Aircraft target priorities.....

John Tiller's Campaign Series exemplifies tactical war-gaming at its finest by bringing you the entire collection of TalonSoft's award-winning campaign series. Containing TalonSoft's West Front, East Front, and Rising Sun platoon-level combat series, as well as all of the official add-ons and expansion packs, the Matrix Edition allows players to dictate the events of World War II from the tumultuous beginning to its climatic conclusion. We are working together with original programmer John Tiller to bring you this updated edition.

Moderators: Jason Petho, Peter Fisla, asiaticus, dogovich

Post Reply
dgk196
Posts: 248
Joined: Tue Mar 21, 2006 2:30 am

Aircraft target priorities.....

Post by dgk196 »

AAAAAHHHHHH!!!!

If I send out cannon armed stuka's that promptly attack infantry units next to the tank target I'm going to scream somemore!

I feel that the target priorities per aircraft type should be assignable. Three basic categories. Vehicles, guns, other. Then at the start of the game you would have to set the target priority order for each aircraft type. Example Ju87G's might be, vehicles/guns/other.
While the Ju87b might be guns/other/vehicles. And so on! Then when the aircraft go out on their mission armed for the types of targets they are expected to encounter and have been tasked with attacking, they will actually accomplish their mission. The target types are generic enough to keep players from micromanaging targets, and allowing some level of variance.

Dennis
dgk196
Posts: 248
Joined: Tue Mar 21, 2006 2:30 am

RE: Aircraft target priorities.....

Post by dgk196 »

39, and counting, viewings and no opinions? I am the only one who thinks this is a 'problem'?

Dennis 
User avatar
XLVIIIPzKorp
Posts: 224
Joined: Tue Oct 24, 2006 12:34 am
Contact:

RE: Aircraft target priorities.....

Post by XLVIIIPzKorp »

Hey!! Alleluia pal! I'm with you 100% on this one. Jason???? How about some selectability for target types? Dennis has a real point here. We have the ability to set op-fire for individual units, sure would be nice to set target types for air... maybe at the start of the game.

Couple nights ago I watched my 87G's ineffectively strafe Russian infantry.... that were in the hex next to the JS II's.... on the road... in clear terrain.
Legionaer
Posts: 449
Joined: Fri Jun 08, 2007 10:38 am
Location: Mainz, Deutschland

RE: Aircraft target priorities.....

Post by Legionaer »

ORIGINAL: dgk196

I am the only one who thinks this is a 'problem'?
No, you´re not alone! [;)]
I create and revise: OoB´s, ToE´s, Weapon Values for Modern Wars (forever CWE!) Working on OoB´s for the new CSCW and scenario playtesting for the Beta Brigade.
User avatar
Jason Petho
Posts: 17554
Joined: Tue Jun 22, 2004 10:31 am
Location: Terrace, BC, Canada
Contact:

RE: Aircraft target priorities.....

Post by Jason Petho »

1.03 has on-map bombers available for a few countries.

Those so inclined can create new scenarios with them.

** Bootcamp 6 (I believe) will be an excellent introduction to their potential.

Jason Petho
User avatar
cpdeyoung
Posts: 5379
Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2007 3:26 pm
Location: South Carolina, USA

RE: Aircraft target priorities.....

Post by cpdeyoung »

On-map bombers are a great idea. As air power is modeled now I do not enjoy it. I am almost sorry to see aircraft added to my OoB. I know the WW2 situation of air support control was not as flexible as now, but these were human pilots, dedicated to successful prosecution of their missions, no where near as clueless as modeled now. I cannot wait to see on-map bombers.
dgk196
Posts: 248
Joined: Tue Mar 21, 2006 2:30 am

RE: Aircraft target priorities.....

Post by dgk196 »

New bombers!? That's great! Medium, light, dive bombers or what? Which ones? Come on give us a hint!

One 'Enola Gay' and my victories are assured, at last!


Dennis
User avatar
Huib
Posts: 251
Joined: Tue Nov 21, 2006 3:17 pm
Location: Nederland

RE: Aircraft target priorities.....

