Cavalry Reinforcement?

Tanaka · Post by **Tanaka** » Fri Mar 06, 2009 6:05 am

Can anyone tell me why my infantry is filling up with men but not my cavalry? I have plenty of horses...

Joram · Post by **Joram** » Fri Mar 06, 2009 6:44 am

Replacements for cav, artillery and guard come in at quarter (or is it half, don't have rules in front of me) of regular infantry I believe so that may be part of what you are seeing.

Mus · Post by **Mus** » Fri Mar 06, 2009 7:46 am

Does Guard receive reinforcements at a lower rate?  I havent seen that in my games.

Joram · Post by **Joram** » Fri Mar 06, 2009 8:42 am

Yes, absolutely it does.  If you see a unit you think is a guard getting as many as other infantry, then the unit may not actually be a guard but just very high morale.

Tanaka · Post by **Tanaka** » Fri Mar 06, 2009 6:18 pm

Hmm well my cavalry has not been filling up at all...

I can transfer men from one cav unit to the other and it fills up but other than that nothing else happens [&:]

Mus · Post by **Mus** » Fri Mar 06, 2009 8:39 pm

ORIGINAL: Joram

Yes, absolutely it does. If you see a unit you think is a guard getting as many as other infantry, then the unit may not actually be a guard but just very high morale.

Ok well theres a little weirdness with Guards right now from what Im seeing in games. Reference my comments in other threads. I believe certain rules with Guards may not be working correctly or may not have carried over from COG to COG:EE but is still referenced in the manual.

Tanaka · Post by **Tanaka** » Sat Mar 07, 2009 6:40 am

Anyone else having the same problem of the two irregular cavs Spain starts out with never filling up? Is the only way to fill to tranfer men from one to the other and disband the empty unit?

Russian Guard · Post by **Russian Guard** » Sat Mar 07, 2009 4:54 pm

ORIGINAL: Tanaka

Anyone else having the same problem of the two irregular cavs Spain starts out with never filling up? Is the only way to fill to tranfer men from one to the other and disband the empty unit?

I've played Spain and those units have received reinforcements. Are you sure they are in supply?

Edit: added image

Tanaka · Post by **Tanaka** » Sat Mar 07, 2009 5:33 pm

ORIGINAL: Russian Guard

ORIGINAL: Tanaka

Anyone else having the same problem of the two irregular cavs Spain starts out with never filling up? Is the only way to fill to tranfer men from one to the other and disband the empty unit?

I've played Spain and those units have received reinforcements. Are you sure they are in supply?

Edit: added image

Hmm Ill post some screenies. Im assumming foraging prevents this?

Tanaka · Post by **Tanaka** » Sat Mar 07, 2009 5:36 pm

Supply...

Tanaka · Post by **Tanaka** » Sat Mar 07, 2009 5:39 pm

Draft...

Tanaka · Post by **Tanaka** » Sat Mar 07, 2009 6:10 pm

Ah I see now the only way they will resupply is with a depot!

morganbj · Post by **morganbj** » Sat Mar 07, 2009 10:10 pm

Well, I can confirm that guards get replacements.  In my current game, my guard unit has 8,999 men.  My readiness is set at 9.  The unit started the game with 5,000 something, I think.
 
It takes a long time with guards, but it happens.

balto · Post by **balto** » Sat Mar 07, 2009 10:31 pm

ORIGINAL: Tanaka

Ah I see now the only way they will resupply is with a depot!

So does this mean you only get reinforced is if you are in or next to a Supply Depot? So you do not get reinforced while Foraging?

morganbj · Post by **morganbj** » Sat Mar 07, 2009 10:41 pm

I think there is a priority for reinforcements.  This is those in supply, either by depot or in a city, get reinforced first, then those who forage.  I also think the foraging replacement rate is much less.  But my memory may be wrong about replacements for foraging units.
 
In practice, I always assume that only those in a city or in a depot will receive replacements.  Every so often, I move depleted units back to a city just for that purpose.  To do that, I transfer men from one unit to another to partially fill one and make the other ready for R&R in Munich, or whatever.  After things settle down after the first year or so and my draftees become much more plentiful, I just let nature take it's course and only move units to a city when I get one creamed in battle.

Tanaka · Post by **Tanaka** » Sun Mar 08, 2009 4:21 am

ORIGINAL: bjmorgan

I think there is a priority for reinforcements. This is those in supply, either by depot or in a city, get reinforced first, then those who forage. I also think the foraging replacement rate is much less. But my memory may be wrong about replacements for foraging units.

In practice, I always assume that only those in a city or in a depot will receive replacements. Every so often, I move depleted units back to a city just for that purpose. To do that, I transfer men from one unit to another to partially fill one and make the other ready for R&R in Munich, or whatever. After things settle down after the first year or so and my draftees become much more plentiful, I just let nature take it's course and only move units to a city when I get one creamed in battle.

Hmm I never knew that about putting units in cities. As depots are so expensive I will try that instead thanks!

As far as the foraging goes I played months and months and my spanish cavalry never filled up with men at all...

Cavalry Reinforcement?

Cavalry Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?

RE: Calvary Reinforcement?