The Power of Inexperience / GreyJoy(A)-Rader(J)

Post descriptions of your brilliant victories and unfortunate defeats here.

Moderators: wdolson, MOD_War-in-the-Pacific-Admirals-Edition

kfsgo
Posts: 446
Joined: Wed Sep 15, 2010 11:06 pm

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by kfsgo »

ORIGINAL: GreyJoy

Unfortunately we have strict HRs that limits night bombing to 10k feet and to 50 max bombers during the full moon nights.... Not a viable option...

You have to kind of admire Rader's brazenness in setting up this stuff, in a way.
For the third mission, LeMay had designated Osaka, not as yet hit by a major air strike. Osaka, situated on Osaka Bay, the eastern limit of the Inland Sea, was Japan's second city in size and in industrial production. Its harbor facilities and excellent rail and highway connections made Osaka an important transportation center. It produced about one-tenth of Japan's wartime total of ships, one-seventh of her electrical equipment, one-third of her machinery and machine tools. The Osaka army arsenal furnished 20 per cent of the army's ordnance requirements. No airplanes were assembled at Osaka, but nearly a fourth of its half-million workers were engaged in the manufacture of parts and components for aircraft and engines. Osaka was also a great commercial city and an important administrative center. Because of conscription and the mushrooming of war industrial plants in the suburbs, the population of the city proper had shrunk from 3,254,380 in 1940 to an estimated 2,142,480 in February 1945. This shift had reduced the density of population (to 81,000 per square mile for the central commercial section and adjacent residential-industrial districts) without greatly affecting the built-upness. The scene of many earlier disasters, Osaka had cut a number of firebreaks through congested areas to add to the protection given by its numerous canals and had built many modern fire-resistive buildings, but its crowded districts of highly inflammable houses offered an ideal incendiary target.

The Osaka strike was scheduled before final results of the Nagoya mission had been evaluated. Reports from observers were sufficient, however, to raise doubts as to the correctness of the tactics followed, and operational planners tried to reproduce the pattern which had worked so well at Tokyo. The intervalometer setting was changed back to fifty feet and crews were warned to achieve a higher concentration in the target area. No specific method was prescribed although crews were briefed to check position carefully before releasing the bombs.

Thanks to heroic efforts on the part of maintenance crews, the command was able to put up 301 B-29's in a late afternoon take-off on 13 March. The planes carried the same 6-ton bomb load, but the low wing was given .50-caliber ammunition for lower forward and aft turrets as well as for the tail guns. When the force of 274 planes that got over Osaka found an 8/10 cloud cover, it had to resort to radar bombing. This proved an advantage rather than a handicap. Unable to sow their bombs by sighting visually on pathfinder fires, bombardiers were forced to drop after a controlled run, releasing on an offset aiming point. With this technique, the B-29's achieved a thicker and more uniform pattern than had been possible with the impressionistic methods used at Nagoya.

The results showed conclusively that the Tokyo raid had not been a fluke. The 1,732.6 tons dropped on Osaka in about three hours wiped out 8.1 square miles in the heart of the city. The chief commercial district was ruined, and fires were kindled in the industrial sections where 119 major factories were destroyed, including some engaged in heavy industry. As the flames spread rapidly, fire-fighting and air-raid protection (ARP) services were completely demoralized. Casualties mounted as persons were suffocated in makeshift shelters or were burned trying to run through the flames. The records of the Osaka fire department listed 3,988 dead, 678 missing, 8,463 injured.

Note that the B-29B, which will make up half your total B-29 allotment from March 45, is explicitly a night bomber - all the defensive armament except the tail gun is removed.
User avatar
JeffroK
Posts: 6416
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 4:05 am

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by JeffroK »

ORIGINAL: GreyJoy

ORIGINAL: JeffK

GJ needs to capture at least one of the bases, this should be first priority as it makes the others more stable.  Pick the weakest and concentrate on it.  Smash it and dont be afraid as long as you are destroying his units.




Easier said than done my friend... Those pesky bases have 400,000 men each, with a HUGE amount of CD guns and AA guns, that make them almost untouchable for my bombers and my BBs can bomb them only by 30k yards (so very little damage)...

Today i'll test what Kfgo has suggested and see what happens...

Again you cant do anything, so in the end you'll accept a self sustained POW camp?

Time to get cracking and do something, can you slip troops between bases?
Can you lift off a Division or two from your beachheads and concentrate on 1 only?

What thoughts about knocking away some of the props, I believe you have a reserve, will it get used?

At least work out a plan and go for it, your Death or Glory approach seems to have fizzled out/

By the way, if forced to choose between GF and AE, toss the computer in the bin!
Interdum feror cupidine partium magnarum Europae vincendarum
User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: GreyJoy

Unfortunately we have strict HRs that limits night bombing to 10k feet and to 50 max bombers during the full moon nights.... Not a viable option...


then you're bust. Having one side being in full fantasy mode with the other one stuck means the stuck one losing.
User avatar
paullus99
Posts: 1671
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2002 10:00 am

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by paullus99 »

Given the situation - your house rules are virtually guaranteeing that Rader is going to win this one. That he can throw thousands of aircraft at you, you can slaughter then by the thousands, yet he keeps coming back again and again, and yet you can't use the one huge advantage that you have, in a scenario designed to give the Japanese all the advantages they can get.