Post by Huib »

The key to succesful airstrikes in a game is simply that the designers add enough of them. If you know that at a certain battle aircraft influenced the battle, just add enough airstrikes: if the target is missed one time, better luck next time. Also given the scale of the game it is best if designers add only ONE type of aircraft to the scenario.
I see no need for a change in the game. Central control over the battlefield by the players is already much better than from any commander in the field.
User avatar
Warren
Posts: 19
Joined: Tue Oct 02, 2007 4:08 pm
Location: Ohio, USA
Contact:

RE: Aircraft target priorities.....

Post by Warren »

One thing that I have noticed in PBEM is that players will place a lattice of disposable units along routes where air strikes will likely target to potentially draw off the strike from an intended target. I am not sure if visibility is a factor in calling off a strike but it should-especially now with variable visibility.

I think strikes should only be called in by specially FO units designated for that capability and observing the target hex. Otherwise the strike should have a very good chance of being called off and or scattered.
dgk196
Posts: 248
Joined: Tue Mar 21, 2006 2:30 am

RE: Aircraft target priorities.....

Post by dgk196 »

So, I was thinking. How many mission classifications would there need to be?

Direct support, attacking targets that can be seen by ground units. Flown by ground support aircraft only. Air units allocated prior to the start of the game.

Interdiction, attacking targets behind front line units, against specific units, but out of sight of the front line units. Flown by any aircraft type. Interdiction missions should be preplotted, limited area, prior to the start of the game.

General support, attacking area targets in the rear area's where either formations are seen deploying, or suspected. Flown by any aircraft type. Air reconnaissance reports required at the start of the game and plotted out on the level three or four map without the ground units on them, just a description of their presence. A hex area attack instead of a unit in-the-hex attack!

Dennis [:)]
User avatar
Dumnorix
Posts: 793
Joined: Thu Mar 15, 2007 12:37 pm
Contact:

RE: Aircraft target priorities.....

Post by Dumnorix »

Hallo Jason
Which abilities have your on-map bombers - surely indirect artilleryfire. Thats not good for airattack - no flighing graphic and no air defense fire to this artilleryfire-on-map bombers.
I already tried out before 3 years.
I think this is Rubbish !!! - does not help us.
New airfightsystem with an 3rd weapon-category would be funny and effektiv.(Take a look in my scriptideas for new airfight!)
H.Balck
dgk196
Posts: 248
Joined: Tue Mar 21, 2006 2:30 am

RE: Aircraft target priorities.....

Post by dgk196 »

I don't quiet follow you, what is rubbish?

Mission types?

Target priorities?

Reconnaissance?

Mission Planning?

Support Assignment?

AAA would be as applicable!

Dennis [:)]
User avatar
Arctic Blast
Posts: 1157
Joined: Wed Apr 04, 2007 5:58 am
Contact:

RE: Aircraft target priorities.....

Post by Arctic Blast »

I believe it's simply Dumnorix 'subtly' declaring, once more, that either you follow HIS brilliant idea, or it can't be good. [8|]
Meditation on inevitable death should be performed daily.
User avatar
Warren
Posts: 19
Joined: Tue Oct 02, 2007 4:08 pm
Location: Ohio, USA
Contact:

RE: Aircraft target priorities.....

Post by Warren »

ORIGINAL: dgk196

So, I was thinking. How many mission classifications would there need to be?

Direct support, attacking targets that can be seen by ground units. Flown by ground support aircraft only. Air units allocated prior to the start of the game.

Interdiction, attacking targets behind front line units, against specific units, but out of sight of the front line units. Flown by any aircraft type. Interdiction missions should be preplotted, limited area, prior to the start of the game.

General support, attacking area targets in the rear area's where either formations are seen deploying, or suspected. Flown by any aircraft type. Air reconnaissance reports required at the start of the game and plotted out on the level three or four map without the ground units on them, just a description of their presence. A hex area attack instead of a unit in-the-hex attack!

Dennis [:)]

Well my original thought was to critique the existing model, but I like the way you think!

I definitely like the idea of air reconnaissance missions where one could try to spot enemy units.

Interdiction could be declared at the beginning of the game for specific air units such that when the enemy is expending moving points and is spotted there is a slight possibility of being attacked by an air unit 'on station'. Once an aircraft is designated for interdiction mode it is locked into that for the remainder of the game.

An air strike in a 250m hex should be area fire for HE; if AP, it is directed fire at one target designated from a priority list.

Regards.
Post Reply

Return to “John Tiller's Campaign Series”