DUD Torps

[ltfightr]

Im my games so far the IJN's torps are duding at a rate comparable to the USN. That just does not seem right and is getting frustrating. I can understand if that is being used a a generic miss but I would rather them say miss than torpedo failed to detonate.

[Terminus]

Yeah, well... The torp dud rates are 80% for the Mk 14, and 10% for the most common IJN sub torp. We've had plenty of people complaining that the IJN scores too many victories with their torps...

[WingedIncubus]

Random fluke, me thinks. 

[invernomuto]

Bad luck. In my game (AI historical, scen 1, jap side) my subs have very high hit rate compared to the allies ones...

[ltfightr]

Bad luck is certainly my luck. I have seen the other rants.

[Curty]

In my Guadalcanal scenario 5 TBFs attacked a jap xAK. 4 duds against the hull and 1 miss![:@]

[Cribtop]

In Guad as Japanese my subs have had two or three duds, but have managed to account for all THREE USN CVs escorting the Watchtower amphib assault. I won't complain about that! [:D]

[joey]

ORIGINAL: Terminus

Yeah, well... The torp dud rates are 80% for the Mk 14, and 10% for the most common IJN sub torp. We've had plenty of people complaining that the IJN scores too many victories with their torps...

From what I have seen so far, your rates seem accurate in the game.

[Tophat1815]

ORIGINAL: Terminus

Yeah, well... The torp dud rates are 80% for the Mk 14, and 10% for the most common IJN sub torp. We've had plenty of people complaining that the IJN scores too many victories with their torps...

In the Aleutian Island scenario I also have had a very,very high dud rate. Including "Hit!But no explosion" messages. I don't think its a fluke.