I think this one needs to be thrown out the window - tell Rader the deal & let him come up with an in-game solution.
Never Underestimate the Power of a Small Tactical Nuclear Weapon...
cwDeici
Posts: 70
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 2011 4:49 am

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by cwDeici »

Virtually impossible might be a bit too strong, Nemo told us GJ could have destroyed his AC factory capacity in 1-3+ months with varying levels of focus, but that doesn't change the overall picture of things being stacked against an originally completely green GJ playing scenario 2 with homerules favoring Japan. It's a miracle to his credit and an open back door that he's managed to come from behind to probably finishing the war in 45.

I'm not sure I see the point though, since they agreed to play like this knowingly.

I'm sure Rader is aware Sc2 is a JFB wet dream, even if he thinks low-level stratbombing is broken and unrealistic.
User avatar
EUBanana
Posts: 4255
Joined: Tue Sep 30, 2003 3:48 pm
Location: Little England
Contact:

RE: HAIRY TO THE BONE

Post by EUBanana »

ORIGINAL: GreyJoy
A damned mistake costed me 4 CVEs...[X(]...yesterday night my GF (Valentina) decided it was wise to spend the night by my appartment...so we went out with friends and when we came back i had the turn to play...i placed her on the sofa and asked her (politely) to stay quiet, to watch tv, and to leave me alone for an hour... it lasted less than 20 min...that she started to complain (That game is more important to you than me...you are obsessed by that game...who gives a **** about a canadian engineer who lives on the other side of the globe etc etc etc...bla bla blah....)...so i had to rush the orders and probably i messed up a bit...

Harsh. My other half knows that when the "Bee Game" is on I am otherwise engaged.

(She calls it the bee game because the hexes make it look like a honeycomb :) )

She actually likes it, she likes how regular it sounds. The music starts, depth charges and torpedoes, the drone of bombers, the whistling of bombs, explosions, artillery and machinegun noises, and finally kinda peaceful music for half an hour plus. She's heard it so many times now she knows the drill. [:D]
Image
cwDeici
Posts: 70
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 2011 4:49 am

RE: HAIRY TO THE BONE

Post by cwDeici »

ORIGINAL: EUBanana
Harsh. My other half knows that when the "Bee Game" is on I am otherwise engaged.

(She calls it the bee game because the hexes make it look like a honeycomb :) )

She actually likes it, she likes how regular it sounds. The music starts, depth charges and torpedoes, the drone of bombers, the whistling of bombs, explosions, artillery and machinegun noises, and finally kinda peaceful music for half an hour plus. She's heard it so many times now she knows the drill. [:D]

She sounds nice. [:)] You're a lucky man!
kfsgo
Posts: 446
Joined: Wed Sep 15, 2010 11:06 pm

RE: HAIRY TO THE BONE

Post by kfsgo »

By the way, here's another version of the sandbox with some assault shipping prepositioned so you don't have to sit around for a week and a half waiting for it:

https://docs.google.com/open?id=0B1Hrlf ... VkMTZkMThh
User avatar
EUBanana
Posts: 4255
Joined: Tue Sep 30, 2003 3:48 pm
Location: Little England
Contact:

RE: HAIRY TO THE BONE

Post by EUBanana »

ORIGINAL: cwDeici
ORIGINAL: EUBanana
Harsh. My other half knows that when the "Bee Game" is on I am otherwise engaged.

(She calls it the bee game because the hexes make it look like a honeycomb :) )

She actually likes it, she likes how regular it sounds. The music starts, depth charges and torpedoes, the drone of bombers, the whistling of bombs, explosions, artillery and machinegun noises, and finally kinda peaceful music for half an hour plus. She's heard it so many times now she knows the drill. [:D]

She sounds nice. [:)] You're a lucky man!

That I am.

Unlike Greyjoy, not for his romantic liaisons, but due to the house rules he's labouring under. Night bombing was a major part of the war at this point, LeMay and all, and this has been HRed out of existence entirely?

I think a problem with the HRs in these games is that they tend to focus on what happens and what should not happen in 1942. Few games make it to 1944 or beyond, but when you do reach this stage those HRs begin to look dated, as they are attempting to constrain you to 1942 practices which no longer make historical sense.
Image
User avatar
GreyJoy
Posts: 6750
Joined: Fri Mar 18, 2011 12:34 pm

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by GreyJoy »

Hi guys....well, i'll talk about the night bombing HRs with Rader...let's see what he thinks about it...
 
