WW2 in Europe scenario need work?

Advanced Tactics is a versatile turn-based strategy system that gives gamers the chance to wage almost any battle in any time period. The initial release focuses on World War II and includes a number of historical scenarios as well as a full editor! This forum supports both the original Advanced Tactics and the new and improved Advanced Tactics: Gold Edition.

Moderator: Vic

therockyfroggy
Posts: 57
Joined: Thu Jul 26, 2007 7:08 am

RE: WW2 in Europe scenario need work?

Post by therockyfroggy »

I'm totally the opposite in the type of game I look for. I remember playing EU or EU2, cant remember which, and the point of some of that game is to see if you can do better with any country that what they did historically...so, If I, as Belgium, could take over more land than what they actually had...that might be a victory for me cause I did better historically.....to me, that's boring. That's why I don't like Civil War games which are more historical and less gamey....I want a game...I want a Civil War game where each side has roughly good chance to get an outright win, based on having to do everything correctly as far as production, upgrades, recruiting, battles, etc. using somewhat historical men, armies, populations. I like winning games, not trying to do slightly better historically....that is something that usually isnt very hard, seeing as we know what happened historically already and can adjust based on the errors that were made historically.

ORIGINAL: SMK-at-work
Now you're being insulting and saying that I'm not interested in playability - what I'm not interested is in pampering the Axis side so they have a mythical 50% chance of winning WW2........that's not playability for me...that's laziness.
seille
Posts: 2048
Joined: Tue Jun 19, 2007 8:25 am
Location: Germany

RE: WW2 in Europe scenario need work?

Post by seille »

ORIGINAL: SMK-at-work
sure the Maginot line was never really tested...but they didn't have enough troops to Eban-emal any large part of it, and it was a major obstacle regardless.

Actually I sort of got off on the wrong foot - I don't mind the Maginot line being destroyed....the problem was really that he had enough troops in the West to do it so early - starting turn 3 - so it seemed to me that he was able to transfer troops to the west far too quickly - he was able to do this because he only used the East Prussia troops to conquer Poland - none of the others were required......so the problem for me wasn't the Maginot line so much as the setup in poland.

At least it's getting me familiar with the editor! :)

Hey SMK, we´re not that far away from eachother than i thought !!
The possible early Maginot line attack using the troops from Poland campaign is indeed a bit unrealistic compared to the
real timeline. Perhaps it would be better when the germans could not attack before spring 1940. The attack would be more difficult and
the allies would win some time.
The attack would then be very hard for Germany since the allies would gain XP and entrenchment and could fortify in depth.
The positive effect on the game is that the Axis player has to spend more ressources to go through. He´ll need more troops and
some more upgrades. He could not kick England that easy out of the war.

In the first games i played with Tom in the testing phase we attacked always the Maginot line AFTER the winter using the offensive card.
I was the first one attacked already in december or january and now this is unfortunately something like standard.

As i said here i would not have problems when Germany can´t attack before april or may 1940.
Maybe it´s possible to start a poll for that.
Post Reply

Return to “Advanced Tactics Series”