ORIGINAL: AW1Steve
Very well played! [&o][&o][&o] Still seems a suprise that my forces , despite sighting you 1st (via RADAR) and being evenly matched , came off so badly.[&:] Lesson learned! [:D]
Thank you kind sir. My take on advantages is as follows:
1. I had Tanaka [&o] as my TF commander. What was your commander's Fetchmyslippers' naval and agressive ratings?
2. You had just finished bombarding the p*** out of Attu when I caught you. I would bet your CA and CL AP ammo. was low from the onset of the surface shoot out. There's also the issue of the 'bombarding disadvantage' when such a TF is caught by one intent on surface combat.
3. You did get the first shot after RADAR identification. However, your CA's first salvos were ineffectual, thus remitting any bonus conferred by said ID.
4. Early salvoes from my CAs selectively hit your fire control centers-particularly on the Santa Fe. I would venture that this rendered her command center a charnal house aflame.
5. Long lances make a mess out of damaged light cruisers. [&o] I believe that Kiso provided that kindness. [&o]
6. Don't know why the allied torpedoes failed to score. IIRC, Nachi scored with 3 TTs against Wichita herself.
7. CA Maya was dealin' it with her 20cm guns. Penetrating hit after penetrating hit after penetrating hit. Working up and down the line. Her gunnery was something to behold. The allied reprisal was muted by comparison, but Maya got into the action a little later than the others.