Kfsgo: Thanks again! I've made several tests...under the current conditions supplies seem to be flowing even with a full US Corp landed at Ominato...
The key is the strenght of the japanese forces in a contested base. If the japanese force has a strenght = or > than the allies in a contested hex, the supplies flows without any problem...:-/
 
I'll do some more tests but i fear this idea won't work...[:o]
 
User avatar
Grfin Zeppelin
Posts: 1514
Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2007 2:22 pm
Location: Germany

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by Grfin Zeppelin »

I always knew you must be Theon Greyjoy. Geting distracted from the war by a woman...yeah thats Theon [:D]
Uhm...how is your sister ? ^^

Image
hades1001
Posts: 977
Joined: Mon Dec 17, 2007 4:05 pm

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by hades1001 »

Am I the first one to express my surprise about 14 months earlier production of one Japs best fighters?

How the hell did Radar achieve this? This is way off the balance chart now. 14 months!
Image

As swift as wind;
As calm as wood;
Invasion like flames;
Defense like rocks.
User avatar
Grfin Zeppelin
Posts: 1514
Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2007 2:22 pm
Location: Germany

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by Grfin Zeppelin »

ORIGINAL: hades1001

Am I the first one to express my surprise about 14 months earlier production of one Japs best fighters?

How the hell did Radar achieve this? This is way off the balance chart now. 14 months!
If I remember right their game had a bug which made this happen and is solved now. R&D facory contributed points if repaired or not.

Image
veji1
Posts: 1019
Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2005 5:28 pm

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by veji1 »

The very existence of that Bug should allow GJ to throw the HRs out of the window. I mean what would Rader say if there had been a bug giving an infinite number of MIdway class CVs with their complement of brand new planes starting july 1944 ?

I think if presented convincingly but tactfully, the case for the dropping of the bombing HRs is very strong and Rader would agree to it.
Adieu Ô Dieu odieux... signé Adam
hades1001
Posts: 977
Joined: Mon Dec 17, 2007 4:05 pm

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by hades1001 »

Thanks milady, but I'm still wondering how long did they use that patch in terms of game time?
ORIGINAL: Gräfin Zeppelin

ORIGINAL: hades1001

Am I the first one to express my surprise about 14 months earlier production of one Japs best fighters?

How the hell did Radar achieve this? This is way off the balance chart now. 14 months!
If I remember right their game had a bug which made this happen and is solved now. R&D facory contributed points if repaired or not.
Image

As swift as wind;
As calm as wood;
Invasion like flames;
Defense like rocks.
Wuffer
Posts: 402
Joined: Thu Jun 16, 2011 7:08 pm

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by Wuffer »

Ante Portas


Seven years after landing the situation of the Greaks was really desolate. Most of the former heroes were dead and the survivors suffers badly, whipped out by cholera and pest, while Troy's walls were strong as ever... And even worser, the sons of Hektor had been grown up now, thirsty for reverange.
In this situation, GJ Barcas showed his real genius: Instead of making quick and insufficient turns, he left his fighters and last elephants alone for few days and visit his GF.
And then he reminds himself of the only Odysseus, who's advice had always been spot on - meet the right people at the right time...


User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: GreyJoy

Hi guys....well, i'll talk about the night bombing HRs with Rader...let's see what he thinks about it...

Kfsgo: Thanks again! I've made several tests...under the current conditions supplies seem to be flowing even with a full US Corp landed at Ominato...
The key is the strenght of the japanese forces in a contested base. If the japanese force has a strenght = or > than the allies in a contested hex, the supplies flows without any problem...:-/

I'll do some more tests but i fear this idea won't work...[:o]


you just have to look at the ZOCs. With your troops landing in the hex you control no ZOCs and so troops and supply can flow. If you try to march your troops out you will find out it won't work as you don't control a ZOC you may march through.
User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: Gräfin Zeppelin

ORIGINAL: hades1001

Am I the first one to express my surprise about 14 months earlier production of one Japs best fighters?

How the hell did Radar achieve this? This is way off the balance chart now. 14 months!
If I remember right their game had a bug which made this happen and is solved now. R&D facory contributed points if repaired or not.


According to n1849123 this is no bug but has always been possible if you know how to. And I have not heard about it being changed, of course, I may not have heard everything.
User avatar
Crackaces
Posts: 3858
Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2011 3:39 pm

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by Crackaces »

ORIGINAL: castor troy

ORIGINAL: Gräfin Zeppelin

ORIGINAL: hades1001

Am I the first one to express my surprise about 14 months earlier production of one Japs best fighters?

How the hell did Radar achieve this? This is way off the balance chart now. 14 months!
If I remember right their game had a bug which made this happen and is solved now. R&D facory contributed points if repaired or not.

According to n1849123 this is no bug but has always been possible if you know how to. And I have not heard about it being changed, of course, I may not have heard everything.

If I am reading the question correctly ... According to Michealm this was a bug and is fixed ..

[1108q4]
Fixed Restored fully repaired factory needed before R&D starts [MEM]
"What gets us into trouble is not what we don't know. It's what we know for sure that just ain't so"
veji1
Posts: 1019
Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2005 5:28 pm

RE: 1st oct 1944 Shidens ONLINE!

Post by veji1 »

If it's a bug and it has massive effect on the game it can either be legitmately affected by HRs designed to deal with it (limited conversion to Shindens for so and so months, etc...) or just free your 4E or their shackles.
Adieu Ô Dieu odieux... signé Adam
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”