Couple of criticisms

[alfonso]

ORIGINAL: Smirfy

ORIGINAL: alfonso

How much ammo did the unit receive when it was 18 hexes away from its HQ?

Nearly 100%

No, no how much it has, but how much it received, in tons.

[Smirfy]

ORIGINAL: hattrick1



How many Offensives did the Russians have that failed because they over extended their supply line. How many times did the Russians after learning not to over extend the supply line stop and wait for the supplies to build up before continuing.

Is the logistical situation that the Russians had historically in the game using the same logistical game mechanics as the Germans? One of the two biggest reasons keeping the Russians out of Berlin was supply, this might explain why the Russians in the game are in Berlin in 42 or 43. They never have to wait for supply.

Glad somebody understands the ramifications of having zero gravity in game. I prefer to get away from the German/Russian side of things to just general mechanics but yes there is little to stop a Russian or a German player bar railroad repair (even at that I forgot to do that the first half of one of my offensives and it made little difference).

If you take the first Russian winter offensive against the AI there is nothing to stop you except role playing and the AI spamming units. This needs addressed

[Smirfy]

ORIGINAL: alfonso

ORIGINAL: Smirfy

ORIGINAL: alfonso

How much ammo did the unit receive when it was 18 hexes away from its HQ?

Nearly 100%

No, no how much it has, but how much it received, in tons.

if that is ammo recieved = 34

[alfonso]

Can you post a screenshot similar to this? Perhaps any developer could explain what is happening in your game, if there is an issue, and in the process we all can learn what all those numbers mean...

Edit: 34 tons of ammo do not seem a very large quantity, because my Division in the picture received 358.

[Smirfy]

Whats the take screen key?

edit my ammo is near 100% so does not need much

[KenchiSulla]

So you are not expending ammo?

Just hit prt scrn and use paint to edit it and make it a JPEG file.

[alfonso]

ORIGINAL: Smirfy


Whats the take screen key?

In my keyboard it is at the right of F12, and above Insert, in a group of 3 keys. Then you have to open Paint, and make "Paste". Then you can save the image as JPEG file, and embed it in your post

[alfonso]

Thinking about your unit.

It seems that

a) yours is a small unit, which intuitively seem easier to supply

or

b) you were near full capacity, because you did not expend much ammo with that unit.

[alfonso]

ORIGINAL: Smirfy

ORIGINAL: Cannonfodder

What kind of german opposition are you facing? And are support units being committed to battle? How does the supply picture look (drawn in and expended). Where is your railhead? How many trucks are you loosing? I now understand what you are saying but it doesnt really say anything without additional information.....

Panzer divisions and defence in depth, nope but sure who cares the way Im going through the Germans it aint important. The additional imformation is largely irrevelant Im 18 hexs from HQ. I have 30% supply 50% fuel and 100% ammo and my railhead is about 6 hexes away. I have plenty of combat numbers

You just cant get your head round this HQ's are a redundant feature their effect on the game is so marginal they are just clutter. The only gravity is the huge number of German units to plough through.

This game need some serious mechanics inserted.

Cannonfodder asked about German opposition because if there was severe fight, ammo is expended. Advance in open country does not expend much ammo. The question was not irrelevant.

[Smirfy]

Having no luck with this

[Smirfy]

ORIGINAL: alfonso

Thinking about your unit.

It seems that

a) yours is a small unit, which intuitively seem easier to supply

or

b) you were near full capacity, because you did not expend much ammo with that unit.

It is 5 Armoured corps and two mech corps of the 5 tank army which have been in continuous action fighting up to 3 times a week

edit from Kiev to just outside Lvov

[alfonso]

ORIGINAL: Smirfy

ORIGINAL: alfonso

Thinking about your unit.

It seems that

a) yours is a small unit, which intuitively seem easier to supply

or

b) you were near full capacity, because you did not expend much ammo with that unit.

It is 5 Armoured corps and two mech corps of the 5 tank army which have been in continuous action fighting up to 3 times a week

edit from Kiev to just outside Lvov

If a unit as big as a Mech Corps only needs 34 tons of ammo to reach 100%...

a) the fight in the last turns has not been very severe

or

b) something is wrong with the ammo expended in your battles. But if you see my screenshot (a Tank Div out of HQ range) I had 19% of ammo before supply, and then received 358 tons to reach 59%, if I interpret the numbers correctly. (I think the manual is wrong about the meaning of my 19%).
My Div did expend ammo, I don't understand what happens in your case.

[Smirfy]

ORIGINAL: alfonso

ORIGINAL: Smirfy

ORIGINAL: alfonso

Thinking about your unit.

It seems that

a) yours is a small unit, which intuitively seem easier to supply

or

b) you were near full capacity, because you did not expend much ammo with that unit.

It is 5 Armoured corps and two mech corps of the 5 tank army which have been in continuous action fighting up to 3 times a week

edit from Kiev to just outside Lvov

If a unit as big as a Mech Corps only needs 34 tons of ammo to reach 100%...

a) the fight in the last turns has not been very severe

or

b) something is wrong with the ammo expended in your battles. But if you see my screenshot (a Tank Div out of HQ range) I had 19% of ammo before supply, and then received 358 tons to reach 59%, if I interpret the numbers correctly. (I think the manual is wrong about the meaning of my 19%).
My Div did expend ammo, I don't understand what happens in your case.

Here is the problem, forget the numbers the problem is thus; A tank army has fought its way 180 miles from its HQ without appreciable detriment to its abilty to continue to fight. The HQ serves no function and is merely redundant, the presence of supply serves no purpose and is redundant, fatigue serves no purpose and is redundant. In reality I should be able to rotate units to smash fatigued Germans instead I can push my units on and on and their fighting capabilty is largely unnaffected (likewise niether is the germans). What is the point of printing a 300 page manual out when you can just keep going and going with most of the features irrevelant?

Because the "enviroment" of game is limited because all these things are far from crucial or decisive the game becomes bland. I did not test it (because I role play a bit to protect the AI) but I am sure that my offensive could have become general along the front and I would suffer not detrimental effects. That I'm afraid is nonsense and goes along way to explain the angst of the German player in the winter of 41.

[Smirfy]

Looking at fatigue a bit more A unit of the same type in the line which has not moved or fought in 4 months has the same fatigue as one that has fought over 180 miles not that it effects much.

[ParaB]

Have you perhaps massively increased your logistics level in the settings? Or have lowered your enemy's morale and logistics? I ask because what you report is so much different from what I see in my current game with the Axis that I can't really believe it. Some screenshots would be apreciated.

[KenchiSulla]

Seriously having trouble understand what is happening in your game. I tried a few turns on the axis side (am in a defensive position in my PBEM now) and as soon as I advance a lot I need to slow down to enable my units to receive supplies and fuel... What are the settings you are using?

[Smirfy]

ORIGINAL: ParaB

Have you perhaps massively increased your logistics level in the settings? Or have lowered your enemy's morale and logistics? I ask because what you report is so much different from what I see in my current game with the Axis that I can't really believe it. Some screenshots would be apreciated.

Nope just on default settings for both sides which is default (100). I messed up my photobucket account and get it back in 48 hours. Why would I lie? think I have got it uploaded now.

[Smirfy]

And showing the distance

[Smirfy]

distance

[KenchiSulla]

I see soviet corps expend about 20%-25% of ammo in a deliberate attack. Apparantly this unit hasnt attacked last (few?) turns... It draws less supply then it would when close to its HQ. It probably also isnt commiting support units..

The way I see it, your opposition in front of you has already succumbed to the initial assault (with HQ in range?). What does the map look like?