part of the interception or only the fighters? Should they be split into different units?

Thanks for any thoughts and other thoughts about things not asked here - general strategy advice or advice for this scenario would be great!

Thx
AARS:
CEAW-BJR Mod 2009:
tm.asp?m=2101447
AT-WW1:
tm.asp?m=1705427
AT-GPW:
tm.asp?m=1649732
tweber
Posts: 1411
Joined: Wed Jun 27, 2007 1:32 pm

RE: Russia41 strategy questions

Post by tweber »

The soviets start out w/ a 2-tier HQ system. Stavka on tier 1, every other HQ on tier 2 directly under Stavka. Is there any reason to modify this structure? For example I could put all of the HQ's that start w/ no troops attached under another HQ so there would be a 3-tier structure. Would this have any advantage/disadvantage and would another approach be better?

In general, it is good to have a higher level HQ receive supply. You want to keep this back and make sure it is not cut off. It is good to have your reinforcements go directly to the threatened front. You need less trucks. Also, each transfer across HQs reduces readiness to so you avoid an extra cross HQ transfer.

As to the number of HQs, more HQs means that you HQ range is shorter. Also your transfer range is shorter.

HQs do cost 5 pp so if you can get by with fewer HQs, you can harvest the pp by disbanding. Also disband an HQ that is hopelessly surrounded (you can create a regular counter to dump all the units in the HQ and you have now saved 4 pp).
Some soviet HQ's start out w/ no troops attached. Should new units be built using political points to fill out these HQ's w/ units subordinate to them? Would the political points be better spent on research instead of building new units? Or should units be transferred from other HQ's to these empty HQ's?

It is good to use these units to make lines in the rear. You want your units in place for a turn or 2 before the front advances to their position. Also, keep close tabs on staffing levels. If you have an HQ group with excess staff, shift the staff to another group.
There are a lot of Soviet units on the frontline with what seem to be valuable formations (artillery, flak, light tanks, etc). What's the best way to get them out? There doesn't seem to be much strategic movement capacity for the Soviets at start - I can SR a few units out using Stavka as the moving HQ but other than that can only take out a very few formations (3 or 4 I think).

The Soviets start out with a larger army then the Germans. If you can rescue significant front line forces, you will win easily. If you are playing the Germans and are not able to isolate the Soviet troops near Bialystock on turn 1, start over and keep trying until you do.
Each Soviet HQ start out with one city producing for it and Stavka starts out with 4 cities producing for it. Should every city be funneled to Stavka or is it wise to have each HQ w/ a dedicated city producing for it?

Funnel supply through Stavka and direct reinforcements directly to the front.
How much political point production should the Soviets be doing at start? And should Stavka cities be doing it?

Before you build pp, harvest as much as you can from surrounded units. If you have 3 units on top of eachother in Bialystock, compress to 1. Also put isolated units on roads so that Germany will get them at some point. An isolated unit safety off the supply paths can be ignored in most cases.

Once your counters are harvested, you should probably make sure you have 10-15 pp per round for operational flexibility. Any more and you are doing research, which you cannot affort to do in 1941.
If a city is left dedicated to an HQ what type of production would be wise to set it to? Supplies? Trucks? Staff? Infantry? Is there any type of production that should be left to Stavka vs another type that should be for the frontline HQ's?

If the city is about to be surrounded, the garrison will nead supplies. Check the stocks of the units and the supply need to see how much to build. The Soviets do not need trucks in the summer. I build rifle, lt tanks, staff, and engineers. Build only enough staff to staff at 100% staff power. Build enough engineers to blow bridges. Everything else goes to front line units. MGs and bazookas are not a bad idea as they are as cost effective as rifle against infantry and tanks respectively, but they use less supply. The tradeoff is that they are less cost effective against divebombers.
Is it smart to have dive bombers and fighters in the same air units? If the unit intercepts will the dive bombers be part of the interception or only the fighters? Should they be split into different units?

The Soviets should lose most of there initial air force, so this might be academic. If you have researched to a high level of fighter, it is better to seperate the fighters from the dive bombers as the fighters have longer range. Seperating units gives you more flexibility (you can attack more targets) at the cost of the counters. In the early war, put whatever air units you have together to save the unit cost and get them to the rear quickly.
Thanks for any thoughts and other thoughts about things not asked here - general strategy advice or advice for this scenario would be great!


I like to disperse units and defend in depth. If you make your standard unit 20 rifle with a lt tank, it is cheap. You can cover a front 2 hexes deep with these units. The German player could take out any given hex, but will have difficulties getting through your line. Avoid tank concentrations as you are vulnerable to air attack early on.

Try to position your units and then don't move them unless you need to avoid encirclement. This allows them the opportunity to entrench.

If you do have to retreat, try to step back into favorable terrain. If you are in the plains, take 2-3 steps back. The Germans will take the ground but will not be able to attack you with lots of action points next turn.



EricSilver_MatrixForum
Posts: 61
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 11:15 am

RE: Russia41 strategy questions

Post by EricSilver_MatrixForum »

Thanks for the wise advices, tweber.


[;)]
Post Reply

Return to “Advanced Tactics Series”